This is the third installment in the Victorian Mystery series.

The trio of house-mates, Sarah, Hugh and Mick, need to solve the murder of the hangman who was hanged in his own pub. The story leads them around London and England, and into Newgate Prison. They make enemies and friends and eventually solve the murder, of course.

I liked that the main characters are a motley crew, a female photographer, a homosexual lord, and a schoolboy in love with a much older actress.

What I didn't like about the story, how the three friends came together is never really explained. It is hinted at and will certainly make sense if you have read the first two books. Since I didn't read the first two books in this series, I would have liked a little more background information.

I was skeptical at first - it's the third book in a series, about Victorian London, and about a female protagonist, which are three things that are out of my normal reading comfort zone. However, I gave it a try and I am glad I did! It was a very intriguing mystery with plenty of twists, turns, and action. All the characters were well-developed and I honestly did not feel like I was at a deficit for not reading the rest of the series. Even though the book took place about 200 years ago, I did not feel like it was super "old timey." I recommend this book to any fan of mysteries.

A well written addition to Rowland's Victorian mystery series. I would not recommend coming to this title without reading the first two books in the series. The characters background is quite established by this point, and small details would be missed if you have read the rest of the series. A dark and complicated mystery that holds your interest until the last page. I came to this book without the benefit of the other books in the series, and now I must read them.

Sarah, Hugh and Mick get their next case when they are called to a gory crime scene. A man - Harry Warbrick - is found who was decapitated after hanging. Sarah, Hugh, and Mick are quick to see that it was a murder. Their boss Sir Gerald tasks them with solving the crime which puts a new, hot-shot reporter's nose out of joint and doesn't endear them to the police department either. It especially causes trouble with Sarah's boyfriend PC Barrett and his boss Inspector Reid who already carries a grudge against them.

The case gets complicated when they learn that the victim was the hangman who executed Amelia Carlisle, the baby-butcher, who murdered hundreds of infants left in her care. The gang is sure that Warbrick's death had something to do with that hanging but happenings at hangings are covered under the Official Secrets act and they can't get anyone to talk.

This story was filled with twists and turns. All of the lead characters' romances were under pressure. Sarah and her police officer boyfriend are stressed because they are working as rivals on solving the crime. Hugh's relationship with Sir Gerald's son is not only stressful but also illegal according to English law. Mick's crush on an older actress is tested when she becomes the lover of one of the prime suspects in their case.

Sarah is also busy trying to find the father who abandoned her mother and her 20 years earlier when he was accused of raping and killing a young neighbor girl. Inspector Reid is determined to bring the whole case back into prominence to get his revenge on Sarah because she's a better detective than he is. In Sarah's quest to find her father, she learns some things about her parents' past which explains why her mother treated her the way she did.

This was an engaging mystery with a great setting and strong characters.

While working for the Daily World, photographer Sarah Bain with her two friends and co-workers, Lord Hugh Staunton and Mick O’Reilly, are called out to a crime scene. That of the hangman, Harry Warbrick. But is it suicide or murder. And if murder why? While working to find the guilty partner Sarah is still trying to find her father and so disapprove that he may be guilty of murder some years previously.
Throughout the book some of the dialogue seems a bit too far-fetched. While some of the relationships between the characters seemed somewhat forced. Overall a satisfying mystery even though I didn't take to any of the main characters.

I arrived late to the party for this series. The Hangman’s Secret is the third book in Laura Joh Roland’s Victorian Mysteries series. Fortunately, there are enough callbacks and exposition for me to feel like I wasn’t missing too much to understand the characters in this fair to middling mystery. There are problems with the writing in this book that almost put me off (discussed below), but the mystery itself was interesting enough that I just had to keep reading.

Protagonist Sarah Bain, with her partners Lord Hugh Staunton and the very-much-ragtag Mick O’Reilly have become semi-official investigators by The Hangman’s Secret. Sarah has been hired to provide crime scene photos for the ambitious owner of a London newspaper, Sir Gerald. Hugh helps as bodyguard and investigative partner, while Mick keeps his ear to the street to sniff out gristly murders and useful information. Neither Sarah nor Hugh is very happy with this arrangement, but it does pay the bills. As The Hangman’s Secret kicks off, Sarah and Hugh have been summoned to the particularly messy death of a local pub owner and hangman. It might look like the man hanged himself if not for the fact that everyone knows that he was a consummate professional who would never have botched his own hanging. (The details of the botching are definitely not for the squeamish.)

