Cover Image: The Birthday

The Birthday

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

The Birthday is great as the first book to introduce Detective Ward and her series. I am hoping that this story is a good sign for how the rest of the series goes because the mystery was both intriguing and dealt with both the case as well as Natalie herself. There is so much that makes a good mystery and Carol Wyer has covered them all and I think any mystery fan would enjoy this book as well as the series to come. Thank you Netgalley and Bookouture for the chance to read The Birthday ahead of the release to review.

Was this review helpful?

Child abductions and murder lots of suspects but all the crimes seem to be linked, is this the work of a serial killer or grudge killings or is this something else. Guessed who the killer was but could not work out motive. A very enjoyable read

Was this review helpful?

I am already a fan of Carol Wyer having read/followed the Det Robyn Carter series so when I saw this, I just had to read it.

This author never fails to let you down, this book started off with a little girl Ava Sawyer dressed in a pretty yellow party dress going missing at a Craft Centre where she was attending a birthday party in 2015. Roll forward to present day and the craft centre has been taken over by another company and the workmen are in to dig the place in preparation for their plans which are hampered when a body of a little child is discovered beneath the soil.

Det Natalie Ward is called as the SIO on the case and having some personal issues herself in her family life and regrets/guilt over another case of a young girl she didn’t manage to save, she is determined to find out what happened to Ava. When another body of a young girl turns up dead wearing a yellow party dress, the two cases surely have to be related? This girl was at the party in 2015 also. Natalie and her team pull out all the stops and put in all the hours in a bid to catch this child killer before any more bodies turn up, its not an easy task as there is no evidence, the killer has meticulously covered their tracks!

With so many suspects to be interviewed and eliminated it was a classic case of who dunnit? The author has a way of dropping subtle clues but not enough for you to actually guess the killer and what a twist!!! Very well written and pulled together, I am looking forward to more in this series, not sure my husband would agree mind you as I read this book in a day and he kinda became a book widower and the poor kids having to fend for themselves ha ha!!!

Many thanks to Netgalley, Bookouture and Carol Wyer for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

The Birthday by Carol Wyer is a thriller that encapsulated me from the very first page. I had no idea what what going to happen and the author did not give it away at all. There were subtle clues but that was it. A little girl at a birthday party wearing a yellow dress is missing. Fast forward two years and now we have a body of another girl that has been found. The second little girl just happened to be at the same party as the missing girl two years ago. The author weaves together details that you would not think of while reading this type of book. I so wanted to find out whodunnit. Will the author give it away? You will have to see for yourself. 5+ stars out of 5

Thank you netgalley as well as the author for allowing me to read this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a gripping thriller. It was full of excitement and suspense! With crazy twists and turns!

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own

Was this review helpful?

Little Ava goes missing during a birthday party, and nobody can figure out where she went - she was wearing a bright, lemon-yellow dress - she couldn't have gone that far, could she? But two years later, when another little girl's body turns up, and it is discovered that the child in question also attended the same birthday party ... suspicions start to rise.

Natalie is haunted by a prior failure, and is determined to not let this one slide by her again as a DI.

This book was engaging and interesting, if not totally unpredictable. I'd recommend it to fans of the classic domestic thriller, with a twist.

Was this review helpful?

A well written and intriguing first installment in what I hope is a new series. Fast paced plot with enough twists to keep the reader guessing

Was this review helpful?

I'm so glad I took the opportunity to request this one as it hit almost every single thing I want/need in a domestic thriller. The story was compelling, the characters were well developed, it did a good job diverting your thoughts on who might have done it, and it constantly had me second guessing myself.

I truly enjoyed the premise of the novel even though it's something that has no doubt been done dozens of times over. The difference with this one is that the author didn't hold your hand throughout and gradually try and guide you to who had actually committed these crimes. She left subtle clues that weren't very easy to pick up and it ultimately left the story a complete mystery until the last 10% when it climaxed into actually catching the killer.

I thought all of the characters were well done in a very small way. I didn't feel like any of them necessarily held any greater amount of backstory then any of the others and that they all had a very well done "team" dynamic which flowed very nicely. I'm used to reading thrillers where the lead detectives are mainly focused on and not the whole unit so I felt very refreshed with this team.

