Resilient Faith

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 20 Dec 2019

Member Reviews

This book is SO good! Sittser reflects on early Christian faith, and how it formed a "third way" to the dominant Roman and Jewish cultures of the day. He provides historical and theological reflections on the way early Christians worshipped, practiced spiritual disciplines, discipled and lived. The book is accessible and very enjoyable to read. Rather than drawing a lot of parallels on how we should be more like these Christians, he simply paints a picture of how they lived and leaves it with the reader to reflect on how we should to - which was powerful and effective.
Was this review helpful?
Gerald Sittser, in Resilient Faith, asks how the early Christians were different, as the “third way?” They lived as “alien residents” in but not of the world. They refused to conform to the “first way” of Greco-Roman civil religion and to the “second way” of Jewish ethical and ritual religion. Instead, they followed the “third way” of allegiance to Jesus Christ as Lord and the Kingdom of God. They immersed into culture, but over time, transformed it from the inside out. In his own words, here’s his central argument: “the early Christian movement became known as the Third Way because Jesus himself was a new way, which in turn spawned a new movement—new in theology, in story, in authority, in community, in worship and in behavior. Christian belief was so new, in fact, that it required Christians to develop a process of formation in the Third Way to move new believers from conversion to discipleship, from outsider to insider, from observer to full-fledged member, which produced generation after generation of believers who, established firmly in the faith, were able to grow the movement over a long period of time. Rejecting both accommodation and isolation, early Christians immersed themselves in the culture as followers of Jesus and servants of the kingdom of God.” 

With careful scholarship and historical and social analysis, Sittser shows how the early church grew as a spiritual and social “resistance movement” that carried the message of the Gospel birthed in the Old Testament and carried over into the New Testament with the incarnation, resurrection, ascension of Jesus Christ, the long awaited Messiah to all peoples, Jew and Gentile. They portrayed by belief, book (Scripture), and bishops (centralized leaders) a new authority that empowered and expanded a network of Christians who lived in close proximity to each other and to their pagan communities in packed urban centers. He argues that they lived from a new identity as a commonwealth and household of faith, and worshipped the one true God by observing the Lord’s day, with rhythms of prayer, signing the cross, reciting the Lord’s prayer, memorizing liturgical script, practicing discipline and virtue, and receiving the sacraments, as a counter-culture to onlooking mystified Roman citizens and Emperors who could not control or eliminate them. One key element, according to Sittser, was the eventual and extensive use of the catechumenate (a disciplemaking training program in Christian belief and behavior).

Sittser demonstrates a careful and cohesive and interesting historical, social, and religious presentation as to how the early Christians expressed and propagated a transformational resilient faith. In my opinion, where he misses the mark, as we even see in the book of Acts and later secular and religious literature, is that he does not present the data of a vibrant Spirit-empowered-and-led movement of Jesus followers who prayed, prophesied, performed miracles and healing, as they proclaimed and propagated the gospel of the Kingdom. He pays scant attention to the supernatural mission of the outpoured Spirit who unleashed the church to become an exponential torrent of unstoppable power that crossed all social, political, economic, religious, and cultural barriers. Yes, they garnered a new identity, authority, and household, with Christian belief, book, and bishops. Yes, they lived with virtue and social grace and served from love and care for all types of marginalized peoples. Yes they developed training that brought pagan converts into the Christian commonwealth. But spiritual formation infused by the indwelling Spirit and guidance by the Old Testament and New Testament Scriptures set the content, framework, and impetus for missional ministry in and through a pagan world and on into Christendom to the modern day. 

Sittser’s conclusion in his final chapter is brief and disappointing in that he could have drawn some daring principles and practices from his otherwise superb historical treatment and leverage them for today’s church. Perhaps the reader will draw their own. This is a solid book with much valuable historical information, but history is always subject to the historian’s interpretation, bias, purpose, and limitations. 

“Book has been provided courtesy of Graf-Martin Communications and Baker Books in exchange for an honest review.”
Was this review helpful?
What can Christians today learn from the early church? That is what I hoped to learn by reading Resilient Faith by Gerald L. Sittser. I learned that and so much more.