Sarah et al. are not allowed to treat the hangman’s death as just another job. Sir Gerald, in a fit of inspiration, declares that Sarah’s team and his new hire, a sexist reporter, will solve the mystery before the Metropolitan police. Sarah doesn’t want to be a detective. Her policeman lover definitely doesn’t want her to be a detective, either. But when the man with the purse strings gives an order, it has to be obeyed. Fortunately for Sarah and her partners, the people she interviews are generally willing to cough up all kinds of useful information. The ones who don’t go straight to the top of the list of suspects.

The way witnesses repeatedly give up information so easily was one of the things that bothered me about this book. It didn’t seem realistic to me the way that characters in late 1880s London would trust Sarah or that they all had such good memories. I was also bothered by Rowland’s missteps in the dialogue. There are a lot of too-modern phrases and sentences that a British English speaker would not say. The wrong notes irritated me. I stuck around because I had my own theories about what happened that I wanted to see confirmed. If nothing else, after reading the complicated Vita Nostra, The Hangman’s Secret was a chance for my brain to cool off.

I’m not interested enough to go back and read the first two books in the series and I doubt I will be keeping an eye out for future entries. I feel let down by The Hangman’s Secret because I know Rowland is a better writer and researcher than this. I really enjoyed her Sano Ichiro series, which is set in Shogunate Japan.

Set in 1890 London this novel features Photographer Sarah Bain, a photographer for “Daily World” newspaper though she usually ends up like a detective solving crimes even before the police do. She do this with her friends Lord Hugh Staunton and Mick O’Reilly. The books opens with Sarah called to a gory crime scene. A hangman named Harry Warbrick somehow died hanged and decapitated. The police, which includes Sarah’s boyfriend Barett, believes it’s a suicide but they can’t ignore the clues. Someone has hanged the hangman. And

Sir Gerald Mariner, owner of the Daily World, wants Sarah and her crew to find out what really happened. But suddenly, a name Amelia Carlisle, a “Baby-Butcher” showed up in their investigation and Sarah, Hugh and Mick never thought that they might be solving the most dangerous crime they ever encountered so far.

First, when I requested this book on Netgalley, I wasn’t aware that this is third in a series. But it didn’t affect my reading and comprehension at all. In fact, the author did an amazing job on inserting past information to give the reader more understanding.

Second, I was fascinated by the concept of this book. A hangman murdered by hanging and I haven’t really read anything with a hangman before. And then as the story goes on, I realized, I got more than I bargained for. There are plenty of twists and turns I didn’t see coming. I love how layered the mystery is. And it was well done. Even more complex because of Sarah’s personal problems in the way. The pacing is good and I’m usually entertained.

Third, the characters are unique and diverse with their various backstories. I love the friendship between Sarah, Hugh and Mick. It’s fascinating how much they love their job. 🙂 I also enjoyed the character of Barett. The romance between him and Sarah is shadowed by the mystery and crime aspect of the book and I think the author did a good job for doing so.

Now why I rated this a star short? There’s one character that I don’t understand the purpose except for antagonizing Sarah and her crew. The writing though overall is okay, it took me a while before I get into it. And for me, this book needs a serious editing. Just the first paragraph almost threw me off. I read the word ‘Window’ three times. That can be changed. There are also paragraphs where most of the sentences starts with the same pronoun. If I read it aloud, it won’t be good to my ears. BUT I AM READING AN ADVANCE READER’S COPY so I’m sure it’ll be fixed on the final copy.

Overall, I enjoy this book and this won’t be the last book I’m gonna read from this author.

The year is 1890 and Sarah Bain, crime photographer for the Daily World, has been summoned to the scene of a grizzy death. With her associates Lord Hugh Staunton and street-wise Mick O’Reilly, she goes to the Ropemaker’s Daughter, a pub in Whitechapel owned by the official hangman for the British government. There they find the hangman Harry Warbrick dead. The initial response is that Warbrick committed suicide, but an examination of the scene quickly proves otherwise. Warbrick’s head, still in the noose, was actually severed from his body which had dropped to the pub floor. No reputable hangman, and Warbrick was the best, would botch an execution this badly.

