Cover Image: When She Returned

When She Returned

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I was eager to read When She Returned, so I was super excited when I got the chance! I have only recently discovered Lucinda Berry, but so far she has not disappointed. For me, When she returned was a page-turner from the very first page! I liked the story-line and the characters felt real to me. I am definitely going to be reading other books from Lucinda Berry!

Was this review helpful?

When She Returned by Lucinda Berry is a gripping read that pulled me in immediately with its intriguing premise. Having read the author's previous novel, I was more than anxious to devour this one, and it did not disappoint.

Kate Bennett has been missing for eleven years, presumably having been abducted from a Target parking lot, leaving behind a husband, Scott, and five year old daughter, Abbi. The family is left devastated, but Scott eventually remarries and life moves on. But when Kate turns up at a gas station with an infant in tow and begging for help, the lives of everyone in the family are thrown into turmoil, and no one is entirely sure whom they can trust.

The novel effectively moves between 'then' and 'now', and is told from various points of view. Kate's time away from her family is chronicled in her own voice and is well fleshed out and wonderfully frustrating. I must admit that I found the ending to be extremely satisfying.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Kate and Scott had an enviable life once— that is, until she vanished into thin air, leaving all of her belongings in the car and her loving family at home. Over a decade later, after she's been declared dead and Scott has been remarried to a fellow widow- Kate's found terrified, pleading for help with a seven month old infant in her arms. Now everybody's life is turned upside down and the secrets begin unraveling..

When She Returned is a psychological thriller written by an actual psychologist, which is what ultimately drew me in. Surely if anybody can write a psychological thriller, it's somebody who underwent years of schooling to understand the human mind and behaviour. Right?

I have to admit: I skimmed over the "Then" sections out of pure boredom. They were jam-packed with useless dialogue and seemed kind of.... filler-ish. As if Lucinda Berry had a word goal, and those chapters were dedicated to meeting it. The cult itself was incredibly underdeveloped and underwhelming, and the ending was, too. I saw that plot twist coming from a mile away.

I absolutely adored Meredith— and her sons, I suppose, though we don't see much of them. She was incredibly patient and understanding, even with her husband doting on another woman, and even with everybody snapping at her all the time. I guess I liked Abbi, too, since I could understand her excitement at finally meeting her mum and making memories with her once and for all. But you know who I pretty much always disliked? Scott. Meredith really deserves better.

Overall, and even if some parts are predictable or frustrating, I enjoyed this book. If you're looking for a short thriller, try this one out!

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing me with a copy of this title in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Gripping from the first word. Love her writing style in that the story is told from different characters point of view. This is my second novel by this author. Started it immediately after finishing Saving Noah. Can't get enough of this author right now

Was this review helpful?

I abandoned the book after the half. It wasn't my kind of book, I failed to connect with the characters and the story itself, although the premise sounded promising, was somehow flat and unreal.
I look at the other reviews and guess I missed something - but I always agree with Simone Beauvoir: not every book is for everyone, and that doesn't mean it's a bad book - it just doesn't fit. Therefore I never drag along if I'm sure that a book and me won't ever fit.

I'm sorry but yet want to thank the publisher and Netgalley for providing a copy!

Was this review helpful?

This book was great. There were so many twists and turns that it kept me roped in. I love this author and her other books are amazing as well. This lived up to the expectation

Was this review helpful?

Wow! It took me a while to get into this story but once I did - WOW! I couldn't put it down. I was disappointed with the ending - I felt it abruptly ended. But I would recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

When She Return is a great book that hooked me from the first chapter. I could not put it down. Well written and interesting characters.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my gosh! What a roller coaster ride!! This book grabbed me from the very beginning and did not let go until the final sentence!! What a wonderfully disturbing psychological thriller!! So many twists and turns, my jaw just kept dropping!! Awesome character development. Rich with domestic/cult type drama that kept me so engaged I could not put it down. Highly recommend!
Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

Scott and Kate Bennett seemed to have a fairytale story- they had met as children and always known they were meant to be. At least that is Scott’s story. Kate on the other hand is chafing under an existence that never changes and is thrilled to be back to work as a reporter though she loves her 5 year old daughter Abbi. One of Kate’s assignments upon her return is to investigate a group that is helping people with addictions without asking anything in return called Love International. The interview with the founder Ray Fischer intrugues her and she keeps visiting long after the assignment is finished.
A few weeks later while on a grocery shopping errand, Kate disappears- her keys, purse and shopping bags still in the car.

Eleven years later Kate is found in a gas station with a newborn daughter asking for help.
Scott spent years of his life devoted to finding Kate but after joining a support group, met Meredith and married her.
They are shocked to get the call about Kate.

This was an easy, quick read but somehow not quite satisfying. The interactions between the characters did not feel natural or real. Abbi at age 15 demanding that she be included in every conversation and refusing to respect boundaries really stuck out. The situation with the two wives in one house with a husband who obviously never got over the first wife was the most hard to swallow.
This is a good summer read for those of us who want a quick story that does not require a notepad to keep track of characters.
Thank you to #netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy in exchange for my opinion.

Was this review helpful?

This is another excellent book by Dr. Berry. I highly enjoyed this thriller and it is very well-written.

Was this review helpful?

I am a big fan of Lucinda Berry. This book did not disappoint. Very good storyline that keeps you glued to the book until t he end.

Thank you for allowing me to read this book!

Was this review helpful?

"We wanted to see if what we had was powerful enough to make someone give up the love they had for something greater."
That quote sums up this book pretty well. A mother gives up her family (willingly or not? read to find out) and then escapes and returns 10 years later after her daughter has grown into a teenager and her husband has buried her and remarried.

