Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I’ve quickly become a Kubica fan as I’ve read more and more of her books. With that said, I didn’t feel like this one suited me.

The book opens with Jessie’s mom, who has been battling cancer, dying. Jessie has been unable to sleep, and the one time she did, her mom died without her. From there, Jessie has to try to pick up the pieces of her grief and move on. When she gets a call from her college letting her know that her social security number is tied to someone on the death registry, Jessie sets out to try to learn more about the person she is.

Interspersed with Jessie’s story are passages about her mom, Eden, from before Jessie was born. They tell a story of a woman who is so desperate to have a baby that she goes into debt, sabotages her marriage, and even entertains the idea of kidnapping someone else’s child. Slowly, her story reveals the truth of Jessie’s origins.

The novel has Kubica’s trademark twist ending, but it wasn’t one that I loved. Jessie’s insomnia makes her a narrator who becomes increasingly unreliable, to the point where some of her passages were almost impossible to read. I recognize that this is down to Kubica illustrating the effects of insomnia, but it was a style that didn’t work for me. Those passages didn’t hold my attention as much as the Eden passages, and even Eden stars to deteriorate mentally as her baby obsession grows.

Lots of Eden’s tales made me sad, and Jessie’s made me crazy. The book was ok, but it’s not my favorite by this author and not one I see myself reading again.

Was this review helpful?

It's just Jessie and her mom before her mom passes away from cancer and she is left alone. She never knew her dad and she has no other siblings or friends. Her mom's last words are to "go find yourself" so Jessie applies to college but a registration official calls and says her social security number belongs to a dead 3 year old girl, who died 17 years ago. There are 2 timelines in this book, current day with Jessie's POV, and another set in the 90s with Eden. Eden's only goal in life is to get pregnant. The two timelines seem like two completely different stories but as the novel progresses, you'll see the thread that ties them together. In all honesty, I read some of the spoilers online and contemplated aborting the book early on because of the ending. I agreed with a lot of the other reviewers who felt the author took the easy way out in wrapping up the plot. Obviously I'm not going to spoil it for you by detailing it here. I'm glad I continued till the end and was able to make my own judgment though (definitely not a perfect book but still enjoyable). I'm not sure I'd place this book in the psychological thriller genre though which was a bit disappointing since that's my favorite type of novel but it was still a readable choice.

Was this review helpful?

Not what I expected...it was tough enough to get through the wild psychological ride with one of the main characters and then have it turn into that ending? I'm all for a good twist but this was not really for me. This was my first Mary Kubica and still want to read her other works, I just hope the twists aren't laid out like this. 2.5/3 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and Harlequin/Hanover Square Press for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I've read all of Mary Kubica's books, so when I was approved for an ARC of When the Lights Go Out, I was pumped!

I wasn't a huge fan of Every Last Lie, but I thought her first three books were phenomenal, and the blurb made this one sound great.

And there were great parts about it. Kubica's writing is always very good, but I did question some of the word choices when Jessie was narrating. As a 17 year old, I would expect her to say whites of her eyes, as opposed to sclera, for example.

The biggest success of the book is the portion told from Eden's point of view. She is easy to empathize with as she transitions from a newlywed with a perfect life to a woman who really struggles through adversity she never saw coming, and then matures for the sake of her daughter.

I thought that using sleep deprivation as a vehicle for an unreliable narrator was unique. I was looking forward to the challenge of sifting through the clues to find out what was reality and what was blurred by sleeplessness. 

The story is fast moving and I was desperate to race through to the end and figure out what was going on. I could not wait to find out how it ended--until I found out how it ended.

To say that I was angry is to understate how I felt. I'm writing this review two full days after I read this book because when I woke up yesterday, I was still truly pissed. Like, I want to give this book zero stars kind of pissed. 

The ending is just disrespectful to the reader. These thriller wait for the twist kind of books should aim to be difficult to figure out, but the reader should be able to at least look back and think, 'Ah, so that was what was going on!'

There was none of that here, given the ending.  

