Cover Image: When All is Said

When All is Said

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I struggled a little with this book unfortunately. It didn’t grip me as much as I would have liked and I didn’t care much for the characters.

Was this review helpful?

Stunning, moving, gripping and well written - i was so ready for the ending that it moved me and did not make me too sad. It seemed the right solution - his mesmerising voice was finished with his story, and his great love fully explored in his long life. The sadness was pervasive but not a downer as he recounts events in his life. We also feel the different ages of himself as he recalls events, and people. Really wonderful ...

Was this review helpful?

This book told the most wonderful story in a really interesting way. We meet 84 year old Maurice Hannigan at a hotel bar. He then proceeds to "toast" the 5 people who have made the biggest impact in his life. During the toasts, he pretty much tells his life story - warts and all in some cases. A story that felt, at times, that I wasn't just simply reading, no, instead I felt like I was sat next to him, in that bar, in the Irish town he calls home, listening to him telling me personally. Not for a while has a book consumed me as totally as this one did, a character who touched me as much as Maurice did. I really did feel like I had found a new friend by the end of the book and I really didn't want to leave him behind. All that despite the fact that he did some really horrible things along the way. But doing bad things doesn't make you a bad person. The whole being more than the sum of its parts really rang true in Maurice's life as he also did some wonderful things along the way.
Maurice does a fair bit of rambling along the way, leaving some stuff unfinished for a while and he pops off at the occasional tangent but, to me anyway, this just added to the realistic nature of his storytelling. But when all was said and done, the whole picture he painted of his life was complete and clear. The ending of the book is pretty obvious from the beginning (for me anyway) but that doesn't make it any the less emotional when it comes. But, although I sobbed at times through the book, I also laughed and cried happy tears as well as running the gamut of a whole host of other emotions. He really got under my skin more than most characters. Probably one of the reasons that I would love to listen to this as an audiobook too.
All in all, a lovely story that tugged at my every emotion and left me bereft at its conclusion. In a good way I hasten to add. My thanks go to the Publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Was utterly engrossed in this - some really beautiful writing and human characters, and a really satisfying read.

Was this review helpful?

At the bar in a grand hotel in a small Irish town sits 84 year old Maurice Hannigan. He's alone as usual. So pull up a chair and charge your glass, because Maurice is finally reading to tell his story. He will raise 5 toasts to the five people who have meant the most to him. Stories of joy, regret, a secret tragedy kept hidden and a fierce love that never found its voice.

What a heartwarming but also a heartbreaking story this is. A beautifully written story. An old man sits at a bar and toasts the most important people that have been in his life. All but his son have passed away. This tear jerker of a story covers every emotion from joy, sadness, love, compassion and much much more. Intertwined with these toasts lies another story, a mystery that involves a once rich family that was cruel to Maurice's family. You will guess the ending but that won't make you think any less of this wonderful story. I do recommend this book.

I would like to thank NetGalley, Hodder & Stoughton and the author Anne Griffin for my ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Maurice takes us back through his lifetime in a small village in Ireland. Each toast describes a different time, beautifully written, the reader is transported back and can really visualise his life. True to life and enjoyable reading.

Was this review helpful?

Sitting alongside 84 year old Maurice Hannigan we listen in as he recounts, in an intriguing direct address to his absent son, his life story - the highs and lows, the loves and losses, the deprivation and the riches of love along the way. And he raises a glass to toast the five most important people who have travelled with him and affected and sometimes transformed his life. He is irascible, grumpy, unloveable and loveable in equal measure and his narrative reveals what has made him the grumpy old man of today. But oh the lyrical quality of his story-telling, the Irish lilt to his spoken voice. You feel that you are sitting on the bar stool next to him listening in to the imagined conversation with his son. Poignant, funny, sad, bad-tempered, wilful, grumpy, loving, undemonstrative….ultimately unavoidably loveable! Raise your glass and enjoy. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Being in the same position myself it was most interesting to share into someone else’s end life. A man sits on a bar stool in a posh hotel contemplating his life and times lived as a Irish farmer in a rural community. During his lifetime he has progress from being just a labourer to a land owning farming tycoon. His thoughts dwell on the four most important people that enhanced his life and weaving though it all those that hurt him the most. A long story about love, retribution, recompense, and a man’s efforts to square the circle.

Was this review helpful?

How I loved this book! Without a sgadow of a doubt my favourite one this year. A book-length monologue, delivered by an 84-year-old Irish farmer in a hotel bar and addressed to his absent son...hmm, I hear you having doubts. But the voice of Maurice Hannigan, raising a toast to each of the five people that shaped his life, this candid laying-open of all the wrinkles of his years captivated me as no other story has done for a long time. A most powerful tale of hidden feelings, revenge, love, grief and determination. And no doubt it will linger long after having finished this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is storytelling as in the oral tradition, with our elderly narrator reflecting on his life and the changing times in rural Ireland, before and after the Celtic Tiger boom. As he relates his story in a letter to his absent son, we relive all the highs and lows with him.
It is a timeless tale, where 'a poor lad makes good’ as in folklore - and one that could have been written by H E Bates or even Thomas Hardy, but written as if spoken in the lyrical Irish vernacular that you can ‘hear’ as you read. The characters are so well-written (especially the beloved older brother) that the story held my interest throughout, despite the often heartbreaking events and inevitable conclusion. Have your box of tissues handy.

Was this review helpful?

