Cover Image: HIS SICILIAN CINDERELLA: Harlequin Manga

HIS SICILIAN CINDERELLA: Harlequin Manga

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I absolutely adore everything Harlequin Manga has put out recently and His Sicilian Cinderella was no different. These mangas take no time at all to read and I highly recommend them.

Was this review helpful?

I just can't seem to get enough of the romance mangas. Love them. Love the artwork and love that they are adapted from some truly excellent stories. This one is no exception. Beautiful. Romantic. Captivating. And pardon the similar reviews for all the books. I'm catching up and have loved all of them.

Was this review helpful?

Actually book is better than the manga version. It gives better portrayal than the manga and it is probably because everything has to be shortened in manga version. The story was quite a little bit jumping around also in this manga version. It leaves some readers particularly me with some difficulties in understanding the plot if they haven't read the book version.

Was this review helpful?

This book's exposition was pretty weak because it was difficult to follow what was happening throughout the beginning, but the rest of the story was cute and fun, even if a bit rated G. Enjoyable and quick! I'm sure I'd love this if it were adapted from a book I've already read, but since I wasn't familiar with the source material I couldn't quite connect to it.

Was this review helpful?

As an Italian, I found this story disturbing. Abuse and crime are not an Italian prerogative, and the story is full of cliches. However, if you manage to look beyond the stereotyped mafia characters, there's some good lessons to be learned in terms of power of forgiveness and resilience to hard times. The art is not the usual manga, it is a powerfully drawn trait that will haunt you and give you a graphic measure of how distant from our present standards this story is, but the comics are nonetheless beautiful. Despite cringing at the idea that my country should be judged based on a work of fiction set in the 1950's, I do recommend it

Was this review helpful?

Review to come on Goodreads/blog on Sunday/Monday.

So the last and final of the Harlequin Manga I requested. *is sad* Another party comes to a close, I hope everyone enjoyed all my reviews for these books, I hope that soon I can hold another party.
This book, was definitely one I was curious about, but also very very worried and that is the biggest reason why I waited for this one until the very end. It is about a mafia filled island, a girl and her lover, the girl was sold to be prostitute and now years later these two meet up again but he looks at her with anger and resentment? It just didn't make sense, not like the girl wanted to be sold as some kind of sex toy. But I guess we will find out just what is going on. Here I go.

The story is already quite confusing. So he doesn't want her if she is forced into prostitution because he doesn't want to date a prostitute. Sure, I can imagine, but from what I see she doesn't have such of a choice about it, she already too deep into it. :| AH, and we find out that she indeed never had a choice.. That poor girl. She couldn't escape. :( Wow, what a terrible island, what a terrible place. I wonder how they can just keep this going on, then again it takes place in 1920... Which is a long time ago.

More confusion as we travel back 3 years back. Yes, there was a time noted at the beginning but I didn't think we would travel back. I had to actually scroll back to the beginning chapter to see what year that took place in. So we finally see how Matteo and Bella met up. Though for most I was just bored as there was a ton of dialogue about the mob and the island, how the families work and how Bella was destined to become a prostitute due to who her mom is. I just wanted to get to the point, show us how they got together!

We also learn more about Matteo, about his past.

Again, please just get to the present day, we are already at page 40 of 128... come on.

Here we go, we are getting back to the present again. I did like seeing how Matteo and Bella got together, even if it was just for a short while.

But this story is so weird.... so I guess she had sex with the boss? She calls him her husband... What the fuck is going on with this story. I just can't keep track what is going on.

What the hell? She threw champagne over Matteo and his new lover? What the fuck? Girl? What?

Um, so something did happen when she escaped? To me it seemed that the man did nothing, but I guess the artist/author decided instead to just let that part out.. I know he grabbed her and made some demands.. but nothing happened after that.... *confused*

So, I am at the end, and it is that I wrote down words, because otherwise I wouldn't have been able to write a review. What a weirdly written and drawn story this was. So much unneeded dialogue, so much stuff that didn't make fucking sense, so much confusion, so much let out that could have made the story better. The art was also just OK. I am sad that I end the party with a negative note. :(

Was this review helpful?

I didnt like this at all. It started with a flashback and then proceeded to tell the story but it just wasnt smooth. I also think the story was just to angsty for me. The artwork was great but the story itself wasnt,

Was this review helpful?