Cover Image: The World That We Knew

The World That We Knew

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Whenever I read a book written by Alice Hoffman I feel as though I've been given a beautiful gift. I love The World That We Knew; magical realism at it very finest.

Was this review helpful?

The World We Knew
Alice Hoffman

What does it mean to lose your mother? How much can one person sacrifice for love? In a world where evil can be found at every turn, we meet remarkable characters that take us on a stunning journey of loss and resistance, the fantastical and the mortal, in a place where all roads lead past the Angel of Death and love is never ending.

When you open the book and start reading it, you become aware right off that you are reading an Alice Hoffman book. It’s a slow gravitational pull into her signature writing style, and well written storylines that we are all familiar with.
The World We Knew, Hoffman gives new life to a turbulent and horrific time in our world’s history.
A spellbinding emotional charged look into that period. The characters come to life and are well developed and engaging. The book is evenly paced and stimulating. She has masterly captivated the human spirit.
Hoffman weaves, Jewish Mysticism, to create, a thought provoking book, about, Love, Sacrifice, Tragedy, and the Human Spirit.

This is unforgettable and beautifully written book.

I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley for an honest review

All opinions are my own

Was this review helpful?

I couldn’t stop reading this novel. Several times throughout I found myself holding my breath or breathing heavier because the events that happen are so distressing and horrifying. The writing is so powerful that the room around you disappears. You will be in 1940s France feeling the fear, anxiety and hopelessness but also love and kindness.
The story begins in Berlin 1941. Life for the Jewish people is becoming more unbearable everyday and deportation is beginning. Here you meet the main three women of the story. Ettie, the rabbis fearless daughter. Lea, a 12 year old child who is forced to become an adult far too early. And Ava, a creature created to be an emotionless robotic guard. She is to guide Lea to safety and protect her at all costs. Most of the novel takes place in France starting in Paris then moving to the countryside. A sad time in history but like all terrible things there is always good and hope that shines through.
I’ve read many books about the Holocaust but never one that had the element of magical realism and fairytales. For me that signature of Alice Hoffman’s is what made this novel so wonderful.

Was this review helpful?

Devoured this in two days!! I love Alice Hoffman and this one did not disappoint. I absolutely LOVED that it was "based" on a true story and how she felt like she had to write this woman's story. I loved the supernatural components and the underlying theme of family and love. Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I found the premise of this book really interesting from the note from the author which was an older woman finding her after an event and saying she must write her story. Her story being the children that escaped the Nazis during WWII.

This was another great read by Alice Hoffman. I enjoyed the components of magical realism present in her stories, and this one is no exception. This was about three women and their stories of life during WW II. I enjoyed the writing and didn’t want to just speed through it like I do with others.

I really enjoyed the new history I learned about. I’ve really come to appreciate historical fiction.

Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster for the ARC! I was really excited to get to read this so early.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review

Beautiful and moving, a story of women surfing and thriving with a little bit of magic and Jewish mysticism. Exactly what you would expect of a Holocaust novel from Alice Hoffman, and then make it twice as lush and sensual (no small thing for a Holocaust novel). Perfection

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully written novel in which Jewish children survive WWII in France via extraordinary and supernatural means. Ettie, a brilliant young woman, agrees to create a golem to watch over Lea, a child sent by her mother to relatives . Over the course of the novel, Ettie and Lea grow up, forge lifelong relationships with others, and, along with their various love interests and vengeful desires, work towards the end of the war. Ava, the golem, watches over Lea, falls in love with a crane, speaks languages no human knows, and eventually faces Azrael, the Angel of Death, in a lovely but predictable encounter. While the characters never felt very deep to me, the book is mostly a pleasure to read, and Hoffman writes descriptively and fluently.

I do wish, however, that her reference to homeopathic treatment was not a positive one. She suggests that eating homey can save a person from thousands of bee stings. Not only is this not really a homeopathic treatment, but in this time when people are shunning vaccines and dismissing medical science, it's dangerous to suggest that remedies like this are efficacious.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

Alice Hoffman is a wonder. Every time I read one of her books I think that it is the best book I have ever read. <i>The World That We Knew</i> reveals the horrors of the Holocaust in Germany and France but does so within a lyrical style. Here there is not copious bloodshed, just overwhelming loss surrounded by all-encompassing love.

