Cover Image: The Book of Flora

The Book of Flora

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thanks to NetGalley and Meg Elison for letting me read and review the newest book to the Nowhere series. The third installment is through the perspective of Flora. I absolute love this series because the series tells a tale of hardship, friendship, and survival. If you loved the first two books, you will definitely love this book. I do hope there are more books to follow with this series!

Was this review helpful?

The third and final book picks up where "The Book of Etta" leaves off, in the community of Ommun, the underground mormon city. Present and past alternate, the story going back and forth between an older Flora writing in her diary on the island of Bambritch and flashbacks of Flora’s past journeys.

It was nice to reconnect with this series, although I didn’t enjoy this last installment as much as i did the other two. For me, the focus on gender ‘issues’ gets too much space in this book, and the actual story much less. Okay, I understand that you want to promote gender equality, but it would be nice to have a solid story, not just gender challenged characters (homosexuality, gender dysphoria, 5α-Reductase deficiency, etc) and rumours about asexual reproduction.

Imo, the first book in the series was the best, the second was good, and this one just ok.

Was this review helpful?

This is the final book in this serries. It picks up where rebooking Etta left off. I read it in less than 24 hrs! It is an action packed conclusion to this series. Flora is a really interesting character and we get to find out her full story in this volume. I enjoyed the descriptions of the apocalyptic world as Flora recounts her memories of where She came from and the many battles fought just
to survive. Flora is a survivor first and foremost. This book makes you wonder what would you do? A satisfying conclusion.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the first two books in this series – if enjoy is the right word for a series that is dark, brutal and bleakly beautiful as The Road to Nowhere is. The book of Flora picks up from where the Book of Etta left off. No one is completely right or completely wrong here and one of the things I appreciate most is how the black hat is passed around, meaning the villain may be someone else at any given time. The series has raised a lot of important questions regarding gender and choice. In a world where the survival of the species is paramount and the population continues to decline, women are valued more for their ability to give birth that for anything else. But what if you don’t want children? Does that make you less of a woman? What if you are trans or gay or bisexual? At what point do the needs of the many give way to protect the needs of the individual? Naturally, it gets ugly, with everyone at some point expressing an opinion that is harmful or ignorant as regards someone else. And then there’s both the perceived power and the chattel state of women depending on where you go, one position just as constricting and imprisoning as another. Ellison really delves into the dark creases of humanist and feminist argument, and she doesn’t present you with facile answers. These books are a tough read but well worth it. Other feminist dystopian epics don’t quite reach where these books go.

Was this review helpful?

*I received an ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thanks for the free book and sorry that it took me so long: I had to read the first two books first. They had lived on my tbr pile for ages...*

In this third instalment of The Road To Nowhere series, the narration focuses on Flora, whom we already know from The Book Of Etta as a trans female (I didn't particularly like in #2). I grew to like her in this book though.

The future is queer and gender issues are the main theme of the book. In a world where women are scarce and babies even more scarce, where is the place for lesbians, for trans or intersex people? Are you a woman if you cannot have children? These questions do not need a post apocalyptic setting to be discussed: if a woman refuses to have children, she is told that she wasn't a 'real' woman. Trans women have to fight for their rights, because feminism should embrace all females.

Anyway, back to the book. It was very interesting to see how language, science and knowledge deteriorate in this dystopia. Where will humanity go? What different forms of 'society' (on a smaller and larger scale) are formed? I'm all in for thought experiments.

I disliked the part about magic and evolution. Yes, fanatics are everywhere, but seriously? Just too much for me. How can people be so dumb? Okay, maybe it's the lack of science, education and logical thinking, but I just couldn't deal with it. Maybe that makes it the more realistic. Yet, I know that people get the more superstitious the less science and factual knowledge exists. So maybe it's just my rationality going on strike and refusing to like that part.

Well written again, highly immersive, interesting and I enjoyed reading it.

Here is my favourite quote from the book:

"It's no great crime to live as a man. Men are plentiful and everyone understands why you do it. Women lying with women is a waste, but you'll hardly get killed for it. Living as a woman without being one is the thing that always stirs hate and violence. As if there is some great deception in it. As if it is the worst kind of fraud. Yet a woman who cannot breed or will not try is never the same sort of problem. And women past the end of their blood are no thread. I am no different from them."

3,5-4 stars because I didn't get Connie, I thought that the ending escalated far too much and I had wanted some sort of closure. Not sure why I'm not happy with the closure I got, but I'm not happy.

Was this review helpful?

