Cover Image: CITY 1

CITY 1

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Light-hearted manga about young adults navigating life. I didn't really find it humorous which is what I expected going in so the overall reading experience was underwhelming but the art was well-crafted.

Was this review helpful?

Slice of life manga about a slacker in her early twenties who is attempting to dodge all responsibilities (rent, repaying loans to her friends, etc) with varying levels of success. The humor is very slapstick and the art is cartoonish. I can see how it would appeal to fans of that style of comedy but it's not for me, unfortunately.

Was this review helpful?

It's funny because I don't typically like comics. I was surprised that I liked this! I expected to enjoy it, but I really liked it a lot!

Was this review helpful?

The concept of City by Keiichi Arawi was an interesting concept. The comic starts with Midori Nagumo, who is in debt and is behind on payments. Though the reader is introduced to different characters, there is no flow to it. Many characters were introduced with each chapter, giving it a different pov depending on the character. I have to admit that some scenes were hilarious like the “duck lips” scene between Nagumo and Niikura. I would like to see the manga get adapted, maybe it might be far more comedic than reading it. If the story had centered primarily on one character than several, I could have loved City far more. I am interested to see what the other volume may hold. This was an average manga for me, but let’s see what the future holds for it.

Was this review helpful?

This is a very fun read full of genuinely hilarious skits from the characters. Not only is it full of humour, without me realising it, it even touched me about hope and dreams.

This is the kind of story I would totally read after an exhausting and tiring day. It's just so much fun and it leaves me feeling happy and craving for more.

Was this review helpful?

Keiichi Arawi's City is a graphic novel that will make anyone laugh while reading it. I didn't expect much when I downloaded the reading copy provided by the publisher. But after I was done perusing it, I want to read more of the funny banters of the characters in the story. I'm anticipating the release of the second volume of this excellent manga by the author next month, and hopefully that there's a chance that there will be an ARC also of the said volume.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting concept, but the plot was disjointed and had to follow. However, the artwork was relatively strong, and with a bit of polish this series might flesh out and become more appealing.

Was this review helpful?

A quirky unique manga from the creator of Nichijou, full of wacky and zany Japanese humour. City is made up of a series of short character driven stories all centred around the city they live in.

Was this review helpful?

Nagumo is dirt broke, unemployed and has a gambling addiction. She's also behind on her rent payments. She steals an expensive idol, breaks it and ends up working at a restaurant to pay back the owner. The owner just so happens to be the son of her landlady, so it's all very messy. Hilarity ensues. Nagumo is a pretty entertaining, lazy bum that makes everyone's lives a living hell. Basically, Nagumo is a toned-down version of Haruko from FLCL.

There is no real linear story in City; it comprises of little stories that overlap here and there with recurring characters like Tatewaku, the gullible teenage boy who pratfalls at every joke that his father and sister chuck at him. There's also wacky policeman that is completely incompetent at doing his job and some minor characters who are thrown slapdash into the middle of things.

Overall, City was a fun read but it left me wanting. I love the simplistic style, fast pace and blurry action. I enjoy how everyday life is flipped on its head and transformed into something a little crazy, but I feel that the author was reluctant and left a lot of the potential hilarity untapped. I'd definitely want to read the next volume.

"Perhaps if I kept stacking up such happy moments, I'd have a crazy amount of happiness"

Was this review helpful?

I picked this book up for the cute cover art and ended up enjoying the style quite a bit. This manga relies on slapstick humor that at times was very confusing, yet I ended up liking the oddly paced stories that overlapped and skipped around a bit. Primarily following one young protagonist who is broke and always trying to borrow money to pay her rent, this book weaves together a restaurant owner, a police officer, an elderly woman, a young lady working for the news with the horoscope section, and more characters together in the city in which they all live. City is a quick read with a very cute art style.

Was this review helpful?

