Cover Image: The Water Dancer

The Water Dancer

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

When one of your favorite authors f’n blows your mind . ⁣

Understand, this isn’t your ordinary slave narrative. Set in mid-1800s Virginia, The Water Dancer is about Hiram Walker whose life is deeply affected when he nearly drowns in a river. Born into slavery and robbed of all memory of his mother, Hiram is gifted with a mysterious power that sets him off to find his freedom.⁣

In an interview with The New York Times Coates said that, in his research for the book, he came across numerous references to water in relation to those forced into slavery, starting with the Middle Passage, when many jumped off ships to escape enslavement. These images stuck with him. ⁣

The cover art by Calida Garcia Rawles is fitting in more ways than one. This novel is not one to be missed, I highly recommend you check out books4usbyus own voice review. ⁣This isn't my final review as I am still processing so lookout for my Goodreads post coming soon.

Thank you One World Books for gifting me this copy this ⁣

Was this review helpful?

This book needs some serious editing. I had to force myself to finish it. I. Not sure why it needed the teleportation at the end, and it really lost me.

Was this review helpful?

Many works have been written regarding man’s original sin, but Mr. Coates’ first foray into the world of literary fiction, is a unique addition to a story that has been told by countless others. We meet the primary character, Hiram, as a child, essentially an orphan, having lost his mother to the evils of slavery, whose only remaining parent is the plantation owner. “Hi” is intelligent, engaging and gifted, and blessed with a photographic memory. Despite Hi’s impressive memory, his only memories of his mother are comprised only of those that have been told to him by others, which emphasizes the trauma of their parting. Though Hi’s abilities are acknowledged by both the “Quality” and the “Tasked”, he is nonetheless doomed to a life of servitude that involves caring for his white half-brother, Maynard, because of his race...that is until a chance and magical encounter wherein Hi becomes aware of another gift, the gift of conduction, which may just be his ticket out of the miserable condition of forced servitude.

During Hi’s journey to learn more about and to develop his magical gift, readers are introduced to other characters that one would expect to see in a book about slavery - terrorist slave catchers, “Uncle Tom’s”, abolitionists, poor whites (the “Low”), and the newly freed. But the manner in which Mr. Coates introduces these characters is again, novel and refreshing. As to be expected in a book with this subject, Mr. Coates does not shy away from detailing the atrocities and horrors of slavery. But Mr. Coates also leaves readers will a sense of hope for the future.

In summary, Mr. Coates’ presentation of this stain on our nation’s history was unique in both its rendering and storyline. Moreover, each sentence is meticulously written, providing readers a literary smorgasbord. I took my time enjoying each and every morsel of this offering and look forward to Mr. Coates’ next work of fiction.

Was this review helpful?

I love Coates’ essays and his earlier non-fiction book, Between the World and me. This is a solid entry to the fiction world, a slave narrative with elements of magical realism. But, unfortunately, not my favorite of books in this category.

Was this review helpful?

Powerful. As a white woman, I will never know what it is like to live in another color skin. And I will certainly never know what it is to be a slave. But Ta-Nehisi Coates allowed me to glimpse that world, that life for a moment. And that brief view was transformational. His exploration of freedom, as a concept and as a way of life is extraordinary. I was transported. This is a stunning work.

Was this review helpful?

I have just finished an extraordinary book.

The Water Dancer, bhy Ta-Nehul Coates, is an odd mix of history and a bit of fantasy, or perhaps of old ways, old powers that are lost to us in the modern world.

It's a book of affirmation and redemption even as it tackles degradation and oppression. It is an unrelenting indictment of slavery and a celebration of freedom, but there are unimaginable costs associated with the path from one to the other.

It's a tale of sacrifice, and of power.

Hiram Walker is the child of slave and slave-owner, an unholy combination that shapes his whole life. He has the power of conduction, a mysterious capability merging physical transport with spiritual memories. He's betrayed more than once; his actions are sometimes motivated by his own desires and the betrayals are not always by other people.

Along the way we learn a great deal about slavery, about the old ways of Virginia, about the underground railroad. We meet Grandma Moses. We see a Philadelphia that is strangely familiar to someone who has lived there, while being utterly foreign in many ways. It's not always easy to tell what is real and what lives in the world of imagination.

Don't miss this book. It will make you think.

