Cover Image: Detective Nosegoode and the Museum Robbery

Detective Nosegoode and the Museum Robbery

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Children and their parents will love the three amusing and clever mysteries contained in Marian Orton’s third volume in this series, which features a brilliant police detective with a savvy, talking dog named Cody. The pair work together to solve crimes, and the dog is nearly his master’s equal. As with the classic Encyclopedia Brown series, readers can match wits with Nosegoode and Cody and see if they, too, can crack the three cases in this book. The book is beautifully translated from the Polish and boasts charming illustrations. Even though this is the third in the series, I was never at a loss, and I believe the books can be read in any order.

In the interest of full disclosure, I received this book from NetGalley and Pushkin Press in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

There were three short mysteries in the book. The stories were incredible and cute! To solve the mysteries, the detective had to be very smart and conscious which is what kept my attention the most. All the three mystery stories were solved so logically. There were many challenges that tested the intelligence of both detective and his friend, Cody. This little talking dog was excellent in two of the stories. I love the relationship between Cody and Detective. They were more like friends and partners in solving the mysteries than a master and his dog. Cody’s sharpness and mockeries were hilarious. I enjoyed his speeches in this book. This is an amazing book full of adventurous mysteries that kids would love to solve with smart Detective and his witty talking dog.

Was this review helpful?

I was sent a copy of this book in return for my independent honest review. What a lovely little collection of three stories. I had not come across this series before and love the talking dog. Great stories to read aloud to younger primary children.
Well translated into English. Sure my little Grandaughter will love this one

Was this review helpful?

This is the most brilliant series of sweet detective stories - I read it to my class and they loved the characters and the plot twists. I love to share translated fiction with them to open their eyes to countries around us and this really inspired their hunt for more books on a similar theme. They loved reading a story that helped them to see similarities with them and the world around us and were amazed how well it had been translated. We'll definitely be reading even more books from this author and this publisher - thank you!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this sweet and fun early chapter book which has three mysteries featuring the detective and his dog. It would make a great book for early/mid primary school children - either to be read out to them or as a book for them to try on their own if they're more confident readers. This is definitely the easier end of that spectrum but it's still a lot of fun. I haven't come across the series before, but I'd happily read more and will be adding this to my list of books to buy for children as gifts.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book as it provided such an interesting story, with a plot that weaved in and out, with strong and interesting characters. I thought the introduction with how the crime would be committed was a great place to start as it meant the reader would wonder how the robbery still occurred.

Was this review helpful?

Great children’s story. This will surely sparkle their immagination.

Was this review helpful?

Three nice simple stories which would be super for Y2-4 (and Y1 to listen to). It's a little old-fashioned in a classic way; there's no whizz-bang chases and dramatic effect, just a careful unravelling of each mystery with the help of Cody the talking (and very useful!) dog. There's definitely a sense of Sherlock Holmes in the Detective's cleverness, and the gentle humour rounds these stories out into pleasant reads. Kudos to Pushkin Press for enabling the translation.

Was this review helpful?

There were three short mysteries in the book. What a wonderful stories they were! So as title suggests the Lower Limewood had quite number of thieves this time. and only experienced Detective Nosegoode and his famous dog, Cody, can solve the mysteries and catch the thieves.

In the first mystery, identity of culprit was revealed earlier in the book, all detective needed to do was keep close eye and stop them from stealing the most precious painting of the museum. Looks very easy, right? But trust me detective had to be very smart and conscious which I’m sure will keep reader attentive as well. It was nice mystery and loved seeing detective so enthusiastic while playing the role.

I was just thinking the famous Hippolytus was not mentioned in the story but was rewarded with double Hippolytus advises in the second story. The second one, about finding a thief who stole money from the cash box at Ashworth Chess Club, was little silly in my opinion and kind of different than all mysteries I have read in this series. It showed how smart Detective Nosegoode was and he had a great observational skill as well that helped solving the mystery.

And the third! This time there was great surprise. He got a letter from his great friend informing detective about the ‘Elusive Hand’ thief into his town on opening of grand exhibition. Our little guy Cody beats Detective here by his attentive nature and cracked the case like his favorite bone. This one was funnier than other two stories.

All the three mysteries were solved so logically and surprisingly more simple way than the first two book. There was a challenge as well as smartness of both detective and his friend, Cody. This little talking dog was brilliant in two of the stories. I loved the relationship between Cody and Detective. They were more like friends and partners in solving the mysteries than a master and his dog. Cody’s wittiness and sarcasms were hilarious. I enjoyed his monologues in this book. He was so adorable that all children would love to be his friend.

I must admit author came up with interesting funny names throughout this series. In this one, we meet Mr. Fiddlestick, Mr. Graylag, Mr. Bee, oh and nicknames like doughnut and Beanpole. It would be so amusing for children to read such names along with great little mysteries to solve.

Another thing I liked was eye catching pencil sketches with all required details but they were in less amount in comparison to first book. There were more words to story than the sketches which was kind of good.

This book and in fact series is best for young reader who like to read sleuthing mysteries and parents would love to have this book for their children as there isn’t any violence or bad language. And there are little advises from the great Hippolytus, a friend of Detective Nosegoode, on being a great detective and how to catch thieves.

Overall, it was amazing bunch of adventurous mysteries that kids would love to solve with smart Detective and his witty talking friend- Cody.

Was this review helpful?

I read this title as standalone and now would be delighted to read the rest of the series! Kudos to the translator for introducing such a gem to the English-speaking audience, and certainly to Pushkin Press as well.

Lively and engaging stories that had me chuckling for most part. I absolutely enjoyed it and will get my own copy when it comes out.

I am also looking forward to more of the author’s works being available in English. In the meantime, join Detective Nosegoode and Cody in their exciting adventures!

Was this review helpful?

I have to admit that I adore this cute series. I love the talking dog and I love even more that he's not even a main plot point usually. It's almost as if he's just one of Nosegoode's friends to help him talk through the crimes and figure them out. This particular book in the series is the first that's had multiple cases and this lends itself to those beginning to read chapter books even moreso than the others. Kids in that age group do struggle with their attention span even if they don't have some sort of disability so it's great to see books catered to them. It's also free of language, sexual content and most violence although there is a short fight sequence in this one but nothing involving any sort of gore. I very highly recommend it.

I would like to thank the publisher, author, and Netgalley for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?