--I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are poorly my open and not influenced in any way.--
I've been following the Road to Nowhere series since it began, so I'm kinda sad to see it end! This final part is very different and not as explosive as the first two, but then, Flora is not really fighting for survival like the midwife or fighting a slave trader like Eddy, so it's fitting.
Flora is a really interesting character and I actually wish we got more of the backstory from her life! Eddy I liked in the book of Etta, but here he's not the most likeable, and it's really neat to see them in someone else's perspective. The book as a whole felt a little more aimless: there's not as much world building as the first two and so much of it takes place on a boat going pretty much nowhere and meeting very few new people and seeing very few new civilizations (which was my favorite part of the first two). Then there's Connie: they REALLY needed to introduce them earlier in the book so we could see them develop as a character to what they turn out to be because there was almost no propose to their being there until almost the end. I would've liked to see more of them and see more interactions between them and Flora.
Is this a satisfying end? Eh, it kind of just stopped, but I can see some of the finality. I really like that this picked up where Book of Etta left off, but I'm not sure if Flora was necessarily the right person to end the series with.
Overall, it's good, but it's just very different with some odd pacing and characterization that comes seemingly out of nowhere. I look forward to get other works!

Was this review helpful?

I missed the first two books in this series, but the author is clearly an excellent writer, so I plan to circle back and read the others ASAP (not ideal, and I was "propped up" at times by the reverence for books 1-2.). But, this is a well-written novel with a satisfying ending. It was certainly thought-provoking, with solid characters and interesting takes on gender roles.

I appreciate the free copy, and glad I found a new talented author!

Was this review helpful?

The Book of Flora is the 3rd and final book in The Road to Nowhere trilogy. My thanks to NetGalley for allowing me the opportunity to read this amazing conclusion.
The book picks up where the second book "The Book of Etta" leaves off, deep below ground in the community known as Ommun. The story is told going back and forth in time between Flora writing in her diary from an island referred to as Bambritch (current) to flashbacks of her history and her journey that took her to Bambritch.
In this book we learn much more about Etta/Eddy's history as well as Flora's history which I found both interesting and sometimes confusing. I say confusing because both of these characters share the same issue of gender identity. Etta was born a woman but thinks of herself as a man and Flora is a man who identifies as a woman. The stories of the two of them weave in and out so frequently sometimes it became confusing to figure out who was the person talking. But really maybe that was the point. It really wasn't important how they identified but about how they interacted with each other and those around them.
A newer character in the book is someone referred to as Connie. Connie says she was born a girl but physically became male as he reached puberty. Again, the characters in the story referred to Connie as they or them so gender sort of fell to the background.
In any case the book really tied up everyone's story in a very satisfactory way and I think really makes you think about how relationships are made no matter who you are.

Was this review helpful?

The satisfying conclusion to the trilogy, it is important to read them in order. As always, I was pulled in through the beautiful writing to a world of people trying to survive in this new world. Dark. Powerful. Interesting and intense.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the first two books in the series more. The Book of Flora fell flat for me. I was expecting more. While the story is engaging and the characters are likeable, I just couldn't find a connection.

Was this review helpful?

As soon as I received this ARC from Netgalley, (so thank you so much for letting me read this for an honest review, NG, you guys are doing the goddess’ work) I immediately read the first two books for context on Kindle Unlimited and then dove into this one. That was 3 books in four days, I’m wiped.

The first book was breathtaking and I loved it but Etta was too hardened for me and Flora was too ambivalent. I wanted to adore these last two books so much, but they both left me wanting.

The Book of Flora gets 3 stars from me. I love the new names for the places we all know so well, although, I will admit, it took another reviewer for me to realize Shy was Chicago and not Cheyenne. Flora picks up the torch of the midwife in this one and I’m a liberal Californian, same as the author, so I found the gender lectures a little “preaching to the choir” for me as I am already well-versed in trans etiquette, so it became noisy for me listening to her drone on about it, we get it, girl, you’re progressive af, power to the queers, now tell your dang story.

The plot felt as meandering as Flora’s journey. I felt the sex in this one was thrown in as fan service and I’m sorry, but I’m not as obsessed with Alice as the author is, she’s ridiculously self-absorbed and letting her steal the ending from the title character was the worst moment in the whole book. It should’ve just been called The Book of Alice.

Flora is a beautiful woman who deserved better than Eddy and Alice, in my opinion. She has such a big heart and her instincts went too long unheeded by Etta, the bully. I feel like the Big Bad in this book made not a lot of sense, so the ending threw me off guard, I saw it coming but I wonder now if the author is a mother and all that that entails. It’s a good end but I’m glad it’s over.

May the Alexandria always be seaworthy and the libraries as pristine as the one in Demons.

Was this review helpful?

