Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I read this book, and form the hype surrounding it, I really expected it to be amazing. Unfortunately, it just didn't grab me and immerse me into the story how I hoped it would. I think what really took away form the plot was the switching of narrative and how the structure of the story was set up. The podcast elements where hard to invision for me and I had a really hard time connecting to Sadie on a level that would have helped me to understand her motives more. I understand that losing her sister who had become like a child to her was difficult and that she had a rough childhood, but I really had a hard time believing her. I gave this story a solid three stars because there were elements that I liked, but it didn't do anything amazing for me as far as the reading experience went.

Was this review helpful?

A great mystery book. The concept of the book was amazing and the Author made sure she didn’t stray from her point in the book or dragged the story. I don’t think I ever read a book so dark and twisted like Sadie.
Thank you to netgalley and St.Martin Press for a copy to give my honest review

Was this review helpful?

cw: pedophilia, CSA, abuse, drug addiction
disclaimer: I received an advanced copy of this book from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for review consideration. All of the opinions presented below are my own.

It seems like nearly everyone has been talking about Sadie lately. Intriguingly, pieces of it felt like they tied pretty closely to The Female of the Species, which I read directly beforehand. The formatting is what was most interesting about it. Half of the book is a podcast -- where I’d imagine the audiobook version would have come in very handy -- and the other half is from Sadie’s perspective directly. In this way, things that we could never necessarily know from one perspective are revealed to us through the other. While this method could be flawed in the wrong hands, Courtney Summers is able to carefully craft a chilling masterpiece, slowly (but not too slowly) revealing the full story to her readers.

Was this review helpful?

In Sadie, we have West, a podcaster who hears a story about a local girl and is now on the hunt for Sadie and to find out what exactly happened to her and where is she now. Sadie has a very mysterious feel to her, people tend to think she went on the hunt for her sister’s killer but where and who she thinks this person is a mystery. Sadie sees herself responsible for Maddie’s death since she was the one looking after her after their mother left them. We see Sadie’s dark side but as we slowly see what kind of life she has led her pain and anger is understandable.

I loved everything about this read. I listened to the audio which I recommend because it's amazing! I loved the podcast idea and the interviews format which totally gave me Dateline vibes. I enjoyed how all these different styles gave it a definitely unique feel and made it so interesting not to mention it really added to that dark creepy kind of feel...in a good way!!

This was without a doubt one of my favorite reads of the year, I felt for Sadie and the things she had to endure in her life. I liked how she was strong despite her hardships in life, even if that meant doing things that weren’t right. All in all, Sadie is a winner, this has a lot of elements I look for in a great read. I like the different points of views we got which just made the read so much more enjoyable. If you get the chance to read this please do you won't be disappointed.

Was this review helpful?

I'm struggling on how to start this review because I'm not sure how to articulate this feeling I have now that I've finished SADIE. I'm heartbroken, angry, awed, and ready to push this book into the hands of every reader I meet.

SADIE follows the investigation into missing teenager, Sadie Hunter who left town without a word after her sister, Mattie, was brutally murdered. Desperate for answers, Sadie's honorary Grandma, May Beth tasks a radio host, West McCray, to look into her disappearance.

The format was part radio show transcript and part narrative, as Sadie hunted down the man who killed her sister and McCray searched for Sadie months later.

Like Sadie herself, this book was brutal, unforgiving, and deeply emotional. Even though we never met Mattie, I felt I knew as much about her as Sadie. Her presence was so engrained in the book as West investigated their lives and Sadie worked to avenge her. My heart ached for Sadie and Mattie and all the broken girls that are like them.

I really think, despite it being a hard read, that this book should be required reading for it's hard truths and wonderful storytelling. Courtney Summers is a master storyteller, subtly laying out details that create a devastating account of characters that feel as real as the people on the news.

Thank you, Courtney Summers for sharing this story. Thank you for telling Sadie's story, the entirety of it, ugliness and all.

Was this review helpful?