Ich habe leider nie Nichijou gesehen oder gelesen. Das was ich kenne ist aber unglaublich unterhaltsam. The City ist ein neuer Manga von Keiichi Arawi. Die beiden teilen sich ihren Stil in Bezug auf die Zeichnungen von Charakteren sowie ihren kuriosen Humor. Nagumo ist arbeitslos, sie hat ihr gesamtes Geld bei einem Pferderennen verspielt und muss jetzt irgendwie die Miete begleichen. Nikura ist Nagumos Freundin, hat ihr schon oft Geld geliehen und lässt sich diesmal auf keinen Fall ausnutzen. Es folgen bizarre und unglaublich lustige Situationen, übermächtige Großmütter, mysteriöse Statuen und vielleicht sogar ein Job für Nagumo.
Ich sage bizarrer Humor und stelle fest, dass es schwer ist Arawis Humor in Worte zu fassen ohne jede Punchline zu verraten. Es gibt beispielsweise ein Orakel in der Tageszeitung. Diese ordnet einen "Glücksgegenstand" einem Sternzeichen zu. Als dieser ein Minirock ist, muss Tatewaku, der in einem Restaurant arbeitet, überlegen ob er jetzt einen Minirock tragen sollte oder nicht. Arrrgh, lest es einfach, es ist großartig. Jeder Witz sitzt und es gibt so unglaublich viele Kleinigkeiten die zusammenkommen, dass es eine Freude ist in dieser Stadt durch die Gegend zu laufen. Oh und es gibt einen alten Typen der überall Kameras angebracht hat und das Geschehen versucht sowohl zu beobachten als auch zu beeinflussen.

Ein guter Comicladen, der englische Mangas führt, dürfte The City demnächst auf Lager haben. Ansonsten bestellt das Büchlein einfach. Ich habe für diese kurze Review eine digitale Kopie des Manga via NetGalley erhalten.

Was this review helpful?

Well, City is actually better than Nichijou, which was a good thing, since I'm not a fan of absurd Japanese humor. Arawi's style is so distinct and his humor isn't the easiest one to digest, really. The art feels slightly unfinished compared to Nichijou. Everything happens in a nameless city or it could just be called City, who knows. Different characters do things, work and live and there's interaction and happenings. Slice of life basically without any deeper meaning or plot. Midori Nagumo is the supposed main character and she's out of money and tries to come up with plans how to make money and not lose her apartment due to it. Like this, all the characters are somehow bound to Nagumo and her craziness. Basic Arawi, then. This works for a couple of books, but tends to get boring along the way when there's nothing to the comic. For now it's OK.

The font is absolutely hideous and it varies. It looks detached from the comic and I just don't get why it changes for no good reason. The basic one looks cheap too and doesn't fit with the style at all. The art looks slightly crude at times and the line work is shady from time to time too. City is newer than Nichijou so this makes no sense unless Arawi has changed for more rougher style. I'm amazed this series was translated, since Arawi and his humor aren't the thing here. Yet, it's good that stuff like this gets translated and not only the most obvious ones - just that there could be better ones.

Was this review helpful?

'City, 1' by Keiichi Arawi is the first manga I've read that had me laughing out loud at the strange characters and situations.

It all takes place in a small section of a city. Midori Nagumo owes money for her rent and her elderly landlady is after her. This sets in motion a chain of events including a restaurant punch card, a friendly policeman, a boy wearing a lucky miniskirt, and a surprising martial arts master. When it's all done, I met quite a few characters and lives in this little section of the city.

I loved the humor and the art style of this manga. A lot of times, the humor can kind of go over my head, but the ludicrous situations and the weight put on normal things made for some great comic setups.

I received a review copy of this manga from Vertical Comics, Kodansha Comics, and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

I feel like this book was the preview of a really awesome series. We were introduced first to Midori - this young girl with an extremely snarky and self-serving attitude. She's avoiding her landlady - a crazy strong old lady - because she can't pay her rent. Why? Because she gambled it all away! I was surprised when the synopsis referred to the girl she is constantly pestering for money as her "best friend". Midori isn't exactly the type of girl I would want as a best friend. One who can be described as keep your friends close, your enemies closer. As I said, self-serving.

Then there was a brief blip about a girl who thought crumbling an eraser was fun. Was this a flashback of Midori before she became a college student? If so, oh my gosh girl, what happened to you?!

Then there's the little blip about the broccoli. Though I consider our broccoli-photographing girl a bit crazy to consider Midori a friend, I enjoyed their encounters. And the hilarious thing is - as she's laying on the floor taking a photo of broccoli, I thought oh my gosh, you're a booknerd with food! Because how many times have I set books up on the floor and sat there with my phone, trying to get just the right picture? 

