Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This novel moved like a fast train, making me wonder: what happened to Geo in the past, and how do those events impact what's happening now? Geo is arrested for her part in the murder of her friend, but we don't really get to know the details until the end. Part thriller, part mystery, the book keeps you wondering and guessing.

I don't want to spoil the plot twists (though they're not too shocking for the avid mystery reader), but I will say that this novel had me torn. I loved the pace and thriller aspect, but I didn't like the graphic elements of the crime (which did nothing for the story), nor the 'twist' in the end, which made me thoroughly dislike the main character Geo.

A good mystery if you like a juicy, shocking read. Not so recommended if you read for character...

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for this Advanced Readers Copy!

This book is incredible. It is a complex plot as an easy read. Although the main character was caught up in some difficult issues, you couldn't help by cheer her on and wish for her peace. This book will have you guessing until the very end! Highly recommended. I will definitely be reading more Jennifer Hillier books!

Was this review helpful?

“The past is always with you, whether you choose to think about it or not, whether you take responsibility for it or not. You carry the past with you because it transforms you. You can try to bury it and pretend it never happened, but that doesn’t work. Geo knows that from experience. Because buried things can, and do, come back.”

Jar of Hearts gripped me from the start! A story that pulls all kinds of emotions, it’s honest and real, it’s shocking, and it’s full of twists that keep you engrossed to the end.

This story gives you mixed emotions. The writing is very detailed and leaves nothing to the imagination. It’s precise and well written. I enjoyed the way it was broken into parts. I especially enjoyed how the mystery is slowly revealed through these parts and pieces. The author does a great job of making you feel everything Georgina Shaw goes through throughout this story. Georgina’s past is catching up with her, but all the details of that fateful night have not yet been uncovered. As details emerge, and the story unfolds, these complex characters leave you stunned.

“But the guilt? It never leaves. It hangs around like a bad smell that no amount of bleach can eliminate. You can get yourself a new life, get yourself a new love, go to jail for the terrible thing you helped do…but the guilt is still there, stinking like an invisible piece of rotting garbage underneath your bed that won’t go away no matter how many attempts you make to clean it. Because that smell-of rotting flesh, of rotting soul-is you.”

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. The story was solid all throughout the book and it ended with a bang! Really good twists and turns - some of which you could see coming with all the build up/some of which were totally shocking! This is my first book from this author, but I will definitely be checking out more of her works.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun mystery! Kept me wanting to find out more. In the beginning i wanted to hate the protagonist, but in the end, it all turned around. Bravo, good read!

Was this review helpful?

This review is also posted in my blog :
https://onewordtoomuch.wordpress.com/2018/04/30/jar-of-hearts/

Thank you to Minotaur Books and Net Galley for a free copy of this book in trade for an honest review

It’s a complete story of love triangle, betrayal, the foolishness of youth, spiced with jealousy that leads to murder and story about second chances in life all written in a perfect package. Supporting the story is characters with emotional burdens that makes me feel sometimes sympathize, angry, or confused. This is a story that part of it you could relate to. Whether you’re the popular girl (like Angela Wong), or the unnoticed beauty (like Geo) or the helplessly falling in love but get no response (like Kaiser), or the cute guy with mental issue (like Calvin), each reader could emotionally attached to it.

Since the beginning, the story is getting back and forth between the past and the present. The story opens with the trial of Calvin James and Geo is sitting in the witness stand. She’s been hiding the secret of Angela’s death for 14 years and finally has to paid for her sins. Along the way, we got an insight on how Geo’s life in prison and what happen on the past. The story is easy to read and the transition between the present and past is done smoothly. But with each step, the past is revealed little by little that lead to the night of murder.

At first the plot is quite straight and easy, but it get twisted when there are 2 murders that looks like the Sweetbay Strangler style. Did Calvin do this? The clues are thrown in the previous chapter and the truth comes out later. I think this is a drama with a crime twist.

Characters are both strong and weak, as well as sick and sane, this book got the complete package. Geo as the main character is pictured as the popular pretty girl, independent but somehow falls with the wrong guy. But she came out strong and dare to take what life offers her: a second chance in love and life, making things right. Kaiser is your boy next door, someone nice, honest and dedicated to what he believed. He’s as tormented as Geo about Angela’s disappearance and death. He’s more tormented to see that Geo is more interested in Calvin than in him. Calvin is a conflicted character, there are things unconnected between his behavior. He could kill women by choking and raping them, but he can’t bear the sight of blood when he buried Angela’s body. This is a killer with a heart? Not sure how to categorize this guy though.

The end is quite surprising. Never see it coming. This is the first book from Jennifer Hillier that I read, but I would love to read other books from her.

Recommend for those who love a good crime and mystery story with a twisty plot and lots of drama.

