Cover Image: Six Goodbyes We Never Said

Six Goodbyes We Never Said

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Naima is a young woman coping with the tragic loss of her father, a fallen Marine. Interspersed throughout the book we get glimpses of their relationship through visual voicemails left from her dad, who obviously cared about her a lot. She was angry with him before he died, for leaving her again, and now that he's gone, she is expressing anger, guilt, and pain through actions that don't help her move on from it, but ways that help her cope in the her own way.
Dew Brickman is recovering from the sudden death of both his parents due to a car accident, and learning to let go. He is a little awkward and needs some help with social skills, but he means well and often has incredible insights into other people's emotions.
Dew knew about Naima from Naima's father before he died, and has taken becoming Naima's friend on as a personal crusade. Unfortunately, Naima doesn't feel like it's Dew's place to know personal details from her father, or to try so hard to be her friend when she has no idea who he is. She thinks it's a little bit creepy, and she wants to grieve in isolation. Their story is one of friendship and learning to let go.
Full disclosure, I have not yet finished this novel. This is not due to the worth of the book, but rather to the fact that I didn't realize how spot on the ways in which each character acted and reacted due to their trauma would be. I work at a school for kids who have experienced trauma, so many interactions I have with them can feel like some of the moments described in the book, which felt a little heavy to be reading in my free time. That being said, I feel the author did an excellent job of portraying three specific cases of teens (and a ten year old) living and expressing themselves post trauma.
Perhaps because of my experiences with work, this book felt very intellectually heavy, and therefore was a bit of a slow read. The pacing was pretty steady throughout the story, but it definitely wasn't a fast paced book. Based heavily in emotional expression and awkward social interactions, there were constant moments when I was cringing because the characters were not getting their intended outcomes in social interactions, and instead having many negative moments, probably a lot like real life. While Ganger definitely invited empathy throughout each of these scenes, sometimes it felt rather boring and I wasn't as motivated to read it as other books.
I received a copy of this book via the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

When reading Six Goodbyes, there were definitely many elements of it that I absolutely adored, but also many elements that genuinely broke my heart. This novel explores grief, having PTSD and OCD tendencies, establishing routines and breaking them, understanding anxiety and how to cope with it, and overall, learning life in a way that reconstructs your entire life.

Definite trigger warnings for potential suicidal thoughts, GAD, OCD, and PTSD.

Meeting Naima and Dew was a whole experience - these two are such complicated characters, and understandably so. They both find a way to come together despite their differences and they learn to understand each other in a new way. I do, however, feel that they were the real reason there was any continuing force towards 'plot' progression.

I think seeing the bits of audio between the voicemails from Naima's dad, and the audio clips that Dew uses are two very exciting inclusions that would be so cool for the audiobook! I definitely am interested in reading via audiobook so I can hear what the Candace and her crew decide to do with that, but I'm not too sure if I'll end up giving this a re-read because I don't think this ended up being the book for me.

I found myself dragging along the story, and although my heart did ache for Naima and Dew, I couldn't help but feel connected to them. I don't want to constantly feel sorry for a character, but I want to have a deeper connection. I think the writing style also wasn't my cup of tea too, so it just became really difficult to finish, along with the fact that that it wasn't a very engaging story through and through.

Despite this, I do think the purpose in writing this story in the way that it is was done very efficiently. In the blurb, it says it's not a love story, and that's definitely true. Struggling with grief and one's personal battles is something that continues to be something that anyone can really relate to - so if you're looking for something that does explain what life is like in that matter, this could be something that interests you.

Was this review helpful?

