Cover Image: Miracle Creek

Miracle Creek

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I initially thought the courtroom literary thriller type plot sounded intriguing. Young and Pak Yoo run an experimental submarine called The Miracle Submarine and one day, after leaving Young in charge of the session, Pak disappears and the submarine explodes with people in it. Was this intentional? If so, who would have the motive to do this and why? While I was interested in finding out these questions, the narration of the story, from various points of view came across as mostly a whole lot of telling. Each person told the story of their pasts, how they came to be in the Miracle Submarine program etc. While there was an underlying question of who's telling the truth, I found the structure boring, the courtroom scenes underwhelming, and overall just couldn't connect with any of the characters. This one wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars

Wow, what a story! This book surprised me in so many ways, which is something I didn’t expect going into it after reading the summary. On the surface, this looked like a typical mystery / thriller but with a unique premise – a hyperbaric oxygen therapy procedure gone horribly wrong and subsequently a young single mother gets put on trial for murder – yet a few chapters in, it became apparent that there was nothing “typical” about this story. In fact, I had a hard time categorizing this book, as it’s one of those stories that starts off with a crime committed – in this case, a fire that was set, resulting in multiple deaths and injuries – but as the facts about the case are debated in court and each character gets to tell their side of the story from their perspective, the narrative evolves into much more than just an exercise in determining guilt or innocence in order to solve a case. Rather, the story becomes a deeper exploration of various issues and experiences that many of us deal with in real life: the complexities of relationships, the obligations involved with marriage and parenthood, the bonds of family, morality and ethics as it pertains to how one deals with incurable medical conditions, etc. – throw into that mix a truly resonant immigrant story, one that gets to the heart of the Asian immigrant experience in terms of culture, acceptance, identity, and the effect this experience can have on those who live it every day. There was a lot of depth to the story as well as to the characters, all of whom I felt that I could relate to and connect with in one way or another, despite coming from a completely different background and, with a few of the characters, not sharing any experiences in common.

This was a book that I found very hard to put down, to the point that I very nearly finished it in one sitting except for the fact that I needed to sleep for a few hours in order for my brain to properly function so I reluctantly had to finish reading in 2 sittings instead. It still amazes me that this is the author Angie Kim’s debut novel, as this was so well-written and the individual threads of the story were woven together so seamlessly, there’s no doubt in my mind about her talent as a writer. I’m typically not a fan of books where courtroom dramas are front and center, as I tend to find them too drawn out and confusing, but this one was very well done, with a perfect balance of twists and turns as the trial went on with the cleverly placed backstories that kept me constantly second-guessing each character’s involvement leading up to the incident. The ending was surprising and not anything at all like what I expected, yet made perfect sense with the way the story played out.

In interviews and articles, the author talks about her family’s own experience with hyperbaric oxygen therapy, which she incorporated into the narrative alongside additional research that gave the story an altogether authentic feel. At times, I felt like I was reading about a real-life court case involving real-life people — a criminal case written so convincingly, I had to remind myself time and again that this was a work of fiction. The realistic nature of the story compelled me to immediately go online after I finished the book so I could find out more about the author and also get some additional background on what I had read.

This is a book you want to go into knowing as little as possible and just let the story take you where it leads. With that in mind, I don’t want to say too much more other than give yourself sufficient time to read this one because once you pick it up, you most likely won’t want to put it down!

Received ARC from Sarah Crichton Books (Farrar, Straus, and Giroux) via NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Well-paced novel that centers around a crime but isn't crime fiction. (Also is not yet another Gone Girl imitation!) Wonderful use of rotating points of view and a very rich exploration of family dynamics.

Was this review helpful?

This is definitely perfectly described as a literary, legal drama. This book took me a little longer than normal to get into, only because I am a criminal attorney and sometimes reading about what I do in my job was exhaustinggg. However, that aside, this book was completely beautiful and engaging. It gave me Little Fires Everywhere vibes in how we got to see so many glimpses into the lives of the people surrounding this trial and tragedy; also in how the book really made you think in terms of "what would I do in this situation" and "what is the right thing to do." Overall, a strong and thought provoking book!!

Was this review helpful?