The last book in the Road to Nowhere trilogy (although no one lives in Nowhere in this book) is written by Flora, a "horsewoman" who met and fell in love with Eddy in the Book of Etta. Flora is a transwoman. Horsewomen come by this name because they concentrate and use essence of mare urine topically in order to change their hormone levels and make their skins smoother and more womanly. Now, I know that this has indeed been done in the past, but I have a hard time believing that horse estrogen ointment is going to change someone so significantly that they will appear female to the casual viewer. Of course, Flora also dresses female and takes pains to modulate her voice, but Eddy, who is gender fluid himself and is familiar with passing, had no clue that Flora wasn't biologically female until they had a frank conversation/groping session in a cave in the previous book. Even though Eddy himself has had to conceal his gender identity, he got pretty pissed at poor Flora and doesn't treat her especially well in either book.

I had some issues with the book myself. Flora was raised by a slaver and essentially helped to train other young children like herself to sexually service adults and then be sold on. Hence, Flora has a very different attitude to slavers than Eddy does. While Eddy is very black and white on morality, Flora has a more nuanced attitude toward people doing what they need to do to survive. While moral relativism does have a place in the world, and Flora obviously grew up damaged because of how she was trained, once again the author has a damaged character who is differently gendered- is it because this is who they always were or is it because they have been damaged? The two-for-two on sexual abuse = gender fluidity/transgender doesn't sit well with me.

This is another travelogue book. Eddy is searching for the men who trained him as a raider. Nowhere has been destroyed, and the characters in this book (Eddy, Alice his sometime lover, and Flora) don't want to start over.

Flora visits Chicago on her own, and learns the mythology the city has created for itself. It is entirely female (genderwise, not biologically) except for child slaves. Flora makes the astute observation that wherever there is luxury, there is slavery supporting it. That's as much true in this world as in a post-apocalyptic one, to my intense discomfort.

The group ends up traveling up and down the east coast, ends up on a boat in Florida and eventually travels all the way to the coast of the Pacific Northwest (former Washington state). This is a lot of ground to cover (literally) and I wasn't as engaged by the story because there wasn't as much of a focused purpose to it. Once again, the group encounters other odd and unique societies. Flora ends up buying a genderfluid child from a slave auction and decides that she will then mother this teenager. Flora clearly wants a family badly, but she never asks this child if they want to be part of her family ( there are a lot of consent issues in this book) and the child ends up going very, very bad.

This book uses a flashback mechanism. At the beginning, Flora, as a sixty-something year old elder in her community, is writing in her book and preparing the community archives to survive an overwhelming attack from an invading force. Her current preparations are interspersed with her past travels. To the author's credit, I didn't figure out exactly what was happening until shortly before it did.

I did have an issue with the antagonist in the book. I've spoiler-warninged this already, so I'll go ahead and discuss it. The commander of the invading army ends up being Flora's estranged child. They have this idea that women can learn to be able to procreate without men being involved (parthenogenesis) and it turns out that they are right! Magic, for lack of a better term, has made some human women able to do this. So, this person decides that they need to kill all women who CAN'T do this to make room for those who can! Very disturbing and insane. The whole magical virgin birth thing seemed like a bit of a bridge too far from the previous things that have been possible in this series. The whole final confrontation came about because Connie, Flora's adoptee, is still fixated on Alice, who was part of the group that rescued them. Connie had a crush on Alice as a teenager and apparently hadn't gotten over it in the past twenty-plus years? The whole end felt contrived and the beats of the finale felt predictable.

I never connected to Flora the way that I did to Eddy or the Unnamed Midwife. I didn't find her as likable, although she did have some interesting insights. She also had some weaknesses and blind spots that I didn't care for. The travelogue felt less purposeful this time. The best part- Eddy, twenty plus years later, still does not give a fuck what anyone wants to do to him- he just wants to get through the bullshit. He also ends up in the place that I would personally want to end up in this world: a battleship that has been converted into a floating archive and protected place for women who want to be librarians for the archive, off the coast of California. Sounds good to me! Put me in a giant library/fortress that can't be overrun and let me read and record.

Was this review helpful?

Outstanding, thought-provoking ending to a unique trilogy

This book, time wise, is set partially about forty years after THE BOOK OF ETTA but goes back and forth through the different time periods of Flora's life.

You should read the first two books in the trilogy to fully appreciate this book. This is a lengthy book but a fascinating one - one that held my interest all the way through.

This entire trilogy explores male and female roles in depth along with gender assignment (I guess that's the right term). It discusses childbirth, children, parenting, sex, rape and an entire gamut of combinations. It was thought-provoking and uncomfortable in spots for me.

There are some other post-apocalyptic books out there that include some of the same ideas as this trilogy such as THE HANDMAID'S TALE, CHILDREN OF MEN, AND SLEEPING BEAUTIES but this is a very unique story in and by itself.

I enjoyed it very much even though it did make me uncomfortable.