Recognizing the inevitable fate of her beautiful Jewish daughter in Berlin, a mother seeks a protector for her child, Lea. This protector, a golem named Ava, escorts the child out of Germany to France. (According to the Jewish Encyclopedia,"in Jewish tradition, the golem is most widely known as an artificial creature created by magic, often to serve its creator.") Ava's only purpose is to protect Lea like her mother would. Once in Paris, they meet with other Jewish families who have waited too long to make their escape from the Vichy French. Although most of these characters are Jewish, most are fairly nonreligious. They consider themselves French and the sudden viciousness of their neighbors is incomprehensible. Hoffman does portray the efforts of some communities and organizations to protect children. These communities, some religious and some not, represent the best of humanity when surrounded by the worst evil.

Ava's growth, from created golem to lover of nature and life, is remarkable. All the characters in this novel experience sacrifice and love, terror and joy. Read this book! Read this Book! READ THIS BOOK!

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure how I felt about the author exploiting a piece of tragic history and turning it into something mythical but somehow it worked and was executed in a way that didn't taint it.

Was this review helpful?

Usually by the time I’m halfway through a book, it’s been intriguing enough to make me want to read it. Sadly, that’s not the case with this one. Beautifully written for sure, it for some reason I just can’t maintain an interest. So I’m not finishing it, because life’s too short to force yourself to read books that you don’t love. I won’t, however, add a review to another online source because this may very well be someone else’s cup of tea. And my noninterest shouldn’t dissuade someone else from giving it a chance.

Was this review helpful?

Hoffman is among my favorites as she blends humanity and magic so beautifully. To take a Holocaust novel and combine it with a golem is genius, and her writing is always top notch and unforgettable. She deserves another smash hit, and I’m happy to spread the word as always. So happy to have read it.

Was this review helpful?

I was privileged to read the ARC of "The World That We Knew" through NetGalley. Alice Hoffman spins magic into her novels, this one a golem, which I had never heard of before. A golem is a Jewish being created by extremely strong male rabbis that becomes a servant/slave/protector to whomever the creator designates. This story is set during WWII when a Jewish mother can not leave her elderly infirmed mother in Berlin, and begs a Rabbi's daughter to create a golem to protect her young daughter escape from Germany. I love Alice Hoffman's novels and this new tale confirms those feelings. I am thrilled when I see a new novel, totally absorbed while reading the story, yet saddened when done knowing I must wait for another new tale from a master storyteller!

Was this review helpful?

LONG....( ha.....again?/! ......I couldn’t help myself), but NO SPOILERS...
This book has crawled under my skin. It’s a book of womanly strength, love, and wisdom....set in WWII.

Usually I write a review immediately upon finishing it.
I’m glad I waited. It took me longer to read this novel more than others of the same length. I paused longer - lingered longer - over sentences. I also spent time studying history I was unfamiliar with.

With feelings of being small - in my own ability to write a review of this very ambitious historical novel - I needed time to let my feelings neutralized - contend with my thoughts - and local my ‘Courage Hat’. I’m not going to get this right - but I promise to do the best I can.

My ‘very first’ inner voice response ( after reading “The World That We Knew”), was....”close, but still not ‘The Dovekeepers’”.
I quickly marked ‘read’ with 4 stars highlighted on Goodreads...., but I think I knew in my gut this was equally valuable to me as ‘The Dovekeepers’. I was just a little ashamed at how much more I had to work - ( I’m Jewish and read many Holocaust stories - shouldn’t I know these basic facts by now?).....
THE HISTORY IN HERE THAT I DIDN’T KNOW....which I’m grateful to having learned -many thanks to Alice Hoffman- is NOT SOOOOO BASIC!!!
I did some serious thinking for a few days about this book - along with some re-reading of passages and dialogue. I also re- studied historical facts - filling holes in my education. It’s amazing to me how many gaps - ‘still’ - of WWII history have been left behind. At least for me.

