Cover Image: The Last Singer

The Last Singer

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I loved the cover for this book and it is what really drew me in. The story overall is good; I was very interested because of what was written about the book but to be honest, this was not really my cup of tea. It was nicely put together and the plot was there, but I felt like it could have been better written at parts. However, this was a fantastic idea and I am glad to have read it.

Was this review helpful?

I wasn’t able to get into this book at all. The premise of the book was promising, but I seems that the author did not deliver. Parts of it were very predictable.

Was this review helpful?

From the very start, I wasn’t able to get into this book. The premise was promising, but I felt that the author did not deliver. Parts of it were very cliche and predictable. There was nothing really special about this book that made me want to continue reading the series.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book by this author, It was pretty enjoyable. I would give this book a 3.5 star rating! It was a pretty Quick and easy read!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley for providing me with a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.

This is a really tough review for me to write because I was constantly torn between loving and hating this book.
I think this is the type of book that could have used another round of editing with a more critical eye, because a lot of the issues that I had would easily be fix-able.

What I loved: The idea of this world is phenomenal and right up my alley: climate change caused most of the world to be flooded, once citizens turn 18 they have to go to a floating city built of domes and tunnels connecting the domes on the rough seas. Within this city, everything is controlled, you sleep in assigned quaters, do your assigned job, and pretty much better follow all the rules. In this world, we are following our main character, who has a secret power that is forbidden (possibly because only women have these powers) navigating friendships in the new life and training for the ultimate tournament where the winner gets a wish granted.
The world building is a lot of fun, I admire this set up and the overall plot idea.

Sadly the characters decisions and the continuity of the plot had a lot of confusing points that either did not make sense or were hard to follow. Without going into spoilers I can say that at last every other chapter, I was really getting annoyed by decisions or by how the story was jumping around.
I also did have a few issues with some writing style choices. For example I am not a fan of the writer telling me what to think/question. I truly believe it is an authors job to make me connect things by hinting towards it. I do not like that after very clearly hinting towards it, when the author then adds several questions in a row like "Was there a connection?"

Overall I really want to get into the sequel to hear how the story develops, but I did decide that I only would want to do that in a buddy read where I can bitch about the annoying parts together. Sorry, but this is how annoying bits become fun for me and I can deal with it when I really want to see how the story progresses.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly this just wasn't my kind of book. I had a lot of trouble getting through it and didn't even finish it. Nothing against the book, it just wasn't my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

I am so angry with this story. For it not living up to its potential. It is one thing when a story is bad without any possible retribution to revive it but when a story does have that hidden gem and it really sank…it’s like why.

The description of the story is what first caught my eye. A story about a girl with a voice, miss-matched eyes, and a falcon tattoo that belonged to a sisterhood who a rebellion is dependent upon. I know that I should not have expected much from a book about a rebellion with a “the savior” trope, but I did not want to miss an opportunity, so I clicked the request button. But, woe me, for how wrong was I?

Now onto the details, where do I even begin? The nonsensical plotline? The flat characters? The gagging stereotypical love interest romance trope? The idea and set up of the world building was intriguing: a world where climate change has reached such severity that some countries we know today have are no longer in existence forcing people to work in Hypor, a floating city that has limited jobs for women. The way the story was delivered with stereotypes of the heroine and her love interest is the reason why my heart cared very little for this book. Some of the characters’ decisions were all over the place with no real backing to their actions, especially Brynna who just left me bored out of my mind and speechless that someone could be so dunce. Like the characters, the plotline was chaotic and made no sense with a fast pace that went from one point to another point in a blink of an eye. I was really looking forward to enjoying this story but unfortunately, it let me down.

Was this review helpful?

*I received a free copy of this ebook from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*

The concept of this book sounded interesting, but the book itself fell flat for me. Brynna, the main character, lacked much personality--she felt more like a plot device than a character. Throughout the book (and based on the descriptions of the two sequels), it seems as if the author wanted to see how many different situations she could put Brynna into. It just didn't work for me.

Other characters were pretty bland, too. Brynna's mother existed as a way to tell readers how the world got to be in its current state and to cryptically tell Brynna about singers. Jarryd was a connection to the rebels. Calia was the mean girl who caused everything bad to happen. Ruby was the reason Brynna got to compete (because it made complete sense . . . ?). Kaaluk is supposed to be a love interest (see second book description), but he's hardly there.

