Cover Image: Uncanny Valley

Uncanny Valley

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Anna Wiener is a young woman with an English degree and no technical experience. Her memoir starts as she enters the heady and often overly optimistic world of start-ups. Sky high budgets, charismatic founders, lots of misogyny and non-diverse hiring make for a work bubble that glorifies the technological boom and downplays the downsides of the new world.

Wiener is good at evaluating her own process and beliefs as she moves from job to job as a support person, a role that doesn't garner a lot of respect even though she refuses to hide in the background of the companies where she works. She discusses with care and detail how the tech economy can isolate people and push out the middle class in cities where tech takes over.

This is book is compulsively readable and asks readers to consider whether a predominantly online life has value or instead leaches life from our lives.

Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

For how infrequently I read memoirs, this was a really decent choice. Attracted as much by the very apt title as by the context (an insider tell all of behind and in front of the scenes toxic culture of Silicon Valley) I found this book to be an immersive read almost immediately. A quality the narrative maintained throughout, so much so that for all intent and purposes it read just as dynamic as any work of fiction. Ay, but therein lies the rub…this wasn’t a work of fiction, this was a real story told by a real person who lived it. So where with fiction you can easily go and talk about the protagonist, here it would technically constitute a personal attack on the author. Tricky business…reviewing memoirs. But ok, let’s give it a go. So the protagonist is a young woman, a typical and nicely self described linty liberal of Brooklyn NY, a bookish, analog person working a thankless low paying job at a small publishing company. She becomes intrigued by the startup culture, eventually enticed into trying it on for size, first on 3 months trial basis with a small company in NY and then onto a proper well paying job in a much larger company in SF. And thus begin her adventures in San Francisco, a city that isn’t just the base for startup culture, but also a place irretrievably and radically by it. Terrifyingly expensive, aggressively gentrified to suit its new denizens, the upwardly mobile young hip people with too much money, the author presents San Francisco (the city she still resides in according to her bio) somehow even less inviting than NY. Just a sort of prohibitively expensive yuppie mecca. In that representation she is pretty much consistent throughout. But her relationship with the startup field is…well, it’s mixed at best. She constantly has moral qualms which are constantly overridden by the devotion to steady paycheck. She provides a fairly disparaging image of the entire culture, the way it perceives the world…all information is data, all things can be optimized and improved, preferably through a neverending series of apps. The author sticks with the job (two jobs actually) for several years before the deleterious effects on one’s soul and moral fiber become too egregious and then she leaves to write about it. And really, as far as jobs you do in your 20s or things you do for money in general goes, all things considered she did well, even leaving with a sizeable payout. But apparently it wasn’t easy. And here’s the thing…she complains about it…a lot. Which may or may not sit well with some readers. For me…I understood where she was coming from and a lot of what she said was relatable, but there was an aspect of my brain just screaming…first world problems, these are all first world problems. The author is very smart and very self aware, so none of this ever comes across as obnoxious or whiny, but it does tend to dominate the book at times. That level of white privilege that allows the person to complain so effusively about doing a fairly easy job (customer service in sweatpants from the comfort of her couch at times easy) for crazy amounts of money. So anyway…there’s that. But other than that, it was a really good read. I didn’t even think I was all that interested in Silicon Valley, I barely made it through the pilot episode of a tv show dedicated to it. Analog most of the way, I appreciate technology, but cautiously and certainly don’t live by or utilize many or any really apps. For me it’s all fairly vague, all those jobs that will disappear the second zombie apocalypse arrives, but this book brought it to life quite vividly, if unappetizingly, and I’m glad to have read it. Very well written too, self aware, clever, funny…very smart book, actually, not quite an expose, but very nearly. Certainly a strange and quite a soulless and ugly sort of culture of excess and grotesque pursuit of optimization, but then again the future might very well be written in code the Silicon Valley entrepreneurs are so enamored with, so there’s that. Interesting read, sobering, lot of food for thought. Recommended. Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book, having grown up, lived, interviewed and worked at companies in the Silicon Valley. Now that I work in the city, I can relate even more to Wiener's experience. Like many others, I found the intentional not-naming of tech companies, CEOs and places to be a little distracting since I kept pausing to look up the references. Wiener has a talent for accurately describing the slightly out-of-body disillusionment of being part of this culture, from the fashion choices to tech circle philosophy. A good read if you are also a bit burnt out from the Silicon Valley grind.

