This one took me a while to get into , because I had no idea it was part of a series , with that said this is one of those series you have to read from the book 1 and on word to understand what it going on.

To imply Special Agent Jason West is a bit of a basket case means you must know him intimately—much like Chief Sam Kennedy does. He knows that the stalker who has been threatening Jason is still out there and the fact that he can’t always be with Sam is frustrating them both. As diligent as Jason may be, too much casual drinking and late nights that are interrupted by recurring nightmares have begun to wear him down. His latest case is only adding to his already overtaxed mind. There has been a discovery of a hidden cache of World War II treasure that includes a rare Vermeer.

This isn’t necessarily a new thing as Jason has seen various stolen antiquities surface before. This case, however, is complicated by two things. First, the deceased man in question has left the trove of priceless works of art to his family who swears they don’t have them. Secondly, the guy who “liberated” the treasure was under the authority of Lieutenant Commander Emerson Harley, Jason’s beloved grandfather. Since both the thief and his grandfather are deceased, it’s imperative that Jason do everything to clear his grandfather’s name of any hint of wrongdoing. The problem is it goes directly against FBI rules for Jason to head up an investigation where he obviously may have a compromised view of who the criminals really are. So now Jason is hiding from his stalker, from his boss, and even from Sam, the man he loves. He must see this case through, but that could mean the end of his FBI career and of his relationship with Sam.

West and Kennedy are back in the fourth installment of Josh Lanyon’s Art of Murder series. Before I proceed, I must caution you these are not standalone novels; they should be read in order to not only understand the line of work Jason is in, but also his tumultuous relationship with Sam Kennedy. For those who have read the first three books, you are aware that Sam and Jason have finally admitted they love each other and are trying their best to keep a long-distance relationship alive. While this book doesn’t end on a cliffhanger, per se, if you know Sam and Jason’s history, it won’t surprise you to know that all is not wine and roses for these guys despite their attempts to stay together. If the stalker isn’t trying to kill poor Jason, then the FBI handbook and Sam’s rather rigid view of how others, except himself, should follow the rules laid out in it to the last detail is sparking some friction between he and Jason.

This time Jason has a vested interest in the case he is working on and has pretty much crossed a line he knows might get him into some pretty big trouble. Between the interesting twists and turns this mystery takes, Sam’s minor sexual fling showing up and trying to wrangle a way onto his team, and Jason’s fears of discovering the grandfather he respected and worshipped may have looked the other way and okayed some war time looting, this novel kept me riveted. Once again, this author uses murder, a bit of mayhem, and fiery sexual tension to craft a story that I wanted to start rereading as soon as I got to the end.

Josh Lanyon is the queen of nuance and a master at building a story to an often shocking climactic ending. When you couple that with this rather tortured love affair between Sam and Jason, you have a recipe for a fantastic murder mystery romance that definitely satisfies. Honestly, waiting several more months to a year for the next installment is kind of killing me already. This was a good, good read—the classic Lanyon I have grown to love.

If you haven’t yet picked up this series, I encourage you to do so. If you’re ready for this latest book, I will say that I highly recommend this one—it was entertaining from beginning to end.

The Monuments Men Murders was a wonderful reminder of everything I love about Josh Lanyon. It brought me back home. The mystery was so good. I was completely invested in every aspect of it, but what really sold the plot was all the art history. I was fascinated by Verneer, and I wanted to see the art so I could understand just how important the lose was.

I also loved coming back to Sam and Jason. When the series first started I wasn’t sure if I felt any actual chemistry between these two men. That instant electricity was something I’d come to appreciate about Josh Lanyon books, and with Sam and Jason I didn’t feel anything. Today, finishing The Monuments Men Murders, I felt it. I smiled, and swooned, and fell crazy in love with these agents and the balancing act their walking between their love and their careers.

With one book I’ve been reeled right back in, and I can’t wait for what’s next.

I can always count on Josh Lanyon for an interesting, well developed plot, intelligent dialogue, and amazing chemistry between her main characters. The Monuments Men Murders does not disappoint. All of the cases surrounding the Art Crimes Division have been wonderful, and I really enjoyed the story of missing art stolen by the Nazis.

The ongoing relationship between BAU Chief Sam Kennedy and Art Crimes FBI Agent Jason West is at a stable place when the story opens. What happens to cause their discord in Monument Men Murders is a fantastic twist, and gives those on Team Sam even more ammunition! In his defense, Jason has important reasons for doing what he does, and as the captain of Team Jason I’m still going to bat for Jason’s motives.

