Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Wallflower Most Wanted by Manda Collins is an interesting tale. This historical romance, brings out the most unusual characters for this genre. Beautiful yet exceptionally talented women who are looked at as strange among the society of their time period. However, their family and closest friends love them for who they are. Then, there are the men they meet...seduction, heat, and passion are mixed into the atmosphere creating a raw and unforgettable story.

The men can't resist temptation in the form of the these exciting women. Strong, independent, talented and smart women...who know what they want in life. It was hard not to love the especially the main characters focused in this novel. Miss Sophia Hastings has been made an heir. Her talent is painting. She's an outstanding artist that can make people think and feel what she has painted. I loved her fiery spirit. Her strong will and determination came from her Aunt who is a force to beware of...

Miss Sophia Hastings ends up injuring her leg and meets the dashing yet remarkable vicar in her area. Every lady wants to marry him. His good looks cause for the flock of women to surround him. Yet Miss Hastings isn't flocking him despite how attracted she is to his looks and charms. When Reverend Lord Benedict Lisle pulls his full on charms, there's no resisting him...

Reverend Lord Benedict wants to help people. He has no stomach for war yet he can defend himself and those he cares about...especially, the wallflower known as Miss Hastings. Both him and her suffer with the opposite sex coming to them for attention. Neither one enjoys this. Yet as their chance meeting happens, so does the danger. Over hearing a crime plot, both characters end up pulling closer than they ever dreamed. Maybe, they'll find their match after all...unless the danger gets to them first.

Wallflower Most Wanted by Manda Collins is a super sweet, funny, and charming book. I couldn't resist it. The temptation was too great. The characters were lovable. Each one had a personal connection to the situations happening and their personalities made the story that much better. It was believable. Manda Collins beautifully wove this tale into a romance unlike any other. Overall, I highly recommend it to all.

Was this review helpful?

DNF - unfortunately i was unable to finish this story. I picked it up and put it down so many times

Was this review helpful?

Wallflower Most Wanted was a fast-paced romance with a compelling plot and a charming group of characters.

Sophia Hastings is a master painter and dedicates herself fully to her craft believing it to be of more importance than her love life. After an unfortunate accident while painting on the cliffs near Beauchamp House leaves her literally falling into Lord Benedick Lisle’s arms, Sophia begins to rethink her position. When the two overhear a plot to kill a local artist, Sophia is determined to get to the bottom of things and Ben insists on helping her. The two quickly find themselves in a dangerous position as the culprit is willing to stop at nothing to see their goals accomplished.

Sophia is incredibly passionate about her work and has found that during her time at Beauchamp House she has created her best works as coming there has allowed her to express herself more freely and has given her the opportunity to discover who she is. In addition to her devotion to painting, Sophia also cares deeply about social issues particularly those dealing with women and children. She incorporates her interest in these issues into her paintings which tends to make the people viewing them uncomfortable. Sophia has a very close relationship with her sister Gemma and I loved seeing more of their sibling relationship than we’ve seen in previous books.

Ben is the vicar at the local church in the town where Beauchamp House resides and arrived in town after events in a previous book left an opening at the church. Ben became a vicar as he knew as a second son he was destined for the church or the army. He has little interest in church politics and instead simply desires to help people. Ben grew up touring his family’s properties with his mother and visiting the tenants. It was during those visits that he learned how to talk to people and offer them comfort. Ben is very close to his family and I enjoyed seeing his interactions with them.

Prior to the start of the book, Ben and Sophia interacted very little and thus their relationship does develop quickly on page. Both of them were physically attracted to one another right away but try to chalk it up to their encounter at the cliffs. However when they begin spending more time together and getting to know each other, they start to connect on a deeper level. Ben felt more sure in his feelings before Sophia did which was a nice change of pace from most romances. When their relationship does progress physically, it’s very steamy and there are several sexy scenes that are quite enjoyable.

Like Ivy and Daphne before her, Sophia was given a mystery to solve by Lady Celeste that was perfectly suited to her area of expertise. While trying to solve her mystery, we learn some new information about Lady Celeste that clarified a few things from previous books and helped tie up a few loose ends. I was surprised to learn who the bad guy was as the author does a great job concealing their identity.

Wallflower Most Wanted was a fantastic installment in the Studies in Scandal series and I’m excited to finally get Gemma’s book, One for the Rogue, soon. I highly recommend these books for fans of historical romances with unconventional heroines.