Was this review helpful?

The description of Jennifer Hillier’s “Jar of Hearts” intrigued me, and I believed I was in for a treat. Reading the novel, however, soon blunted this feeling.

There are pages and pages of the author telling us how the characters feel, but little of the emotions show in the action, making it difficult to embrace the people we’re supposed to care about. It’s not that the author didn’t offer the information. It’s there, but the presentation is what transform the potential of an exciting scene into a vanilla blandness. On occasion, this bled into the dialogue, leaving the characters with unrealistic conversations.

Many instances contradict with my personal knowledge of how prisons are run. Inmates (especially in multiples) living in Maximum Security would find it almost miraculous to escape, Maximum Security is not “gen pop,” and Max inmates do not live in dormitory-style settings (perhaps there have been instances of maximum security inmates living this way, but it is hard to imagine it being allowed to happen). Questioning suspects by officers not allowed to offer Miranda rights wouldn’t occur (at least, not in the random manner described) and daily listening to lawyer-inmate phone conversations would constitute violations of lawyer-client privilege. The idea of paying a prison officer $100 a month for information that could be obtained at no cost – especially to a police officer working an active case – doesn’t make sense, though it is more believable than a Maximum Security inmate being given sharp objects and allowed to work in the prison barber shop or kitchen. I could go on, but you get the idea. A few hours of deeper research could have legitimized much of the background the author presented. The creation of a fictional prison didn’t bother me in the least. Twisting and bending normal prison procedures did.

Authors at times strive for whatever will inject a high level of surprising events, the “twist” that at times provides high satisfaction to readers. Sometimes, the best plots are those that contain the most simplistic elements. I felt enough suspense that the simplistic plotline would have succeeded. Ms. Hillier performed well in this area, the flip-flop of past and current events neatly dovetailing as she worked toward the climax. The multiple twists inserted at the end didn’t work for me, and the explanation to justify a major change in direction seemed rushed. Additionally, the abrupt change-in-direction of the major characters did not ring true, especially with those who I would label as psychopaths.

I completed the book because I was caught up in the suspense aspect I previously mentioned. I truly expected “Jar of Hearts” would finish with more power and believability than it did. Coupled with the elements listed above, this is an offering that will appeal to some readers as well as Ms. Hillier’s most devoted fans. Two-and-a-half (rounded to three) stars.

Was this review helpful?

Really riveting book. One of those books you don’t want to put down and don’t want to do anything else until you’ve finished it. Really liked this one. Haven’t read a book that grabbed me and held my interest in a really long time.

Was this review helpful?

When Geo was 16, her best friend was murdered by Geo's boyfriend. Geo unwillingly played a role in the crime and as a woman in her early 30s, spends time in prison. While she is in prison, her ex-boyfriend escapes. Murders begin and they are eerilly similar to the murder of Geo's friend. Geo is set to be released and she believes these murders to be a warning to her.

The book flashes back to the past, where we see the relationship unfold and understand more about the original crime. It also focuses in the present time, where detectives are working to solve the current crimes.

The book is a dark, edgy ,shocking, deeply terrifying psychological thriller. It is very fast paced. I found it to be a unique book, very different from the usual thriller. I couldn't put it down!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Macmillan/ Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for allowing me to read Jar of Hearts, by Jennifer Hillier.

As Georgia, aka Geo, and her best friend, Angela, head to a high school party for fun and excitement, they don’t have any idea how exciting the evening will be. One of the girls will not make it home and the other girl lives with the secret of that night for years. Calvin, the handsome older boy, has won the heart of one of these girls, and will change her life forever. The reader is kept in suspense wondering what really happened that night, who will be missing next, and how will anyone survive this terror in a small town. This book is a real page turner, keeping you guessing right up to the end. What an exciting read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you netgalley for the opportunity to read this book. Let me start off by saying it was amazing. This is the first book i have read by jennifer hillier , amd definately will not be the last.

Kaiser ,Angela, and Geo , are the best of friends in high school. Everything is wonderful until Geo meets Calvin. At sixteen years old she falls head over heels with him. Hes older and mysterious, with a dark side that Geo sees but at sixteen she chooses to ignore . At that age we dont listen to anyone and this will change her life forever. When Angela disappears and is found murdered and dismembered no one suspects Geo or Calvin and she leaves Calvin and memories of that day far behind . A successful businesswoman she still has the fear that the police will show up and arrest her for helping Calvin cover up the murder of her friend, and finally they do.

