This book was an interesting read. It blended high fantasy with a more realistic-historical fiction feel. The adventure of going forth from Swan Island with a quest in mind, the excitement of the unknown, the danger of undercover work, the book had an excellent set-up. However, while I enjoyed the story, I had to read carefully to keep up with the plot. There seemed to be two strands going at all times, right up to the end, and it never really felt like they were completely tied together. I enjoyed the mystical element of the book and the tension between Dau and Liobhan, but it felt unfulfilled. I hope that there is a second book in the works because there are so many questions left over and so many avenues that seemed important but were left unexplored.

Great muse of writing, thank you for your gift of Ms. Marillier's talent!
A wonderful tale done with respect to Celtic folklore. It was a joy to read such strong true story. The primary protagonist is a competent young woman, a genuinely powerful and talented musician and warrior. The elven queen is both powerful and delicate. The adopted brother is a bard and something more. All and all, a genuinely good book