Cover Image: Stanley’s Girl

Stanley’s Girl

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Stanley's Girl by Susan Eisenberg is a collection of poetry that comes from a unique perspective--a woman working in the construction industry before women had any place there. Although a couple of poems stray from being specifically about construction, the majority of the collection deals with all of the pain, fear, and heartbreak that had to be endured just to be seen as qualified to step foot on a construction site.

The poetry gets very serious by tackling all of what you would expect a woman to have to endure being one of the few to get the ball rolling, such as blatant misogyny, hazing, harassment, and even assault in some instances. What may come as a surprise is the blatant disregard for human life simply because someone isn't the same as all the others, to the point where seeing if a woman is going to make a fatal mistake becomes a spectator sport. Very powerful collection.

Was this review helpful?

Fully formatted review available at : https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2265936083

I don't typically read poetry, but I was eager to read about a new-to-me topic: women in the construction industry. In these poems, Susan Eisenberg tells the stories of the women and people of color who entered an industry that didn't want them.

Eisenberg entered the construction industry in 1978. In the early 1980s, she became "one of the first women in the country to achieve journey-level status in the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)." At that time ≈2% of building trade jobs were held by women; that number has held steady throughout the decades.* Reading this book of 44 poems felt like reading a journal. The emotional impact far exceeds its 84-page length. I felt so much rage while reading about what people endured while simply trying to earn a living. There were repeated appeals from bosses and 'sympathetic' bystanders to ignore threatening behavior. A man urinates on a woman's car, yet she's the unhinged one for confronting him. People were put in dangerous—sometimes fatal—situations to either teach them a lesson or for company entertainment.

She recognizes the additional hardships faced by people of different races and ethnicities,"all the undercurrents and sideshows" that she was previously unaware of ("White Joe Miller and Black Joe Miller"). In Part III, she examines issues faced by women in other male-dominated industries, such as the standard of medical care for female veterans. After decades of being issued ill-fitting prosthetic feet designed for men, a prosthetic foot was finally designed for women in 2015.  Some of the poems address Eisenberg's personal life, such as a poem about a harrowing childhood that in some ways prepared her for the challenges ahead ("Navigating Uncertainty") and a poem about the time she was stalked and confronted about one of her poems ("Poems About Gaza by Jews" with the repeated refrain "he found me").

Other memorable poems:
"Welcome" - All the extra knowledge that had to be learned, far beyond the scope of the actual job.
"Introductions" - The consequences of asserting oneself on the construction site.
"Below the Radar" - A variation of the "twice as good" saying.
"Troublemaker" - The neverending list of all the things a woman should’ve done to avoid negative consequences or escape judgment. (Spoiler alert: There's nothing she could've done.)
"The Jobsite Marksman" - "He'll swear he slept through high school. Lie! In History he took careful notes, then machine-cut keys to the tenderspots:"
"Go-Getter" - At the risk of losing her job, a single mom/ironworker apprentice is forced into a fatal situation.
"Power" - A black woman is excited to be offered an onsite opportunity beyond making coffee and sweeping, but the crew had ulterior motives.

The pioneering people in these poems took their place on the frontlines in hopes that future generations wouldn't have to fight so hard. It's important to hear their stories because as time passes and situations improve even slightly, there's a tendency to forget about how hard people had to fight to get to that point or why laws were enacted. These poems are also a reminder of all the work that’s still left to do. This book mostly deals with events that happened from the late 1970s to the late 1990s, but the issues addressed are not just in the past. Anyone who has ever been an outsider in a workplace will be able to see their own experiences in these poems.

Susan Eisenberg also wrote Pioneering: Poems from the Construction Site. If you are interested in the topic but aren't really into poetry, she wrote the oral history We’ll Call You If We Need You: Experiences of Women Working Construction(1998). The introduction (available on Google Books) provides interesting context and makes me want to read more.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, what a powerful collection of poetry, and from a unique perspective, which made the reading all the more compelling. Stanley's Girl is a collection of poetry dealing with being a woman working in construction and all of the horrific sexism, abuse, and constant danger that comes with that. Every poem hit home with great power, particularly the titular poem, about an experience with a co-worker who was a wonderful help but also a terrible racist.

Was this review helpful?