Cover Image: Probable Claws

Probable Claws

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I'm a sucker for this series - and this is one of the better installments. This time around Harry and her various animal friends are investigating a murder (of course) - a drive by shooting that takes their small town by surprise. Why was Gary targeted? You'll meet a new character who will try to help solve the mystery. Simultaneously, in alternating chapters, there's a story line set right after the Revolutionary War that will give you lots of information on Virginia history. Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC. If you haven't read these before, feel free to start here. If you have, you know Brown has a good sense of humor and a gentle way with her animal characters.

Was this review helpful?

This is a mystery series that I've been reading many years. This book is interesting with the mystery but also the historical story as well. I'm not a big fan of the today / year's past style of books, but this one was written well and it was very clear what was happening in which time period. The mystery is well-written and fast-moving so that it really kept my interest.

These characters are old friends that I've grown to love. I love the description of the Virginia countryside and would like to visit. I'm already looking forward to the next one in the series!

Was this review helpful?

I have heard much about these books, so I was glad to get a chance from NetGalley to read and review this book. I was really disappointed in Probable Claws. There was too much verbage, for one thing! The animals were cute, but not outstanding. The mysteries surrounding the deaths were too drawn out. The two time periods did not help any. I felt neither time period mystery was satisfactorily solved. In general, I was hoping for a good mystery but ended up being glad when the book was finally finished!

Was this review helpful?

Rita Mae Brown continues to knock her sneaky pie books out of the park. My students read her series every year.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great read - very interesting and entertaining! I loved the historical parts interwoven throughout the story. It took the story to a deeper level. The characters, both human and animal, kept the story flowing and engaged the reader. It was well written and a wonderful recreational read!

Was this review helpful?

Probable Claws, Rita Mae Brown’s 27th Mrs. Murphy Mystery, employs a lot of the things we like best in these mysteries such as ingenious murder, engaging banter between the animals as Harry Hairsteen’s totes her pets around town into possible dangerous situations and, of course, that particular southern charm that Brown uses to elevate even the most diabolical of her characters. That charm extends to additional personalities that seemingly have nothing to do with the folks in Crozet only because they exist in the 1700’s. Eventually, we are given clues to the connection between the past and the present but, as much as I enjoyed the side story, it was a little disconcerting. I was left with the impression that RMB enjoyed writing about the 18th century mystery more than she did the 21st.

Was this review helpful?

Another installment of the Mrs. Murphy mysteries, but where is Mrs. Murphy (a cat)? She is mentioned once in awhile, but Pewter takes full stage in this novel. I miss the interaction between Mrs. Murphy and Tucker. I also miss the simple mystery and simple interactions between Harry and the people of Crozet. What happened to Harry's best friend Susan? How can this book cover several months in Harry's life and Susan is barely mentioned?
The mystery itself is well done, but I frankly skipped over all the historical chapters that are interspersed in the book. I'm not interested in Virginia history. And, the philosophical discussions between the characters seem rather staged and artificial, as if the author wants to put her political/philosophical opinions out there, but is trying too hard not to be obvious about it.
I'm disappointed in the direction this series has taken in the past few books. It's no longer a nice cozy mystery that I can relax with. It's got too much other stuff in there that maybe some would say adds depth and complexity to the story line, but it's just not why I read these books. And, the artwork has gone downhill as well. The person who did the illustrations in the early books really was able to put life into the animals. Not so much with this illustrator.

Was this review helpful?

We gain new characters in the animal population of Harry Harristeen's farm and a Crozet architect, adding some new twists to the adventuresome tales of crime solving in a small Virginia town.

A gifted architect is gunned down outside of his office as he's talking to Harry and her companions. They are horrified as a motorcyclist aboard a new Ducati speeds up to them, shoots the architect and speeds away before anyone can do anything.

Did he offend someone, or is it related to his architectural business? When a lot of his files and archives disappear following the locking of the office, it reveals that the key to the crime must be rooted in the notes and records of past jobs, and county building codes.

Pewter, Mrs. Murphy, and Tucker are always on hand when Harry goes about town, and they meet a large spider living in a baseboard crack in the architect's office. There's also a small metal stud, similar to the studded decorations on the motorcyclist's leathers, or on other leather items. Is it a related clue?

Another person dies suddenly in her office of unknown causes, as her young wolfhound puppy watches in horror. He tries to wake her up as her co-workers discover that something terrible has happened.

Are these things connected? Is there a big construction company involved? Pirate the puppy needs a new home, too, and the deputy brings him to the Harristeen home, a waif who needs a loving place to be.

This book also has an antebellum Virginia story line, back in the slavery era, and I'm sure it will connect more obviously to the present-day story line, but I usually skim through those chapters. I do enjoy the full-length books devoted to those early Virginians.

If Virginia truly does have those large spiders as described in this book, I don't think I want to make their acquaintance.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC from Netgalley and I'm glad I did. I love this series and I eagerly await the next. I normally don't like books that switch back and forth in time but Rita Mae Brown does a fabulous job. I feel like these people are my friends and of course who doesn't love the animals. Definitely 5 stars and please hurry with more!

Was this review helpful?

I love this series and I love that now there is history involved. Harry still gets into all kinds of trouble and the animals help her get out of said trouble.. Was thrilled by new pet...

Was this review helpful?