Was this review helpful?

Miss Sophia Hastings is one of the 4 Beauchamp heiresses. She is an artist who is a talented painter. She paints about social issues which are considered quite controversial, not just for a woman, but for any painter.

She and the Reverent Lord Benedick Lisle overhear two men planning to eliminate someone. Sophie insists that when Ben tries to find out who may be in danger, she is also involved.

Each of the heiresses are talented in different fields. This is third in a series and the two previous stories have involved two young women who were involved in mysteries and also found men they married. The village looks at the young women as unusual, but generally they are included in village life. They are not necessarily understood, but they are welcomed.

It seems that there is a forgery ring in the area. They are making copies of very valuable paintings and selling them to unsuspecting buyers.

Sophia and Ben are on the trail of the people responsible. As the clues appear, they are led almost in circles before facts start fitting together.

For me, this was not as appealing as the earlier books in the series. It is well written and the plot is interesting. But the mystery is relatively easy to solve. The relationship between Sophia and Ben seems to move rather quickly considering Ben is a vicar in a small village. I just felt that the story went in fits and starts.

Sophia and Ben are very appealing characters. He is personable and open to doing good works for people in need. He is deeply immersed in village life. She is very involved in her work to the point of having tunnel vision. Both of them are intelligent, amusing, charming and generous to others.

Ms Collins is a talented author and though I did not like this book as well as the others in the series, it is still an entertaining book.

I received this book from the publisher through NetGalley. I am voluntarily writing this review and all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I like that Ms. Collins gives the women intelligence and that these women use their intelligence and not just sit around talking nonsense. This story is a good bit more slow burn than the other stories in this series. I had not read a book with a vicar as the hero and was not sure how it would be pulled off but it worked. Both Sophia and Benedick are very likeable characters and their romance was cute and sweet. The mystery was very good (as in all of Ms. Collins’ books). You never know what will happen next and who is the villain. Looking for stories that are not the norm? Read this series.

Was this review helpful?

Great book. I actually didn't guess "who done it" until it was revealed. Can't wait for her next book.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and St Martin’s Press for this book. A very enjoyable regency romance - a spirited heroine with a difference and a dashing hero. What more could one ask for on a cold winter’s evening. Any fan of this genre will love this book.

Was this review helpful?

I did not finish this book. For some reason the main male character being a Vicar turned me off a little bit in terms of this being a “romance” novel. I’m still a amanda Collins fan BUT this just wasn’t the book for me.

Was this review helpful?

I'll admit I was a little hesitant about reading a love story about a vicar. In my mind, when I think of a vicar I think of creepy Mr. Collins from Pride & Prejudice. This man isn't any vicar. He is Reverend Lord Benedict Lisle, second son of the Duke of Pemberton. He was introduced to the Studies in Scandal series in book two and I liked him, so I was willing to step out of my reading comfort zone and give him a chance.

Once Ben found the woman he was meant to be with falling off a ten foot cliff, I knew this wouldn't be any ordinary love story. Miss Sophia Hastings was lucky Ben was walking along the beach that day. The fall and the overheard conversation set the pair off in search of a forgery ring and love.

Sophia is one of four young ladies whom inherited Beauchamp House from the late Lady Celeste Beauchamp. Her artistic talent and ability to show the world thought provoking pieces caught the eye of Lady Celeste, earning Sophia a place at Beauchamp House. Just like her fellow heiresses, Lady Celeste left Sophia a mystery to solve. Find the perpetrators swindling art lovers by selling forgeries through a local gallery.

Ben and Sophia tangle up in each other as they work to find the culprits. I would've thought a vicar would show more restraint than Ben did when it came to his affections toward Sophia. Turns out even vicars have a libido that runs wild when confronted with beauty and brains all embedded in one woman. It made for one wild ride for the vicar and the artist! I was on edge thinking "Will he or won't he?" When Sophia needed to, she gave him the little push he needed. I gave her a virtual high five for going after what she wanted.

While this is the third in the series, it can be read as a standalone. I do highly recommend reading the first two installments, Ready Set Rogue, Ivy and Quill's story, and Duke with Benefits, Daphne and Dalton's story. The series is not over yet! Book four, One for the Rogue, Gemma and Cameron's story, is set for release June 26th, 2018!

Was this review helpful?

I was not a fan of this novel. I found it hard to get into the story.

Was this review helpful?