I received this book from 47 North and Amazon Publishing through Net Galley in the hopes that I would read it and leave an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a fast read and flowed fairly easily through each chapter. The reviews about reading the earlier books makes a lot of sense because I did not read the earlier books and found myself a bit lost for some time at the beginning of the story. It took me a few chapters to get a feel for the writing as it's original and untamed. This is a strength and a challenge for the author. I can see how someone will easily abandon this book quickly. But, the writing is crafted so cleverly that it would be a mistake to leave early. There were many memorable phrases in this book; I was a highlighting feign on my iPad. But the story itself was not something of note and I was surprised by that given its apocalyptic tease. I had a constant tug of sadness for Flora and her life experiences as a slave, lover, and midwife and glad to see the story play out for her.

Was this review helpful?

I was very much looking forward to reading the third instalment of the Road To Nowhere trilogy, and thanks to NetGalley I got to do it even earlier than I’d hoped.

The Book of Flora continues the tale first started in The Book of the Unnamed Midwife, and links directly to events from The Book of Etta. Fair warning to those new to the series, I’m not sure I’d have enjoyed this book as much as I did had I not actually read the two preceding novels.

Though the Road to Nowhere series is set in a very grim dystopia, The Book of Flora felt less dark to me. Flora, the protagonist and narrator’s journey is the main focus, and we follow her exploration of the world, her place in it and how it relates to her. I loved learning more about Flora, she was such an interesting character in the previous novel. I just wish (as always) life wasn’t so hard for her. Elison and her world can be very rough on her characters. I did feel the end was a little rushed, and I really wanted to delve into both the happier, more peaceful times implied in Flora’s retrospective narrative passages, as well as the revelatory change discovered at the very end.

I find the Road To Nowhere novels quick reads, but not because they are easy. On the contrary they are set in a grimdark world full of terror and violence which strike me as uncomfortably plausible. Even so, the first novel, The Book of the Unnamed Midwife, remains my favourite of the trilogy, and one of my all-time favourite novels.

Anyone who has enjoyed any of the other novels in the series should definitely read The Book of Flora, and those who haven't should give them a try! Meg Elison’s writing is compelling, flows well, and her ideas are as fascinating as always.

Was this review helpful?

Being a completist isn’t really all that great when it comes to books. Mostly it gets you stuck reading books all the way through that you might have abandoned otherwise. And yes, it is the completist in me that requested this book on Netgalley and set off reading it, just to see how it all turns out in Ellison’s womencentric dystopia. Small mercies, this was the last in a trilogy, trilogies are infinitely more manageable than series, although not as great as standalones. Book 1 was pretty good and totally worked as a standalone, before the author decided to expand her fictional universe. Book 2 was inferior, decent enough, but not on the same level and apparently utterly unmemorable, because I was unable to recall any of its plot. Thought reading book 3 would jog the memory, but no…nothing. And as a standalone book 3 really doesn’t work, you have to have at least a passing familiarity with this world and its complex gender roles and breeding practices, which I did but from book 1. So ok, if you’ve read the trilogy, you know about this strange world where most of the man died out and women are now in charge and they live in small communities located in the ashes of civilization and govern themselves by varied rules. The book splits its time about evenly between the various reproduction scenarios and superbly complex gender politics. The protagonist and narrator of this one is on something of a personal odyssey to find a place that’s right for her and the book covers her journey, found destination and looks into the future to offer readers an idea of what’s next…and what’s next is apparently a form of agamogenesis. Sort of appropriate, I suppose, to end that way a trilogy so heavily concentrated on procreation. It’s interesting enough of a concept and would probably ideally be read pretty close together to maintain a working familiarity with characters and plot intricacies. I wouldn’t have continued with this, if Ellison decided to serialize it, but trilogy offered an appealing closure and it was quick enough of a read. Nowhere was there page count available (so frustrating), but if I had to guess, it’s somewhere in the 275 to 300 page range. What’s the deal with trilogies anyway? Are the readers meant to remember the plots for a year or so and then get right back into it? Reread the books before the new one comes out? Seems more practical to just wait for all three to be out. At least if the first book has the decency to announce itself as book 1. Anyway, this was entertaining enough, I found out how it played out, the ending was fairly satisfactory. Not sure it was necessary to expand the original book into a trilogy, but there it is. Ellison is a good writer and it would be interesting to see what she comes up with next now that she’s free of the Nowhere world. Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third title in the Road to Nowhere series and you need to read them all in order to get a handle on what’s happening. In a dystopian future, after a plague has killed millions and left few women, females are more rare than gold. They are treated like queens, chattel and slaves alike. Flora and her friends are looking for a way to leave the ugliness of their pasts behind them as they join a group of survivors where there are rumors of a new way to reproduce, a place where gender is “fluid”. But is this really a place of hope or just another place where the women will be exploited or enslaved? The first book in this series is still by far my favorite. The second didn’t appeal to me at all and I almost didn’t read this one, but I’m glad I did. Maybe it’s the times we are now living in, but I felt a real connection with Flora and the other women in a world so hostile to females

Was this review helpful?