I consider myself a pretty lenient reviewer; I wouldn't actually give a book zero stars. There were good things about the book, so I will give it two stars, but begrudgingly.

When the Lights Go Out is expected to be published September 4, 2018.

Thank you to Park Row for providing an ARC through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I've been a fan of Mary Kubica since The Good Girl. This new psychological thriller is no disappointment, I enjoyed it. The story is slow-paced but keeps you on edge.

Thank you NetGalley and Harlequin for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Jessie Sloan''s mother dies of cancer, and her dying wish was for Jessie to "find herself". So Jessie sells the house she grew up in, signs up to go to college and finds a new place to live where there are no ghosts from the past. Then she receives a call from the college saying her social security number belongs to someone who has been dead for 17 years. This prompts Jessie to go on a quest to get answers to who she really is, and everything spirals out of control.
I really enjoyed this author's previous book, but this one fell short for me. There were twists at the end, but it just left me more confused and dissatisfied than anything. That said, give it a try and see if you come to a different opinion.

Was this review helpful?

What a great book this was! I enjoyed the dark and twisty story line. It kept me guessing and I never did quite get all the ins and outs figured out. This story of Jessie is everyone’s worst nightmare - being left alone in the world and then not quite knowing who you are. I would highly recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

Just like her other books, Mary Kubica successfully navigates the multi-person narration; this time between mother and daughter. The book shifts seamlessly between present day daughter Jessie, and mother Eden before Jessie was born. I thought I had the entire story figured out from an early point, but I was wrong -- there is a great plot twist! Mary Kubica never disappoints with her interesting plot lines and surprises. A must read for the fall!

Was this review helpful?

Jessie Sloane is on the path to rebuilding her life after years of caring for her ailing mother. She rents a new apartment and applies for college. But when the college informs her that her social security number has raised a red flag, Jessie discovers a shocking detail that causes her to doubt everything she’s ever known.

Finding herself suddenly at the center of a bizarre mystery, Jessie tumbles down a rabbit hole, which is only exacerbated by grief and a relentless lack of sleep. As days pass and the insomnia worsens, it plays with Jessie’s mind. Her judgment is blurred, her thoughts are hampered by fatigue. Jessie begins to see things until she can no longer tell the difference between what’s real and what she’s only imagined.

Meanwhile, twenty years earlier and two hundred and fifty miles away, another woman’s split-second decision may hold the key to Jessie’s secret past. Has Jessie’s whole life been a lie or have her delusions gotten the best of her?

My Thoughts: From the first page of When the Lights Go Out, I thought that I had a good grip on where this story was going. Narrated by two characters, twenty years apart, we slowly learn the story of a mother and a daughter. But the bizarre twists and turns lead us to scratch our heads and ponder everything we thought we knew.

Who is Jessica Sloane? What secrets did her mother, Eden, keep from her, and why? How did Jessica’s grief lead her down some very uncertain pathways? Has Jessica been living with a stolen identity? Was her life a lie…or a strange dream?

As I read, I couldn’t help thinking of movies I’ve seen in which the conclusion shows that the whole story has been a fabrication…or a Twilight Zone of some kind. So I felt stunned. And as if I, too, had been led into a kind of alternate reality, which I then had to interpret and sort through. Until the last sections, I was headed toward a 5 star rating…instead, 4 stars from me.

***My e-ARC came from the publisher via NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Mary Kubica, and NetGalley for the chance to read this book before it hits shelves later next month. This book was good, nothing like I had thought it would be. I liked how the author goes back and forth from past and present. I had so many questions as I was reading it, and then when I got to the end, I had even more. I didn't really like the twist at the end, like I said I still wanted to know some things. I really didn't like her friend Miranda and I felt like she was just parading around her fertility in front of Eden, knowing that they were having trouble. I think I want to read some more books by Kubica, seeing as this was my first one. Twisty ending for sure!

Was this review helpful?

I usually like Mary Kubica books but I was very frustrated with this one. The story was like a slow burn, not much happening, but I held on feeling it would all pay off in the end. However, I was disappointed with the twist at the end.

