Member Reviews

I was so excited to see Fiona Barton's newest book on Netgalley. I had no idea it was going to include Kate until I actually picked it up to read. I was really excited to see her character pop up again. Even though these books have turned into a series, you can read them as a standalone. I do have to say each book ends up being better than the last so I would highly recommend starting from the beginning for the full experience.

So the story is about two girls who on their trip to Thailand go missing. Kate Waters, the eager reporter, jumps on the chance to cover the story. She also has a son who is currently living in Thailand. She soon begins to find out that her son might have something to with the missing girls. Kate will do whatever she can to get to the bottom of this story.

So after reading this I saw some people were saying they thought the story was a bit slow. I have to agree but I felt Fiona's writing still keeps you engaged in the story. It was a slow pace but I found myself wanting to know more each step of the way. I also think it helps that she writes such short chapters. I would tell myself just one more chapter so many times. It really helps.

Another thing that I enjoyed is the point of you. You have the point of view of the mother of one of the missing girls, one of the missing girls, Kate, the reporter, and the detective on the case. I really enjoyed the point of view of the missing girl. I enjoyed hearing about her trip and trying to find out what ended up having to her and the other girl. I do wish there were more chapters in her point of view. I know there weren't because the author probably didn't want to give to much away. I do feel we could have done without the point of view of the detective. I feel his point of view didn't really add much to the story. I didn't really care what was going on in his life. It just felt a bit unnecessary to me.

Overall I thought this was an enjoyable story. I liked that it was a slow pace. I feel it really built up for the surprises that happened towards the middle and end of the book. Fiona really does a great job keeping you engaged with the story. I couldn't wait to find out what actually happened. I do hope she ends up writing another book with Kate in it. I would like to see how she's been dealing with everything that ended up happening in this book. Plus I her stories just keep getting better and better.

*I received a free copy of this book on Netgalley in exchange for a honest review.*

Was this review helpful?

Love this author. The setting was interesting and the plot of missing young people really hit home with me

Was this review helpful?

This is a captivating search for two teenagers, who went on a seemingly innocent trip to Thailand, but this story is so much more than that. When the girls aren’t heard from again, their families beg for help from the Thailand police. Then, they turn towards journalist Kate Waters who is quite interested in telling their story and help search for the girls.

Kate Waters is having her own family difficulties when her son left home two years ago and hasn’t been seen since. The story takes a personal turn for Kate.

Fiona Barton sure has a wonderful knack for writing twists and turns. It almost felt as if the story was over early, but it was far from done. It’s told from different point of views - the journalist, the detective, one of the girls, and the mother of one of the girls. It’s a clever way to bring it all together.

I didn’t always like all the characters, but my heart went out to them. This author knows how to grab her reader’s attention and keep it to the end of the book. I read the last book, but have to go back and read the first one. Although this is the third book in the series, it can be read as a standalone.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this book. The story is about two girls who go to Thailand together after school and then go missing. It is told from different perspectives. A reporter from a newspaper is covering the story. An English police detective is also involved. The characters are all somehow connected but the reader only finds out towards the end what the connection is. A good and quick read with an interesting plot.

Was this review helpful?

The Suspect by Fiona Barton was an interesting mystery read. The main characters - "The Mother", "The Reporter", and "The Detective" were all well written and easy to identify with.

While I thought this was a good book, I was able to figure out the story pretty early on. I was enticed to keep reading to see if my thoughts were correct and how exactly they played out. I did have a difficult time keeping track of all of the "secondary" characters i.e. the other members of the police force and press, but that didn't seem to hinder the story line at all..

I will look into reading other books by this author as well as the first 2 books in the Kate Waters series.

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Children grow up and leave home. It's the natural order of things. But in The Suspect, two eighteen-year-old girls, Alex and Rosie, go on what is supposed to be a joyful first trip on their own to Thailand. When they are reported missing, their desperate, heartbroken parents find themselves thrust into an international spotlight as they struggle to learn what the girls were doing when they suddenly disappeared.