Sadie by Courtney Summers is an eye opener. This book is filled with so much sadness. When you come across the book, know this, Sadie is a very difficult book to read but you won’t want to put it down. I really like that Summers tackles some really difficult subjects.

A little about Sadie: Sadie has a younger sister named Mattie. Her mom is an addict that always has a new boyfriend. Sadie does not know who her father is. She is continually getting bullied at school for her stutter. Like I said, not an easy read. Then Sadie loses her favorite person in the world. Her sister.
This book deals with so much. If you want a book with hard subjects this is the one for you. Some of the subjects that are covered are neglect, abuse, sexual abuse, drugs, murder, revenge, heartache, the list goes on. From the very beginning of this book you know that Sadie is out for revenge. The author definitely gives you an easy way out.

I thought that the way the Summers wrote Sadie that it was super unique. The story is told through Sadie’s point of view and podcasts. This podcast is obsessed with Sadie and telling her story. I liked the dual narrative because we were able to see the outside of Sadie’s situation but at the same time we got to learn from Sadie herself.

This book is not an easy read at all. I thought it was very well written. Sometimes it can be tough reading or even writing about difficult subjects. I thought Courtney Summers did a wonderful job.

Was this review helpful?

Sadie hasn't had an easy life. She has raised her little sister, practically by herself, with little to no gratitude. When Mattie is found dead, Sadie's world spirals into despair. After the police do not bring the killer to justice, Sadie decides she's going to take it into her own hands and seek revenge for her baby sister, who she loved more than anyone.

She goes missing, her car is found, but there's no lead on where she was going or who she was searching for. Then West McCray joins the fray. West is a journalist and radio personality, he starts an investigation of his own, looking for Sadie. What he uncovers is not what you would expect.

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this. It was everything I want out of a YA mystery/suspense book. The intrigue of Sadie's path, the people she encounters along the way, and the secrets she uncovers is one thing. But the way that Courtney Summers presented the story was so unique. It makes the story unfold in a way that only adds to the story. Sadie definitely has those stereotypical teenager moments, Summers doesn't make her teenage characters seem unrealistic. Sadie is following a trail to a person she is quite sure is guilty, she's asking questions that are relevant, and moving through the struggles with realistic responses. She doesn't have some supernatural trait that makes her know when someone is lying and she doesn't have the backing of a governmental agency who sees the next prodigy detective. She's a normal teen, who has had a hard life, who wants answers and justice for the person she loved most. I would highly recommend this book for anyone who loves mystery and suspense, but especially if you're looking for those qualities in a YA novel.

Was this review helpful?

I was fascinated by this YA mystery! 'Sadie' is a gripping story of a girl (Sadie) who disappears a few months after her little sister, Mattie, was murdered. Devastated, Sadie sets out to find Mattie’s killer.

Throughout the story, we slowly learn the awful truth’s of Sadie’s lonely life with her mother, what she endured growing up, and how she tried to make a difference in Mattie’s life. How she wanted to protect Mattie.

West McCray, a producer and radio personality, receives a call from May Beth, the girls' surrogate grandmother, who asks West to help locate Sadie. He agrees. He also begins a serialized podcast chronicling his investigation with interviews and information he uncovers along the way.

The story is told from two points of view. One from Sadie’s and the other in the form of McCray’s podcast, “The Girls.” The cool thing is you can actually listen to the podcast on Apple or Stitcher.

Although the podcast is really well done, and I listened to most of the episodes before I started reading the book, I found it a little redundant as the podcast is pretty much word for word what is written in the book. I would have liked some added information, but again, the podcast is brilliant and well made.

Sadie meets some interesting people during her quest, and there are some twists and turns in the story, some I didn’t see coming! And as in life, there are some questions we never find an answer to.

'Sadie' is a raw, dark and engrossing novel. I wasn’t sure what Sadie’s plan was, or if she even knew. I didn't know if she would find the man she was looking for, or if she did, could she accomplish what she set out to do - which is to kill him.

Was this review helpful?

Courtney Summers knocked it out of the park with Sadie. Sadie was a quick read; you'll have a hard time putting it down.