DNF at 35%. I really wanted to like this book, but I just couldn't get through it. Before I start my review, I wanted to discuss a couple of positives about this book:
1. There is some pretty amazing diversity in this book. One MC is Latino, plus-sized, and suffers from anxiety, depression, and OCD. The other MC is also Latino and is adopted. There is a side character that seems to be pansexual (but to my knowledge she doesn't actually giver herself that label, at least to the point that I stopped at).
2. This book is own voices. The author, like our MC, suffers from anxiety and OCD.
I always hate when I have to give such an amazingly diverse book a negative rating, but I'm also not going to give a book a good rating when I didn't enjoy it. Now, let's move on to my issues:
1. I wish the formatting of the book would've been done better. This book is dual perspective, however only one character has their own chapters, which means the perspective changes within the other characters chapter, and it does so in a confusing, unnoticeable way. The perspective change happens during a section of mixed media that includes a voicemail and an unsent email draft, but the perspective change happens right below the unsent email, and is the buttons of a voice recorder with "Dew GD Brickman" beneath it in faded gray. The reason this is so confusing is because there's no space between the email and the recorder buttons, so the first few chapters, I didn't even notice that we were changing perspective, which obviously made me super confused the entire time. These buttons are also how you're supposed to follow the timeline of Dew's perspective, which I honestly didn't realize until right now. As you can imagine, I was confused the entire time I was reading this book.
2. I wasn't a big fan of the writing style. It seemed a little all over the place and kind of clunky at times.
3. I have no idea how this book is supposed to end, but I will say, the way this relationship/friendship/companionship/whatever it ends up being begins made me super uncomfortable. The very first meeting between Dew and Naima happens when Naima is in her grandparents back yard and Dew is watching her through a hole in the fence next door. Then, he basically becomes obsessed with her. He can't stop thinking about her, all he talks about in his therapy sessions is Naima, all after a 10 second meeting. This is something I have personally been through, and I just couldn't get behind that.
4. I just wasn't enjoying this book and I wasn't feeling anything towards the characters, which is when I knew it was time to stop.
I wish this could've turned out differently, and this is absolutely not a bad book, it's just not a "me" book. I know other people will read this book and adore it and see themselves in it, and for that reason, I am happy that it exists in the world.

Was this review helpful?

Heartfelt and touching story that deals with mental health issues! I really love how it deals with the subject lightly and not too rushed. Although it doesn't give away a very cohesive plotline, the writing makes up for it. The characters have something to say and it is clearly portrayed in the book.

Was this review helpful?

I received an e-ARC from the publisher (Thank you St. Martin's Publishing Group) via Net Galley in exchange for an honest review

The Good Stuff:

1. I liked how the characters were introduced so I actually enjoyed the beginning of the story.
2. The writing was great with witty dialogues.
3. The story highlighted many important topics that need to be talked about more to help others understand the struggles of those with mental health issues.
4. This book is great for people who are going through a difficult time, coping with the loss of a loved one, and/or battling mental illness. I think they'll be able to resonate with the characters and hopefully find some comfort by reading the story.

The Issues:

1. Although I liked the beginning, most of the book was difficult to get through. I was unable to connect with the characters at the level I would have liked.
2. It was difficult to understand some of the things that were going on with them and everything began to make sense only towards the end.
3. It would have been better if the book was a bit shorter. There are certain scenes that didn't seem like they added anything to the overall story.
4. I wish there had been more of Nell. Maybe a chapter or two with her POV? She did lose someone too and she did struggle with trying to find ways to connect with Naima and help her work through her issues.

Random Thoughts:

1. I felt really bad for Nell throughout the whole book. I don't think I've seen anyone try so hard to connect with someone.
2. Dew is a sweet, sweet boy. Definitely too good for this world.
3. I'm glad this was not a love story. It was nice to see a beautiful friendship blossom between two people instead.
4. I loved Violet. I thought she was pretty cool. I would have liked to have known more about her.

Overall Impression: 3 stars
It was a not a bad read and I would definitely recommend it to someone who would find solace by reading this.

Was this review helpful?

REVIEW #SixGoodbyesWeNeverSaid by Candace Ganger is about 17 year old Naima, who is struggling to navigate life after her father’s death while also dealing with her complex OCD and GAD. Dew is also trying to deal with a number of social anxieties in the wake of his parents’ deaths, and could really use a friend while figuring it all out. Then he meets Naima and everything changes – but not in the way that either of them expects – as the two of them try to find their way back to being okay(ish). This is no love story – if you ask Naima, it’s not even a “like” story. But it is a story about love and fear and how sometimes you need a little help to be brave enough to say goodbye.

There were a lot of things to love about this book. The characters felt really vivid to me, and I loved that they were so richly drawn and flawed. The writing is engaging, well-paced and full of emotion. Their pain broke my heart several times throughout the book. I particularly felt for Dew – his optimism in the face of an awful tragedy was so heartbreaking. I just wanted to hug him and tell him that it was all going to be ok. Naima was prickly but ultimately I did feel for her and I was invested in knowing that these two were on the path to healing by the end.