The world building was also somewhat weak. Most of the time, it was done through conversations with Brynna's mother or other characters. It would usually start out with something like, "We've talked about this. You remember that . . . " If I had been Brynna in those conversations, I would have been very impatient about having something re-explained to me in detail. And then I had questions about the floating cities. How exactly do they work? Are they affected by storms? Is there something that keeps everything inside the domes from rocking with the waves? How were they built? How do natural features (waterfalls, underground water tunnels, mountains, ravines, etc.) exist inside of them? Other than that, we know that women are oppressed--their job choices are limited, their forced to wear jubas (long dresses that restrict their movements and have hoods to cover their heads), etc. I'm not sure how society went from where it is now to that point--it's hard to believe women today would allow that to happen. Unless, I suppose, the characters of the story are from a place where women don't have a lot of rights already.

Notes: May have been a little swearing.

Was this review helpful?

3.5

I felt that in some parts the book fell kind of flat, it wasn't impactful and felt kinda "meh. But, I thoroughly enjoyed this book (as a casual read), i had a good time reading this throughout 2019. The world building is great, the concept of futuristic world with floating cities is rather interesting (i.e. it's f***ing cool).

The Last Singer is cool in my books and i think you should read it too. (Do it.)

Was this review helpful?

*I received an ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thanks for the free book.*

I really enjoyed this book a lot as the world-building is amazing: the world has changed after climate change, countries longer exist, strict rules apply for all citizens to start working in the floating city of Hypor once they turn 18. The women are limited in their job choice.

Brynna is finally 18. She must leave her parents and start working as a translator. She finds out that the government is trying to hide a very important secret so she joins the rebellion. Her secret gift is her voice: she is a singer and has healing powers. But her powers must remain hidden from the world. I loved the details like falcons, mismatched eyes, singing healers, and a floating city.

If someone asked me what kind of a book is this I would say it's a mixture of Dystopian, Sci-Fi and fantasy. A good mix that creates a great book full of so many surprise.

I would recommend this book to my friends and family.

Was this review helpful?

I received this as an ARC from Netgalley, thanks for the free book. (All opinions are my own)
I felt the storyline for this book was strong in the beginning and intriguing, I was very excited to delve into this book, however there were many moments where I didn’t feel connected to the main character at all. So it was hard to continue reading. Another reviewer stated “maybe because of the tell don’t show writing” I couldn’t figure how to put that into words but she did wonderfully and I must say I agree, I felt a lot of times characters would just spew out a lot of info at once rather than showing through details so due to that it was hard to feel apart of the story. Unfortunately I could not finish this book, I lost interest very quickly. Hope the best to other readers!

Was this review helpful?

A world where singing is banned leads a strong, female character into a realm of secrets. Her recent discovery of a rare, special ability just as she is about to leave home creates the beginning to a fun fantasy story. 

The unique aspects in this book quickly brought me to the end. The world building alone with the climate change mixed with society's rules regarding a strict work ethic are just the first things I noticed. Then add in a secret sisterhood helped to peak my interest. 

But unfortunately, I felt like the book didn't live all the way up to the my expectations. The writing was easy to read, but I felt like as the story progressed, the writing began to feel a little flat. 

Overall, the unique concepts quickly reeled me in, and the dystopian world was very interesting to read about (there are a ton of stuff that happened in this world). I gave this book 3 out of 5 stars.

If you love stories that blend genres together, this book may be for you!

Was this review helpful?

The Last Singer is a sci fi dystopian story. In the future, climate change has caused major change. The world no longer exists as it once did. Everyone must work in the floating city. It begins well but just tapered off until I lost all interest. The characters seemed generic. The setting was not well developed. The writing was okay. I skimmed through a lot of the story
Overall just an average read. Thanks to NetGalley for an arc in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

*I received an ARC via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. Thanks for the free book.*

I did not like or enjoy this book a lot which is sad as the world-building is kinda cool: the world has changed after climate change, countries as we know them no longer exist, strict rules apply for all citizens to start working in the floating city of Hypor once they turn 18. Women are limited in their job choice they are not allowed to dress as they want to.

Brynna has to leave the safety of her parent's island and start working as a translator. When she finds out that the government is trying to hide the fact that the world is in danger from the sun, she joins the rebellion. Her secret gift is her voice: she is a singer and has healing powers. But her powers must remain hidden...

So, why didn't I like this book? Climate change, feminism (or so I thought), sci-fi, power struggles, rebellions...sounds good. Yet the characters remained flat, they made decisions I could not follow, almost stereotypical (potential love interest's only feature are his green eyes, female protagonist has long hair and a secret power) and I just could not feel anything about what happened. Especially Brynna annoyed me. Furthermore, the story progresses extremely fast - one page people leave to fight, the protagonist goes to sleep, next page they are back... It lacked depth and detail.

In addition I was annoyed that the feminist world-building (only women have healing powers, there used to be a women's only sisterhood) could not really be found in the novel: "Don't let your brother's confidence overwhelm your feminine instincts." Wtf are feminine instincts? Nobody's bothered by that but me? Geeeeeez.