Told as a podcast, Summers is in tune with what is culturally relevant. The podcast perspective gives some relief from the dark and raw content of Sadie's POV.

Highly recommend (mature audience) - 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I really thought I was going to love this book. I'd heard so much buzz about it before hand. I love podcasts, especially crime podcasts, and I love a good revenge/mystery. But I just... didn't care for it. I can't exactly put my finger on why. It's cohesive, with a straightforward plot, but something about it just felt "too much." I will attribute this to the writing style, I guess it's just not for me, and to the sensationalization of the podcast aspects. Maybe it wasn't the intention -- but it felt like mocking to me. The uncomfortableness of the narration is the *point* here, and normally I love that style, but I just felt bored with this one. I know I'm in the minority...

Was this review helpful?

I really like the way Courtney Summers tells the story of Sadie, with two points of view. I really want to know what happened to her with the journalist West McCray. Sadie is a character who is always alone, all by herself. It is painfull to read, I feel so deeply with Sadie. Il like the way how the author cover this topic. A good discovery of the writing of Courtney Summers.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this book was just not for me. I was unable to finish. I tried to like it as it was getting good reviews but I could not connect with any of the characters or the storyline.

Was this review helpful?

This title caught my eye while browsing NetGalley...

“Sadie hasn't had an easy life. Growing up on her own, she's been raising her sister Mattie in an isolated small town, trying her best to provide a normal life and keep their heads above water.
But when Mattie is found dead, Sadie's entire world crumbles. After a somewhat botched police investigation, Sadie is determined to bring her sister's killer to justice and hits the road following a few meager clues to find him.
When West McCray—a radio personality working on a segment about small, forgotten towns in America—overhears Sadie's story at a local gas station, he becomes obsessed with finding the missing girl. He starts his own podcast as he tracks Sadie's journey, trying to figure out what happened, hoping to find her before it's too late.
Courtney Summers has written the breakout book of her career. Sadie is propulsive and harrowing and will keep you riveted until the last page.”

Whew, what a book!
Immediately, I became engrossed in this story... following Sadie along her journey for justice and
West McCray's radio podcast, 'The Girls'.

Everything about Sadie felt gritty and real. Especially in these days when so much abuse & crimes
go unreported and people are never punished.

While I've had Courtney Summers on my radar for a long time, I've never read one of her books
until now. Believe I will be looking into her works further... her writing was very good.

Honestly, I can't put into words how this book made me feel.
I would highly recommend it, despite the tough subject matter.


I received this electronic book from NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.

Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for this opportunity!

Was this review helpful?

This book stole my heart and delivered a gut-wrenching and mysterious story that left me wanting more. It's the story of a young woman's anger and pain and desire for vengeance after the murder of her little sister. This is a thriller, but it's more than that -- it's a twisted love story -- and one that stayed with me well after I had finished reading.

Was this review helpful?

Compelling mystery with a fascinating protagonist. I was intrigued by her development. Excellent addition to the classroom.

Was this review helpful?

Courtney Summers's new book, SADIE, is told in two alternate timelines. In one timeline Sadie is searching for her younger sister's killer. In the other timeline a Serial-type podcast host, West McCray, is searching for the missing Sadie. McCray's sections are told in the podcast format, which makes for a really interesting read.

SADIE is suspenseful and serious and sad. It is about some really rough (but important) themes: revenge, small-town poverty, drug addiction, child molestation, abandonment. (Huge CW for child abuse.)

I read and really enjoyed SOME GIRLS ARE and ALL THE RAGE by Ms. Summers, so I knew that I could expect something gritty and painful with this one, as that seems to be her specialty. And I was not wrong. This book packs a huge "oomph."