The author takes us on an extensive journey of Christianity. Using the Bible, writings from early church leaders and secular books on the history of Rome and the emergence of Christianity. It is clear, early on, that the church began to have problems once Gentiles were adopted into the faith. For example, when the Apostles were alive, they made Israel's Bible (the Torah) the Christian Bible. They used it in worship, in sermons and quoted it in their writings. The church, during the time of Apostolic Leadership, kept the Sabbath on Saturday as God had commanded. Using the Torah, they were able to show new believers God's plan of redemption, starting at creation and would end with a new heaven and a new earth. For the disciples, the Torah was a "glorious narrative, and Jesus is at the center of it."

The problems began after the apostles were all gone, and more and more Gentiles became believers. Unfortunately, unlike the gentiles of Jesus' time, these believers knew nothing of the Jewish Torah or the Jewish faith and began to separate themselves from it. The author covers a lot of ground about how and why the church separated itself from Jewish Christians, and it is an interesting read.

The author included many quotes and notes from historical church figures like Eusebius, Ignatius of Antioch, Polycarp, and Irenaeus, among others. He also included Gnostic and heretical writings from Marcion of Sinope, who was expelled from the church as a heretic. I loved these bits of information because they began to show a picture of how quickly the church lost its focus as Jesus being the centre of all things.

An interesting tidbit of history was on catechumenates and the very Catholic rituals that began to be observed during the 3rd century. New believers were put through a carefully choreographed initiation of examination, lessons, indoctrination, etc. before they were accepted as believers. The description left me feeling like the early church operated like a cult. Belief in Jesus and confession, along with repentance, just weren't enough. This 3rd-century ritualistic observation included the daily recitation of the Lord's prayer, daily exorcisms, anointings, confirmation, baptism and partaking of the Eucharist. These were all needed to become a Christian. But eventually, even this discipline in the early church faded. I am glad, as the more I read, the more it sounded like they were replacing faith with more rituals and laws to follow.

If you are a student of the Word, you will enjoy this informative book on early church history. While I disagree with the author's conclusions as to how the 21st-century church should operate today to survive in a hostile world, it is still an interesting read.

I received this book courtesy of Brazos Press and NetGalley for my honest opinion.
Was this review helpful?
Resilient Faith: How the Early Christian "third Way" Changed the World by Gerald L. Sittser is a very good history of the Christian faith. Sittser writes of the beginnings of Christianity, its recognition as the "third Way" (in addition to Roman and Jewish beliefs), it becoming the recognized default religion in the West, and the challenges it faces today in an increasingly secular world.

Sittser examines how the lessons and actions of the early church may be the answer to Christianity regaining its place in the lives of people who have turned away from the church as well as helping to restore the moral compass our society seems to have lost.

Highly readable and fascinating, this gets a 4-star review from me.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Brazos Press for allowing me to read a copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased review.
Was this review helpful?
Finding a middle path, a way that meanders between any extremes, or some "third way" has been the pattern among many movements in the path. Evolution sees it as "survival of the fittest." The secular world views it as natural selection. The business world thinks of new potential as a new wave. Whatever it is, the possibility of a new way in the midst of conflicting old ways is always a path of hope. In the Early Church, this "third way" is the Jesus Way. Jesus spoke about this as He moves among two huge forces of resistance: Roman and Jewish. Followers of Jesus were also known as followers of "The Way." This way has resisted the Roman persecutions, the Hellenistic cultural forces and Jewish legalistic regimen. In doing so, this way of Jesus impacted the early centuries and is continuing to do so today. By studying the why and how of this Third Way, author Gerald Sittser helps us understand and learn from the resilient gospel of Jesus, and to see its relevance today in our increasingly challenging world. The recurring question that Sittser asks throughout the book is this: How did the Christianity flourish in the light of persecutions and inhospitable conditions? On top of these, they had to resist worldliness. They had to battle heresies. They had to endure being ostracised for their beliefs and lifestyles. Interestingly this "third way" disappeared overnight upon the official recognition of Christianity after Constantine's influence in AD313. It also took on negative perceptions due to the crusades, the Thirty Year War, and many other politicizing of Christianity. In our modern era, we are challenged with a post-Christian hostility, a Millennial scepticism, and the rise of new age spiritualities. In writing about faith and the resilience of the Christian beliefs, Sittser aims to help us see the future with hope even as the days appear dark and daunting. He does this by comparing and contrasting the old and new eras constantly. It flourished in the early centuries because it was deemed new and novel. It was also seen as a major threat to the pre-existing establishment then. During the persecution era, Christians pledged allegiance to Christ incurring the wrath of the Roman emperors.  He begins this with a focused look at how the ecclesiastical tradition helped shaped faith through the ages. However, he soon discovers that it was not the Church per se, but the belief in Jesus that is more significant. The Third Way is the Jesus way. For in Christ, we see a bridge between the old and the new; the old world and the new world; the renewal movements and the desire for spiritual refreshment; etc. This pattern of renewed focus on Jesus and revival in the Spirit is what makes the Christian faith resilient.