This was a nice romance with likable leads. It is the third in series, and I have not read the previous two. It mostly worked as a standalone, but there were characters featured in other books present that knowing their backstory might be helpful. The premise of the series revolves around four women with special skills or talents who share an inheritance. I imagine the first book gets into the details of the inheritance more, but it seems to be some sort of competition for the inheritance. Despite the competition, they have become good friends. Sophia is a talented artist, and her sister is there as one of the four as a paleontologist.

The hero, Ben, is a Vicar and second son of a Duke. He has been asked by the home office by way of his brother to investigate a series forgeries coming out of Little Seaford, the setting of this novel. To help with his investigation, he seeks counsel from Sophia, since he respects her artistic talent and knowledge. They had met on occasion as members of the same community, but the investigation kindles attraction into romance. Due to the unconventionality of her home, Ben and Sophia are left to consult alone often.

While I think this was mostly a nice, straightforward romance, there was little depth, and it was superficial. I didn't feel much for the characters or their love. It was just nice and not more. The writing and pacing was decent, but there were elements of implausibility in the subplot and the characters that made this difficult at times for me. Ben being the son of a Duke with independent means, not needing a career, seems unlikely to have chosen to be a vicar. He was also a vicar with considerable experience in the bedroom, so he just didn't seem like a vicar. Also the whodunnit was quite implausible

Overall, this is a pleasant story if you can suspend belief. If not, then it's probably not the book for you.

*I received a free copy of this from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I had the pleasure of reading this book that is wrongly labelled as romance. It is actually more of a detective story than a romance, but trust me, that is just OK.

Please do not be misguided by the title, Sophia Hastings is anything but a wallflower. She’s bored by all of the attention she often gets from the eligible bachelors in Little Seaford and other towns in the county. She is a gifted painter whose dreams are far from the loving housewife and mother kind of future. But then one day when she’s working on a landscape painting she falls from a cliff only to find herself in the presence of the only eligible bachelor who doesn’t seem to woo her; Lord Benedick Lisle, the vicar.

But Ben had noticed her of course, and he’s besotted with her as any of the other men are, or they rather seem to be. But what had caused the girl of his dreams’ fall literally at his feet? When he’s helping her recover from her fall they hear a threatening conversation between two mysterious men up there on the cliff. It's the scheming of the assassination of a third man, and thus Ben and Sophia find themselves involved in an investigation in which murder, forgery and betrayal are afoot.

And love, of course, this is a mystery book but not without reason it’s labelled as romance. Both Ben and Sophia like each other since before the book even started, perhaps there were hints of this liking in previous books just as Sophia’s sister and Ben’s brother fall in ‘fight at first sight’ in this story (and they will have a story in the final book of the series, but you didn’t learn it from me). Despite the fact that they soon find themselves comfortable in each other’s company it isn’t until half the book is done that they share a first kiss and then realize about their feelings (surprisingly unlike in most novels that I’ve read, they are very clear about their feelings and... well I won’t spoil it for you) and this is because the mystery plot is the main plot, and the romance is something built around that plot, but it’s not a secondary plot either, don’t worry about that.

I loved both Ben and Sophia, as characters alone and together. They’re very resourceful both of them, very smart, strong and, when they’re alone, sexy. Who would have thought that vicars could be this sexy? And she’s a fierce woman, avant-garde in many things, definitely stubborn and lovely. And I loved how well they understand each other; like, he actually really falls in love with her when he ‘sees’ her in her paintings, her spirit and her mind. And she understands the kind of man he is and why he became a vicar, and she loves him all the more for that.

The mystery side of the novel was just ok. It was clear who the one behind the plotting was; they tell it to you right from the start. But even if they didn’t it was obvious. Still there were some surprising elements that you see coming but at the same time you don’t see coming. And the final plot twist was something that I hadn’t foreseen. It’s not an amazing detective story but it’s good enough, like ie: an episode of ‘Murder, She Wrote’. I’d love a series of books of The Vicar and the Painter Private Investigators.

If I have to point out something that I didn’t like was the pace. It was slow at the beginning, right up to the 50% or so of the book, and then all of a sudden (precisely as Ben and Sophia let out their feelings) the pace quickens and the story becomes so exciting it’s like reading a different book with the same story. But that didn’t stop me from enjoying reading it. It was just, disconcerting. I have to say that I enjoyed this book thoroughly once the pace changed, but I was liking it enough before, otherwise I would have stopped reading altogether.