I have one very specific complaint about this book. It's that the setting is so underdeveloped. I think I may have been especially sensitive to the setting issues because I grew up in Colorado, where the story is said to take place, and happened to reading this book while I was back visiting. This should have added a richness to the experience of reading Sadie, but instead it put a damper on it because there is absolutely no sense of place in the book at all. Where is Cold Creek, Colorado? Is it a dingy little mountain town, a dingy little desert town, a dingy little prairie town? I can't picture it at all. Also, Sadie drove all over Colorado, and I have no idea where she was driving. Was she driving through the mountains or the prairies or the desert? Does she cross from one to the other? There are quite a few distinct environments to pick from in Colorado, and anyone who has driven through it knows that to drive through Colorado is an experience. But none of that comes through in the book. I feel like Sadie lives on a white piece of paper. And that definitely detracted from the gritty realism the book was going for.

Also, as far as I could tell from the book, Sadie never leaves Colorado (and if she does leave the state the book really should have told me so), but at one point the characters have to travel from one town to another and it is supposed to take 5 days. 5 days! How big do you think Colorado is? You can drive across the whole state from corner to corner in 10 hours. You can drive across the whole of the United States in 5 days. I really hope this 5-day thing was fixed in the finished copy. If it was, please let me know.

The setting issues really bothered me. They were a constant niggle in my brain that I could not stop thinking about despite the drama and trauma of the plot.

Was this review helpful?

Have you ever waited a few years between reading books by an author you’ve enjoyed in the past, only to pick ups heir latest book and be blown away? That’s exactly what happened with me and Sadie by Courtney Summers. I’ve read three books (Cracked Up To Be, Some Girls Are, and This is Not a Test) all in 2012, and I enjoyed all of them, so I’m not sure why it’s been 6 years, but I’m so glad I returned to her writing in time for Sadie. Sadie is a powerfully written mystery about a teenage girl, Sadie, who goes missing not long after her little sister was murdered. The book is told in a combination of podcast excerpts and passages from Sadie.

Sadie is a very dark story, where I was simultaneously wanting to know how turned out but afraid to know. The story is realistic and painful, messy and complicated, and the writing is flawless. Sadie’s voice is so real. I already know this novel will make it on my top ten books of the year (and I’ve read over 100 so far). It’s an emotional and page-turning story. The audiobook, which I listened to, has an incredible full cast that really feels like listening to a podcast. The audiobook also includes my favourite narrator, Rebecca Soler as Sadie, and as much as I recommend this book which I am sure would be remarkable and memorable no matter what, I do highly recommend that format. After Sadie, I can promise it will not be another 6 years until I pick up another book by Courtney Summers.

Was this review helpful?

Sadie is a very powerful YA novel with a unique writing style. As someone how has recently gotten more into podcasts, I loved that part of the dialogue. I felt like I could close my eyes and hear the podcast unfold. Although with the podcast chapters, we have Sadie's first-person narrative. It is heartbreaking to see the way her story unfolds but it is a story you can't stop reading.

Was this review helpful?

I was so enthralled with this heartbreaking book but the ending has me torn. I get what Miss Summers has done, but it's also left me unsatisfied. I have to know. I can't rest until I know.

Was this review helpful?

One of the most fascinating characters I've read about recently and the most unique way of telling the story combines to make this a five star book for me. This would be memorable without the podcast aspect, but that's what makes it extra special. As we read the story from Sadie's point of view, we also get sections of a true crime podcast centered around the missing woman and her murdered sister. Both Sadie (the missing) and Wes, who runs the podcast, are searching for answers. He's always steps behind her, and we're left wondering what'll happen if he ever catches up.

Mattie was Sadie's purpose in life. She was her little sister, but in many ways Sadie acted as her mother. She cared for her, made sure she ate and went to school. She kept her safe... until she couldn't. Until Mattie, only a young teenager, was found dead. Now Sadie has a new purpose: find the killer. Make him pay. No matter what the cost. No matter who she encounters on the way. No matter how dangerous it is. She'll make him pay.

Bleak, heartwrenching, and undeniably powerful. This is one that will stay with me for some time and one I've already made a point to recommend to other readers. If you're not generally a YA reader, don't be afraid of this one. It stands on its own without ever relying on the usual YA troupes. It might feature characters in their teens, but it's a dark and moving story. One of my favorites this year.

I received a copy to review from Wednesday Books. This in no way affects my opinion.

Was this review helpful?