Final verdict - I am eager to see how this series progresses. It's definitely one that I will be buying in paperback format so that I can give it the attention it deserves. Midori is definitely one frustratingly intriguing character.

Was this review helpful?

City 1 is a surreal fast-moving episodic Sunday Comics-style manga.

Nagumo (20) doesn’t have her rent money. She tried to double her money by playing the horses and lost. Her landlady, called the Granny, is insistent. Niikura, Nagumo’s best friend cannot loan her the rent money. Nagumo goes through many schemes trying to pay her rent. Granny is a street brawler (literally).

City 1 contains twelve 12-page stories. All involve city life and build on each other. Some are ironic, some are humorous but all do not seem like traditional manga.

I’m not sure if the problem is in the translation or me not understanding Japanese culture well enough despite my worship of Studio Ghibli and mecha anime. Do Japanese really touch the gills of a shiitake mushroom or rub an eraser to relax? City 1 is clearly meant to be a madcap comedy. It fell short of that for me. However, tastes vary so I’ll give this comic 3 stars.

Thanks to the publisher, Kodanska Comics, and NetGalley for a copy.

Was this review helpful?

Very funny and had characters that are actually relatable. I believe some of the older teens at my library will enjoy reading it when we purchase it!

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun and enjoyable read, which I would recommend for almost any age above seven or so. I am eager for the next book in the series. The whole book is a bit random, but I love that, and a lot of times it made me laugh out loud. The illustrations were thrilling, and (I don't know if it was translated, but if it was) the translation was brilliant.

Was this review helpful?

1.5 stars

I do like manga but I didnt enjoy this volume. I liked the artwork but I didnt really understand what the book is trying to convey. It seems to be about the antics of the main character who is always broke and borrowing money from a flatmate. I think some of the jokes and the storyline have been lost in translation. Not a good one for me, although the artwork is enjoyable.

Copy provided via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It might not be readily apparent since I read such a large volume of fantasy and science fiction, but I've always really enjoyed a good slice of life manga or anime. I was extremely excited to pick up just such a manga from the creator of Nichijou. City Vol. 1 by Keiichi Arawi is a slice of life manga with surreal humor and great characters.

City Vol 1 is set in an unnamed city somewhere in Japan. Our main character is Midori Nagumo, a college student with no cash but plenty of get rich quick schemes. She lives in a regular apartment building in a regular city that is filled with memorable, definitely unordinary people. This story revolves around Midori as she struggles to pay off her debt to the landlord and the people who live and work in her neighborhood.

Midori is a great character. She is always in debt and always has a scheme. Alas, most of her schemes don’t come to fruition and her elderly landlord will go to any lengths to get her cash. Her best friend knows better than to lend her money, going out of her way to avoid such scenarios, but to little avail. Midori’s reckless, irresponsible, and tons of fun to read about.

Though Midori is the main character, there is a large supporting cast. All of the characters are related somehow, even if it isn’t quite apparent at first. Chapters tend to be short and focused on a smaller set of characters. Indeed, we don't see much of the city itself. The majority of the action takes place in a few key locations that are all in the same neighborhood. Character's cross each other's paths, sometimes without knowing their connections. It's a small world filled with quirky people who are each just trying to go about their daily business.

This is a slice of life manga with plenty of surreal humor. If you like that genre, you’ll probably find at least some chapters that you’ll really like. Certain sections prove more memorable than others, but overall the manga was quite a fun read.

The art is unmistakably Arawi’s. Or, if you’re like me, makes you exclaim ‘oh, that looks like Nichijo!’. Characters are downright adorable and have rather expressive faces. Basically, if you enjoyed Nichijou’s art style you will enjoy City as well.

At the end of the volume is a map of the city where the story takes place. Unfortunately, nothing on the map was translated. While I like the concept of including the map and appreciate this inclusion, not bothering to translate anything on it renders it rather useless for anyone who can’t read Japanese.

City Vol 1 by Keiichi Arawi is a great slice of life manga that was ton’s fun. If you like slice of life manga I would highly suggest picking up a copy of this.

Was this review helpful?

I am trying to expand my reading and have recently gotten into graphic novels. This was a super quick and fun read. Looking forward to continuing the series. Loved that each was different but in the end in all made sense.

Was this review helpful?