I can’t wait to read Gemma Hastings’ and Cameron Lisle’s story in One for the Rogue (Studies in Scandal, book 4) that’s coming out in June, but for now, Ben and Sophia will have their HEA.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced reader’s copy of this book.

One thing I’ve enjoyed about this series is the mystery each heroine has had to solve. I thought the twist as far as the mystery thread in the story and the reveal was well-written. As far as the romance, Benedick and Sophia began working together to solve the mystery and their relationship built from there. I felt the conflict for why the hero and heroine couldn’t be together was brought up and mentioned but the characters didn’t come across feeling very strongly about it. As a result the romantic conflict wasn’t as strong.

Overall, I enjoyed this book and am looking forward to the next book in the series.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book to be a very enjoyable read! It was intriguing & had a unique plot. I have not read any of the other books in this series. I found this book to be very interesting on it's own.

Was this review helpful?

Sorry folks but this one was not for me. I found it to be too slow, and I made myself turn the pages and I hate that, if I get a book I want to be interested but when you kind of make yourself try to get into it, it just kills is for me. It was discombobulated for me, slow then dry then rushed..Hate bad reviews, but sometimes you can't help it.

Was this review helpful?

I have absolutely loved this series, and I cannot wait for Gemma's story! Sophia and Ben were adorable, and I loved the interaction between all the characters.

Was this review helpful?

I received this from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This is book 3 in the studies in scandal series. In this series, we have four blue stockings that in her it’s a house that comes with conditions and mysteries. This book we have a hunt to stop a smuggling ring through in a romance and you have this book. It was a really good read. I enjoyed it a great deal.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third in a series in Beauchamp House, where Lady Celeste left her here home to four scholastic young ladies, all with different studies. What happens, is mysterious, mayhem, and potential murder! Lady Celeste has left clues to each young lady. The next young lady is Sophia, a painter, a very talented painter she is, bringing light from the self centered attitude of the ton, as they ignore a dying young woman, on the way to their pleasure pursuits. Lord Benedict, the second son of a Duke, is a Vicar in the County. Of course , there is no way , a scandalous female painter, and a Lord, who takes his calling seriously, could ever be together, it's quite out of the question, or is it?
I highly recommend! Thanks! Enjoy!
carolintallahassee 👒

Was this review helpful?

Sweet read but a little underwhelming. The romance was cute but I felt the rest of the story was a bit boring.

Was this review helpful?

Manda Collins continues her delightful series A Studies in Scandal with artist Sophie Hasting as the heroine in Wallflower Most Wanted. The hero is the local vicar, Lord Benedict Lisle, a younger son of a duke. The four ladies who have the opportunity to inherit Beauchamp House are continuing in their quest to solve the ‘mysteries’ handed them by Lady Celeste Beauchamp following her death. The entire concept of leaving her home to four bluestockings is interesting in itself.

Sophie literally drops in on Lord Benedict while he is out for his daily walk. They overhear a plot to do away with someone. That night Benedict’s brother visits him to ask him to investigate a ring of painting forgers. The group is recreating works by famous painters that have been missing for decades. And, selling them to unsuspecting buyers at quite a profit.

Sophie and Ben join together to try to solve this mystery while she is still nursing a sprained ankle due to her fall. Ben gets to carry her about just a bit making the chemistry begin quickly between them. Although there is definitely a sensual aspect to this book as with all of Ms. Collin’s books, she handles it very well considering our hero is a vicar. He is human after all.

As with previous books in the series, there is a death and the magistrate is involved. He begins to think there is something wrong with the House. Serena, Lady Celeste’s niece agrees, there is something wrong, but it is due to her lack of chaperonage as her charges keep marrying with special license. Serena is determined that Sophie will not need one, too.

I love the way Ben defends Sophie when one of the bad guys appears to be able to hit her. He is all alpha male when that occurs. Ben does not believe in fighting and was not cut out for war, thus part of his reason for becoming a vicar. He surprises even himself.

Needless to say, this is another great book by Manda Collins. You won’t want to put it down once you start. Although ‘Studies’ can be read as a stand alone, I have enjoyed reading the previous two books in the series allowing knowing the characters better. Additionally, Ms. Collins intermingles characters from other series, such as the Lords of Anarchy. You begin to feel as if you know most of England through her books. They feel like familiar friends. (I realize Gemma is the last of the four ladies, but I am looking forward to Serena’s story, too.)

Was this review helpful?