So....first acknowledgements: I’m deeply grateful to our award winning author. I appreciate Alice Hoffman’s dedication to writing about a remarkable period of history. I appreciate the immediate connection with the characters - her lush luminous prose - the extraordinary storytelling - and for being a real inspiration for me personally in opening my heart in seeing the importance to keep learning.
I was not only submerged in the intricate relationships - but page after page I fell deeper into the richly imagined world....pausing to google historical communes and children’s orphanages....( none of which I knew about).

Thank you ( and I’ve said this 1 million times before… But I’m sincerely thankful), to Netgalley- and the publishers who have trusted me enough to offer an advance copy to review - and with this book - special thanks to Simon & Schuster’s Publishing team.

It was tumultuous times. I asked myself - what was the most important personal goal in a world where evil was rampant everywhere you turned?
TO LIVE....the goal was TO STAY ALIVE... to LIVE!!! I thought about every possible successful turn in my life and those in the lives of others. What stands out is ‘somebody’ was FOR ME... somebody was FOR MY FRIENDS.

For Lea...her mother, Hanni, was Lea’s biggest allied. The world was black with horror. Millions of Jews tortured, separated by those they loved - many were made to dig their own graves - castrated - humiliated - millions murdered - at the rate of a thousand a day in Auschwitz. WE KNOW THESE THINGS.....
YET...ALWAYS HORRIFYING.....felt ‘newly’ on any given day.
One of the strongest themes for me is the POWER of a MAGICAL-REMARKABLE - DEEPLY LOVING relationship between a mother and daughter. Throughout all the storytelling adventures from beginning to end....I was constantly moved by a mother’s love for her daughter.
This excerpt is soooo beautiful.....speaks volumes:
“Night after night, in the trees or in the grass, Lea dreamed of her mother. She heard Hanni’s voice in the wind, in birdsong, in falling leaves”.
“I was with you when the roses bloomed with silver petals, when you saw Paris for the first time, when that boy looked at you, when you learned prayers in the convent, when you ran through the woods”.

Soon after meeting twelve year old Lea, shy, but highly intelligent, ( and having survived a frightening failed rape intent)... Hanni Kohn, her mother, will do anything in her power to have her daughter protected - which means sending Lea far away from Berlin.....save her from the Nazi regime.
Hanni’s husband - a medical doctor - was murdered outside the Jewish Hospital. He had saved 720 souls. After Simon died - it was believed- and hoped for - in the Jewish religion - that “perhaps on the day that he left OLAM HaZEH, the world that we walk through each living day, those who had been saved we’re waiting for him in
OLAM HaBa, the World to Come”.

Hanni refused to believe that her husband’s life meant nothing.
“In Berlin, evil came to them slowly and then all at once”.
Hanni was determined that Lea would live and save more souls.....
“It would go on and on, until there was more good in the world than evil”.

SUPPORT IS CALLED FOR.....
Grandmother, Bobeshi, had told Lea stories and told her “to be a wolf”. Lea learned early to rise out of darkness- she became “the flower on a stem of thorns”.
Lea learned - from experience- about The Angel of Death. The “angel” took away the evil man who tried to pick a flower ( Lea), and all he got was a handful of thorns....then he got what he deserved: death!
Grandmother Bobeshi was sick, bedridden. Hanni needed to honor the 5th commandment- she couldn’t leave her mother.
But each day groups of Jews were taken to Grosse Hamburger Strasse - then soon be sent to their deaths on trains to resettle Jews in the East.
NOT LEA......

Tante Ruth was over hundred years old. Her father was a rabbi in Russia.....called a magician. Her own husband was named The Magician’s assistant. The men studied the Zohar, The Book of Splendour, - holy mysteries. Women were denied the opportunity to study- denied Torah study. However, Tante Ruth learned a lot listening to the men debate. After her husband died ( who knew 72 kinds of wisdom that he learned from his father), Ruth believed in their miracles. It was believed that all creation came from thought, language, and mathematics.

