I started this book almost one year ago, but when I was not able to read it in one sitting, I postponed the entire thing till it disappeared into my reading pile. Finally, in an effort to clean up my to-read list, I started paying attention to those I have had with me a while.
I give all this up in the very beginning not to claim that it is not a good book, but to indicate that it is a hard one to read in one sitting. All the harm that happens to the individual women is almost an iteration of a particular combination of horrors. It does not help to know that this cycle probably continues for someone or the other now.

The author lives in the US and is put into contact with a former (and hopefully later as well) beekeeper who is helping rescue women from the Daesh. The fates of the Yazidis seem to be dire and the hardships just escalating. The author introduces poetry in between with her own reflections that provide some space between visiting the next rescued woman and or family. I had to put it down in between to be able to pick it up again. It did serve as an eye-opener to the never-ending loop of terror many people must be living into this day. There is hope since our team of dedicated smugglers smuggle out the kidnapped women, risking their own lives in the process. I will not forget the content in a hurry.

I received an ARC thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.

These stories are important to read but the style of the book made it difficult to connect with the narratives. I stuck with it because I felt I owed it to the women in crisis to bear witness to their lives, but the stream of consciousness/interview style was very difficult to follow at times.

These stories of Iraqi women escaping the brutal ISIS are powerful and touching. The beekeeper, outside of his peaceful beekeeping activities, assists these women to safety in Syria and Turkey. A brave and poignant book, well worth the read.

I found this book deeply unsettling that this was allowed to happen so recently! Haven't the human race learnt by it's mistakes from previous genocides!
Alth6the style of the writing was difficult to follow it was compelling reading.

Thanks to NetGalley, Dunya Mikhail and the publishers.

In today’s political climate, meaningful conversations about the refugee crisis, ISIS (Daesh), and universal violence against women should center these harrowing stories of women escaping from Daesh. The book is packed with so much to process that it is all the things--hard to put down, hard to keep reading, hard to pick back up, and hard to stay away from. The stories of what has happened to these women are worse than anyone could possibly imagine. It makes the current xenophobia around taking in refugees in Western countries particularly appalling.

Personally, the organization and format of the book was difficult for me to follow. It reads as though it was directly transcribed from conversations with Abdullah (the Beekeeper), who runs an extension operation smuggling these women out of Daesh and back to their families. Even mundane snippets like saying goodbye and arranging the next phone call are transcribed. For example, he may tell a long, emotional story about a family he rescued who was kidnapped, the men and elderly murdered, the women and children sold, the women raped and beaten, the children forced to make rockets, etc. for pages. Then, the writer says something at the end like, “Amazing work!...I have to go meet with students now. Can we talk again on Thursday?” It takes away from some of the gravitas of the moment and does not feel like it belongs in such a heavy book. Transcribing it in this way also made it difficult at times to follow when Abdullah would provide updates on individuals he previously mentioned. I would have preferred each chapter be dedicated to a woman’s story and the rescue operation.

Interweaving the transcribed phone conversations are poetry and the author’s flashbacks. All of it is lovely, but it is confusing and disjointed in one book. I found myself skipping over those parts to get back to Abdullah’s stories. I would be very interested in reading the author’s memoir and poetry, but in different books, with The Beekeeper of Sinjar focused just on rescuing women from Daesh. Some background information on possibly the rise of Daesh and who the Yazidis are would have fit well in this book, too.

I would give it 5 stars for the content that Abdullah, the Beekeeper, contributes and 3 stars for the way in which it is told. I do think these stories are important, and everyone needs to hear them.

I received a free review copy from the publisher in exchange for my honest unedited feedback.

Beekeeper of Sinjar

Thank you to Netgalley and to the publisher for an advance ARC in return for an honest review.

This is not a long book.

In fact, when I got to the end I was left feeling is that it? But short though it may be its harrowing reading. Sometimes almost with your hands over your face in shock and horror.

The book is a compilation of recollections of (mostly Yazidi) woman kidnapped by ISIS (Daesh), helped by the Beekeper of Sindjar, Abdullah Sharem who smuggles escaped woman to safety. Before the war in Iraq he was a Beekeper hence the title.

This is not written by an author but a poet, it is also based on the women’s recollections some made in person, and some over the phone. What this novel achieves is being an oral narrative of these women’s horrific experiences. Being kidnapped, raped in front of their children. Watching their sons become radicalised by ISIS. Watching their elders being murdered.

(Apparent) rumours of woman and children not sold as sex slaves being sold for body parts.

What is also achieves is being an oral narrative of the kindness of strangers who helped the woman (and children) get to freedom. The dressmaker who hid a woman and her two children in her shop for three months.