Was this review helpful?

Anna is in her 20s and ambitious. She doesn't like her job in NYC so thinks maybe a tech one in SF would suit her better. She learns fast and yet doesn't get the recognition she wants or attention she feels she deserves. Misogyny is rampant in the tech industries. She wasn't counting on that. There are hirings, firings, scandels throughout the book, but since this is a nonfiction memoir and she never names the companies she works for or the people she works with, we don't get a full sense of what's going on. I found the writing sometimes evocative yet sometimes downright confusing.

Was this review helpful?

Hype can be a good and bad thing for a book. For me, the hype ruined Uncanny Valley. Since maybe July of 2019, this book has been heralded as a send-up of Silicon Valley, a scathing and witty critique of everything wrong with tech culture, by Goodreads and The New York Times alike. I was expecting such when I picked it up, only to discover that it is a completely mediocre piece of nonfiction that recycles many opinions about tech that I've heard before.

The author, Anna Wiener, is a tech outsider. She's an assistant at a publishing company in New York, working hard for minimum wage, before deciding to leave the industry and work for an ebook startup - still literature-adjacent, but with more of a tech bent. When that job doesn't work out, she moves to San Francisco and joins a data analytics startup in a customer support role. After a few years there, she moves to work for Github. She realizes that she does not like the self-importance of tech, how everyone in the industry thinks they're changing the world when they're really ruining it. She critiques the subcultures and hobbies that abound here: spiritualism (think: yoga, astrology, reiki, sound baths, silent meditation retreats), crafts and working with your hands for fun, obsessive and mandatory team bonding in city-wide scavenger hunts and happy hours and ski trips, etc. She hates the sexism and lack of diversity that is so commonplace here. She hates talking to other people in tech, particularly brogrammers (despite kinda dating one, oops). She hates it all! But she doesn't leave the industry.

I felt that Wiener's book may have been more topical and relevant a few years ago. In fact, it ends right after the 2016 election, where the author is truly awakened out of her coastal elite bubble. Since then, we've seen countless send-ups of the industry, repeating the same ideas that everyone has of how overrated and self-obsessed tech is. I don't think that this book adds anything new to the growing zeitgeist of how terrible Silicon Valley is.

The writing style was also off-putting to me. Instead of referring to companies and people by their names, she dubs them with obvious epithets, repeats them a million times, and makes the reader do the work of putting two and two together. Facebook is "the social network everyone hates." Amazon is "the online superstore." Google is "the search engine giant." Microsoft is "the litigious Seattle-based software conglomerate" (or something like that). Her own employer, Github, is "the open-source startup." Even The Matrix is "a movie about a group of hackers who discover that life is a simulation." THE MATRIX. JUST SAY THE NAME OF THE MOVIE. I didn't form a connection with any of her coworker-characters because she didn't even give most of them names. Instead, she referred to them by job title: "the solutions manager," "the data analytics company CEO," "the technical co-founder," etc. All of this felt impersonal to me.

Wiener also does a lot of telling, not showing. Instead of giving us a compelling narrative about one of her work retreats, she presents a list of compound activities of general actions that happened on the trip: e.g. there was drinking, people played games, we ate at a diner. Not only is she generalizing these activities and implying that the apply to every company in this industry, but she's not making me feel engaged with the subject matter and story at hand. This technique might be effective for an article or essay (which I understand is how this book was originally presented), but it's not effective for a long-form work of nonfiction.

Overall, the hype killed this for me. If I hadn't expected something great, I might have liked this a little more (still not that much, I'll admit). Thank you to FSG for the ARC via Netgalley!

Was this review helpful?

I was a big fan of Silicon Valley (the HBO show) and like memoirs so decided to try this out.

