Cover Image: How to Fracture a Fairy Tale

How to Fracture a Fairy Tale

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this collection of short stories, ranging from lush to outwardly bizarre takes on classic well-known tales. I liked it a lot more than I originally thought that I would. But as with books consisting of short stories, I find it difficult to review the book as a whole, so instead, I'm going to highlight a few of my favourite stories from this collection.
The Bridge's Complaint.
I really enjoyed this one, and it was unique because of its central point of view, that which is from an inanimate object, a bridge. I enjoyed reading about the bridge's tales originally told from a troll.
Godmother Death.
I don't know if this is common knowledge, but I absolutely love any sorts of re-tellings and/or personifications related to death, the angel of death and others. And so this story was especially interesting to read, and I quite enjoy tales told from somebody simply recalling a story somebody else told them. In this case, godmother death.
Happy Dens.
This was by far my favourite story. An original spin on a nursing home, certainly, this story entails the untold stories of well-known wolves in classic tales like the Three Little Pigs, where of course the wolf is portrayed as the bad guy of the story. This story sets out to paint such wolves in a different light, cleverly suggesting there are two sides to the same coin, and so far a world has only looked upon one side and taken it as absolute fact.
Brother Hart.
I just found the very present theme of family in this story very heartwarming, though it has heartbreak as well, but the enchantment in this one is interesting, especially since it's never really explained. But in this case, it makes it more enchanting to have finished reading.
Slipping Sideways Through Eternity.
This one was a bit confusing at first, and by the end, you're a bit less confused but still haven't really been explained anything to. However, there's a payoff so it's acceptable. This was really sad, taking place in the Holocaust. You really just need to read it to really understand the emotions that come with it.
Great Grandfather Dragon's Tale.
Told in the point of view of an old grandfather dragon to his young dragon grandchildren, this story entails the history of how dragons and humans came upon an agreement that impacted both creatures of this very day. This has a present theme of story-telling, as most of the stories in here do, however, this one is more impactful considering it's centred around dragons.
The Golden Balls.
What the hell. I don't know what else I can possibly say about this one.
The Woman who Loved a Bear.
I was getting serious 'Brother Bear' vibes with this one, once the bear of the story actually shows up, and the child which the grandfather is telling this story to is very impatient for the bear to come in. This is fantasy but one that clearly mirrors colonialism, it was transfixing from start to finish, and if you didn't see the plot twist from the beginning, the payoff at the end should be just magnificent for you.

Was this review helpful?

I've spent a good deal of my academic life studying myth and folklore and still love reading fairytales twisted and turned into different - yet familiar - narratives. Yolen's retellings cover a range of fairytales, myths and legends from all over the world, updating some of them with an irreverent voice, while maintaining the dark undertones of the others, all retold in an undeniably charming fashion that keeps the tradition of storytelling at its centre. What I particularly love about this 'fractured' collection are the reminders about how storytelling (that is, the verbal repetition of stories and not the writing down) used to be - and still is - so integral to culture, and how these stories would take on different elements and elaborations as they were repeated, becoming new tales for new generations, blurring events, interpretation and personal responses.

A fantastic collection and one that I thoroughly enjoyed. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

How to fracture a fairy tale presents a series of alternatives for stories that we're already mostly familiar with. These are alternate versions of various fairy tales that are sometimes humorous and sometimes moving. Some of them where very interesting and quite intriguing. Other stories I found quite anticlimactic, and sometimes they felt too short or written in a haste. Overall it is a well-written anthology that can be a quick and pleasant read.

Was this review helpful?

I really liked a few stories in this collection, but overall it didn't wow me. The fact that the stories were drawn from other anthologies shows, as there was a huge variation in the tone of the stories that I found a bit jarring. This is worth reading if (like me) you love fairy tale retellings, but it isn't the best option out there.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars actually

This book was a joy to read. I really love short stories and the ones I enjoy the most are retellings of fairy tales or those that are reminiscent of the old tales I have known by heart since I was a little kid.

This is the first Jane Yolen book I have ever read and I was gripped by it with the synopsis alone. When I was granted an ARC of this book, I got excited and immediately read it.

I enjoyed reading this book but it had its negative points. There were stories I wasn't able to comprehend that much, mostly because of the seemingly archaic writing style and the confusing allusions and innuendoes imbedded in them. Also, there were stories that were TOO SHORT to be insufficient and I was left hanging and confused at the end.

Nevertheless, there were stories I completely loved. I also adore how Yolen "fractured" the tales and gave them different twists. I would also love to praise this book for its dragon content.

All in all, How To Fracture A Fairy Tale is an entertaining book for fans of fairy tales and retellings, like me. If you also love dragons, I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

Lovely, lovely collection of re-told, fractured and twisted fairy tales. The author puts a new and fascinating spin on tales from all over the world. I enjoyed this very much.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautiful collection of stories that feels like I'm discovering fairytales all over again. Yolen's constant awareness and wit fractures plots and characters archetypes into something new and familiar. Granny Rumple in particular brings this to mind as Yolen gives it a haunting familiarity for those who know their Jewish history - the spilled blood, fear in the air, and a family torn apart in a patter that repeats for hundreds of years. Her other stories also demonstrate how fairytales do not exist in a vacuum, and are products of the cultures and people that give birth to them. This reminds us the power of stories, and is something she expands on in her notes in the end. In fact, I wish more anthologies had these author's notes because it really does show the fun and creativity that was involved.

I would recommend this to fans of fairytales, those who suffered hearing my undergrad research on monster narratives, and folklorists, Buy a physical copy because this should be something to cherish.

On a side note: do you know how hard it is to find reimagined Jewish folktales? I am literally going to throw copies of 'How to Fracture a Fairy Tale' at my friends because there are now more to read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Tachyon publishing for the arc of this book, I did enjoy the retelling of these old fairy tales, Cinderella was my favourite, but I have come to the conclusion short stories aren’t for me, they are too short, I wanted a couple of these stories to carry on, but over all a good read.

Was this review helpful?