The Third Way overcame many challenges in the past. It overcame religious and political persecution in the early centuries. It overcame the politicizing of religion, or the Constantinian effect on the Church. It overcame the theological battles against heresies. It overcame the attacks on the Theology of Christ; Trinity; the Person of Jesus; etc. It overcame the cultural divide; language differences; ethnic distinctions; and many other divisive elements of society. While the Church played a huge part in preserving the Third Way, it is not ultimately the reason for the resilience of the Christian faith. For the Christian faith is more a movement rather than a monument.

My Thoughts
Christianity now has become post-Christian. No longer are we seeing the West as a Christian country. It has gone to the other extreme, to become like the Rome of yesterday, where the religion is the world. The world is increasingly secular, atheistic, and overwhelmingly hostile to anything to do with Christianity. Yet, during moments where things look dim and dark, it is heartening to take a look at history, and in spite of overwhelming difficulty, the faith continues to grow in leaps and bounds. The Third Way then is still the relevant Third Way today. This bears testimony to the living Christ. By tracing the historical resilience, Sittser shows us that what happened in the past could embolden believers today to remain hopeful in spite of marginalization of religion. This "something else" is about going back to the fundamentals of our faith. In our modern Church scene, people are seeing revival in terms of megachurches, loud music, attractive programming, and so on. Yet, these things are mere cultural adaptations where people adapt the faith to fit the cultural expectations. This will not make the faith any more resilient. A simple test would be this: Remove these expensive equipment, ambient atmosphere, comfortable chairs and fads, we would realize that only Christ makes all the difference. The early disciples didn't have what the modern church have. They don't even have any training from the theological curriculums of our modern seminaries! Their teacher is Jesus and their guide is the Holy Spirit. We too have the same Teacher and Guide because Jesus and the Holy Spirit is with us.

One of the most famous words from Dr Richard Halverson, former chaplain to the US Senate was: "In the beginning the church was a fellowship of men and women centering on the living Christ. Then the church moved to Greece, where it became a philosophy. Then it moved to Rome, where it became an institution. Next it moved to Europe where it became a culture, and, finally, it moved to America where it became an enterprise." I would even add that today, it has become a nice add-on instead of the main thing. This book is heavy on Church history, and gives readers the foundation of understanding the unique challenges faced by the early church. We should not take the simplistic approach that in order to grow, we must replicate the past to reinvigorate the present. No. Instead, we should be encouraged by our ancestors who fought the good fight and finished the race. Every generation will have their own battles to face and to overcome. We shall overcome but only in Christ. For without Christ, we can do nothing. With Christ, nothing is impossible. The belief in this alone will not only continue the legacy of the Christian faith, it strengthens our faith too.

Rating: 4.25 stars of 5.

conrade
This book has been provided courtesy of Brazos and NetGalley without requiring a positive review. All opinions offered above are mine unless otherwise stated or implied.
Was this review helpful?
This was a pretty good survey of church history. It would be suitable for seminary classes and laypeople serious about learning about this topic. The writing is engaging, and the subject is well researched. 

I'm not sure this book would be quite right for the average reader looking for something interesting to read in terms of new ideas and ways of living the Christian faith. While the author emphasizes the Catechumenate of the early church, the emphasis is firmly focused on history, not the future. 

Nevertheless, this is a worthwhile book for those seeking to learn more about church history from an expert.
Was this review helpful?