To be published 24 September 2019. I read a pre-release copy.

Was this review helpful?

This beautifully crafted novel tells the story of Hiram, one of the "tasked" in Virginia who is educated for the purpose of being a manservant to his half-brother -- his father's white son and heir to the plantation. The story is compelling and as a reader I found myself very invested in Hiram's future. The magical realism elements of the story are woven into the narrative and provide a way for readers to better understand the violations and losses inflicted on slaves.

Was this review helpful?

The setting of this book was absolutely impeccable. I haven't read many novels about slavery in America (I'm Canadian, so it's not a huge part of our school curriculum or an aspect of history I personally studied), but this book is definitely an excellent exploration of that time period. Nothing is overly explained, but there is very clear imagery about how status and race works. I loved Hiram's perspective on the Tasked (slaves) and Quality (the high-born whites who own slaves), and Hiram himself is a sympathetic and bright narrator, if sometimes naive or overly wishful.

That said, I sometimes stumbled upon the narration and prose. Coates can write beautifully, and there were many passages I found incredibly well-written - ideas about slavery and human nature laid bare in such devastating clarity. But there were simultaneously points that just lost me in the narrative, making me go back to reread in order to understand what was happening. The aspects of magical realism were also a bit lost on me; magical realism can be a hit or miss, and I don't quite think I connected with it here.

I am putting the book aside at about 60%, but with the hope of returning to it again in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I have read and enjoyed Mr. Coates’s essays for years. He is a powerful thinker and writer. Thanks to NetGalley and Random House for sending me an ARC of Mr. Coates’s first novel in exchange for an honest review.

The Water Dancer tells the story of Hiram, a slave (or a “Tasked”) who is the son of Rose, a slave, and her owner Howell Walker, the Master of Lockless, a slowly failing tobacco plantation in Virginia. Hiram has no memories of his mother, who was sold away years before the book opens. After an accident kills Maynard Walker, Howell’s legitimate son and Hiram’s half-brother, Hiram discovers he has a special power. Following Maynard’s death, Hiram escapes Virginia, joins the Underground, and eventually realizes what is most important to him, and how he wants to use his power and live his life.

Your mileage may vary on Hiram’s power, later labeled “conduction.” It is a bit of magical realism, and is pivotal to the plot. I got used to it as the story progressed, but I never quite got comfortable with it. I would also say it made the first chapter, which was a small flash forward where you are dropped into the scene of Maynard’s death, especially confusing.

Still, the writing is impeccable and evocative, sometimes grand and other times intimate. The themes raised within the story are familiar to a regular reader of Coates. The staggering accumulation of wealth permitted by slavery. The powerful importance of family history and stories. And that poor whites should be economically allied with blacks but were instead: “a degraded and downtrodden nation who endured the boot of the Quality, solely for the right to put a boot of their own to the Tasked.... [f]or all of us were low, we were all tasked, and we should be in union and arrayed against the Quality, if only the low whites would wager their crumbs for a slice of the whole cake.” Most of all, in a way I have not experienced before, The Water Dancer dramatizes the deliberate slavery-era plan of breaking up black families to keep slaves weak and disorganized, and illustrates the profound effects such cruelty had on those family members.

I expect Mr. Coates will reach a new audience with this novel. Hopefully some of those new readers will be motivated to seek out his other writings, especially The Case for Reparations. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Whoa what a journey! This book is definitely going to be making headlines and bestseller lists when it comes out. Hiram's story was heartbreaking and captivating at the same time. Coates' writing is beautiful and I do not know how he was able to convey a slaves life the way he did. I definitely will recommend this book to everyone.

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this wonderful book .

Was this review helpful?

This is not an easy book to read. Narrated by Hiram, the main character, a slave born to the white male owner of the plantation, Lockless and Rose, his slave mother. The author takes the reader into the life of the slave and tells us their fears, the longing of family and the every day struggles. It's not easy to read as you become involved in their lives and feel for them and the injustice of how slaves were treated and torn from their families.
Their hope comes from the Underground Railway and Ta-Nehisi Coates takes you there. As the reader, you see how hard it is to walk away from the only place you know and run toward freedom and a new way of life. The twist is the ability which Hiram and a few others are able to help others escape through Conduction.
It's beautifully written. The hope and help of those fighting for their freedom will never be forgotten.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book that I have read by this author and it will not be the last. This is a beautifully written story about a brutal time in history.

