Cover Image: Women Under Scrutiny

Women Under Scrutiny

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

My heart goes out to the 65 women (and more) who were featured in this book. Thank you for being so open and vulnerable.
This may not be a very uplifting read, but an important one. It is an honest and very intimate view on the relationship women have with their bodies and how women are treated based on their looks and how women treat each other.

The articles and poems in this book have been written by a diverse group of women, of all ages and with different backgrounds. They share their stories about bullying, body image issues, self-esteem issues, fat-shaming, eating disorders and mental health issues.
Randy Susan Meyers even adds her own commentary to the book by describing her own fight with body weight and how this anthology came to live after writing her novel Waisted.
On a final note: Some of these pieces are not easy to read. So please be aware of the content.
Was this review helpful?
Powerful, raw, unmediated and I believe that each of the women that participated in the writing of this book experienced something powerful not only as a cause for the writing but while also creating their art.

Of course, the book touches on sensitive topics but it is absolutely amazing and more people should be reading it.
Was this review helpful?
Unfortunately, I was expecting more from this book than what I received. I felt like there was little range in the stories that were being told (predominantly about struggles with weight and body image) and little variety in the delivery or overall message of these stories. While I admire conciseness in writing, I felt like the shortness of many of the pieces in this book were only reflective of a lack of deeper material. Nonetheless, I applaud these women for their bravery and their willingness to share their truths!
Was this review helpful?
It took me a bit of time to be able to process how I really felt about this book. It certainly wasn’t what I expected it to be. These short stories, poems and essays written by women are some of the most raw material I have read in a while. Each woman shares the unfiltered truth of how she feels about her body image, how the world’s standards can be an awful judge and there are stories of shame, guilt, mental illness and everything in between. Most of the book was hard to read in the sense that it was heartbreaking to realize what women go through whether it be in their own heads or some idea of perfection thrown at them by society. Kudos to all the women who were willing to share and be so transparent to help break some of the stereotypes and stigmas. Job well done.
Was this review helpful?
Unfortunately I was disappointed by this book. The vast majority of truths focus on weight and to be honest I was hoping for a lot more diversity. Women are scrutinised for an array of things outside of weight and to tell the truth I was getting tired of it being the focal point. It also says this book is meant to include artwork but I only saw 2 pieces of art?

Really interesting premise but sadly the execution wasn't for me.
Was this review helpful?
It took me quite a while to process my thoughts about this book, and I’m not sure if it is because of the topical subject matter or the volume. It brought back many memories where people have passed seemingly innocuous comments about my own appearance and/or body. 

The articles, poems, and artwork talk about society’s double standards when it comes to the appearance of women. Women have shared their stories about fat-shaming, bullying, body image issues, self-esteem issues, eating disorders, and mental health issues that arise from the unhealthy obsession with weight and/or body shape.

The pieces have been written by a diverse group of women, of all ages and with all sorts of backgrounds. While this makes the book representative of everyone’s voices, the quality of writing takes a hit at times. Without sounding dismissive of the pain behind women’s lived experiences, I want to say that the volume could have been slimmer because some articles/poems did not add anything fresh to the narrative.
Meyers adds her riveting commentary to the book, describing her own battles with body weight and how this anthology arose from the experience of writing her novel, Waisted.

Final thoughts: There’s a lot to process in these essays. They’re not all easy to read. Some are serious and tragic, whereas the others imbue humor into painful topics. You, as a reader, must have the courage to read these honest and brave accounts of women who have been targeted for their appearance and body shape.
Was this review helpful?
*Thanks Netgally and the author for the arc, all thoughts are completely my own *
I wasn't sure how to rate this book, not because it is bad, it's actually really harrowing the way some people's relationships with their bodies are.

This book brought me back to being a teenager, uncomfortable in their own body and thinking they were fat when they weren't. 

Its hard to read about different women's stories about them being scrutinized over their bodies. 

I would definitely recommend this book if you're into diet culture
Was this review helpful?
An evocative and honest anthology of stories, essays, and poems about navigating the world as a girl/woman, body image, and sometimes, finding self love/self acceptance despite the societal pressure to conform. Some of these works were beautiful in their vulnerability, others just barely scratched the surface, but overall a collection worth reading.
Was this review helpful?