For journalist Kate Waters the search for the two girls becomes more than another attempt to get an exclusive story. Her own son, Jake, left home two years ago to travel around the world after abruptly leaving school. He has communicated little with his parents in that time. When Kate begins chasing the story of Alex and Rosie, she has no idea of the personal connect that she will discover or how it will impact her family.

"We don't always know what our children get up to when we're not there, do we?" Author Fiona Barton brings back the character of Kate in this creative, unique mystery. The story is multi-layered and will resonate with readers long after they read the last page. The theme of whether it is possible to ever really know another human being is not a new one in literature. Perhaps less explored is the question of how well parents can ever really know their children. Or how they respond when parents learn that their grown children are not really the people they believed them to be. In The Suspect, at least two sets of parents are confronted with those questions as the search for Alex and Jenny proceeds. In this instance, the 2 young women journeyed to a country they had never visited before, where they did not know anyone, and their safety depended upon their ability to depend upon and trust each other. However, Barton illustrates with startling clarity how such a trip can go tragically wrong. Concurrently, the reporter following the story finds herself dealing with her own family crisis when it is discovered that Jake was at the same boarding house as the two girls. Barton has believably constructed a mystery that, as it is unraveled, evokes a deep emotional response, particularly from readers who are parents.

The story twists and turns, providing shocking surprises at a pace as relentless as the parents' frantic search for their children. Barton also looks at the roles the media plays in such events, shaping public opinion and loyalties which shift uncomfortably as details about the girls' fate and Jake's activities emerge.

The result is a haunting, heartbreaking story exploration of parents' relationships with their adult children, the difficulty inherent in watching children grow and venture into the world on their own, and the way parental expectations can impact the relationship. It is ultimately a thought-provoking tale that would be ideal for book clubs, providing plenty of themes and colorful characters for vigorous discussion.

Was this review helpful?

This was just alright. I found it a little slow for the first half of the book, and I didn't really have any interest in the characters in the way that I would like. The mystery was interesting enough, but it wasn't the best that I've ever read, either. The ending was kind of just alright for me, too. Nothing inherently wrong with the book, it just didn't pull me in like I was hoping that it would.

Was this review helpful?

When reviewing books, I strive to be as honest as I can without being rude. I have never written a book and I admire anyone who has. This statement is not a prelude for a negative review, more like a bit of advice. When you start a series with book one and for whatever the reasons do not care for it ; do not give up on the series. Give book two a try. This was certainly the case for me with Fiona Barton’s Kate Waters series.

I did not like the first book of the Kate Waters series, The Widow. I did not like Kate. I found her obnoxious, pushy, and invasive. I finished The Widow but I was not sure if I wanted to read any more books in the series. When the second book The Child released; I was intrigued by the synopsis and gave Kate Waters another shot. I absolutely loved The Child. Somehow Kate seemed softer. She came across as resourceful rather than devious; a truth seeker rather than invasive. Kate Waters has now become one of my favorite characters in crime fiction.

In Thailand two teenagers, Alex and Rosie are on a trip of a lifetime, away from their families in England for the first time. When the girls fail to call home to get the results of their placement courses, Alex’s and Rosie’s parents report them missing to the Thailand police. Investigative Journalist Kate Waters learns of the missing girls and jumps at the chance to cover the story for her newspaper. Once Kate arrives in Thailand she discovers her shocking and troubling connection to the missing girls.

Reading a crime fiction book from the perspective of a journalist is always fun for me. Unlike police officers, journalists have little to no authority when interviewing witnesses. They cannot make someone come in for questioning or walk freely around a crime scene. They have to be smart, intuitive, and fast on their feet. Kate is able to read people, by their body language and where they choose to pause when answering a question. While I was reading I thought, Kate would make a great police detective.