“Miracle Submarine” is a smart, perceptive, highly addictive courtroom procedural that offers much more than the customary plot of the whodunnit novel. At its center is a Korean immigrant family struggling to make its American dream come true in a small Virginia town by marketing a pressurized oxygen chamber – the Miracle Submarine – to people desperate for a cure of a variety of medical issues. Most are parents of autistic children, and one of them is accused of murdering her 8-year-old son and another mother by causing an explosion at the experimental facility.
The novel deftly seesaws between the trial and the experiences of the main characters, exploring issues of race, immigration, disability, marriage, family, and even smoking as drivers in the evolving mystery. It offers particularly compelling insights into the challenges faced by the mothers of autistic and disabled children, who are not always the heroines society presumes them to be.
The overarching theme is how complicated lies are to maintain – big lies, little lies, lies about relationships, money, identity, and yes, even smoking. But staying silent is just as bad, as becomes clear when all the pieces fall into place. It is the silence that destroys friendships and families and becomes a cancer eating away at the central character’s soul.
Angie Kim is a gorgeous writer, and her background as a Korean immigrant, trial lawyer, and parent elucidates this taut page-turner. She takes her place in the literary crime genre right alongside Celeste Ng and Kate Atkinson.
Thank you Sarah Crichton Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review the ERC.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! It excels on several levels. First and foremost, as a courtroom drama. This was probably my favorite part. I loved the drama. And many times, as the reader, you didn't know what the person testifying was going to say until they said it. Kim did a great job revealing just enough to the reader throughout the story to let you know what's going on and keep you interested, but yet she withheld enough that time and time again there were surprising revelations. That's a hard line to walk but she managed it! Kim also did a great job with character development. There are many key characters in this story and I feel like she did an excellent job at fleshing them out - giving them depth and making them feel real. Really well done!

Was this review helpful?

<b>Miracle Creek</b> is set up as a court room drama, with added mystery and quite a few families under Angie Kim's literary microscope. Central to the story are the Yoos, a Korean immigrant family. Pak, Young and their daughter Mary run Miracle Submarine - a hyperbaric oxygen tank used to treat different diseases. Most of their patients are young children suffering from autism. The only adult is Matt Thompson who is being treated for infertility. One evening there is a terrible explosion at Miracle Submarine that leaves two dead and many more injured. Pak is paralyzed. Matt loses the use of his hand. Mary's face is permanently disfigured. These physical burdens are nothing compared to the emotional scars of the victims or the secrets and lies that threaten the fabric of their families.

On trial is the mother of the young boy who died that day. What would possess a mother to kill her only son? Was her motive attention or freedom? Elizabeth's suspicions of the protesters may be well founded but are they correct? Did Pak commit this heinous act in an attempt to defraud his insurance company? Kim keeps you guessing and questioning until the bitter end. Usually this is a recipe for a very good mystery. But what makes <b>Miracle Creek</b> exceptional is that Kim manages to give depth to a host of characters exposing their flaws and revealing their secrets so that at the end no one is blameless and all bear some of the guilt of this tragic event.

I was pleasantly surprised by this debut.
I understand why <b>Miracle Creek</b> is garnering so much critical acclaim and media attention and look forward to reading more works by Angie Kim.

<i>Special thanks to NetGalley, Farrar, Strauss and Giroux Sarah Crighton Books and Angie Kim for advanced access to this book.</i>

Was this review helpful?

I received an e-ARC from Netgalley and the publishers in exchange for an honest review.

3.5 stars.

This was so-so for me. I didn't really get into it and figure out who was who till about 30/40% in, there are a few people to try and keep straight. I was able to figure out the who (so that was a bummer) but not the why so that was good. I loved the courtroom setting!

Was this review helpful?

Miracles are the stuff people dream about, for love, money, freedom, and often cures for serious illness.
A Korean family were dreamers, for a better life in America and they made it happen. Young and Pak Yoo worked hard to get to the USA, and their dream was for their daughter, Meh-hee-yah, to attend a good college and live a good life. Meh-hee-yah changed her name to Mary early on to fit into her school. The family worked tirelessly to succeed.

Eventually, Young and Pak opened an alternative treatment center known as the HBOT, a vessel that delivered hyperbaric oxygen therapy. People desperate for solutions to conditions not responding to traditional scientific methods like autism and infertility turned to oxygen therapy for help. Some people thought it was working, and others did not.

On a hot summer night in August 2008, the chamber caught fire and blew up, killing two patients and severely injuring others. The novel describes the court trial that followed. The story with background on each person involved is a heartfelt story of disappointment and loss. Beware of miracles; they could become nightmares. Nina Kim has succeeded in bringing me into a complex courtroom drama.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Miracle Creek checks a lot of boxes for me - family drama, a whodunnit, court room proceedings, great characters and excellent writing. The family featured is a Korean immigrant family who runs an experimental medical business that people seek "treatments" for who have autism, infertility and other life altering "ailments". This course of treatment is highly controversial for some and when a fire is responsible for killing two people during a treatment, a murder investigation begins and fingers are pointing everywhere.

It took me about 100 pages to get into the rhythm, but once I found my footing I couldn't tear my eyes away (unless I was forced to since I can't read all day and night 😉). The court room scenes were <b>riveting</b> and I felt like I was there. Picture your favorite court room drama on TV - this was just as good. When the reader wasn't in the court room, we were treated to flashbacks that delved into each characters side of the story, which gave new information to what we already knew. Angie Kim was very clever in her writing, which made it difficult to figure out who started the fire.