2 Stars. I'm sorry but this book just wasn't for me...

Was this review helpful?

DNF at about 40%.
I really wanted to give this book a chance, but it just failed to interest me at all. The characters are flat as cardboard and the worldbuilding is as thin as gauze. The plot had potential to be interesting, but it's not done very well and combined with all the forced conversations and the lack of interestinv characters or places... There's just not much here to interest or excite or make me care about these people and this place at all.
Underdeveloped, is what I would call this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and Xpresso Book Tours for a digital review copy of this book!

I'm not entirely sure why this book and I didn't work out. The premise was quite promising: We have a futuristic society with Sci-fi elements, we have a young girl with a magical voice that she has to hide for others and we have an interesting game of chess played by the politicians to gain the ultimate power. It's quite surprising that something went wrong between me and the book and it's hard for me to pinpoint exactly what it was.

Firstly, I think the point of view didn't really work for me. A lot of world building and mythology was explained through dialogue instead of actually shown to us and I discovered that this also happened with the bigger plot. The main character is not in the centre of things and doesn't really know what's going on if the other characters don't fill her in. It feels like maybe she was simply not the right character to tell the story.

And maybe it's also because of the tell don't show writing that the characters and world never really came to live. I don't have the feeling that I know them, care for them and I can't really picture the world either. I still feel like I've been watching everything from a distance and was never really part of it.

On top of that the story itself felt a little chaotic. It was hard for me to see the clear line, to see which story was actually being told, what was important. I felt like there were so many side plots and unimportant scenes that took up a lot of time and space, that the book failed to make a true point. I understand it's only the first book in a series, but it doesn't feel like a solid base to build the rest on.

I really had hoped that this was a story I was gonna love, but it seems I was wrong. I guess that can happen sometimes. Luckily there are loads more books to read and my new favorite is very likely among those!

Was this review helpful?

The synopsis sounded really good and I did enjoy this, but I found it struggled to hold my interest at times. I am still interested to see what will happen in the future of the series, but the pacing just seemed a little off at times. Character growth seemed to be lacking but hopefully that might change in future books. Enjoyable and I did like the characters, hope for more in the next books

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for a free copy for an honest opinion

Was this review helpful?

The blurb was quite interesting, but I found the book to be just "okay" overall. It's a bit of a mix of dystopian, fantasy, and sci-fi. Brynna is an interesting character. Based on the title, I expected there to be a bit more of a focus on the singing than there was in the story. There were some pacing problems and lack of development with some characters. Fans of books such as Hunger Games will likely enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

Brynna Bokk’s knew that her 18th birthday would change her life for good. Forced by law she leaves her loved island and moves to Hypor City to fulfill her duty of 5 year work for the Council, but once truth is discovered of endangered planet and evil plan of the head of the council she joins the group of rebels to try and save others. She needs to be careful though as she also her secret of her own...

If someone asked me what kind of a book is this I would say it's a mixture of Dystopian, Sci-Fi and fantasy. A good mix that creates a great book full of surprises and extreme tension.

What I liked the most? I think that we have seen this story from a perspective of a person that doesn't really stands in a front of the rebellion but just a person that is trying to help. Brynna is a great asset to have, especially with her special powers and knowledge of languages, but she is not running as a leader, yet at least. It's great to see different point of views in novels like this one. She also is not perfect and all her weaknesses make her a character that I want to follow throughout her adventures. All this makes this book original and interesting, making me want to read more and more of this author- Marjorie Lindsey.

I have read somewhere that this is a first YA book written by this author- I just wanted to say 'Great Job'! It was easy to follow and understand, which as a Polish reading in English I appreciate a lot. Even though the heroine is 18 years old I would comfortably recommend this book to ages from 13 up. Especially if you're a fan of Hunger Games!

The only downside of this novel would be that we don't really know what happened to all the secondary characters like Wayland or Marta, just little notes- maybe having so many positive characters isn't a good way to have either, as it is difficult to put all the information in without making it a monstrous of a book. Hopefully we will know more in the next books.


Thank you NetGalley for sending me a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book, though it wasn't extremely riveting. There were parts that kept me wanting to read on while others that didn't really hold my attention, was a little slow at times. The characters were likeable and the plot progressive. I was expecting this to be more fantasy and less dystopian, though I knew it was based in the future the description made it seem like it would be more about Brynna's singing, which only played a small role in the book. The way the book ended I am sure the next books will delve further into the potential of her powers.

I did enjoy this book enough that I will continue on with the rest of the series at some point, I am curious about what is next to come. And although I didn't like it as much as I thought I would the next books seem like they will hold more of my interest.

Was this review helpful?