Sometimes these two men are just such opposites that it’s hard for them to find common ground. Plus the differences in the lives they’ve led and their age gap just have them approaching every situation so differently. Having the whole series from Jason’s point of view, it feels to me that Jason is making all of the concessions (and I think he is). If you agree with me, you’re going to love the way this one ends!

A complimentary copy was provide via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

First, you have GOT to be kidding me with that ending!!!! JL, we've talked about this. Well, I've talked about it. 😊 These endings are not allowed. How am I supposed to wait for a year to read the next book? I hate it when my men are not happy. I am totally emotionally invested in these fictional characters and I love it.

5 star read for sure and I highly recommend. This is not a standalone and must be read in order. Oh how I wish this never ended and how I wish I knew these guys if only to console them and knock them on the head, lol.

Murder, mystery, lost treasure, romance, long distance relationships, two strong men who love each other and are navigating their way they in a relationship that is still new to them. They've never had a relationship like this before and it's hard. I was so upset when the thing happened. I wasn't sure what JL was going to leave me with. Sure they are in the same room when it ends but they are not back to where they were.

Love really screws with reason and logic. Toss in a stressful job and both working hard cases, it's ripe for drama. Jason is working a case that involves his deceased grandfather. He is also still getting over the trauma of Dr. Kyser from the last story. Sprinkle in a family who will do anything to keep looted Nazi treasure, including murder, and Jason is beyond stressed. And Sam, when is he not stressed? Same old same old with Sam. But then he learns that Jason is essentially lying about the case with his grandfather, and I am surprised Sam didn't have a stroke.

I don't really want to say too much about what actually happens plot wise because that will ruin the suspense.

I am addicted to JL and this series. I am so in love with Jason and Sam and really hope the series continues for a long time. The amount of research JL did to make this story real is astounding. How is she not living on a mountain with people pilgrimaging to bring her gifts and services daily? She is a GOD!!!! And the sooner people recognize this the sooner she will have mercy and write more, write faster and grace us with her presence as she bestows upon us those gifts. 😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘

In case you missed it I am a super fan of JLs. Don't make me wait until 2020!!!

In all honesty, I think this was my favorite book in the series and it certainly bounced back from The Magician Murders, which was my least favorite of the series thus far. We saw so much more of Sam and Jason together in The Monuments Men Murders, even if they were not always seeing eye to eye. I like watching this careful, uncertain dance between Sam and Jason. They are so very different from one another, and, yet, they have a connection that is undeniable. Kennedy is slowly seeming to realize his own humanity. It is an interesting journey for him. I think he finally realized in this book that Jason is capable of walking away from him and his rigid, unyielding approach to life and relationships. I think the only thing Sam Kennedy truly fears is losing Jason West, and in The Monuments Men Murders that fear came close to being realized. I look forward to Lanyon exploring this aspect of the relationship in future books in this series, and I would love to someday read a scene from Kennedy’s POV.

Another aspect of this story that I really enjoyed was the investigation into the stolen artwork with its ties to World War II and the Nazi pillaging of so much of the world’s priceless art. Unlike the previous books, this investigation was truly near and dear to Jason’s heart and would have been even without the accusation against his grandfather. His passion for not only recovering but wanting to return the stolen collection to its rightful owners really came through. I even liked his continuing partnership with J.J. Russell. I think it will be fun to see them paired together in future books.

That being said, this book was over in a flash. I felt as if I finished reading it in the blink of an eye. Jason’s discovery and the wrapping up of the case was very rushed. The end came far too soon. I was rather surprised to turn the page just to discover a note that read, "Jason West and Sam Kennedy will return Winter 2020.” I certainly hope that means January 2020 and not December 2020. I don’t want to wait so long for my favorite Lanyon couple to return. I hope in book five we see more of Jason and Sam together, and more of Sam opening up and letting his guard down a bit.

4 stars !

It's been a minute since I read a book with these men in it but I had no problem falling back into their world.

I am no expert in art and most talk about it goes over my head. BUT I find myself interested in the mysteries JL creates around the subject. I was really invested in this mystery since Jason has a personal interest in the case because it involves his grandpa. The characters/suspects were quite interesting as well. I especially liked the older gentlemen who was the decease's friend. He sure knew how to not answer a question.

My issues with the book came with the lack of time we got with Jason and Sam being together. They were literally on page together a handful of times and I just needed more depth and growth. I wanted to see them be on a deeper level. The ending did make up for some of it. Still, I needed more.