In The Suspect, the third book of the Kate Waters series, we find Kate in a different set of circumstances than in The Widow and The Child. She is still a journalist but she is also a major part of a developing story. Her fellow journalists are using all the tricks of the trade on her. The new situation gives Kate a chance to reflect on some of the things she has done over the course of her career; the privacy of a grieving family she invaded to get a picture of them at their most vulnerable moment, the white lie told to gain access to a crime scene. While Kate does not seem ashamed of her past behavior, I do think she recognizes the irony of the situation. I believe this unexpected and forced self-reflection will have a lasting affect on Kate personally and professionally.

Although Kate is the main character of The Suspect, Barton gives readers access to the police officer who is investigating Alex’s and Rosie’s disappearance as well as Alex’s mother. There are also flashbacks from Alex leading up to her disappearance. These multiple perspectives make the story well rounded and gives readers a complete picture of what was going on before and after the girls vanish.

The Suspect, The Widow, and The Child can each be read as a stand alone. Each new installment of the series is a different case unrelated to the last. Characters from previous books are mentioned in The Suspect but they not vital to the plot. Readers in the mood for a bittersweet, shocking yet subtle read, should add The Suspect to their list of must reads.


Murder and Moore Rating:

5 out of 5 stars

Was this review helpful?

Though I have the first book by this author in print, I haven’t yet read it. And when I requested this book, I had no idea that either of them was part of the same series, so…there you go. Fortunately, I don’t think it made much difference, at least not to my enjoyment of the story.

Definitely a slow burn, this one. The first half jumps between narrators, giving insight into what the girls were up to before they went missing, while simultaneously walking us through the parent’s feelings and actions as they try to find them. Honestly, I was a bit bored and even a smidge irritated. Fortunately, it picked up in the second half, when it was finally revealed what became of the girls, and the story started to unravel the who’s and the why’s. Thanks to the second half, I don’t regret having pushed through.

The characters were rather flat as was the mood. There just wasn’t enough character development to latch on to anyone in a significant way. The primary reason for this is there was so much going on, so many different background stories offered as a means to muddy the waters (all that motive!). However, I feel like there should at least have been some deeper connection to Kate and the Detective as I suspect they are the two characters that connect the series.

And the ending! Just. No. Nuh uh. I can’t say for certain that I would have done differently because I’m not in that situation, and I can’t elaborate because *spoilers* but it didn’t sit well with me. Not even a little bit.

Nutshell: Slow start, much better second half, minimal buy in, decent mystery, frustrating ending.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars for a return to Kate Waters! I have always been a fan of procedural series and love watching a main character evolve over various cases. Barton has put an interesting spin on the procedural with Kate operating as a reporter on the periphery of law enforcement. In The Suspect, Kate has more stake in the case than we've seen before, as her own son Jake may be involved.

Laced with tension and unfolding suspense at every turn, Barton has written an interesting mystery with connections even the most observant reader would not uncover. I'm looking forward to seeing what case grabs Kate next!

Thank you to Berkley for an advanced copy. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this novel, as I have Barton's previous novels. This story of a Thai gap-year adventure of two British girls that turns tragic kept me turning the pages, and I found the portrayals of its characters believable. With spare language, this author delivers a punch. No one comes out smelling like rose in the end.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge Fiona Barton fan ever since I read her first book The Widow so anytime I see her books its an automatic buy or request. for me. She some how manages to suck you in right from the get go and this was no exception.

Without going to deep into the book I have to say that this was certainly a roller coaster of emotions and feelings. Just when you think you have it figured out she flips the script leaving you questioning how could you have gotten this wrong and that was me.

Great storyline with great characters and each one played a fantastic part in telling the story.

Was this review helpful?

It’s been two years since reporter Kate Water’s son left for Thailand, so when she gets a tip about two missing girls there, she jumps on the story. The girls turn up dead, and Kate heads to Bangkok to learn why. Take a steadying breath, Barton’s sharp thriller reveals the fear deep in a parent’s heart.

Was this review helpful?

The threads that make up this mystery don’t really start to get particularly interesting until about halfway into this novel.