I did struggle a little to relate to the characters, purely because I’ve never experienced anything like the events in this book myself. The book deals with a lot of heavy topics, like death, suicide, grief, depression, anxiety and mental illness. Even though I don’t feel qualified to comment on those topics, I do think the author handled them with sensitivity and care. The author’s note explains that Ganger herself suffers from a number of similar conditions, and the story really does have that personal feel to it, and I loved the #ownvoices representation.

This one is emotional, touching, honest, raw and heartbreaking, but ultimately hopeful. I enjoyed it but I do think it would be tough to read if you have experienced anything similar to the events in the book.

Is this one on your list? It’s out on 24 September!

Thank you to @stmartinspress for the #gifted copy and for having me on this tour!

Was this review helpful?

Six Goodbyes We Never Said is an own-voices mental health story, following Naima & Drew, both having lost their parents and meeting… getting some help to say goodbye.

I thought this sounded like a very interesting and emotional read, sadly, it didn’t quite hit the mark for me. I found the writing and the delivering of the story confusing and detaching. The book had its moments, and the characters I liked, but how it was executed and told did not work for me at all. I think the book can be important and good for some, but it was not a book for me. I wanted to like it, but the story that was told was not a match with me. 2/5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Note: All commentary on this book has been compared to what is in the finished copy.

I have so many mixed feelings about Six Goodbyes We Never Said. While I enjoyed reading this novel, it was hard to read at the same time for several reasons - and not even because of the subject matter.

First, for the things I liked about Six Goodbyes: This is an #OwnVoices novel, depicting a teenage girl with OCD and anxiety. I can't say anything about whether the portrayal of these was good or not, but the story was enjoyable because of the character's inner struggles with their mental illnesses - struggles that most often leaked into the outside world, affecting the main characters' family members.

I loved that family was a major aspect of this book. Seeing how Naima dealt (or didn't deal) with her father's death was interesting; though maybe more interesting was when we got Dew's point of view, where we read about his foster family and sister, and how Dew's foster mom helped him when Dew had panic attacks. Dew's sister was the best character in the novel, I thought - she was comic relief without being just funny and had her own problems in life that got solved in their own way.

Now for what I really didn't like about Six Goodbyes: My main concern, and why I gave this book three stars, was because Naima was extremely annoying. She doesn't get better throughout the story, either. The book's blurb implies that Naima doesn't like Dew at all throughout the entire story - I won't say what happens at the end, but just know that there's really no chemistry between these two. Nope, not even in a friend way. Why make two characters the protagonists if there's nothing to like about them interacting with each other? Naima is also obsessed with the number six. So of course, everything has to be in sixes. Everything. It almost was as annoying as Naima herself.

Another peeve of mine about this book was that it had so many "audio clip" -looking parts and lines with odd breaks in them - it didn't help the book at all, and it just made the pages look messy. And there's no chapter breaks, either! Just headings that say "Naima" and "Dew."

Now I'm kind of thinking that I want to give Six Goodbyes We Never Said two stars, but I'll keep it at three for its strong topic choice but poor execution.

Was this review helpful?

This book was extremely well written and descriptive. Both Naima and Dew have experienced losses that make them face mental illness and issues. They are able to form a bond that helps them to overcome their pain together and to grow away from their issues. I loved both characters and their dialogues and the people in their lives. There is so much beautiful uniqueness throughout that tied me in and didn't let go.

Was this review helpful?

Ever since I can remember, I've been a worrier. From worrying about what others thought about me, to stressing about doing well in school and even about how my immediate family was doing, my mind was always thinking and dwelling on "what ifs," even as a little girl.

As I grew older, I continued to be plagued by worries, but it wasn't until I was in the throes of (what I would later learn was ) post-partum anxiety after my first baby that I visited a therapist and learned that what I was going through was not just unique to me, that I wasn't a terrible mother, and that my mental health was just as important to maintain and take care of as my body. I learned that mental illness is not something to shy away or be ashamed of, and it was with this awareness and understanding that I dove into this poignant and heartbreakingly real story.

And I believe that is why I came to appreciate and love this novel so much.

From Ganger's author's note in the beginning of this book to the sensitive, detailed portrayal of Naima and Dew as they struggle to navigate heartbreaking loss, anxiety and grief, this book hit me right in the heart because it is so real. While my own anxiety is not nearly as severe as Naima's or Dew's, and I haven't suffered from OCD or PTSD, my heart began pounding a little faster any time either one of them was having an anxiety attack or experiencing the gravity of post-traumatic stress because I could fully imagine what it must feel like simply from Ganger's incredible writing. Showing readers what it feels like to suffer from mental illness is definitely one of Ganger's gifts, and although it was painful and difficult for me to read it at times, it made the book that much more powerful because I felt like I was actually experiencing it with both main characters.