Hanni turned to Tante Ruth - a magical brilliant pillar in their small community of Jews. Neighbors didn’t listen to Ruth when the Nazi policies first began to separate Jews from the rest of the population.
To fight the WICKED......MAGIC and FAITH were needed.
This is how we learn of “The Golem”. The Golem was created by the use of 22 Hebrew letters of the Hebrew alphabet.
The Golem can see the future - among other things - including seeing the exact day and time of a person’s death. It can speak to angels. Ruth sent Hanni to speak to their local Rabbi - knowing the rabbi would refuse to speak to her. He would not allow another woman in the room other than his own wife.....however- Hanni was to talk to the rabbi’s wife. The real miracle help came from the rabbi’s daughter- Ettie.
Ettie brings forth the creature with mud and water.
*Ava Perrin*, ( six feet tall), is the name of Ettie’s creation. Ava, was created to protect Lea, who would follow her to the end of the earth and never abandon her.
Ava - made from clay - wasn’t suppose to ‘feel’....as she was created without a soul. Lea wasn’t so sure. Ava and a heron had a special relationship.

Ettie was bright as a whip - clever - independent - ambitious - defiant when necessary. Ettie’s mother wasn’t helpful to Hanni- but Ettie was.
Ettie wished she were born a boy. Only the most learned person ( such as Ettie was), could use the 72 names of God to bring forth a Golem.
SUCCESS....( and Tante Ruth had said only men could bring a Golem to life)... ha!
Ettie was exceptional - she was born to fight. She re named herself Nicole Duval.

WE FOLLOW Ettie, ( her younger sister Marta died), Lea, and Ava on a long journey.
So many men - had been entering The World To Come...OLAM HaBa. - THESE STRONG WOMEN NEEDED TO SURVIVE.

I learned a lot!!!!! I didn’t (until this book), know anything about the Huguenot residents of Le Chambon - Sur - Lignon - who made a haven for the Jewish people fleeing from the Nazis.

I also didn’t know about Izieu: A Jewish orphanage.
In 1943, a school for children opened at Izieu.... a commune in eastern France.
A year later everyone was gone. The children were sent to Auschwitz. The French government said it was kindness to send the children to be with your parents. Different police were in collaboration with the Germans and all 42 children were taken to Montluc Prison. Not a single child survived.

You’ll meet Julien - a Heron - Dr. Girard- learn of other communes - bombing in Vienna- visit Haute-Loire- ponder over sights, sounds, smells, language, and tidbits of details. Did you know that the German government forced every Jewish women to use the name Sarah after her own name on every official document? I didn’t.
And.....most you feel as if you know the main characters - and minor characters well....
If you are like me.... you’ll be moved by a mother/ daughter strength that you just might either be a little jealous - that you’re on relationship with your own mother was lacking OR....bask in the special love you did or do have with your mother.

A perfect gift to our mother’s who read!!!

Was this review helpful?

Reading an Alice Hoffman book is always magical, and meant to be read slowly as each sentence feels a treat. Her books are such you can reread them and find something new each time, and her writing is nuanced, lyrical and magical all at once.
Her research for this book must have been extensive, because even with all the WW2 books I’ve read, I still learned something new such as the history of the Huguenots.
In 1941- Berlin Hanni Kohn desperate to save her daughter and get her far away, goes to the Rabbi’s house and receives help, instead, from his daughter, Ettie.Ettie is very smart and creates a Golem from clay and water in the shape of a woman, whose one job is to watch over Lea, and keep her safe until the end of the war. As a price, Ettie now has passage to Paris, along with her sister, Miriam. As Hanni takes Ava, the golem home she implores her to love Lea as her own daughter.
This is an incredible book to read, and I loved the writing and the characters. I can’t recommend this book enough.

Was this review helpful?

WOW. WOW. WOW. This book combines the best of what Alice Hoffman does. Fascinating female characters, history, and magical realism. I was not ready for it to end, and likely will read it again.

Was this review helpful?

What a poignant, beautiful story written by the queen of magical realism, Alice Hoffman. Set in Europe during the devastating time of the Holocaust, the Jewish folklore of the magical golem is brought to life in female form with the task of keeping a young girl safe from persecution. Told with a haunting, moral burden you will not be able to turn away from this book. It will resonate in your soul and mind long after the last page is read.

I highly recommend this book. It is due to be published in September. 2019.

Was this review helpful?