Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Loved this book. I loved how the author weaves the story and characters together and loved learning more of the history of this area of the ultra rich

Was this review helpful?

Oh Montauk! A beautiful place, which I visit frequently, so, on a personal level, I loved reading about Montauk of the 1930's, peppered with many facts of its history and culture. This book will make a great summer read, full of gossip, sunshine and love affairs. I really enjoyed it and found it very hard to put down. Thank you NetGalley for the early reader edition, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk tells the story of a summer resort in the late 1930s, and although it is set a decade after The Great Gatsby I thought it had a similar feel.

Beatrice is the young wife of a wealthy businessman and banker who is summering in Montauk for the first time. The novel is full of parties, gossip about the lives of the rich, happy and unhappy marriages and friendships. It also explores some social issues through the contrast between rich and poor, women’s increasing freedom, anti-semitism and the early rumblings of war in Europe.

Montauk is not always an enjoyable read because some of the characters are very unpleasant, but the writing really captured the setting and the characters, and I was interested right to the end.

Was this review helpful?

I honestly cannot say that I was completely drawn into Montauk in the beginning but as the story progressed, I found myself more vested in the lives portrayed and in the outcomes of their interactions.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this epic page-turner about the elite Manhattan crowd of the late 1930s and their early summers at the tip of Long Island, on newly developed Montauk. Beautifully written and well researched, the historical backdrop of how Montauk was transformed from a small fishing village to a summer playground for the rich gives this novel a true cinematic quality. Readers are quickly drawn into this world with all of it's evident beauty and contrasting hypocrisy that lies just below the surface. Beatrice Bordeaux, a converted-by-marriage New York socialite who never quite fits into the society scene, is the central figure in this sweeping story and a character that you cannot help but root for from the very first page. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel from debut author Nicola Harrison. Thanks to Net Galley and St Martin's Press for the ARC - I have no doubt this will be one of the great beach reads for summer 2019!

Was this review helpful?

Woah, what a read! Life in the higher echelons of 1930s American society- ladies who lunch, the movers of Manhattan. The descriptions of the lives these women led were eye opening, the pursuit of prestige, the need to support your husband’s career, the lack of choice the women really had. Beatrice, not long married, travels reluctantly to Montauk for the summer so that she can support her husband’s business ventures. Harry, her husband, is keen to persue his own affairs in the city, and Bea spends each week day looking for something to fulfil her. Fans of Beatriz Williams will enjoy this, as well as anyone interested in this period and the social history of the era.

Was this review helpful?

A lovely and well written first novel about a difficult to find, history, of Montauk. One does not often comtemplate the history of this tiny village, found at the tip of Long Island, N.Y. The setting just before World War II reminds one that life was still quite different for residents residing there and the wealthy summer visitors.

The lighthouse keeper and his meeting with one of these summer visitors is the setting for a romance that brings peril to many entwined in the lives surrounding this endearing couple.

Was this review helpful?

Nicola Harrison's Montauk is the epitome of good women's fiction. Add well researched history, lovely realistic, but lyrical writing and a protag who grows on the pages to become a woman to be reckoned with and you have a keeper. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

This book is bound to be a hit during the summer of 2019. While some of the story was a little slow to me I have to admit that I was entranced in the story. I look forward to seeing what else the author has to offer in the future.

Full review to come closer to release.

Was this review helpful?

Anyone who has been to Montauk will enjoy this beach read. The story takes place in 1938 when Montauk was not 'the place to be' yet, but, just a sleepy fishing village. A group of investors from Manhattan thought it would be a great summer place for their wealthy society wives while they worked in the city weekdays and joined them on the weekends. I especially liked the fact they dined at Duryea's, we did too when vacationing there a few years ago. I also liked the added history of the 1938 September hurricane. #montauk #netgalley

Was this review helpful?

I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of Prosper Redding: The Last Life of Prince Alastor. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Holy smokes! This book was not what I expected at all--it was SO MUCH MORE! As cliche as it is, I could not put this book down. I needed to know if Beatrice would find happiness. I was really rooting for the her to get a break and have it all... I felt all of her pain, humiliation, fear, love, and loss. (Her husband, Harry, was not "worth the skin he was in"! I truly loved to hate him!) Oh what a few tumultuous days I had--with such a contrast between the severely sweet highs and the devastating lows! There were some very unexpected turns which I refuse to spoil, but I must say that I wish some things had gone differently for her. (For this reason alone, I had to rate only 4 stars.) At the same time, I will happily read this author again.

Thank you to NetGalley and Nicola Harrison for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?