If court rooms scenes, or criminal investigations don't quite pique your interest, there is plenty here in the likes of literary fiction, where we go behind the scenes to parents who are literally a slave to their children's lives. There are plenty of discussion pieces here, which make this a perfect book club choice. I highly recommend this and can't wait for Ms. Kim to write her next book.

Thanks to Netgalley, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, and Angie Kim for the opportunity to read and provide an honest review of this book.

Review Date: 4/7/19
Publication Date: 4/16/19

Was this review helpful?

Three stars for Miracle Creek by Angie Kim. There’s plenty of twists and turns in this book to keep you guessing until the end. Each of the characters has a piece of the story, and most are withholding the truth for their own personal benefit. Where I struggled with this story was the obvious gimmick of withholding the truth from the reader specifically to litter “aha” moments throughout the story - it felt less organic to the narrative and more like the book was being written for shock value. I started and stopped reading this for months before finally finishing, and ultimately I felt a bit unfulfilled.

Was this review helpful?

What an impressive debut! This legal drama gripped me immediately and kept my attention throughout many twists and turns. It's told from the perspective of a variety of characters connected to the fire and explosion at Miracle Submarine, an alternative therapy that involves breathing in pure oxygen in a pressurized chamber. Elizabeth Ward, whose son died in the fire, is charged with setting it, but as we follow the other characters during her trial, it becomes clear that everyone is keeping secrets. Besides the mystery, this book addresses a number of heavy issues, and is full of feels, especially near the end. Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

Move over John Grisham and William Landay, there is a new girl in town, her name is Angie Kim and she can write a court room drama just as good or possibly better than you, plus I haven’t read a mystery who dun-it as good as this one since Cormoran Strike hit the stands by Robert Galbraith and we all know who Robert Galbraith is.
I was absolutely blown away by this new author, read this book in just a couple days cause I couldn’t wait to get back to it and didn’t want to put it down when I did. Pak, Young, Mary, Matt, Janine, Elizabeth, Teresa, Henry, TJ and all the others. Wow oh Wow. “Oh what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive.”
This is just about as close to a perfect story as it could be, we follow along on a cat and mouse chase with just a few little tidbits to make us think we are on the right trail, and then she changes the game and we are off on another tangent. I don’t want to give away any spoilers, read this novel, it will be well worth your while and you could learn a whole lot about the emotional roller coasters of parents with autistic or mentally challenged children and the lengths they may go to for help. Plus the ramifications of what can happen with just a little white lie.
Do we ever take the time to sit back, look at our lives and think about those pivotal moments that changed the course of our destiny, was it a missed turn in the road, or was it really supposed to happen all along unbeknownst to us.
Highly recommend!!! I was given an advanced copy from Farrar, Straus and Giroux/Sarah Crichton Books through Net Galley for my honest review, this one gets a HIGH 5*****’s.

Was this review helpful?

Miracle Creek by Angie Kim is a clever courtroom drama that goes between past and present with each chapter a different perspective. When a "miracle submarine" that is supposed to be an oxygen therapy tank to cure everything from infertility to autism starts on fire two people are killed. The fire is confirmed arson but who set the fire and why is the story that unravels throughout the book.

It has been awhile since I read a good courtroom thriller so I was excited to read this book. I felt like the story was complex and interesting. I wouldn't say this was a quick read for me but I enjoyed how all the pieces slowly came together throughout the book and I didn't mind that it took me a little longer to read it. I liked how the characters seemed realistic and how the author explored how parents of children with special needs feel during day to day therapies exhaustion that goes along with their care. I would recommend this book to people who like complicated family relationships, mysteries, and courtroom dramas.

Was this review helpful?

“Miracle Creek” by Angie Kim is a literary thriller set in VA around the mysterious fire of the Miracle Submarine that kills two people. The story follows the murder trial a year later.
The novel alternates between the point of view of all the major characters and has lots of twists and turns along in the way. This book was a quick read for me and the ending unpredictable. Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

“Nothing will happen,...Tragedies don’t inoculate you against further tragedies and misfortune doesn’t get sprinkled out in fair proportions; bad things get hurled at you in clumps and batches, unmanageable and messy.”

If you have the courage to continue after hitting that thought you will read a gripping account of a day that went horribly wrong. Told from the perspectives of those involved, all trying to justify their thoughts and actions, you are shown a myriad of truths, half-truths, and shreds of the truth. You will become involved in a hand wringing courtroom trial that weaves around the truth, the lies, the fabrications and the best and worst intentions of so many that break into a million pieces.