Was this review helpful?

I have only recently discovered author Carol Wyer after seeing an interview with her online. I read her book Little Girl Lost and was instantly gripped and when I saw she had the start of a new series coming out the first of which is entitled The Birthday I was intrigued to see if this one would be as good as Little Girl Lost.
Harriet Downing’s birthday party went horribly wrong when one of the children went missing never to be seen again. Fast forward two years and the body of the little girl Ava has been found. DI Natalie Ward is on the case and is determined to get to find the killer but things have just got a whole lot worse….. the body of another child who attended the party has just been found. Natalie and her team pull out all the stops to try and catch the killer before any more children are harmed but this killer is expertly covering their tracks.
Wow I loved this book even more than Little Girl Lost. If you have read my review of Little Girl Lost you will remember I found it gripping but found that the storyline slowed in the middle part of the book and slightly lost me for a while, well The Birthday is gripping from the very first page right through to the last page. I was completely in the dark right up until the last couple of chapters and I didn’t have even the slightest suspicion until around 75% through and even then I was on the wrong track!
DI Natalie Ward has her own demons from a previous case which we know from little drips of information we are fed from Natalie which helps us understand why it is even more paramount that she solves this case and quickly. We get to know parts of her team members personal life too so we manage to build relationships with the characters which I am sure will develop further in the next book.
I would definitely recommend this book if you are looking for something to hold your attention with a storyline that will have you sitting trying to piece all the clues together.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced copy of this book through Netgalley. This book had me from the very beginning. I love that it kept me on the edge of my seat the whole time. I would highly recommend this book to my fellow readers. Thank you for the chance to review this book!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely loved the first series of books and although I wasn't entirely satisfied with their conclusion I'm glad the author didn't ruin a good thing and turn it into a 20+ book series. I was a bit dubious about reading this book thinking it'd be similar to that series but couldn't have been more wrong. Natalie is very different character and I will absolutely be reading the follow up book.

Was this review helpful?

One of the best I’ve read in awhile because it moves quickly with substance. The characters are raw emotion oftimes and the ending is a real suprise

Was this review helpful?

My first book by this author and it was pretty good. There was decent character build up to set the stage for a new series. The relationships and dialogue were realistic.

Natalie is an interesting character, not incredibly likable. Though as the story progresses she somewhat redeems herself. She has transferred to another station after her last case ended in a tragic outcome due to mismanagement.

There were some twists and turns to add a little intrigue. There were also a few places that the story could have been trimmed up but nothing too bad. The ending was good in that it resolved this case so you aren’t forced to continue reading for answers if you’re not a fan of the new series.

Thanks to NetGalley, the author and Bookouture for a copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Having thoroughly enjoyed Carol Wyer's previous series I was keen to see how Detective Natalie Ward would shape up, and I was not disappointed! An interesting character, Natalie is strongly affected by her failure to solve a previous case, and when a child's bones appear she is determined not to fail again. Her family situation is interesting and her work colleagues also have interesting situations which promise to develop nicely. This is a fascinating case which has surprising outcomes. A really good read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Bookouture for the ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I am a huge fan of the author's other series - Robyn Carter series.

This book was a good start to the series. I liked the main character and it was interesting seeing how she deals with both her professional and personal life. The investigation went well and although I had an idea of who the perpetrator was, it was interesting to see how everything played out.

It was a good read and a good start to the series..

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Carol Wyer’s work, I was excited to see her newest book on Netgalley but I was a bit disappointed it wasn’t part of the Robyn Carter series...until I started reading!
It was a great story, I was hooked from the first page.
I enjoyed getting to know Natalie and her team, i can’t wait to learn more about them.
Another great series by Carol Wyer, check her out....you’ll be glad you did!

Was this review helpful?

I would like to thank Netgalley and Bookouture for an advance copy of The Birthday, the first novel to feature DI Natalie Ward of the Staffordshire police.

When the body of 5 year old Ava Sawyer, who disappeared 2 years earlier from a birthday party at the garden centre where her body is discovered, is found DI Natalie Ward and her team are tasked with the investigation. Their job becomes more urgent when Audrey Briggs, Ava's classmate and fellow party attendee disappears and is found murdered. With no obvious suspects or motive the team are feeling the pressure.