As the book opens, the author is working as assistant in NY publishing. She's overworked, underpaid and not getting promoted, so she decides to take a (non-tech) job at a Silicon Valley start-up.

I liked the writing and found the author's observations sharp and insightful. But the book felt long for something that's really just a LOT of observation. I kept wishing for more structure. It felt too long for what it was.

In the end, this is a book about being in your 20s, having a job you hate, living in a city (after reading this I could never live in San Francisco), feeling like there must be more to life. The portrait of the tech industry is also not great (a misogynstic industry that pretends it's improving our lives while being obsessed with a) collecting big data, b) getting us addicted to their technology and c) spying on us under the guise of improving their products. Yikes.)

Was this review helpful?

A great premise and some engaging early chapters, but my interest started to peter out around the halfway point. I was hoping for a new or more unique look at the female perspective of working in Silicon Valley, but there wasn't a lot of unique insights here. In the end, it just fell a little flat for me.

Was this review helpful?

Listened on audio. I was disappointed by this book unfortunately. It didn’t grab me as much as I was hoping, although I am interested to know which companies the writer worked for.

It does give an interesting look into the tech industry and startup programs.

Was this review helpful?

This is the third audiobook I’ve listened to in the past few months that is focused on Silicon Valley. The first two concentrated on the development and life of specific companies, namely Yahoo and Google, whereas this book takes a look at the culture of technology start-ups. Having previously worked in publishing and at a literary agency in New York, Anna Wiener joined a four-person start-up who were developing an eBook reader app. She was to be the person who knew books amongst this small group of techies. This experience turned out to be short lived, however, as she was soon tempted out to San Francisco where she worked at a data analytics company for the next 18 months. Her third job in a technology start-up, also in the Bay Area, was at an open source software development company – essentially a company that develops software for software developers.

I’d observed from the Yahoo and Google books that a clear distinction exists between technical staff (typically computer engineers or coders) and non-technical staff (sales people, administrators and others in customer facing roles). In short, the technical staff are valued the most. Anna finds this out quite quickly and though it clearly rankles she also finds enough interest and reward to keep her working in this industry for a number of years. She walks us through her various roles, her interactions with people inside the companies and her mindset as she wrestled with elements of her work that clearly don’t sit easily with her.

One element here that I found frustrating is that Wiener seems to have an aversion to names: the people she comes across are simply labelled entrepreneur, technologist, CEO, venture capitalist etc. And the same goes for the companies she works for, uses or simply expresses an opinion upon, these being designated as the Seattle software conglomerate or the social media platform everybody hates. Is there a reason for this or is it simply a style choice? I’m not sure, but I didn’t like it. I did manage to work out some of the companies touched on (I think), with my list including Amazon, Google, Uber, eBay and Facebook. But of course I may be wrong.

The other key thing here – and I found it to be the main thrust of the book – is that in Wiener’s opinion Silicon Valley is run by men, and usually men she doesn’t like very much. She particularly dislikes the way that these men treat the women in their employ. The author, a self confessed feminist, does go some way to explaining how she formed this view and the examples she gives are reasonably persuasive. But for me what fights against this is her obvious antipathy toward the male species in general. Others may disagree but I found it to be a pervasive flavour throughout.

Overall I enjoyed the insight this book provided into how things work in a technology start-up. I also admired the author’s ability to string sentences together, often using obscure words and phrases. But Wiener herself came across as a royal pain in the arse. I know I'll be an outlier here but I'm afraid I found the whole thing to be way too annoying and for this reason I can only award it two stars.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book, it's funny and engaging and put into words a lot of things I was feeling about the tech industry although as a definite outsider. I liked her take as an insider but still an outsider and also find it interesting to contemplate what tech is doing to our society and world. There were parts that made me laugh out loud and also made me contemplate the power of Silicon Valley.

Was this review helpful?

Anna Wiener's memoir follows her departure from the New York publishing circle and change of career where she takes up a position in a tech start-up in of Silicon Valley.