The wait for the final book is such a long wait. Brutal.

Happy reading dolls! xx


I was given an ARC in exchange for an honest review by Netgalley and the publisher.

I haven't read all the books in this series, but I definetly think I need to go back and do so! Lanyon does a good mystery, and this was no exception. The characters are relatable and interesting. Sam seemed a bit cold at times but it was easy for me to see why. All in all definetly recommended!

This is, surprising to me at least, becoming one of my favorite Lanyon series. It started slowly for me. But with each new book, and with bit of Sam Kennedy chipping away as he falls deeper for Jason West, I am loving each. And with the every present fear of Jeremy Kyser lurking around, I’m drawn to every twist and turn that happens in these books. And damn, is Lanyon a MASTER with research. Every painstaking detail had me in awe, to be honest.

BTW, the last chapter, the last exchange between Sam and West had me crying. My heart may not recover. I need the next book immediately.

I definitely enjoyed this and would give it a solid 4 stars.

What I liked:
~ Jason's narrative -- I found him sympathetic and likable, and I loved all the art enthusiasm and history shared.
~ the secondary characters -- they were interesting and kept me engaged in the story and plot.
~ the setting -- although not as present as it could have been, I still liked the overall approach to Bozwin, MT, and I liked spending time there.

What wasn't quite as strong:
~ Sam -- he seemed distant and hard to understand, at times. I especially found his reaction to Jason's work a little extreme. Granted, this is the first of this series that I've read, so it's definitely possible that the previous three would have strengthened my understanding of him, but I did find some of his actions/reactions over the top.
~ the murder-mystery aspect -- I enjoyed the mystery, definitely, but the murder part seemed almost tacked on as an afterthought, and it didn't have the intensity of the rest of the plot.

Still, I enjoyed it and will definitely look for the next one (coming out next year)!

...."there was not one ounce of superfluous flesh on Sam
Kennedy’s body. He ran every day, rain or shine, boxed,
lifted weights, and worked out regularly. He watched his
diet, did not smoke, and only drank to excess on
weekends—which he rarely took, so that was moot.”

Yes! The drool worthy Sam Kennedy is back in this fourth book of the Art of Murder series. This is another solid mystery with two gritty main characters, Sam Kennedy and Jason West.

Jason is trying to solve another art crime which involves artwork that was stolen by soldiers during WW2. This isn't a simple case of artifacts gone missing, his deceased grandfather is also implicated in this crime and Jason knows that his grandfather would never have allowed the soldiers under his command to steal the artwork they should have been protecting.

Jason knows he is too close to the case and he shouldn't be investigating it but he doesn't trust that anyone else will be driven to investigate it in the same way he would. Jason's old enemy Kyser has disappeared and this is yet another pressure on him but he finds comfort in Sam and it seems Sam feel the same way about Jason

“I like to look at you,” he said simply. “I like to look in your eyes, I like to see your face. You’re very expressive, and that’s…enjoyable.”

Sam is still very much Sam with his no-nonsense, "my way is the right way," approach to solving crime. The two men feel for each other deeply and have managed to sustain their long distance relationship but they still find themselves clashing with each other and wondering if they can make it last especially when it comes to their work.

Their road to love is definitely not a smooth one and with a psycho stalker still on the loose and crimes to solve it was never going to be easy.

One of the reasons I like this series is the maturity of the relationship between the two men. Jason is very expressive and deep with his emotions, while Sam comes across as very formal and not given to much emotional expression. Sam's emotions are held beneath a tough exterior but when he is together with Jason the emotions emerge in his actions and speech.

Both men recognise the challenge of their long distance relationship and their differences in personality but do they have enough love between them to make it work?

In the midst of all the relationship challenges is a mystery about stolen art and Jason makes some decisions that could compromise him. I am not really an arty person but I enjoyed reading this. There are so many interesting aspect to the story - art crimes, murder, mystery, love, professional ethics and the shadow of past loves. It makes it a gritty read which is just how I like my mysteries. Roll on to the next episode!

Copy provided by JustJoshin Publications via Netgalley in exchange for an unbiased review.

Lanyon gives us a compelling story here, combining the mystery of Nazi-plundered art treasures (and the possibility that Jason's beloved grandfather was involved in illegal theft) with the continuing arc of Jason and Sam's relationship. Jason is passionate about proving that his grandfather had nothing to do with the misappropriation of a Vermeer painting worth millions and he is willing to flaunt FBI rules and regulations to do so.