This was a powerful, heartfelt young adult book, and I'm so glad I read it. Hope you enjoy it too! Thank you to author Candace Ganger and Netgalley for an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest, unbiased review!

Was this review helpful?

started reading this book before anything happened with my dad. He's been battling cancer for maybe 7 years but recently the last few weeks we've been in and out of the hospital and now we are looking at a timeline. Ever changing but possibly soon. So this book changed for me and the way I connect with these characters changed.

Naima and Dew are both finding ways to grieve after the loss of parents as well as dealing with their own mental illnesses. I thought the book was really good in the way that it is leading you through the characters lives after this loss. As far as plot goes, it's finding a way to live with the tragedy that happened to them and find their own happiness somehow.

As much as I struggled to connect with Naima. I hated the way she treats people but grief comes in all forms so I tried to understand that.

It's hard not to love Dew because he has such a big heart. I hate he has struggle with his social anxiety but he works so hard at getting it under control. You want him to find a place of balance.

I really liked Six Goodbyes We Never Said. It's well written and touching. A book you can feel the heart and soul in.

Was this review helpful?

“𝓛𝓲𝓯𝓮 𝓲𝓼𝓷'𝓽 𝓮𝓪𝓼𝔂, 𝓓𝓮𝔀, 𝓑𝓾𝓽 𝔂𝓸𝓾 𝓯𝓲𝓷𝓭 𝓪 𝔀𝓪𝔂 𝓽𝓸 𝓯𝓮𝓮𝓵 𝓳𝓸𝔂 𝓽𝓱𝓻𝓸𝓾𝓰𝓱 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓹𝓪𝓲𝓷. 𝓘𝓽'𝓼 𝓹𝓪𝓻𝓽 𝓸𝓯 𝓽𝓱𝓮 𝓙𝓸𝓾𝓻𝓷𝓮𝔂”

TL;DR:
What happens: Naima is dealing with both the loss of her father and her OCD and GAD. She is spending the summer with her grandparents and meets Dew, who also recently lost both of his parents and was adopted. He is dealing with his own anxiety and uses a voice recorder to help him process. The two meet and their friendship grows as they both help each other work through grief.
Plot: Not much happens, but it doesn't have to
Writing: A little convoluted and complex, but overall elegant
Characters: Not my favorite; slightly immature

Pros:
-mental health/anxiety representation
-great slow-build friendship, not something you see often!
-beautiful sections of writing and interesting mixed media format

Cons:
-characters seem a bit more immature than their actual age- understood that some PTSD, grief, anxiety, etc plays into this but at least part seems to come from the writing/characterization
-somewhat unlikeable characters, most especially Hiccup the dog!! Dew is mostly chill but has a weird obsession with Naima at the beginning
-weird skips/characters only mentioned, but never seen on screen (Christian?)
-far longer/drawn out than it needed to be

I received an advance readers copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I made it a quarter through Six Goodbyes We Never Said before I decided it's not capturing my attention enough to continue. The topic was interesting to me, as someone who struggles with anxiety, and someone with military connections, but ultimately the pacing felt dense and wasn't holding my interest. I appreciate the opportunity to review this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book was pretty meh to me. There were parts that I liked and parts that I disliked, but primarily, I just didn't find myself that entranced or captivated with the story.

I think it would be better for the people who connect with the representation provided, but that just doesn't include myself.

Was this review helpful?

This is a book about grief. And a magic pixie dream boy. I found Dew to be so annoying and I didn’t enjoy his story as much as Naima’s.

Was this review helpful?

One of a few books that doesn't treat disability and grief like stepping stones to other, less interesting topics. It's not a perfectly neat book, and that's what I liked most about it; the characters aren't always easy to like and they make realistic mistakes. At the same time, it's not a parade of tragedy either. A good contemporary read.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to St. Martins Press and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this book for my review.

DNFed at 8%, which I’m pretty sure I’ve never done before.