We’ve met reporter Kate in the first two books of this series. She’s the only character who tells her story in first person, letting us know that her oldest son dropped out of school two years ago and has barely kept in touch with his family since, obviously leaving Kate, her husband, and her younger son to worry. So Kate throws herself into work. It’s August, and everyone is on holiday, so the newspaper she writes for is desperate for any story that might sell papers. When two eighteen-year-old girls disappear in Thailand, it’s as good a story as any, even though the Thai police and the British police try to assure the girls’ parents that they almost always show up.

Another point of view is of the mother of one of the girls who is missing. Another POV is before the disappearance from Alex, one of the now-missing girls, and is told via her Facebook posts and her private emails to her best friend back home.

This is a decent mystery, but if you are looking for a breathless page-turner, this isn’t it.

Thanks so much to NetGalley for the opportunity to read this novel.

Was this review helpful?

While about 1/2 in, the story really picked up and hooked me...it was a little slow to get going. Several times I thought about setting it aside but since it was a preview, I felt I needed to stick with it. Then, finally it started picking up. Best news is that it ended with loads of twists and turns.

Was this review helpful?

So, do you remember the movie "Brokedown Palace" with Claire Danes? I saw it once, years ago, and it terrified me. It made me never want to travel to Thailand. This book reaffirms that decision.

Okay, maybe it's not that serious. Thai jail is no joke, and staying in a hostel sounds like the absolute worst. I also think its much more an aspect of British culture to travel to Thailand for holiday. Here in the US, we just head to the beaches of Florida or Mexico.

Anyway, I digress.

I LOVED this book. Supsenseful from the jump. Two girls go to Thailand after High School, things don't go as planned, their family has to cope halfway around the world.

The two girls end up staying at a ramshackle "hostel" with a sketchy looking crew. Alex, the more mature of the two can't wait to move on, but is scared to leave without her traveling companion. Not the person she wanted to travel with anyway. (This reminded me of the time I was in Europe with American Music Abroad and roomed with Martha. She would sneak out, drink, bring boys back, etc. I was a soon to be Junior in high school and superemly uncomfortable the entire time....so I idenfied with Alex).

After a tragedy, the story revolves between the girls parents, the detective in England, and the Reporter who lands the story. (The same reporter of Barton's earlier books). Through a twist, there is a surprising connection between the people working this case. It threw me for a loop. And then with about 50 pages left there is a whole other twist that made me gasp out loud whilst I read at me desk at work (shhhhhhhh!).

Super great read, I can't wait for more of her work!

Was this review helpful?

Two 18-year old girls, Alex and Rosie, go missing while on holiday in Thailand. After their parents notify police, reporter Kate Waters jumps at the chance to cover the story. This time, however, the tables have turned on Kate. She discovers that her son who’s been living in Thailand may somehow be involved. What happens when her own family is thrust in the spotlight?

The story is told in short chapters and alternating POVs – the reporter, the detective, the mother, and one of the missing girls. The opening grabbed my attention, though I had a harder time staying engaged with this book versus the first two in the series. At about the 30% mark, the major twist (IMO) was revealed. I thought, huh. Now what’s going to happen for another 300 pages? The middle moved by slowly, but things picked up closer to the end.

I very much enjoyed The Widow and The Child, but something was a bit off about this one. The premise was intriguing, but the execution didn’t grab me, and I never warmed to the characters unfortunately!

Was this review helpful?

When two young women go missing on their gap year adventure in Thailand, their frantic parents are wooed by a reporter, eager to get the story, whose son has also gone off the grid. A fast, suspenseful read that underscores how terrifying parenthood can be after one's children have stuck out into the world on their own.

Was this review helpful?

I liked the telling of this story from multiple points of view. And I also enjoyed that each point of view's story was written so realistically. The mystery wasn't a huge one to figure out but there are some nice twists.

Was this review helpful?

While I quite liked Barton's other books, this one fell short of my expectations. I was excited by the premise (two teens go missing while traveling in Thailand), but the execution was lacking. It's slow-building and I had already guessed the "twist" at the end halfway through the book.

Was this review helpful?