Jason's adamant misguided insistence in lying made me <i>crazy</i>, (and I spent far too much time yelling at my Kindle). Jason has always been committed to his career, so it seemed somewhat disingenuous when, after finally coming clean to Sam about his connection to the case, Jason is stunned to realize he has potentially destroyed their relationship and his career. Also the vague subplot about SA Travis Petty and his past with Sam and Jason's jealousy felt a bit contrived.

But as always, the best part of an Art of Murder series book is how Jason and Sam manage to make their relationship work, and by the end of the book, I was already looking forward to the next book in the series and seeing how Jason and Sam are meshing their lives together. Another great read from Josh Lanyon. 4.5 stars.

I have enjoyed this series so much. Jason and Sam are one of my favorite Lanyon couples and they have a lot of stuff to work out in this book. Jason is investigating a crime that his late grandfather may have been involved in. He hasn’t told anyone his connection to the case because he knows he’ll be taken off of it right away but he doesn’t think anyone else can handle it.

Sam is in the same town as Jason tying up a case with a team he previously worked with. One of the agents working with Sam is a past lover. Jason feels insecure because there are uncertainties in their relationship. Sam never wanted to be serious with anyone, he’s married to his job. Jason knows he would love more with Sam but he doesn’t know how that would work out. He understands Sam’s work comes before him but the longer the relationship moves on feelings will always be involved. The relationship angst in this was so good! It added a depth to the relationship part of the story. What Jason and Sam have has never been the typical relationship and this book tested them majorly and not only because of a past lover.

This ends abruptly but there is a bonus on the authors Patreon page. There is still much left in the air and it seems we have quite a wait for the continuation.

This is classic Josh Lanyon at her finest.

This is a great addition to The Art of Murder series (though I recommend that they be read in order). The mystery is engaging and even the secondary characters are well-developed. The focus, though, is on Jason and Sam's relationship: where it's going (or not), how to maintain it (or not) long distance, and how Jason's current investigation has the potential to negatively impact it (or not). And, as always, I learned a heck of a lot about art just by reading the book (Lanyon puts an impressive amount of research into her work).

Recommended to anyone who loves murder mysteries, M/M romance, and/or the history of European art. -- lyradora

Rating: 5 stars out of 5

Someone is watching. Someone is waiting.

Despite having attracted the attention of a dangerous stalker, Special Agent Jason West is doing his best to keep his mind on his job and off his own troubles.

But his latest case implicates one of the original Monuments Men in the theft and perhaps destruction of part of the world's cultural heritage--a lost painting by Vermeer. Naval Reserve Lieutenant Commander Emerson Harley wasn't just a World War 2 hero, he was the grandfather Jason grew up idolizing. In fact, Grandpa Harley was a large part of what inspired Jason to join the FBI's Art Crime Team.

Learning that his legendary grandfather might have turned a blind eye to American GIs "liberating" priceless art treasures at the end of the war is more than disturbing. It's devastating.

Jason is determined to clear his grandfather's name, even if that means breaking a few rules and regulations himself--putting him on a collision course with romantic partner BAU Chief Sam Kennedy.

Meanwhile, someone in the shadows is biding his time...

When it comes to men and their romances, Josh Lanyon has managed to write some incredibly complex and psychologically convoluted relationships.   Whether it's the brilliance of The Adrien English Mysteries and the long twisted road that Adrian English and Jake Riordan took to happiness or perhaps her Holmes & Moriarity  series with its deep levels of mixed ties professional  of authorship and personal relationships intertwined to confuse and befuddle its two main protagonists, you can count on a story that is both haunting and gripping to the end.

So it continues to be with The Art of Murder series and the tortured relationship between Special Agent Jason West and BAU Chief Sam Kennedy.  Always strained by their own past histories and by the long distance between their offices, the latest attack by Jason's stalker has put additional pressures on Jason's mentally and emotionally.  He's missing his partner's support although he won't admit it.  The constant threat to his safety is imperiling his health, he's not sleeping.  And Lanyon makes us feel every second, every minute of West's anxiety and fear.

For me this series runs neck and neck with Adrian English with its couple and labyrinthine path to any sort of happiness.  And we are only at book four.  Lanyon just demonstrates a consistent excellence in character development, depth of storyline, and overall arc that showcases her prowess as an author.  These are not easy men but hard, articulate, intelligent men in demanding jobs that take them around the country or all over the world in some cases.  It puts them in danger, and has cost them highly in emotional terms. Especially one.    They have hugely different (and by now well known to the readers) back histories that contribute sometimes to their difficulties in their relationship.  Everything they argue about, try to work through is grounded in something authentic and real. So we as readers bleed emotionally with them when they hurt in these times.  And they are many considering who they are and what they are going through.