I thoroughly enjoyed The Birthday which is a taut procedural with several twists and turns. Despite the discovery of two bodies early in the novel it is quite a slow read with team basically chasing their tails as they try to identify and eliminate suspects. The action and tension do, however, ramp up in the final quarter of the novel as they hunt their perpetrator. I like the slow build up as it gives the reader a good feel for the practicalities of hunting a stranger killer. There is frustration, despondency, exhaustion and puzzlement but there is always a sense of hope and determination that they will solve it, although it frequently looks like they might fail. It is very well done and I found myself infused with their spirit as I read on. It is well done. I also like the balance of detective nous and forensics. There is little in the way of forensics at the murder scenes but the team take the gleanings as they are discovered and incorporate them into their investigation. It seems a realistic take on modern policing.

The novel is mostly told from Natalie's point of view with a few chapters devoted to an unnamed child's obsession with a classmate. As these chapters are in italics it's safe to assume they are the killer's history. I'm not interested in this kind of attempt to provide a framework for murderous behaviour so I found it a distraction and less than convincing.

I like DI Natalie Ward who seems like a kind of everywoman. She is smart, dedicated and haunted by the failure of a previous case where they failed to save a teenager. She is also a mother with two teenage children and an unlikeable husband. She is the main breadwinner and has to work to support her family but it doesn't stop her husband from criticising her at every turn. It's an interesting role reversal from the norm and even more interesting that she feels the guilt of it as her husband turns the screw.

The Birthday is a good read which I have no hesitation in recommending.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Net Galley and Bookouture for an advance read of this title. It kept me reading, and kept me guessing until the end, so I enjoyed that part a great deal. One thing I wasn't comfortable with is that there were a "few" (I'm purposely being coy about the number so I don't give anything away) murders of children. I know it was part of the plot, but I felt like that part was a little cliche. The characters felt a bit "unfinished," so my guess would be this will be part of a series. That said, this book kept me reading into the night, and the plot was interesting.

Was this review helpful?

Twenty primary school children go to a birthday party at a garden/animal centre. One disappears without trace. Two years later, when the site is being excavated, a body is found. Within days, the problems escalate...

DI Natalie Ward and her team, frustrated by the lack of leads, get the feeling that several of the adults are keeping secrets

A fast-paced story. Hopefully this is the start of a series

Was this review helpful?

Two years ago, a five-year-old girl went missing at a birthday party, and her body was recently discovered. Now another little girl is missing… and she was also a guest at the ill-fated celebration. It’s up to Detective Natalie Ward and her team to track down the killer, but with few leads to go on, it won’t be an easy task.

I love the DI Robyn Carter series, and looked forward to ‘meeting’ Detective Natalie Ward. My expectations were high, and I was concerned that I would compare the two characters and (perhaps) find myself wishing this novel was about the former—but I needn’t have worried. Wyer easily surpassed all my expectations, creating a dynamic lead character that is every bit as enthralling as the beloved DI Carter.

Natalie Ward’s first case strikes at the heart of every parent’s worst fear—the loss of a child. It wasn’t a stretch of the imagination at all to envision the terror felt by the parents of the missing children, nor was it hard to understand Natalie’s determination to leave no stone unturned in the pursuit of the culprit.

Natalie’s personal life with her husband and children, as well as the personal lives of her team members, were as interesting for me to read about as the investigation itself. Lots of juicy nuggets of information were sprinkled throughout the book about several characters, and I can’t wait to learn more about them in future installments of the series!

I had a lot of fun trying to guess the identity of the killer, and one of my guesses was correct… but it was one guess out of MANY, so it doesn’t count as solving the crime before the Big Reveal happened. Finally knowing ‘whodunnit’ wasn’t enough to dissipate the threat of impending doom, however, and I could barely breathe as they rushed to find and arrest the killer.

Final Thoughts

Wyer’s latest offering sets the stage for what is sure to be another skillfully crafted series. The Birthday is intense, chilling, and the very definition of unputdownable. This is a must-read for fans of crime thrillers.

I received an advance reading copy of this book courtesy of Bookouture via Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?