Someone murdered the hangman and tried to cover it up. The suspect list is soon narrowed to the seven witnesses to Warbrick’s last execution of the notorious baby murderer Amelia Carlisle. Sometime happened in the hanging shed but the witnesses are bound by the Official Secret’s Act and cannot reveal anything. Sir Gerald Mariner, owner of the Daily World, challenges the police to a contest; his paper will uncover the killer before the police do and he gives the task to Sarah and her friends. So begins an intense and terrible examination of Newgate Prison and the corruption within the penal system and the police department before the murderer is revealed.

A second plot, carried over from the first two books. concerns Sarah’s search for her fugitive father who disappeared twenty years earlier after being accused of the rape and murder of a child

I had not read the previous books in the series, but I had no trouble with the considerable backstory. I was soon immersed in Sarah’s London, with its polluted air, gas-lit streets, and colorful inhabitants. This is a fast-paced mystery with strong characters. Everyone has secrets and flaws. Highly recommended.

Sarah Bain and her two friends Hugh and Mick are called by their journalist boss to a gruesome murder. A hangman that has been beheaded! Although the three are despearate to solve another mystery, their actions are seen as meddling by the local police. Add to the mix both Sarah and Hugh's personal relationship problems with the men they love and Sarah and her half-sister, Sally, searching for their father- a wanted man, and you have an action packed story!

Although I had not read the two previous stories The Ripper's Shadowand A Mortal Likeness, there are plenty of illusions to Sarah and other characters past relationships that it could be treated as a stand alone. However, there were parts of the novel that seemed a bit drawn out and repetitive. Also, I didn't really buy into Sarah and Barrett's relationship especially after they meet with his parents in the book. Because of this fact I could not go any higher than a 3 in my rating.

As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words.

Sarah Bain wakes to the pounding on her door just before daybreak. The rude awakenings are part of her lifestyle. Sarah lives above her photography studio and has a sideline for photographing crime/murder scenes in the Whitechapel High Street neighborhood. She and her two partners, Mick and Hugh, have been employed by Sir Gerald Mariner who runs The Daily World newspaper. What awaits her a few streets over may not be fit to print.

The body of bar owner, Harry Warbrick, has been found on the floor of his establishment in a bloody mess. Harry is a victim of his own trade. He moonlights as a hangman to bring in extra cash. It appears that ol' Harry got tripped up on his own rope tightly tied around his neck from the upper floor. Harry ended up at the wrong end of his rope. Murder? But his former "customers" never hung around to retaliate. Then who?

Sarah delivers the plates to Sir Gerald who wishes to get a leg up on the police investigation. He challenges Sarah to take the lead in finding out what happened to Harry Warbrick. She and her partners had a private inquiry service before hooking up with the newspaper. This will play havoc with her love interest PC Thomas Barrett. Is it possible to refrain from telling Barrett all that she knows about the crime?

The Hangman's Secret is the third offering in the Victorian Mystery Series by Laura Joh Rowland. It definitely
reads as a standalone. Rowland nicely fills in the backstories when needed. Rowland swirls the scenery with the sights and sounds of London in 1890 with its factories puffing horrendous chemical fumes and rivers appearing thick in their flow.

Rowland's choice of characters are wide and varied. Even Sarah has some painful experiences from childhood surrounding her father who may or may not be guilty of a serious crime. She still continues to search for him. Rowland slides the true crime character of Amelia Carlisle who actually ran a baby farm during this time period. This tough investigation may have a connection to Amelia as well. Rowland will keep you on your toes with quite the action. The ending will escalate to lives being in mighty danger.

I received a copy of The Hangman's Secret through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Crooked Lane Books and to Laura Joh Rowland for the opportunity.

This was an easy and enjoyable read, especially if you like murder mysteries set in Victorian Britain.
The story-line did twist a little and deepen further into the book although it was not too difficult for the reader to ascertain where the plot was headed. Sometimes I felt the main character was a bit naive with regard to her own safety and that of her friends so that made the detecting a little unrealistic. Otherwise, though, the description was evocative of that era and I would be happy to read the other books by this author.

Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for this copy in exchange for an honest review..

When I requested this book I hadn't realised it was set in Victorian times. If I had noticed I wouldn't have gone for it. How blinkered was I, I was drawn in and hooked after the first couple of pages and then couldn't put it down. I will certainly read more by Laura Joh Rowland even if they are set in Victorian London.

Love the female lead! The story was a fast paced, great mystery. I thoroughly enjoyed it! I will be looking for other books by this author.