The book blurb hinted at a cult being involved in this story and I fucking love cult stories so I requested this. A cult is involved and that's half of the story, but the cult wasn't clearly defined. Maybe I just read too much and so I was underwhelmed by the culty bits because they followed a clear cult script and there wasn't anything new. A reader not as familiar with cults may find this more exciting.

The toher half of the book that's not cult bits was family drama and that was more interesting, but could have been so much better. I wanted more perspective from Meredith (the new wife) on her husband's first wife's return from the dead.

I saw the ending coming and *shrug*. A good fluff book to read if you're on an airplane or commuting and need a little distraction, but don't want to think too much.

2.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Kate Bennett is a part-time journalist and mom who disappears from a parking lot, but returns with an infant at a gas station eleven years later. Her husband Scott, his second wife Meredith, and Abbi, Kate and Scott’s now-sixteen-year-old daughter, all reel with her sudden reappearance and try to coax some information out of a traumatized Kate. The book is told in “then” vs. “now” perspectives, with Kate telling the “then” story and Abbi and Meredith telling the “now”. As the story unfolds, you get more and more insight into what happened the night Kate disappeared, and how the family and the FBI are trying to get Kate to talk.

While I found the story to be thrilling, there were parts of the story that felt out of place and actions that seemed out of character for some of the people in the book. Lucinda Berry does a great job in characterizing Abbi and Meredith, but when reading Kate’s section, it seemed forced. I did find myself continuing reading because the pacing is excellent and the suspense is kept until the very end, but the ending was too much of an “out-there” twist for me to like it personally. I did enjoy reading it and would recommend it to those who like a quick thriller read.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley. Thank you to Thomas & Mercer and to Lucinda Berry.

Was this review helpful?

This is the first book I've read by this author. Before I even finished, I was already on amazon looking at (and downloading) some of her other books.

I enjoyed the story, even if some parts were predictable. If you are looking for an enteratining, fast read ... this is for you.

Thank you #netgalley and #Thomas & Mercer for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?

I just cannot get into the whole cult thing in books. The suspense started out really good and drew me in. But once the cult concept was introduced I ended up skimming. The ending was great though! I have loved her other books so will continue to read her work

Was this review helpful?

Loved this book!

I loved the premise. A woman goes missing, is declared dead and returns years later.

I loved the alternating view points - the missing woman, the new wife and the daughter take turns telling their side of the story. I am a sucker for a book with alternating viewpoints, and I loved these characters. Their thoughts and actions rang true. Did I agree with everyone? No, but their actions rang true to who they seemed to be.

Not only did we have alternating viewpoint,s but we have different timelines. We slowly see what happened to her as we see how everyone deals with her return.

I loved the twists. I thought I knew where this was going, but I was wrong. Then I thought I had it figured out again and I was in for another surprise.

I loved the writing. I was engrossed in this book and it kept me saying the magic words in the book world "just one more chapter". I lost a bit of sleep since I needed to know what happened next.

I received this as an advance copy from #netgalley and this did not affect my review. I can prove it by now going to see if this author wrote anything else. (Did I mention that I loved this book?)

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for this wonder ARC.

The scene started out like a picture in motion. Kate who has been missing for eleven years has finally escaped her captor. This twisted road she has to travel when returning home to find her husband, Scott, remarried and a daughter, Abbi, who barely remembered her. As well as with a new baby in her arms.
As the FBI and professionals started to questions Kate as to what happened eleven years ago and what type of situation she has been in, the story unfold to a more frightening than what is possible.
Was Kate really kidnapped? Who is this baby? What type of danger are they all in now?
Luncida Berry explored a story of survival, deception, and the impossible. This doesn't read like fiction but more of base on a true story.

Was this review helpful?

Things have come undone.........

Lucinda Berry presents a storyline that has the feel of shifting sand under your feet. Can't quite get the balance of it all. Can't quite get a handle on those ships that set sail in these choppy waters.

Kate Bennett is a stay-at-home mother of five year old Abbi in Northern California. The "stay-at-home" portion seems to be driven by her husband, Scott. Kate longs to be back in her journalism lane free from what she perceives are deadend walls all day.

Her former boss calls with an assignment that gets the juices flowing once again. Kate is to interview the head of Love International which is based out of Pierce College. The organization focuses on helping college students who are battling opioid addiction. The interview with Ray Fischer seems to go well along with her boss' approval. It appears that Kate has her foot in the door once again.

But a few weeks later, Kate's car is found in a Target's parking lot. Her keys are in the ignition, handbag on the seat, and shopping bags in the trunk. Absolutely no sign of Kate.

Lucinda Berry fast forwards to eleven years later entitled "Now". Abbi is sixteen and Scott is remarried to a widow named Meredith who has two college aged sons. The quiet suburbia setting is in for a nightmare though. Kate shows up terrified at a gas station in Montana with a baby in tow. The upcoming weeks will find this disjointed family living under one roof trying to piece together Kate's missing years. Traumatized and anxious, Kate refuses to give much information under the scrutiny of the FBI and stress counseling. The chapters will revert to "Then" in which Kate's story slowly takes on a face.

One would think that we have a blockbuster here. Not so fast. What starts out as a high-interest storyline begins to sink under the weight of the "Then" aspect. Without giving away anything more, we have a grown woman acting like a teenage runaway. Everything is built on this premise with the end result falling apart like a Jenga game. So much unnecessary dialogue and elaborate explanations while in "Thenville". A shot of energy at the end was not enough to save this one for me. You may have an entirely different experience from mine. Check it out and see.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley for an honest review. My thanks to Thomas & Mercer and to Lucinda Berry for the opportunity.

Was this review helpful?

This book was incredible.. The story was intense an engrossing.. The ending was incredible and unexpected.. Great book.

Was this review helpful?