Which is a series theme with a truly evil stalker for West.  This is one thread that is chilling in more ways than one.  As it's been playing out, its psychologically physically, and emotionally scary.  After that is a mystery/murder per novel that is enthralling.  Often involving artwork which brings in Jason, then a murder which will involve Sam.  Somewhere all will overlap in a mentally challenging narrative that will have you glued to the page until it's all done.

Like it did here.  Where it looked to tear my heart out right up to the last sentence.

Where it teetered on the brink of despair and barely brought it back again.  Just barely.  Oh these men.

Stories and series like this is one of the reasons I read   They aren't easy but they keep you thinking, your mind and heart are always alert for what's coming next.  And you never see it when it hits you.

So amazing.  Lanyon can't write them fast enough for me.  I need the next one now.

If you aren't familiar with this series.  I have listed them all for you below.  Read them in the order they were written.  Then this amazing novel next.  I highly recommend them all for those looking for contemporary romances with adult long paths to happiness and mysteries too.  Trust me, just brilliant.

Cover art works for the storyline and to draw your eye to the book. Great job.

Sales Links:  Amazon | GooglePlay | Kobo

Book Details:

Kindle Edition, 199 pages
Published June 30th 2019 by JustJoshin Publishing, Inc.
ASINB07R818GZ9
Edition Language English
Series The Art of Murder #4

The Art of Murder Series

The Mermaid Murders

The Monet Murders

The Magician Murders

The Monuments Men Murders

The Movie-Town Murders winter 2020 smh!

Oh, this was FAN-TAS-TIC!

The mystery was, as always with Lanyon, one that keeps you engaged until the end, but this time it felt even more urgent, as it was deeply entangled with Jason's life. And the resolution? Brilliant! Totally unexpected.

Now regarding Jason and Sam... *deep sigh* Let's first come clean: Jason is my favourite. I admire Sam, he's focused and driven, but he wouldn't be my first choice, not even as a friend. He's too... emotional challenged? Closed off? Stand-offish? Nevertheless, he is a great character, ideal for conflict :P

And boy, does he generate conflict here! I understand why he reacts as he does, but that doesn't mean that I justify it. Jason goes to him for help, and he leaves him hanging :/ And the whole Petty thing? Is he really so blind to Jason's feelings?

And yes, Sam does grovel. A bit. When Jason walks away. But I'm afraid that as Sam himself says, he will hurt Jason again.

In a lighter note, I loved JJ and Jason bonding over their utter disbelief at their significant others loving the idea of living in Montana :P

Also, I will never look at pigeons in the same way ever again :P

4* Satisfying, intelligent and believable murder-mystery but unsatisfying 'romance', which...

... isn't new for me with JL.

I think I need to consider Josh Lanyon tales as having a side of almost-romance to be able to enjoy them at their best. This tale is actually really decent, with a proper mystery, some characters I was interested in and an outcome that I had suspicions about, but for me as a reader of romance, primarily, it was more than a little lacking on the romance front.

I did like Sam (who reminded me of Sam Kage from Mary Calmes's Sam/Jory tales) and Jason, but they seemed to both have agendas of their own, and seemed to be icebergs - they kept too much below the surface and it seemed as if each expected the other to know what was inside them deep down, e.g. feelings, being on the same side, but it didn't feel like trust was a thing between them. It also felt as if they put their relationship last of several things, the first of which was their jobs. And, possibly issues they'd had in previous relationships lingered, resonated unconsciously - a guy called Ethan was mentioned at the end, as if he were the reason for Sam's behaviour. I may be doing the leads an injustice, as I've not read the previous tales in the series, but I had enough of these guys' measure from this book, and from the JL series, All's Fair, as the characters from the latter reminded me of the guys here and their personal issues that became obstacles. Am I tarring Sam and Jason and JL unfairly? Perhaps, but I don't mean to be. I did appreciate this book, very much so, and I would like to read the previous and future tales with these guys, as there's an intelligence about the leads and the tale that I don't often get to enjoy in MM, but, on the romance front, I think I either need to accept that that's perhaps not as important to the leads or to the author, or maybe not count on a romance from JL, and that way, if there is one, it's a bonus?