Fourteen years later Geo and Calvin are convicted for Angela's murder. Geo serves five years and gets out expecting to move on and rebuild her life again. Unfortunately some secrets you just cant put behind you and forget about them because they come back to haunt you....
This book gave me chills at times at other times it made me sad. I love how the author lets us see the point of view from Geo at 16 and Geo after prison at 35 . We view life and love so differently as a teenager than we do once we are adults. This book is a must read i could not put it down until i knew what Geo has been hiding all these years. Anyone who loves a good thriller or mystery will love this book.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this story was .....Wow, just amazing really.
I had some serious anxiety while reading this book. Those characters, the setting, the overall story was really just brilliant.
This was my first time reading a book by this author. I very much enjoyed this story and look forward to reading her other books.
I received an ARC e-copy through NetGalley.
#JarofHearts #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I definitely wanted to finish this book sooner!! Sucks being busy a lot but wow! Jennifer Hillier did not disappoint. This was my first book of hers to read and I was highly impressed. Georgina Shaw, Geo, was once in love with Calvin James...the serial killer wanted for the murder of at least three different women. One of those being her best friend Angela Wong. 14 years later, Angela’s body is discovered and Geo was the only person who knew what happened. This book will grab ahold of you and keep you anxious to know just what will happen. You think you know it all and then Hillier hits you...

Was this review helpful?

This is my first book by Jennifer Hillier and I went into it blind, but knowing anything about her writing style nor anything about this book.... I was pleasantly surprised! This book had a grip on me from the first chapter. I could not turn the pages fast enough to solve this mystery !

Was this review helpful?

A dark thriller at its finest, Jar of Hearts is well written and well plotted. Juxtaposing the point of view of a convicted con and a police officer, this story keep me reading until the last gruesome page. Horrifically graphic at times, this gripping tale of friendship, love, and betrayal will not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this story. The protagonist, Georgina Shaw, Geo to friends, is as complex a character as you will ever meet. Early in the story she’s snatched from her successful, high profile job and packed off to prison for a series of poor choices she made as a teen. Bad boyfriend, a night of insanity, the murder of her best friend, and a collision of circumstances ruin her life, and those of many others. And poses the question: What happened to Angela Wong? And where is her body? As the narrative moves back and forth in time, her actions and motives are exposed as the plot twists and turns, ultimately leading to a shocking conclusion. Well written and paced, this is one you must read.

DP Lyle, award-winning author, lecturing, story consultant

Was this review helpful?

Holy page turner! This book had me hooked from chapter one. The most popular girl in school goes missing and 14 years later her remains are found.....in her best friend’s yard. Who can you trust?? Very well written. Easy to want to know more about the characters. I would actually look forward to a follow up on this one. I would like to see the progression of their lives “after”.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book! Perfect suspense novel. It revolves around Georgina Shaw as a 16 year old and then again as an adult. Lots of secrets, twists, and suspense. I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Geo is a successful executive working for a Pharmaceutical company and planning her wedding to its
CEO when she is arrested for her involvement in a 14-year-old crime. When she was 16 her best friend Angela disappeared and Geo withheld what she knew about her murder. Angela may have been the first victim of a serial killer called the "Sweetbay Strangler"--who just happens to be Geo's ex-boyfriend and first love Calvin James. Arresting Gia is the police detective on the Sweetbay Strangler investigation and he was once part of the trio of high school friends--Angela, Geo and Kai. Both Geo and Calvin are sent to prison--Geo serves her five years and Calvin is put away for for life. When Calvin escapes and new bodies turn up, it seems Geo may be in danger.

A dark and twisty thriller with a rapid-fire pace and interesting story and characters, there is a lot going on in this book--so many secrets, twists and turns. Geo is an interesting character--we're given more than enough reasons not to like her but it's hard not to feel sympathetic. Her time in prison and how it changes her and further hardens her is interesting--it gave me strong Orange is the New Black (series--I still need to read the book) vibes. I mentioned dark and twisty--the murders are graphic and hard to read about--especially the new murders which have an even more disturbing twist to them--so fair warning if you have issues with graphic violence and physical and sexual abuse. I do wish that I didn't see some of the big twists coming--I think some things were a bit obvious, causing me to yell at Kai for not catching on sooner. But there were still some surprises and I didn't want to put it down until the end. This is the first book of Hillier's I have read although I happened to have had both Creep and Freak loaded on my Kindle and her writing in this one made me immediately read both after I turned the last page of Jar of Hearts.

Note: I was given a copy of Jar of Hearts through NetGalley for the purpose of a fair review. I was not compensated in any way and my thoughts and views are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Holy crap!!!! What a rush!!! This is the 3rd book of Jennifer Hillier's that I have read and I really enjoyed it just as much as Creep and Freak! The flashback scenes are well done so you are not confused in the timeline, The characters are real, and even though Geo is no angel I admire her determination to make it through her time in prison. It's creepy, and twisted, but it was written by Jennifer Hillier and that says it all!

Was this review helpful?