The others who lent cell phones to allow them to call home and arrange their rescue.

This is recent history, this is not the dark and distance past, and its an important story that needed to be told. It’s not a novel though its an important recounting of women’s experiences in the recent past which makes this an important read.

The Idea behind the novel was potentially brilliant however Dunya Mikhail does a poora job of actually executing the idea. The interviews were highly monotonous, it seems that she had just transcribed them all verbatim. The narrative itself struggles to find a solid footing and mostly flounders for the duration of the entire book. And because she doesn't not put an effort to streamline her ideas and align them together with the plot elements, a lot of characters - especially Abdullah - come off as a little self-indulgent which should not have happened considering the important work that they are doing daily. The bits of poetry at the end of chapters actually worked mostly well for me, so no complaints there.

There are sections about her past which don't properly meld with the main portion of the story and the shift was most often than not jarring. I could also have used with a little bit of background about Sinjar itself and why it is of strategic importance to Daesh. There were certain blanks where factual and historical foregrounding and it seems Mikhail expected her readers to know about those missing bits from the get go. Apart from all that, the stories of the women featured here were extremely harrowing and distressing. It is of course hard for us to understand the true horror of all these acts living our sheltered lives, but Mikhail brings it all home and makes the unimaginable within our cognitive reach.

The story had a lot of potential and It was an important story for everyone to learn about. However, the author did a very poor job of presenting the book. The writing is very fragmented and it reads as if she typed up the conversations word for word. I couldn’t get into the story because it was all over the place and not put together very well.

She also throws in her poetry or bits about her life/her past that didn’t link with the rest of the story. Her poetry didn’t make any sense and sounded pretentious when placed in the middle of a survivors story. She also didn’t talk about the background of the Yazidi people or how important Mount Sinjar was to them which would have added to the story and been useful.

I read the entire book hoping it would get better but it never did. It’s an important story that everyone should learn about but maybe read news articles or other books about Daesh because this book is about as interesting as a news report. I enjoyed hearing the stories from these brave women but the author could’ve done a better job presenting the stories and spent more time talking about Abdullah and giving background on him too. It’s called the beekeeper of Sinjar and I felt like I knew more about the authors personal life and not much about the beekeeper.

Nadia Murad was a 19-year-old going about her life with a prosaic bent of mind when fighters from the Islamic State rounded up the Yazidi community in her village of Kocho in Sinjar District, Iraq. What followed was a tale of indescribable horror and dread. Exterminating close to 600 residents of the village, the rabid terrorists took into captivity Nadia and 6,700 other Yazidi women. Employed as ‘sabaya’ or a sex slave, Nadia endured wanton torture and unspeakable torment. Repeatedly sold on slave markets in Mossul, Tal Afar and Raqqa, Nadia was raped at will by her ‘purchasers’, physically beaten and burned with cigarettes. Adding to her woes was the fact that she lost 46 family members – that included her parents – in the ISIS massacre. After enduring an agonizing twelve months of captivity, Nadia managed to escape and flee to a refugee camp in Duhok, Northern Iraq. Now a resident of Germany, Nadia is engaged in spreading awareness about the atrocities committed by ISIS and their mindless genocide against the Yazidi community. In 2018, In 2018, she, along with Denis Mukwege were jointly awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for “their efforts to end the use of sexual violence as a weapon of war and armed conflict”.

In her eviscerating, emotional and extraordinary book, “The Bee Keeper of Sinjar”, the Iraqi-American poet, Dunya Mikhail chronicles in a searing and poignant manner, the travails, tribulations and tumult of a multitude of Iraqi women abducted by the ISIS and subject to unimaginable acts of barbarity. While it requires nerves of steel and a heart of stone to get through till the end of Ms. Mikhail’s book, it also leaves the reader with a hope that emerges out of the very cockles of the heart. The reason for this surging optimism goes by the name of Abdullah, a former bee keeper who has dedicated his very existence, resources and determination to rescuing these vulnerable women from the despicable, diabolical and dreaded clutches of their sadistic captors. Using an elaborate and highly complicated networks of informants, smugglers and known Samaritans, Abdullah working in close co-ordination and co-operation of the Office of Kidnapped Affairs, meticulously pores over maps, prepares painstakingly in advance, plans escape routes and plucks the desperate women right from under the very noses of the ISIS before transporting them to various refugee camps.