Everyone should have come forward with the truth but the participants learn that their lies demand commitment. “Once you lied, you had to stick to your story”; even if it means creating irreparable harm and destroying innocent people. Angie Kim has plumbed the depths of her characters and made them so real. She has touched on so many different issues creating a believable scenario that heightens the tension, drama, emotion and ending.

Great Book. Great writing. Greater than great.

Thank you Netgalley and Farrar, Straus and Giroux for a copy.

Was this review helpful?

Everyone is keeping secrets in the small town of Miracle Creek...

Have you ever watched a episode of Law & Order: Criminal Intent? That is what this book reminds me of. It felt like a sensational case that was ripped from the headlines and that keeps you flipping through the pages to find out what happens. All the courtroom drama. All the behind the scenes interviews, thoughts of the suspects and the re-enactment of the crime. I was hooked from the beginning and completely shocked at the end. Bravo!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Sarah Crichton books for an Advanced Reader’s Copy of this book. I was so excited when I received the approval to download this book as I was hear so much buzz about this book. The hype is real on this one. The book centers around a murder trial and how it affects this community. This felt a lot like Celeste Ng to me which is probably whyI loved it as much I did.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful debut novel that had me hooked from the very start. It was a moving story full of drama and suspense until the very end. This is mainly the story of a struggling immigrant family trying to live the american dream of supporting themselves and their daughter going to college. Intertwined with their story are the stories of families struggling with autism, cerebral palsy, infertility and losing a child. It brings to light many struggles that families face every day. Throughout the book there's also a question how a fire started that changed these people's lives forever. Suspenseful and devastating this novel will keep you engaged from beginning to end.
I'm grateful that I received an ARC from Netgalley in return for an honest review. I suggest you run to the nearest bookstore and purchase it when it comes out in 2019!

Was this review helpful?

WOW! Courtroom drama at its best with great characters and thought-provoking questions
Young and Pak Yoo are Korean immigrants who run a hyperbaric chamber medical facility in a rural section of northern Virginia where they treat patients with a variety of conditions, including autism. Protesters threaten to shut down the facility, and one day a fire and a resulting explosion destroys the facility and kills a child patient and a patient’s mother. Elizabeth, the mother of the boy who died in the fire, is arrested for murder and brought to trial, but as the trial progresses we find that a number of people had various combinations of means, motive, and opportunity. The protesters had apparently left before the fire began, but Pak Yoo was not at his normal place in the facility; one of the patients’ mothers had said she felt unwell and was sitting on a nearby creek bank instead of being inside with her son; the Yoo’s teen-aged daughter Mary was sneaking cigarettes in the area, and so on. And who called the Yoo’s insurance company not long before the fire asking about coverage in case of arson?
Most of Miracle Creek takes place during the four days of Elizabeth’s trial. This is courtroom drama at its best, as the story unfolds through witness testimony and the reactions of seven primary affected parties. In addition to the Yoo family and Elizabeth, there is also Matthew, a doctor taking hyperbaric treatment for infertility at the insistence of his wife Janine, and Teresa, a mother who was inside the chamber with her son when it exploded. The structure of the story shifts between the perspectives of all of these characters. This type of structure is hard to pull off well, but Kim uses the unifying element of the trial to achieve a coherent story while at the same time letting us get to know her very human characters. We see the Yoos facing the uncertainties common to most immigrants settling into a new country, and their daughter struggling additionally with being a teen-ager in a new society. Matthew is a doctor who is skeptical of any beneficial effects of oxygen treatment on his sperm motility and is hiding a secret. Elizabeth, the mother of an autistic boy, and Teresa, whose son is severely handicapped from cerebral palsy, face motherhood challenges beyond anything they could have expected. They are all very believable people and sympathetic.
The opening lines of Miracle Creek are “My husband asked me to lie. Not a big lie. He probably didn’t even consider it a lie, and neither did I, at first.” This is only the first of many ethical and philosophical problems our seven characters face. There is lying, but there is also simply hiding the truth. When is it okay to do this? How should justice be served? Where should our loyalties be strongest? In addition, in Elizabeth, Teresa, and Kitt, the mother who dies in the explosion, Kim powerfully and convincingly portrays the anguish experienced by these mothers, who love their children dearly but sometimes wish they were dead. Kim raises these ethical questions in very thought-provoking ways.
Miracle Creek is much more than a legal thriller, but it IS a great legal thriller. The reader is kept guessing whodunit, as it becomes increasingly possible that there are many suspects in addition to Elizabeth. The ending is a real shocker and presents one final ethical quandary whose resolution I cannot wait to debate with my friends.
My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance review copy of Miracle Creek and my thanks to Angie Kim for writing such a super book.

Was this review helpful?