
Member Reviews

New Girl for a new month. A psychological thriller with female leads and the word Girl in the title. Now there’s something not even remotely original. But then again it’s what sells and here’s yet another author jumping on that ever so popular and frankly overpopulated bandwagon with her debut. The main plot driver is that the narrator is wildly unreliable and possibly quite bonkers, although just to what extend you’ll find out in the end. Or, if you’ve read this sort of thing before and/or possess even slight powers of deduction, pretty early in the game. The main protagonists here are all obscenely young, something like 20, just out of their teens enough to have this not be YA, but not mature enough yet to not make the stupidest mistakes and seriously terrible personal choices. And roommating situations especially seem to be something that positively reeks of youth, not too many adults would conceive of sharing their living space and essentially their life with a complete stranger. Hasn’t anyone seen Single White Female at least? Anyway, here’s a story about some roommates with a twist, sort of kind of. For all its faults it’s actually very readable, the snack food of literature if you will, and reasonably entertaining. It doesn’t particularly challenge the readers, but doesn’t really insult their intelligence either. Clocking in at exactly 180 minutes it was a perfectly adequate way to spend a morning and just barely satisfy a mystery thriller craving. And it’s Australian, so should technically count for international reading, although the location, outside of topsy turvy weather, doesn’t really that much of a difference in this case. Thanks Netgalley.

This book to me was long and drawn out. I almost stopped reading so many times but powered through to the end. The ending ended up being good, that said it to me was the only good part of the book. I hope others find this book enjoyable, just wasn't for me.
Thanks to the publisher and netgalley for an early release of this book.

1.5 stars. I'm addicted to psychological thrillers. The blurbs always draw me in, and they promise so much intrigue and creepiness and tempt me with secrets that I suddenly *must* know the answers to. Sometimes they live up to my expectations, but often I feel less than satisfied at the end, kind of like I've just eaten too much junk food. This was was decidedly on the junk food side for me. I was sucked in at first, but then it went downhill and I was skimming most of the second half. The ending was bonkers in a way that's sort of par for the course of you've read a lot of these books. So, this one was not for me, and I wouldn't really recommend it--but if you are a committed lover of psychological thrillers you might get more out of it than I did.

This book was just "okay." Most of the time I thought that Mary/Rachel were the same person, like a split personality type of thing. That ended up not exactly being the case. The journal to present tense writing kept the pace of the novel moving nicely, but I didn't feel like everything aligned; some things were mentioned in the journal that were going on at the same as the present tense, so it got confusing. I found the end to be extremely rushed, which was disappointing because Mary's personality was finally just revealed, which was a huge plot twist! The author should've spent more time on the ending and not rushed it so much.

This was an okay read. I liked it but I did not love it. I do feel like it deserves 4 stars since I was interested in reading more and finishing it, but it is not a story I will revisit again.

A good plot ,but it took a long time to get to the plot of the book,id not know sho to trust.Rachel charzcter was a bit wesk, who wojld go out if their way to help someone who they admired from school a bit hard to imagine ,and this is the part that the book falls flat,otherwise a good read.

This book is definitely an ok for readers who like psychological books.. I usually enjoy them but this one fell flat for me. It wasn't a bad book it was just ok...Took a very long time (3/4 of the way) for the plot to get to the point and was a little boring...I was waiting for the big WOW which never came.. Thankyou netgalley for letting me review this book.