This is the third book in the Victorian Mysteries series,yet the story was very easy to read,despite frequent references to the two previous books,which I haven't read.
I found this story to be very atmospheric and evocative of London circa 1890. There is a strong female character, Sarah Bain,who is employed by The Daily World newspaper to take crime photos. This seems to be at the cutting edge of female occupations at this time. I also loved Lord Hugh Stanton,disowned by his family for the grave sin and illegality of being homosexual.
I was also delighted to meet the famous Inspector Edmund Reid,of the Ripper murders fame, the two names are synonymous at this period of time. Due to the hints about how the Ripper met his demise,I am now going to have to read the first two books in this series,who doesn't love a good murder,and Jack the Ripper still exerts such a fascination today.
The initial murder in this book refers to Harry Warbrick,found hanged and decapitated. Thought at first to be a suicide ,doubts were raised, as such a notorious state hangman, would have known the weight and pressures of a body needed to hang without the head being removed. This murder also has a link to Sarah's long disappeared father and half brother,with shameful family secrets being revealed.
Starting slowly and building up to a thrilling finale, there is a marvellous wealth of details and good research in this book. Pleading your belly and being incarcerated in an Asylum is spot on,whereas Baby farming seems so modern. There was good detective work in Leeds,when,following the ramblings of a lunatic,a murderer is revealed hiding behind a false persona .
I greatly enjoyed this book,I could almost smell and taste the sights of Olde London,and some were extremely gruesome!!
I have posted a copy of this review to Goodreads today.

First and foremost, a large thank you to NetGalley, Laura Joh Rowland, and Crooked Lane Books for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.

Laura Joh Rowland takes readers back to Victorian England to continue this mystery series that proves addictive from the opening pages. Sarah Bain and Lord Hugh Staunton have worked well together in the past and, after some results in a recent kidnapping case, have been hired by Sir Gerald Mariner to work at a recently acquired newspaper. Sarah’s skill at photography is sure to help sell copies, alongside the passion she and Hugh have for solving crimes. When they are sent to a murder scene on a tip, Sarah and Hugh discover a decapitated man. He is soon identified as one of the hangmen used across England to execute those deemed worthy of death. During an encounter with the local police, a competition ensues to see who will find the killer first. Sarah and Hugh begin poking around and learn of the hangman’s ties to a ruthless killer, one Amelia Carlisle, who ran a baby farm and was found to have murdered many of the little ones in her care. Working undercover of sorts, Sarah and Hugh make their way to the prison to learn a little more about Carlisle, where they meet the select group who witnessed the hanging. Between learning about this, Sarah’s half-sister comes to call, where she admits that she may have seen their father. Benjamin Bain was thought to have died over two decades before, having disappeared after a clash with the police. However, Sarah came to discover that he had a second family, using a pseudonym. She also discovers that he is wanted as a person of interest in the rape and murder of a young girl, around the time of his disappearance from the Bain household. With new information, Sarah his determined not only to find her father, but clear his name of this heinous crime. When new revelations surrounding the Carlisle execution leaks to the press, Sarah’s job is in jeopardy, though she has other matters on her mind. A killer is on the loose, targeting those who know all about the execution, but Sarah is also keenly aware that there are secrets in her own family that must be revealed before she can learn the truth for her own peace of mind. Rowland has penned another winner, full of great plots and interesting characters. Recommended for those who love mysteries set in Victorian England that have unique twists.

I chose to read the first two novels in the series before jumping into this one, as I felt that it would help enrich the experience. I am pleased that I did so, as Rowland effectively lays the groundwork for this book and develops her characters well in the first two pieces. This novel is just as exciting, set another year or so after the Mariner kidnapping and two years after the Ripper scare made headlines. Sarah Bain remains an interesting character, sure to interest most readers for her relatability and constant curiosity. A photographer by trade, Sarah uses her amateur sleuthing capabilities again in this novel, accentuated by grit and determination to get to the answer. Rowland did well to develop her into a quasi-investigative reporter, utilising all her skills. Lord Hugh Staunton remains her effective sidekick, though it is his interest in keeping things secretive about his true identify that acts as the form of development the reader must accept in this piece. Hugh has been disowned by his family for his homosexuality and his recent relationship could cost everyone a great deal, if it becomes public. Some of the secondary characters shape the story effectively, particularly Police Constable Thomas Barrett. PC Barrett struggles with his love for Sarah and his dedication to the job. His superiors have made it known that Sarah is not welcome to poke around, leading to some interesting secret keeping and revelations between Barrett and Sarah throughout. Overall, the story worked well and kept my attention through to the final sentence. Wonderfully developed in the middle of Victorian England’s most crime-filled years, Rowland captures the feeling of those dark and troubled streets in London’s less savoury neighbourhoods. Rowland has created an interesting series that mixes history with key elements of a decent mystery. I will keep her on my radar and hope that she continues this wonderful series that is both highly entertaining and easy to read.
Kudos, Madam Rowland, for keeping the series fresh with new ideas and established storylines. Victorian England comes alive in your descriptions and I hope the series will continue in the years to come.

