Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Jodi Picoult always does an amazing job of presenting difficult subjects in a realistic way that reflects different points of view. Her writing is as usual strong and is very timely with what is happening right now in many parts of the U.S.. The only comment that I have personally is that the topic of abortion has been covered so much that it was hard to find anything "new." The back nonfiction facts were more impactful to me.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult always writes such thought provoking books. I am always amazed at the depth of the research and the breadth of information and presented opinions in her books. Although I enjoyed the book very much, I expected a bit more insight into the opposing sides of the abortion debate and found the story to be a bit lacking in that aspect. In true, Picoult fashion, the last couple of chapters contained surprises and ah-ha moments that left me flipping back through the book to see how the pieces fit together.. Warning to the reader, the book takes place in reverse chronological order, with each chapter taking place an hour before the previous chapter, so pay close attention at the beginning. :)

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult tackles another hot-button topic in A SPARK OF LIGHT, abortion. I’m not sure why she upended the timeline and jumped back and forth so much, but it wasn’t too difficult to follow. I’m just not sure it added to the book in any significant manner. She did a good job of getting in multiple points of view, but probably won’t change anyone’s mind on the subject. As she stated in her notes at the end, she doesn’t think we will ever bring everyone together on this issue. She left us hanging on a couple of the characters, but that is pretty realistic. This country is in such a mess, we can’t tie everything up with a pretty little bow and have happy endings all around.

Was this review helpful?

Big ol’ damn! Once again, absolutely floored by the content, the structure, the characterization...all of it! You do amazing things with words, Jodi Picoult. I have never finished one of your books without a sense of wonder for all that I learned and all that I FEEL! There’s a reason I have read every book you’ve written and it is just that. Perfectly researched and written stories which are important, heart-breaking, beautiful, sad, smart, and glorious! 🤓💜📚

Was this review helpful?

Jody Picoult does it again. I was unable to put this book down (except at one point where I became so emotional I had to). A Spark of Light hits on the very sensitive subject of abortion, and does it without forcing any opinion on to the reader. I felt for all the characters and at the end was left wondering what the future holds for each. The relationship between fathers and daughters was portrayed wonderfully and honestly.

Was this review helpful?

Everything seems normal enough at the Center. A women's reproductive health facility not affiliated with Planned Parenthood, but trying to give the best care to Mississippi's women. Whether that is birth control or abortions. When the bell rings and a man with a gun enters and begins killing people. 

The story is told from the moments after and then backwards in time. This is a sometimes risky way to tell a story and for this story I wasn't a fan of it. I would much rather have learned more about the women and girls. 

This is a touchy subject. And Jodi has done her research on it. There were the pro abortionists views, the anti abortionists views and the physician's views. Every person struggles with their decisions. All aspects of this subject are tackled and felt.

No matter your stance on the issue, this book will make you think long and hard about your position and what legislation means for the poorest of the poor in our country.

This was a hard read but the research she put into it was solid and I appreciated that.

Well Done!

Netgalley/October 2nd 2018 by Ballantine Books

Was this review helpful?

I have read every one of Jodi Picoult's books,
I was excited and looking forward to reading this one.

The Center for Women and Reproductive Health; The Center for Women, to now The Center
keeps changing names to try to blend in and stay open. It is now barely open. It is attempting to serve women who have run out of choices and time.
This book shows the multiple viewpoints on women issues mainly abortion.

To be human- is to be a canvas for our scars

This book should be read and shared and discussed- Jodi has again written so deeply that she gets to the marrow of an issue like no other author can. This book puts into words what our society should understand.

Was this review helpful?

“You don’t know what you don’t know,” but damn, you’re going to walk away from this one with much more than you bargained for.
In classic Picoult style, a timely, multifaceted story that hits home with the fact that one decision can have permanent and life altering effects. Told from each & every side imaginable, Picoult paints an in depth picture of one of the hardest and most controversial decisions a woman could ever face. Filled with compassion, violence, racism, politics, and intelligence, Picoult weaves the lives of her characters through one another in a plot that is full of wisdom and surprises that will leave you shaking your head and saying aloud,” Oh my God!”
The differences of head and heart, of truth and emotion, of religion and science, of belief and hypocrisy all have a place here in this masterpiece of modern times.
“.. both life and death began with a spark of light.” and this book is going to spark a whole lot more; conversation, passion, faith. People will be talking and arguing over every aspect and character belief, then calling into question and fact their own, because this book is just that all encompassing, it’s that important, it’s just that good. Wow.

Was this review helpful?

"Violence from one angle looks like mercy from another."
This quote from the book easily presents the debate on abortion. Both sides feel strongly and act with great emotion and dedication for their beliefs.
Jodi Picoult describes quite well the painful doubt-filled thoughts of the women having abortions : was the decision the right one? Were her reasons questionable? Did punishment from God await her? These reflections elicit sympathy or at least understanding unless you are anti-abortion.
As the story begins as told in flashbacks, a shooter is in the abortion clinic and has already killed or wounded some. As the standoff continues we learn the stories of each of the hostages- very compelling.
Jodi Picoult very capably shows the dilemmas. "For some the fetus is a person, for others it is a potential."
There is no real answer, yet there is no doubt of the sincerity of both sides. Pregnancy brings about a strictly personal reaction. A joy or a problem?
Excellent novel!

