Cover Image: A Glad Obedience

A Glad Obedience

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I really enjoyed this book by Brueggemann - especially the first half that dissected four psalms.  They were powerful, beautiful reminders of the importance of worship. The second half of the book - unpacking hymns - was interesting, but many of the hymns were unfamiliar to me. Overall a good read!
Was this review helpful?
A Glad Obedience by Walter Brueggeman is a delightful read.  This book is full of gems to be savored one at a time.  It is the why we worship.  I absolutely love it and recommend it.  I received a digital copy of this book from the publisher with no obligations.  These opinions are entirely my own.
Was this review helpful?
One of the consequences of sin is rebellion. Constant rebellion. Whether it is squabbling or dissent; reaction or retaliation; in a world of different voices and mindsets, it is easy for relationships to break down quickly even after years of goodwill. How is it that human beings do not get along as well as they ought to? In Christian Theology, sin has essentially cut ourselves loose from desiring to worship God. This in turn has led to a breakdown in human relationships. It is all connected. How do we fix this? Turn our hearts from reluctance to acceptance; from sadness to gladness; from rebellion to obedience. Even believers too must guard against hidden resistance and unbelief. For example, one might not understand why we sing certain songs during Sunday worship. Without an appreciation of the meaning behind the songs or the message behind the hymn, we lose out on the rich history and theological significance of the songs. In this book, Walter Brueggemann helps us bridge the gap from ignorance to understanding. We learn about framing songs around joyful truth of the gospel. We examine Scripture using the music and songs from various angles. We cultivate creative imagination to let the Word of God speak to us from different angles. We learn also to pay attention to context and to let songs stretch our faith.

Inspired by the 2013 hymnal, "Glory to God: Hymns, Psalms, and Spiritual Songs," the author focuses on two key questions:

    Why We Sing?
    What We Sing?

In the first part, "Why We Sing," Brueggemann looks at four different psalms. In Ps 104, he uses the themes of wonder and awe that inspire praise. Calling it the "best model for a creation hymn," we sing as an earthly response to a glorious God. Lest we shrink the world to our own thoughts and perspectives. In Ps 105, we remember God's actions that moves us to obeying God with gladness. From God delivering Israel from Egyptian slavery to how He redeems us from sin through Jesus, we look forward to a future glory in Christ. We also see how our culture of self-indulgence is a modern form of slavery. In Ps 106, we see our own sinful waywardness to help us be honest with our sins and weaknesses. As a "counter-narrative" to Ps 105, we sing because we need to know the truth about ourselves. We reflect on our rebellious nature. We seek God with continued pleas and revelation of God's truth. We then sing the truth in spite of trouble or despair. In Ps 107, we learn of gratitude that leads us toward hymns of thanks and praise. Lest we fall into ingratitude to give thanks to where thanks are due. Interestingly, Brueggemann discusses Ps 104, 107, 105, and 106 in that order rather than in numerical order. I suppose one can only worship authentically when we deal with the things that hinder us. Ps 104 helps us tackle self-indulgence and self-groundedness. Ps 105 helps us resist ingratitude. Both of these are crucial barriers to remove before we can take a closer and clearer look at ourselves. This is followed by Ps 105 and ps 106 to teach us to resist disobedience and avoid denial respectively. 

Part Two deals with attentiveness to the words in the hymns, to slow ourselves down to the pace of the hymn-mood. For once we pay adequate attention to the theology of the words, we are better able to sing with vibrancy and faith. This is crucial in an age of quick-fix and fast-tempo songs that possess tunes that might be catchy but distracting. Both timing, mood, and words must blend in to exalt truth. I like the way Brueggemann says: Relish. That's what worship is about: relishing and savouring the presence of God. It invites participation. It stimulates the desire of God. It keeps us attentive to the Word and sensitive to the Presence of the Holy Spirit. After listing the selected hymn in full, Brueggemann shows us what relishing means. Each verse comes with a description, like a master scholar exegeting a verse. We move back and forth between the history of the hymn and the thinking of the hymn-writer. We are then given an affirmative truth of why we sing. "Blest be the Tie that binds" brings us to affirming truth of faith in an age of half-truths and deception. "Holy, Holy, Holy" is about how the beauty of God "takes our breath away." "I Sing the Mighty Power of God" may seem to be individualistic, but it was written in the context of a singing community together. IT reminds us that only the power of God could rule the world. "O for a Closer Walk With Thee" is our acknowledgement of our need for God and how He will save and restore us. Toward the end, there are two hymns surrounding the subject of "sparrows" which might raise an eyebrow or two. Upon thinking about Jesus' reference to the birds in his famous anti-worry exhortation, it begins to make sense. "God's Eye is On the Sparrow" connects us in both heavenly hope and earthly reality, and to sing of God taking care not just of the whole world but also on us. "God of the Sparrow" not only carries forth this same theme but helps us worship from where we are: Our creatureliness.

My Thoughts
There are three reasons why I like this book. Firstly, it is a well structured defense for the relevance of hymns today. Just because something is old does not mean it is irrelevant. We need to beware of what CS Lewis has warned us about "chronological snobbery" that makes us thing that only the latest and the greatest are preferred. That is essentially one symptom of living in a culture of "technological fixes." Everything old seem to be waiting for a new fix to come. By resisting this tendency, we are taught to wait on the words of truth, which are timeless. The hymns selected by Brueggemann are quite varied. Many of them are relatively familiar, at least to those in that sing hymns. By the way, I still think that modern renditions of hymns still lack that classic catchy tunes of old. For that reason, given a choice between a new and an old tune, I would prefer the old tunes as the newer melodies could become a distraction in themselves.