Very well done and these characters will stay with me for a very long time.

Many thanks to Netgalley and Random House Publishing Group - Random House for this advanced readers copy. The release date for this book is set for September 2019.

Was this review helpful?

An amazing treat to read, with the words flowing like leaves on a river. I think I was more captivated by the worss themselves than the story. However the story was steller as well and I can't wait to reread.

Was this review helpful?

I was immediately intrigued about 'The Water Dancer,' knowing how popular Ta-Nehisi Coates's last book was. The book began a little slow, but language and writing style is what kept me going- it was beautiful.

The book focuses on a young boy and his experience in slavery, as well as losing his mother. The topics are difficult to read, but necessary to understand the conditions for a large population of people within our history.

This is Coates's first novel, and I will look forward to anything else he writes. His writing was beautiful, as was the thread of magical realism drawn throughout. I have read a lot of books about slavery in the past, and the genre is not my favorite, nor is historical fiction, but it was definitely worth a read.

Was this review helpful?

I've known for years that Coates can write great nonfiction, and it turns out he writes fiction that is equally insightful and precise. Every sentence is a gem, so I had the pleasure of slowing down my reading to savor each one. Coates uses a sci-fi mechanism to explore life under slavery. Breaking the rules of our "known" world was a risky choice, in that it could have made the issue of slavery feel distant. Instead, his imaginative moves add to the vividness of the reader's experience. This book will make you think. It will make you feel. No matter who you are, it will teach you. I highly recommend this for individual reading and for book groups.

Was this review helpful?

In his boldly imagined first novel, Ta-Nehisi Coates, the National Book Award–winning author of Between the World and Me, brings home the most intimate evil of enslavement: the cleaving and separation of families.

This is the dramatic story of an atrocity inflicted on generations of women, men, and children—the violent and capricious separation of families—and the war they waged to simply make lives with the people they loved. Written by one of today's most exciting thinkers and writers, The Water Dancer is a propulsive, transcendent work that restores the humanity of those from whom everything was stolen.

This is the dramatic story of an atrocity inflicted on generations of women, men, and children—the violent and capricious separation of families—and the war they waged to simply make lives with the people they loved. Written by one of today's most exciting thinkers and writers, The Water Dancer is a propulsive, transcendent work that restores the humanity of those from whom everything was stolen.

Was this review helpful?

A thoughtful and powerful story about the rise of the Underground Railroad and the decline of the Virginia plantations. A beautifully written story infused with the power of memory to transport. A great read.

Was this review helpful?

“Slavery was the root of all struggle.”

Hiram Walker was born a slave on a Virginia plantation. Through this book, we follow the struggles of his journey growing up and his fight for freedom. This novel speaks to what a powerful and gifted storyteller the author is. The writing was beautiful and complex, and I really had to take my time to fully grasp all that was being said as each word was with purpose. I loved the development of characters and unfolding of the storyline. A good reminder of all the atrocities that occurred in times past, The Water Dancer was a touch magical and very remarkable.

Thank you to Random House Publishing and NetGalley for an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully written book contrasting mans inhumanity to man through slavery and the love and selflessness of many to fight this in secret. Hiram Walker, is an intelligent slave boy with an amazing memory. His mother is a slave who is sold away from him when he is a young child. His father is the master of the plantation. Through his experiences, the reader learns of the horrific treatment of slaves but also the lives they lead in their private slave community.

Hiram decides to runaway and though he initially fails, he ultimately is inducted into the secret Underground helping slaves to escape. It is fascinating to understand the strategy and capabilities of different components of the Underground movement. Hiram has special powers which he must learn to use in order to help those he loves. Their is some of magical realism in this book but it flows so well.

I highly recommend this book. and truly enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Hiram was born into slavery. And although he was robbed of the chance to know his mother, she left him a great gift. It's a power that he struggles to understand, but when he joins the Underground Railroad, he learns how valuable it truly is. This is a haunting tale of memory, family, and the lasting damage done by slavery.

This is such a powerful story, and the "Conduction" element of the story is a really interesting and unique mechanism. Honestly, I prefer Coates' non-fiction. Some of the dialogue and pacing were tough for me here. But overall, a very unique and interesting take on slavery and shared memory.

Was this review helpful?