I typically don't read historical fiction, but I grew up on eastern Long Island and have spent quite a bit of time in Montauk. So how could I possibly refuse the opportunity to see what Montauk was like in 1938(I couldn't)? It was the beginning of the end of a quiet fishing town when wealthy NYC residents began arriving in droves for the summer.
Beatrice and Harry have been married for 5 years and have grown apart. The thought of spending the summer away from the city, gives Beatrice hope that she and Harry can reconnect. What she hadn't fully considered were the long lonely weekdays when Harry went back to work and she was left to make friends with the other wives. Many of these women are already mothers and Beatrice has very little in common with these society wives. Beatrice grew up in rural Pennsylvania far from the glitz and glamour of NYC and is more comfortable with those who work at the Manor. Will this summer in Montauk be good for Beatrice and Harry or will it tear them apart?
The author did a wonderful job describing not only Montauk but also what it was like to summer with high society. So many rules, so much extravagance, and so little actual love between so many of these characters. No spoilers here, but I will say I was hoping that Beatrice would find some way to belong.
The pace is slow, like a lazy summer day, but not at all boring. It is a look at a simpler time and place and the fact that I read this in front of a fire on a cold fall day, made me long for summer in Montauk. I have read so many wonderful debut novels in 2018 and Montauk is another one to add to that list.
I received a DRC from St. Martin's Press through NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, this book never quite took off for me. I read about 40% before abandoning ship. There was a good deal of set up, and it’s just too slow to get to action for me.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk is an amazing debut novel written by Nicola Harrison. The story opens at the beginning of summer in 1938. The well to do families are arriving at the Montauk Manor. This is the place to be seen and to see others who occupy the top echelon of New York's social and economic status. The husbands will stay the weekend and return to work during the week. This is their schedule for the rest of the summer. What follows shows the dichotomy between the rich and those who work to provide their comfort. Beatrice hopes to rekindle the desire she and her husband of 5 years shared earlier in the marriage. Harry seems more uninterested everyday and refuses to talk about whatever's happening. Beatrice doesn't know that the rich lead very different lives than the middle class family she came from.

The characters are well crafted and believable. The rich versus poor theme is skillfully brought to life when Beatrice tries to befriend Elizabeth who does everyone's laundry. Elizabeth is worried about losing her job if anyone sees them together and pleads with Beatrice to understand she is capable of doing the laundry on her own.. There are so many rich moments that show the difference between the haves and have nots that I could go on describing them but it's much better that you discover them for yourself. I think this book is good enough to be on next year's best seller list.


I received an Advanced Reader's Copy from St Martin's Press through NetGalley. The opinions expressed are completely my own.
#Montauk #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

This was a slow burn for me, but once I got to the 50% point I was fully invested. It was very interesting to read about the beginning days of Montauk as a vacation destination for the more privileged. There was also a little Downton Abbey/upstairs, downstairs feel to it as well. I liked Beatrice. She was strong in her convictions and I respected her. I wasn't happy with the ending, but I respect the author's choice.

Was this review helpful?

I was expecting more from this book -- it was good and I enjoyed it, but as a fan of Beatriz Williams, Fiona Davis and others this was just ok...

It was a quick read and I wished there was a little bit more to the main character Beatrice. It was predictable and all of a sudden it ended and left me wanting more. I did love the descriptions of those who summered in Montauk and the location.

Was this review helpful?

Usually I'm not a huge fan of historical romances. This one though, I thoroughly enjoyed. It takes a look at the summer time in the late 30's living among the wealthy in a beach from front home.
Thanks for the Arc

Was this review helpful?

I did not finish this book after 30% into it. I could not get into it and thought Bea was a very weak character. The other Ladies Who Lunch were just as vapid. I may try this again closer to release date to see if I can get through it. I am sorry this was not to my taste but thank you for the opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

As an English major in college, I took a class on travel writing and had to write about a specific place and what made it so special to us. For Nicola Harrison, Montauk is her place and she does a magnificent job of sharing it with readers. Set in 1938, but with conversations and topics still happening today, this piece of historical fiction is bursting with everything from a local school damp and in need of repair to castle-like manors and a grand, but also useful lighthouse that will change Beatrice Bordeaux's life forever. Harry Bordeaux, Bea's husband, is a successful man and he, along with many others, send their wives to the hotspot, Montauk, for the summer. Since Bea has no children to care for and no job to keep her occupied, she's initially concerned when the summer begins. Very quickly, though, she finds friends and over the course of the twelve weeks spent in Montauk, finds herself as well. This Gatsby-esque tale is sprinkled with a hint of Gossip Girl and has everything: fashion, friends, affairs, feuds, and love. Harrison says it best: "No matter how perfect all these lives might have seemed from a distance, so full of possibilities and promise, we all wanted more" (364). Grab this one ASAP!

Was this review helpful?

Normally I don't read romance type books/novels but found this one very interesting. Enjoyed the historical aspects of how a sleepy beach front community could have become the playground for upper society. How we can overlook the views of the local folks vs. the games of life the summer visitors may play.

I enjoy reading about this time frame from the 1930's, what life was like and how folks lived, their values, and way of life. Interesting twists and turns in the plot that kept me engaged and I felt well written.

Was this review helpful?