Back to the murder-mystery: I got a bit of an education re Monument Men, and yes, I ended up checking out more than was in this tale. I thought all the elements to the tale gelled pretty well, though the shooting at the start and the connection to a certain person, didn't get adequately explained for me. I think this person was in over their head, had allowed someone to influence them, creating a precedent of sorts, and I think the shooting was supposed to be him taking care of unfortunate business, but events preceded their arrival. I can't say much more or it'd spoiler what's a decent, intelligent read, which I did enjoy.

I did find confusing the inclusion of the Petty character, who kind of had a bit part and possibly was used as a red herring, as things didn't really go anywhere. And, to have Jason partnered with someone called J.J, who was also then called Russell, and for both the latter's names to be used was also confusing. Why is that a thing with authors, to use characters with names starting with the same initials? It can cause things to be misdirected or even bogged down whilst I wonder who's who. But, maybe that's just a personal bugbear.

Overall, this was an excellent read and it's a pity that there's about a 15-month wait for the next - at the end, there's mention that book 5 will be out in Winter 2020.

ARC courtesy of the author/JustJoshing Publishing Inc, and NetGalley, for my reading pleasure.

(I will be adding this book review to Amazon as well.)

Excellent work here from Lanyon. I liked it much better than the previous book, "The Magician Murders," which I found cheesy.... at least the mystery part was.

In Monuments Men, FBI agent Jason West is investigating a family in Montana whose now-deceased relative fought in WW2 and may have stolen some precious art from Engelshofen Castle in Bavaria at the end of the war, including a long-lost Vermeer. Jason thinks the family might still have the art stashed away somewhere. A Dutch art expert accompanies Jason and his partner, JJ Russell, to the interviews. The family deny everything. Yet Jason is conflicted here because his own grandfather was head of the Art team onsite in Bavaria; he fears his grandpa might have been involved somehow and wants to clear his name, or at least do damage control.

Meanwhile, the relationship between Sam and Jason smoulders. And that's really what I was reading the book for. I have to admit the mystery went out of focus for me and remained somewhat in the background the whole time, though I liked the dramatic climax.

The pacing is great here. The plot crackles along. Jason yearns for Sam, who is there but somehow absent, in his own Sam-like way. There is a phone-sex scene early in the book, then an intense sex scene, and finally, at the end, after Jason and Sam have fallen out over the case, a very realistic reconciliation scene. Realistic because Jason and Sam now seem equal in power, and it's Sam who has to come to the table, apologize, and rescue the relationship.

And Jeremy Kyser is still lurking out there somewhere!

I liked Jason's ballsiness in this book. At one point he asks Sam sarcastically if he wants him to give back the ring. (There was no ring, the following paragraph makes clear; they have never made any promises.) The lack of sentimentality suits these two men. Finally, Sam is making strides towards Jason, but the relationship is still somewhat raw and painful here, and probably always will be. The stakes are high. I'll keep reading!

Is it just me or do Josh Lanyon’s recent books feel like she’s just going through the motions? I wasn’t too impressed with book three in the series already- it was too short and was rushed at times - but it still wasn’t as wooden and unimpressive as this book. I was shocked by how bad the first twenty percent were - it was as if most of it consisted of descriptions of people’s looks and scenery, interspersed with short and blunt sentences that lacked any kind of elegance. I actually stopped and looked at a different book to make sure it wasn’t just me. The crime plot here is ridiculous and unconvincing, the murder was absolutely unnecessary for the book and the only thing that made it not a complete waste of time was the bit of Sam and Jason at the end. But even their interactions were only shadows of what they were like in books one and two. I know it’s presumptive to make assumptions about an author’s feelings, but this read like she had to force out every single sentence and didn’t have much fun writing this book. Maybe she should have made it a three book series rather than five (or more? But I seriously hope she stops after the next one.) I won’t buy another book by her that isn’t in this series, but I do want closure for Sam and Jason.

3.75 stars

I have loved reading about Jason and Sam since the very first book, and this book was no different. I adored the little moments between Sam and Jason, which don't seem like much, but are so poignant, heartfelt, and touching. However, in this one more than the others, probably because Jason and Sam weren't working together on a single case and the case overpowered the story, I felt like their relationship was very minor compared to the mystery. This plus the complication near the end made me almost lose patience with the hot and cold treatment that Sam is now known for, but I loved his speech at the end and honestly, I could see his perspective, so I forgave him for it :)
I thought it was awesome that J.J. and Jason are becoming closer and better partners and I enjoyed the development of their relationship. The author also does a great job building suspense for Jeremy Kyser, and I cannot wait for the resolution!

I received an ARC of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review