I went into this book excited to read it, the cover is gorgeous and I loved that it had to do with mental illnesses. But holy moly y’all, I’m so lost. The writing is so hard to read that I’m finding myself reading as slow as a sloth and I’m still not getting it. There’s characters being thrown out that I have no idea who they are because they haven’t been introduced but I’m thinking I missed something so I go back to look for them, and they’re not there. The representation of mental illnesses bugged me, the character’s therapists bugged me, literally everything I’ve read so far is bugging me.

With their being two main characters in this book that are both told in first person you would think there would be a distinct way the author would let you know who’s talking, nope. I’m reading along about a girl talking about her periods then all of a sudden it says “spoiled boy”. That threw me for a huge loop until I realized it was now being told from the other main character, without really letting you know.

I honestly really wanted to like this book but it’s giving me a headache trying to read the writing and keep track of what character is currently talking.

Was this review helpful?

This book was about love, loss and friendship. We meet two teens, Naima Rodriguez and Andrew "Dew" Brickman. They both suffered unbelievable tragedies most adults couldn't handle.

I understand that Naima had a rough life and as a result, there were emotional struggles that caused severe depression and a host of other issues. I wanted to like her but I could not stand her. She was rude, self absorbed and selfish. Again others will probably disagree with me because she was the way she was because of her tragic life. Towards the end of the book she had a transformation that I credit to do.

I got the impression that Naima was the central character but I liked everyone else in the book BUT her. Dew had my heart immediately. He spoke so eloquently for a teenage boy and was wise beyond his years. Dew's little sister, Faith was obsessed with Ric Flair. The author had me at Ric Flair!!!
Dew was extremely patient with Naima and she definitely didn't deserve the time and effort he put into foraging a friendship with her. Dew always saw the good in everyone and in most situations.
Overall, it's a good book but dragged on a little too long. I like a good gut wrenching story as much as anyone but it seriously could have ended 50 pages sooner than it did.

Thank you to Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

I’ll be honest. I wasn’t sure what to expect from this book. I really enjoy reading books with characters that have mental illnesses and being in their head. When I saw this book and read the synopsis, I knew I wanted to read it. I made the mistake of reading some other reviews on Goodreads though. Some didn’t like one of the MC’s, others didn’t like either one of the MC’s, and a few others were intent that the girl MC was bi. Anyways, I was nervous going in because of the reviews. But I feel like they all got it wrong. I liked both MC’s and the storyline, and think this is a good book on mental illness.

We follow 2 MC’s, Naima and Dew. Both deal with a lot of different mental illnesses and both are not your normal teen. They also both come from very sad backgrounds. Naima is a super fierce girl who not only lost her father while he was serving in the Marines, but she is also dealing with a complex OCD, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and GAD, generalized anxiety disorder. She doesn’t really like anyone, dislikes her stop mom a lot, and is grieving her father like crazy. What makes things worse is that she was mad at him, before he died, for always taking another tour instead of being home with her. She feels better being with her grandmother and grandfather, but she still wants nothing to do with anyone.

Dew is just a super sweet and caring boy. He lost his parents when he was a little younger and was thrown in foster care. At the moment he is with a family that is loving and treats him very well. He even sees traces of his parents in them. Dew deals with a lot of anxiety, especially since he lost both his parents suddenly. He really wants a friend, and when he meets Naima he thinks he found one.

Although Naima wants nothing to do with Dew, he finds ways to break her barriers and become his friend. He is a little strange in his ways of doing it, and she in return is horrible to him, but it’s so understandable since they are both dealing with such loss and mental stuff. I loved that the author note before the beginning of the book talks about how she too deals with the same kind of illnesses that Naimi and Dew deal with. Because of that, I think she has a pretty good grasp on the topic and how to execute it well.

I know this book won’t be everyone’s cup of tea. But if you are interested in different mental illnesses and love reading books with characters that have them, you may very well enjoy this book! Read it and come back and let’s chat!!

Was this review helpful?

I DNFd this book at about 25%. I just couldn't read any more of the story. I felt like our female main character- I can't remember her first name- was so self absorbed and couldn't get passed her grief and anger. She didn't even want to try. The male main character was more relateble for me. He has anxiety and panic attacks. Our female main character was just angry towards everyone and it wasn't fair. I just couldn't keep reading. And I don't know any about the author, but I didn't get the vibe that she experienced this. Again, I don't know anything about her and didn't read her bio to know if that is the case, but I just felt that the 25% I read I didn't feel like she experienced a military grief.

Was this review helpful?