Was this review helpful?

I didn’t enjoy this book as much as I had anticipated, but I still recommend it to both reading groups and to women’s study programs.

This is a novel wrapped around the thorny issue of abortion. I felt it was often too preachy, and too little novel and too much political treatise.

I found it contrived, looking for a starting point for the author to deliver her views. Those views will lead to rich discussions, but I would have preferred a more nuanced novel which was more interesting than political.

Was this review helpful?

Women from different backgrounds and for different reasons come to an abortion clinic. Their stories are revealed as they are held hostage by a man on a personal vendetta. Picoult deals with social issues in her books and the subject matter in Spark of Light is very current. She presents both sides of the issue in a manner that makes you ponder your own personal beliefs. The main characters are beautifully developed and all worthy of validation regardless of their reasons for coming to the clinic. Love all of Picoult's books I've read and this one is no different. Great read.

Was this review helpful?

It took me until almost the last chapter to realize why this book was written backwards. I struggled with it initially, especially because I had a digital copy and had trouble looking back on what I had read. While I enjoyed this book from the beginning, I wasn't especially attached to any of the characters and therefore wasn't in a hurry to pick it up after a long day.

There is a lot happening in our world today that makes me upset, and this book hit upon some of them. The men who are making decisions for girls and women is upsetting enough-but now that I have a daughter, I can not imagine her having to go through something as difficult as deciding to have an abortion-and then dealing with all of the insane laws, religious people pushing their beliefs, and judgement.

I read this book as someone who is generally open minded and entirely pro choice. It would be interesting to have a book club discussion on this book. I had Willie Parker's book on my to be read list already, and it sounds like something I need to read sooner than later.

When I go back to teaching, this book would be nice to have in a high school class. I was lucky enough to teach in a progressive school in Brooklyn-unfortunately this book won't be as readily available in the states that would benefit the most.

Was this review helpful?

Very good, engrossing read as one would expect from Picoult. However, one of the aspects enjoyed about the author's works are the twist and I was able to figure them out easily early in. Too predictable from that perspective. Overall though recommended.

Was this review helpful?

“There were eleven women in front of him: seven black, two white, two brown. He paid attention to the race of those who came to the Center because for him, the politics of abortion had so much in common with the politics of racism. As an African American male, he could imagine quite easily what it was like to not have jurisdiction over your body. White men had once owned black men’s bodies. Now, white men wanted to own women’s bodies.”

This book right here! As one can tell, abortion is the subject matter and it isn’t a black and white issue. What is morally right? Why doesn’t a woman have the final say over what happens to her body? If we are so pro-life then why aren’t we doing more to provide resources for all women in terms of adequate healthcare and a livable wage?

A Spark of Light will make you ponder, think, and it will make you feel uncomfortable. Jodi brilliantly weaves together the abortion debate with race issues. And, while this book made me feel uncomfortable at times, it’s gonna make white men feel even 100 times more uncomfortable.

One day. Everything that everyone believes can change within the course of one day. I could write so much more about this book but I don’t believe in spoilers and this is one I believe you should experience for yourself. I will end this by saying: A Spark of Light is another masterpiece by this author that I can easily see being made into a film.

Was this review helpful?

Jodi Picoult has always been a favorite author of ours. We have pretty much devoured everyone of her books. However, we feel like the last couple books have been more of a "soap box" attempt to push her views on readers. Yes there is a story behind the world issues, but a lot of the story has personal feelings tied in as well (clearly from the author).

We will continue to try more books from Jodi, but this one wasn't for us.

Was this review helpful?

Another beautifully written book. Ms Picoult always makes you see both of the story, but in this book I didn’t find that.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great story, a little different than Jodi’s usual style, but another amazing tale that captivates the reader. I absolutely love her ability to grab a reader and immerse them in her stories. Highly recommend to anyone wanting a good read and gives one another perspective on social issues.

Was this review helpful?

Nobody can write a book that makes me *feel* like Jodi Picoult. She never, ever disappoints and her new read "A Spark of Light" is another example. As usual, the plot is something that is happening in today's society which makes her books completely relevant. With her usual tremendous dialogue and fast moving plot, Picoult has stunned us again! Five stars and two thumbs WAY up!

Was this review helpful?

Picoult takes on abortion in this book in a timely and sensitive manner presenting all sides of this controversial topic. A timeline that works backward that honestly confused me initially until I realized what was happening.

Was this review helpful?

In A Spark of Light Jodi Picoult tackles the highly controversial topic of abortion. She brings us to an abortion clinic with an active shooter and an emotionally involved hostage negotiator. I loved the way the story developed slowly, going back and fort in time and between characters. This gives the reader time to get to know the characters. And, once you know them, you are more fully invested in the outcome. I will definitely be recommending A Spark of Light to my book clubs.

Was this review helpful?