Despite being quite a slow paced read I found it to be a beautiful one. It's a story of love, life, growth and everything else.
Highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

Maurice is a widower who is grieving for his wife. The book is written as a letter to his son who lives in US. Maurice is reflecting on his life. He is a likeable, selfish and flawed man. The book appealed to me, I felt it was a well written yarn. Easily read. There is no plot as such, just a series of memories. Although the end is predictable it didn't detract from the novel.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting first novel, but not one I ever felt was a real success. You can go elsewhere for spoiler-heavy reviews, but I didn't really ever believe the whole plot where the certain MacGuffin was concerned – just to pass a young man's infatuation with it off as hard to explain, doesn't make it work as such an important story device, and all that it leads to is undermined. As for the authorial style, it's fine, until it seems to want to be funny and fails, as with his Irishman abroad scenes in the US. Finally, however rich the intertwined family sagas may be, as fate circles round two contrasting households and weaves her web, the biggest problem remains the end. However affecting the last few pages may be, the fact remains we can see them coming from the first few, and there is not enough to keep that hindrance from overloading my response to this book. There is some decent stuff here, with an approach to conveying the last century of Ireland's social and economic history that her mentor John Boyne has in spades, but that structure was a bit of a kiboshing for me. Which was a shame. I'll ignore a few smidgens of stars and round it up slightly to three.

Was this review helpful?

Anyone who has read John McGahern or Bernard McLaverty will just LOVE this. The characters are both stereotypical but totally engaging. We have met these folk before on the pages of a dozen great books about Ireland. I could smell the place it was so sharply drawn. Our main character is a man of the land and an unremarkable man at that. The story is like a fairy tale in its imagery and simplicity but you will NOT want to put it down. The cruelty of society and the dominance of one class over another just a few short years ago is stark and shocking. Sadness leaps from every chapter but the iron will of our hero overcomes all that.. I felt part of the story as an onlooker rather than a reader and that is RARE. And even when the end is signposted it comes as both a surprise but logical conclusion. The tissues were out for our heroes stoicism, love and pragmatism. He could have lived 300 years ago and still told this story. The most moving and wonderful book I have read in 2018. I wish I could start again. Someone with a heart will make a great movie out of this and an Oscar beckons for the actor who can conquer the part of Maurice.

Was this review helpful?

What a refreshing different book. No twists to predict , no bloody hand fisted action just there to shock, no big 'reveals' , no crescendo finish, just a beautifully told story. The narrative is fluent, poetic. The scenes vividly recreated. The characters jump off the page. Though the ending is somewhat predictable, it's in a good way, it seems the only fitting end, not a disappointing one. As a debut, it was assured and well written. It is a gem of a book whose characters will live in my memory for a very long time

Was this review helpful?

What a totally gorgeous read, I loved it, Maurice is a wonderful character and his stories are beautiful to read, I'm a little upset I've finished, he's going to stay with me for a while I reckon.

Was this review helpful?

Beautiful. A poignant lament to a life less well lived than it might have been, where you're left grieving for the man who is and the boy who was.

I remained glued to this story even as I realised what was the inevitable conclusion, because the writing is so beautiful and the story so real.

Despite our hero's obvious flaws, he is a man I soon grew to like and to empathise with in all his decisions, good or bad. He's a man like any other, faced with hardships and with opportunities and there's no judgement required, he does enough of that for himself.

There's no growing crescendo here, no big reveals or mysteries to solve, it's simple walk through the life of a man we could all of us know. Hardworking, taciturn, filled with love and, now, regret.

Loved it.

Was this review helpful?

This was one of those books I didn't want to end.

84-year-old Maurice Hannigan takes a seat at a hotel bar, he is grumpy at the delay being served and is feeling introspective.

He takes a drink and as the evening progresses he will toast 5 people who made an impact on his life. Anne Griffin has written this in such a beautiful way, that you feel you are sat with Maurice, listening to his tales and weeping along with him at times.

This is a quiet book, a soulful read that will make you wonder, just who would you toast, who has had that sort of impact on your life? The ending is very moving and this book will stay with me for a long time. I can see this as being a must read when it’s published in 2019 and I feel very lucky to have had a chance to read it.

I would like to thank the Author/the Publishers/NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for a fair and honest review

Was this review helpful?

A beautiful story told with lyric simplicity
Maurice Hannigan, eighty-four years old, sits in a bar in a small Irish hotel and makes five toasts. These toasts are to the five people he loved the most and meant the most to him in his lifetime. As each of the five stories behind the toasts is recounted, the character and life of Maurice Hannigan are gradually revealed until we have the whole picture of a complex and difficult man who has been damaged by his past, but who ultimately finds love and resolution. He has had a lifetime of suffering, hardship, pain and anger, but this has been mixed with joys, happiness, success and love. Although there is a little action, this book is also a page-turner as each of the five characters links into the next.
This is a very Irish story, it couldn’t really come from anywhere else especially with some of the dialogue. The writing is assured, poetic and fluent. Maurice, the main character, is beautifully drawn - warts and all - and although he dominates the story, the details of the other characters are also brought to life in great detail. When all the strands of the story have been brought together, the end when it comes is not entirely unexpected, but very movingly written.
I loved this gentle and beautiful book and found it hard to believe it is a debut novel. I cannot recommend it too highly.
Jane
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review

Was this review helpful?

A lovely, poignant book which is beautifully written. In a bar, an elderly man raises a toast to five people in his life. Through these toasts we learn a lot about these people and about Maurice (the old man) himself. It is almost poetic at times but at others it can be a little clunky. This is mainly when the narration becomes a little expositional, and Maurice over explains things. Otherwise a lovely book. Thanks to the publishers and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?