The harrowing tales narrated by the women makes for some incredibly painful reading. Nadia a young Yazidi woman was sold on the sex slave market for 100,000 dinars (about US$85). The sale was made in a warehouse post an inspection exercise as a process of which the buyers selected their picks like choosing watermelons and after smelling the girls carefully. Nadia’s ‘buyer’ was a man from Chechnya and he carted away Nadia along with her three children (aged six, five and one), to a four-story building in the Tishreen Dam region. Mercilessly beating and raping her in front of her children, Nadia’s captor also had a penchant for “passing her on for a day or two, like presents being borrowed, a practice they called rent.” Nadia and her children worked for twelve hours every day making rockets for the Daesh. “They gave my five-year-old daughter the most dangerous job, tying together the detonation lines. At any moment a mistake could explode the bomb right in her face.”

If young women were taken captive and abused to satiate the sexual appetites of the reprobates, a worse fate (if such an extended misery was to be even possible) awaited the elderly women, the men and the little children who refused to be separated from their families. The Daesh separated the elderly, the men, and the obstinate children from the eligible women and either buried them all alive in makeshift pits or shot them down in a torrent of gunfire.

Ms. Mikhail also elucidates to her readers that even in the midst of savages there can be found miraculous examples of beacons of empathy. A shining example is that of the seamstress Reem. The daughter of a Daesh member, Reem smuggled Zuhour a mother of two in her warehouse, right under the nose of her unsuspecting father before the resourceful Abdullah whisked the trio away to safety. Reem did not even bat an eyelid before putting herself in a ridiculously dangerous position in trying to rescue Zuhour and her children.

The myriad cast of characters facing an existential crisis courtesy the ISIS ways, may be distilled from the assemblage in any refugee camp. In the camp at Arbat, for example, the occupants include Iraqis, Syrians, Kurds, Turks, Assyrians and Persians. There are people from many different regions taking shelter in the camp. Shabak and Christians fleeing from Mosul; Syrians escaping Kobani; Yazidis bidding goodbye to Sinjar, and Muslims escaping across the Tigris from al-Anbar on small skiffs.

This arresting work contains its own bit of gallows humour as well. As Ms. Mikhail writes, some women discovered ingenious techniques to ‘trick’ the Daesh and minimizing the grief caused to them. According to one of the captured women, Badia, who was purchased by a Daesh member originally hailing from the USA, there existed five tricks for escaping the Daesh: “the first trick was to stop bathing for an entire month, until she smelled so bad that the fighters would stay away from her, refusing to buy her. The second trick was to claim she was married, and that the little child beside her was her son. The third was to pretend she was pregnant in order to avoid being raped, if only temporarily. The fourth trick was to say that she’d just stepped outside with her girlfriend to get some air. The fifth trick was to call “the American Emir”, (an influential Daesh member originally from the USA), to make it clear that she was not trying to run away from him.”

The Daesh viewed the captured youth as potential enlistees for both their missions and martyrdom. With this intent they proceeded to give the boys intensive training. As the mother of a boy named Ragheb recollects, “Ragheb was forced to train for four hours every day, learning how to kill, how to chop off people’s heads. They would also teach him Quran for two hours a day and fight for another hour. They have classes on everything, from how to wash your hands to sex education, from impurity to handling an animal, from genetics to just about anything you can imagine – and things you can’t imagine. And finally a personalized sermon to convince him to die for God, so that he’ll be rewarded in heaven. They have special passes to get into heaven that are handed out at the end.”

To quote Nadia Murad, “the daily routine for Daesh is taking drugs, reciting religious songs, going to fight, and then coming home and raping women.” Even after being liberated from the vice like grip of the ISIS these women are scarred psychologically and physically for most of their lives. According to psychotherapist Dr. Nagham Nozad Hassan, the plight of survivors who get pregnant after they are raped is the worst. They develop conflicting feelings between “motherhood and the desire to get rid of Daesh embryos.”

The world is indebted to people of the likes of Abdullah. In spite of immense personal tragedy (he lost his brother and some family members to an ISIS mass slaughter), this former bee keeper from Sinjar has dedicated his life to bringing hope to those teetering on the brink of hopelessness. Ms. Mikhail with her haunting book does yeoman service to the noble deeds of Abdullah by bringing them out in the open for the whole of humanity to admire and emulate.

The selfless and heroic Abdullah has the last word. “With the money I made selling honey in Iraq and Syria, I was able to help save female captives – and I rely upon the same skills in my new work. I cultivated a hive of transporters and smugglers from both sexes to save our queens, the ones Daeshis call sabaya, sex slaves. We worked like in a bee-hive, with extreme care and well planned initiatives.”

We offer our deepest gratitude and respect to him!

I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

Thank you NetGalley!!

The book is about the harrowing stories of women all across Iraq who have managed to escape the clutches of Isis. These are tales of endurance, difficult escapes, and more.
I feel like this is a must-read.