I received this from Netgalley

I fell in love with the cover and I really enjoyed this book. Now, when I read this I was not aware that it was book 3 in a series, so I was a bit lost but that I my fault for not researching more into this before I grabbed the book.

Will I go back and read the others, probably not since I read this one because I more and likely ruined the other books for myself. But I still enjoyed the book.

Well researched Victorian era mystery with plenty of action and a collection of interesting characters. This 3rd episode stands well alone, despite a long running story arc. Those who have followed this series in order will have additional insights, but I started here and found it a satisfying read.

This is the third installment in the Victorian mystery series. Sara, Hugh and Mick have been hired to photograph corpses at crime scenes.. One particular corpse they photograph is a hangman. Who would want to kill the hangman? The chase is on between the police and our threesome to determine the killer. Twists and turns abound, and Sara takes a serious hit to her credibility to solve the murder. But she persists, in spite of Inspector Reid trying to trip her up, losing her job, and in spite of Barrett's pleas for her to leave it alone.
Sara and Barrett's relationship is becoming clearer, and Sara's distrust of him is crumbling. Sara also continues her quest to find her father, and she learns some surprises along the way.
I like this book more than #2. The pacing was tighter, and the characters are growing in depth and feeling. The series continues to grow as well, and the plots are tricky and well thought out. I look forward to the next installment.
I received this book in return for an unbiased review from Net Galley.

This is my first Laura Joh Rowland book and the third in the series. I did not find it necessary to have read the other two books. Victorian mystery is not the genre of book that I would usually read but the book description appealed to me and I’m glad I did. I liked her main characters - Sarah Bain and her friends Hugh Staunton and Mick O’Reilly. Crime Photographer Sarah has been sent by the Daily World newspaper to take pictures of the crime scene. Then she’s told by Sir Gerald, the owner of the paper, that she is to investigate the murder in a sort of contest with the police. And winning the contest is everything to Sir Gerald because he still holds a grudge against the police at how they handled his son’s kidnapping. Also, they can run a series of follow-ups in the paper which will generate sales. There’s lots going on in this book - from personal relationships to gruesome murders. Ms Rowland’s characters are well developed and likeable - I enjoyed her description of 19th century London. An enjoyable read.

Thanks to NetGalley for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review

London in the 1890s is damp, dark and smoky. The perfect setting for a villainous mystery. Sarah Bain is a photographer, quite an unusual occupation not only in that time, but especially for a woman. Sarah works for the local paper, the Daily World, and is at the beck and call of its editor, Sir Gerald Mariner. Sir Gerald likes to publish stories that sell, or the early edition of today’s tabloids. Sarah is often sent to grisly scenes of murder that would cause even the strongest of men to cringe. Yet Sarah is one plucky woman. She isn’t daunted by much.

Sarah lives in a house with Mick O’Reilly, a fourteen year old former street urchin; Lord Hugh Staunton, one dashing gentleman; and Fitzmorris, Lord Hugh’s valet who also stands in as cook, housekeeper and anything else needed. Mick is supposed to be going to school, but he prefers to hang out with Sarah and Lord Hugh carrying equipment and solving crimes.

In this book, Sarah is awakened by someone calling her to a crime scene of one Harry Warbrick, a hangman who is hanged by his own rope. Harry also runs a local pub below his residence. Sarah records the scene of the crime, but is not convinced of the guilt of the man they arrest. Sarah decides to investigate her own leads, along with Hugh & Mick. With this they are off on a dangerous mission to unearth the truth.

This is the third book of the Victorian Mystery series by Laura Joh Rowland. I had not read the previous two books, and this book can definitely stand on its own. Once you’ve enjoyed one of the series, my bet is that you would probably enjoy the others. I am looking forward to catching up with Sarah, Lord Hugh and Mick in the other books.