Was this review helpful?

Spoiler alert!

Flashback to 1986. I was 18 years old; sitting in my dorm room eagerly awaiting the Dallas season finale with my roommate. Way back when entire seasons didn’t drop on the same day. Back before binge watching whole seasons in a weekend was a thing. Back when you talked about the season finale all summer long.

And ding dang it… Bobby Ewing steps out of that shower. What the heck? How can that be? We all saw him die! Really? The entire last season nothing but a freakin’ dream. You could hear the shock and dismay up and down the hallway as we watched with our doors open.

Fast forward 32 years. I feel almost as cheated. Even if you are under 40 and did not watch with the rest of the world, you are probably familiar with the way that producers tried to bring back an actor that had quit the show and subsequently been killed off and buried.

The title should have been a huge clue. What happens “when the lights go out”? I thought it would be a bit more interesting than going to sleep and having a scary dream. Read the book synopsis (I won't regurgitate it here); it is so intriguing.
The book was great until the twist reveal. It was well-written and engaging moving between 1996/1997 and 18 years later, to tell this story of mother and daughter.
In the end, I gave it three stars. I mean, it was a surprise and diversion from her other books. And after all, she gave Jessie what everyone eventually craves at some point in their lives: a few more minutes with someone they love. Something even Pamela Ewing got!
#WhenTheLightsGoOut #NetGalley

Publication Date: September 4, 2018
Genre: Thriller, Suspense, Mystery
Cover: OK
Rating: 3 stars
Source: I received this book from the publisher via NetGalley in return for an honest review. Thank you for the opportunity to read this great book!

Was this review helpful?

I thought this book was a disappointment and I feel like the ending taken was a bit of a cheat. The beginning and middle of the book went smoothly and quickly for me, but then something changed. I will never be like Eden, wanting a child no matter the price paid on her finances and marriage. I will not go into debt just to have a baby. That mindset is ludicrous and foolish to me. So I didn't sympathize with Eden very much. I've loved all of Mary Kubica's earlier works but this one fell really flat for me. I hope I like her next book better.

Was this review helpful?

It's hard to rate a book when you really thoroughly enjoyed it up until a point and then found the remainder frustrating. (hide behind spoiler) If you tend to find dream sequences in movies and television annoying, as I do, perhaps this won't be the book for you. It almost seemed like a lazy way to wrap up the story, and as the events that Jessie dreamed were pretty intense and intriguing, I'd have loved to see the follow through on these instead.

3 stars because I did sincerely enjoy the majority of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Jessie is on her own after her mother's death. As she grieves the loss of her mother, Jessie moves into her own place and adjusts to life on her own. Unfortunately, Jessie soon learns something that makes her question everything. To complicate matters, Jessie has suffered from insomnia since her mother was dying in the hospital. Due to her lack of sleep, she starts having difficulty distinguishing fact from fiction.

Told from the alternating viewpoints of Jessie and Eden. Jessie is a young woman who suffers a great loss when her mother dies. Eden is her mother. Jessie's story takes place after her mother's death. Eden's story takes place twenty years earlier, before Jessie.

Both stories are interesting. Eden's story is about her desire to have a child, and the trouble she and her husband have with conceiving. Jessie's story is about her starting out on her own, moving to a new place, applying to college, but also grieving the loss of her mother. When she learns something that makes her question everything, an intriguing mystery follows.

I'm not a big fan of alternate points of view, especially when they involve alternate timelines. It is nice to see how the pieces come together in the end, but the ending isn't spectacular enough to make this a great read for me. I've seen a few reviews that complain of the ending for this one, but I felt it fit with the story being told.

A slow burn psychological thriller. Dark, tragic, and suspenseful.

I received a free eARC of this book from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was really looking forward to reading the latest from Mary Kubica, but I can’t say that I liked this one very much. It’s not a bad book--it kept my interest--but what a downer!

The deeper I got into the story, the more I wanted to find out Jessie Sloane’s true identity. Problem was, the story was bogged down in Jessie’s grief over her mother’s terminal cancer. Kubica is a master at tuning in to the feelings of loss.