Secondly, Walter Brueggemann continues to amaze me with his ability to connect history with reality. With his knowledge of Scripture, in particular, the Old Testament, and his ability to understand the human struggle, he helps us see old hymns with new eyes of understanding. He makes a great point when he says that hymn singing is a "bold act of resistance" against our culture of "monetization, technological fixes, and instrumental reasoning." The way he directs our attention to counter these three things is worth the price of this book. On "monetization," we are urge to cultivate relationships over the riches of money and worldly things. On "technological fixes," we learn to move away from the worries of problem-solving toward appreciating the essence of "sacramental mystery." On "instrumental reasoning," we substitute "convenience" in favour of covenantal truth.

Finally, it is written by Walter Bruggemann. Fans and readers who enjoy his works will understand this. Any book written by this man is worth reading.

Walter Brueggemann is currently the William Marcellus McPheeters professor emeritus of Old Testament at Columbia Theological Seminary. He has also taught at Eden Theological Seminary from 1961 to 1986. A prolific author, he has written many books, of which "The Prophetic Imagination" and his commentaries have been among the most popular.

Rating: 5 stars of 5.

This book has been provided courtesy of Westminster John Knox Press and NetGalley without requiring a positive review. All opinions offered above are mine unless otherwise stated or implied.
Was this review helpful?
I love the psalms and hymns and was looking forward to reviewing this book. He had some good things to say about the psalms he wrote about, but he was too wordy. I lost interest in the hymns because he just said too much. I would have enjoyed it more if he had condensed it to the main points that he was making.
I received this book free from the publisher for the purpose of an honest review.
Was this review helpful?
I'm giving this only two stars because 1, Brueggemann bows down to false liberal and unbelieving theologians who form their beliefs based on false and unjustified presuppositions. 2. This book was really boring. I have read his books before, and they were fine, but there is something about this book that made it extremely hard to get through. Apart from that, if you can handle the boring aspect of it, Brueggemann has lots of gold nuggets to provide in regards to the psalms and hessed.
Was this review helpful?
Hymn singing is a communal act that reinforces a congregation's identity and faith commitment. It is often the highlight of worship for most in the pews. The hymns comfort and they confirm and they spur to be better.

As choral singer since childhood, I have long understood that to sing is to be part of a community, working together toward a common goal. Singing in worship is an act of praise, a confirmation of faith, and can spur a recommitment of intent.

Walter Brueggemann's A Glad Obedience  examines the tradition of song in worship, beginning with the Psalms and then considering classic and contemporary hymns including “Blest Be the Ties That Binds,” "Holy Holy Holy,"“God's Eye Is on the Sparrow,” "Love Divine, All Loves Excelling," "O For a Closer Walk With God," “Once to Every Man and Nation,” “Someone Asked the Question,” and “We Are Marching in the Light of God.

In Part I, he asks, Why do we sing this psalm? Beginning with Psalm 104, a creation hymn, he breaks down its parts to explain what it meant to its original singers. For instance, "the song is sung in an arid climate" and uses water imagery (You make springs gush forth in the valleys) as affirmation that all life, human and plant and animal, "stand together before the life-giving gifts of God." 

As Brueggemann walks us through the Psalms he leads readers into a deeper understanding of the text and faith.

"We sing our penultimacy as an act of resistance and as a proposal of alternative. The resistance performed by this singing is against the reduction of creation to a series of commodity transactions because it is all gift...It is the affirmation that we live in a generous context of abundance in which there is enough for all of God's creatures." from A Glad Obedience by Walter Brueggemann

Part Two, What We Sing, Brueggemann considers traditional and contemporary hymns. He "relishes the words, phrases, and images that lie deep in our faith tradition" to show how attentiveness to the hymn lyrics challenge the "dominant worldly ideology" and can lead to"joyous risk-taking obedience."

One of my favorite hymns, God of Grace and God of Glory by Harry Emerson Fosdick, is included. "Grant us wisdom, grant us courage, for the living of these days," "Cure thy children's warring madness, bend our pride to thy control," "Save us from weak resignation to the evils we deplore," are lines that seem to be always relevant.

Brueggemann first presents the hymn's historical context, written in 1930, during the depression and in a time when the world "struggled with systemic disarmament." He considers the theological bent of Fosdick's Social Gospel and how the hymn's theology is related to that of his contemporaries Paul Tillich and Reinhold Niebuhr (author of the well-known Serenity Prayer). Then he breaks the hymn down with a commentary.

A neglected hymn which Brueggemann admires is based on James Russell Lowell's 1845 poem "Once to Every Man and Nation." Lowell wrote the words as a protest against President Polk's expansionist war with Mexico as a way to add slave states to shift the balance of power. 

Once to every man and nation
Comes the moment to decide,
In the strife of truth with falsehood,
For the good or evil side;
Some great cause, God's new Messiah,
Offering each the bloom or blight,
And the choice goes by forever
'Twixt that darkness and that light.
            from Once to Every Man and Nation

Brueggemann relates the hymn's time and purpose to the current president's immigration policy. Brueggemann writes, "...when we sing this hymn...we also sing concerning our own moral crisis in which the quality and future of our common humanity is at stake." 

Brueggemann prods us to pay attention to what we sing, to let the words deepen our faith and make manifest in our actions the values we proclaim to hold.  

I received a free ebook from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for a fair and unbiased review.
Was this review helpful?
As always, Brueggemann offers the reader an insightful and thought-provoking investigation of Christian hymnody.  His exquisite interpretation of scripture is brought to bear on considering the "why" behind worship singing.  It is a marvelous resource for both academic and congregational contexts.  Once again, Brueggemann teaches all who have ears to hear.
Was this review helpful?