It may sound like a real stretch, but the story ended up reminding me of an episode of Dallas, the prime time soap opera that was on in the 1980’s. I’ll let readers decide if that is a good thing or not.

I haven’t given up on Kubica and I still have some of her back list on my to-be-read list. This one is just not a favorite.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin-Hanover Square Press/Park Row for allowing me to read an advance copy and give my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars

It hurts my heart a little bit to give this such a low rating, because I LOVE Mary Kubica!

I liked the alternating flashbacks with the present day chapters, however, I really didn't like either character! I don't want to give away too much. I felt that Eden was awful, and while I can't imagine being in her place, I found her quite despicable at times and really ended up having no sympathy for her.

Similarly, Jessie was also a mess! Yes, her mother had just died but really, insomnia is what brings down our main character here? I can't relate, but it just didn't seem super plausible. I could understand being distraught with grief but the insomnia "episodes" delusions were just too much & she didn't seem at all interested in getting "help" so she could figure out what was actually going on. I was hoping she'd pull herself together and get this mystery solved once and for all, like a kick-ass protagonist should! It really stalled the plot - Jessie, repeatedly struggling everyday, seemingly getting nowhere. To me, not much happened.

Then... the ending. I have no words. I basically felt like I had wasted 300 pages. I'm sorry. I'm trying to not be overly critical but I really think MK sold herself short with this one and could've taken it in such a different direction. I think it had the makings of a fantastic novel, the premise was awesome, but for me it just did not hit the mark. If you are a die-hard Kubica fan, I think you have to at least try it out of loyalty. I would not read this one first though if you've never read anything by her, because it doesn't do her justice!

Was this review helpful?

When the Lights Go Out by Mary Kubica had so much potential. With an open mind, I delved into this book. I am not a huge fan of Kubica's but thought I would give this title a shot. The premise was interesting, a young woman, Jessie, is searching for her true identity after her mother dies. Great, I was really rooting for her to find out who her father was. Then there is Eden, a woman desperately trying to get pregnant, and when I say desperate, she is beyond any normal functioning person, and takes her desperation over the edge. This story, told in alternating viewpoints of Jessie and Eden, failed to ignite. Their respective personalities were over the top. Eden with her obsessive desire for a child, and Jessie became a raving insomniac, hallucinating all over the place, barely functioning. It was a stretch, and soon I lost interest. Weird characters are fine, unreliable characters are fine, but these were painted with a heavy brush that's never been cleaned. Then the ending! Really! For those who saw it coming, kudos to you. However, if you have invested so much time into reading a book, only to find that a cheap literary device is used at the end, it is a huge disappointment. For this reason, I can only give this story two stars.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read quite a few books by this author, some better than others, in my opinion. This was definitely one of her better reads, I thought the whole premise was amazing and done extremely well. It was unique and very intriguing. I like to read psychological thrillers without reading much of the synopsis, so this was more of a request based on the author. There were a lot of small details that added up to a great big picture novel. This is one that would make a great movie!

Jessie was so strong, I couldn’t imagine picking up my life and trying to figure out all the random stuff that was going wrong in her life while mourning her mother’s death. I’ve first hand seen the effects of insomnia, and I will say this was a topic widely researched and portrayed very well. I like that there was a sort of multiple point of view vibe. I thought the diary entries about Eden (our other POV) really added that sense of what the heck is going on? I loved that it was so mysterious.

I feel like if you are a fan of Paula Hawkins, you would really enjoy this book. I had a hard time trusting any of the characters and that is one of my favorite aspects in a psychological thriller. I don’t think I would suggest going into this one when you are starting out this genre. I thought the ending really made this whole book worth it, so if you are reading it and questioning if its for you please finish, you won’t be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

A very enjoyable book. Wanting to have a baby and no matter what you do it’s not working. It can destroy a marriage as well as consume your life. The characters in this book are believable and I could feel their pain as well as sympathize with their dilemma.

Was this review helpful?