This suffered from unrealistic expectations on my part: I've seen the book billed as a number of things - comparable to Joan Didion, a brutal expose on the sexist bro culture of the tech start-up business - and while, yes, the writing is good, companions to Didion are going a bit far. I don't know much about start-ups and while I don't wish to devalue the not so great experience Wiener had I just didn't find her revelations all that mind-blowing or revelatory.

An easy breezy read (due to the solid writing) which I wouldn't discourage others from reading... I think I'm just burnt out on tech memoirs!

Was this review helpful?

This is an eye opening and thought provoking memoir about silicon valley, start ups, and figuring out what it means to be yourself when you're not really sure who you are yet. While I found this book to be incredibly interesting and compelling reading, as well as enormously thought provoking to me, I did have a slight sharpness in my response to it that I didn't particularly enjoy. Wiener examines things between the culture she leaves behind and the one she ends up in while confronting her own expectations she holds to herself along with the ideals she wants to embody. At times I was frustrated with her efforts to be both immersed in the tech culture and above it all, but like I mentioned already, to have a book and an author make you confront real feelings and ideas is still a valuable reading experience. I think the writing was wonderful, she is clearly very talented and an interesting writer. I'm excited to se what else she does but might have appreciated more time in between the living and the writing for this memoir.

Was this review helpful?

👍Pick it: If you need another reason to disable spyware, or better yet!, dismantle every device you own.
👎Skip it: If you still genuinely think of Zuck as post-breakup Jessie Eisenberg, and “TheFacebook” an innocent vehicle for his sorrow.

Uncanny Valley is a work of genre-stretching bounds: a Silicon Valley exposé, a cautionary tech-bro tale, a coming-of-age-in-the-startup-age memoir.

And while whistleblowing is all the rage, Wiener’s narrative is distinctly refreshing. She makes no attempt to escape complicit involvement in and infatuation for the (promise of the) Promise Land forged by the hands of 21-year-old billionaires.

She does not feign aloof nor claims to be early-bird woke to Silicon toxicity. Instead, her experience reads like a concession. She drank the nootropic-spiked Koolaid, minimized the malignant behaviors simmering within startup culture, scrolled and scrolled and scrolled, addicted like the rest of us, and made an easy, six-figure salary promoting the narrative.

Despite Wiener’s techno-skeptic position, Uncanny Valley will not read like your aunt’s snarky, uneducated, rant on 'the social network everyone hated'. She’s clever. She’s linguistically-versed. She’s an empathetic-forward analyst, attempting to find the heartbeat within the Valley’s shallowest characters.

Uncanny Valley is a blatant warning about the implications of our tech-hunger. But Wiener is asking readers to meditate on much weightier concepts than the consequences should they choose to swipe right, like:

Why does screen-free stillness actually feel ominous?
When did disconnect become sacrilegious?
Am I paying attention?
Is my identity my own?
Or have we all merely become data-generated humanoids, predictable algorithms feeding the Big Brother beast?

Was this review helpful?

While I found the look into the workplace and its culture to be somewhat interesting, I just couldn't get into this memoir. It was a bit of a slough for me to read as I found the writing style and lack of nuance to be its downfall. "Uncanny Valley" reads more like a long form essay than any memoirs I've read in recent years. There doesn't seem to be anything distinctive or a draw.

Was this review helpful?

Anna Wiener's workplace memoir explores her behind-the-scenes experiences at some Silicon Valley startups during the dot.com gold rush years. She witnesses disruption and innovation on many levels, and finds herself inhabiting an economic and cultural frontier that's contemporary, complex, and continuously evolving. Ms. Wiener does an excellent job describing cultural and economic development of the tech industry, along with rapid changes in the SF Bay Area. She juxtaposes history and geography with nuances of her personal career growth and vulnerabilities. This insider's view of the often-bizarre startup culture offers provocative themes for discussion: who controls tech, women in the workplace, cyber addiction, new tech vs. tradition, rags/riches disparity, idealism, ethics, power dynamics, gig economy, life purpose, ambition. Highly recommended for those interested in the high stakes world of IT and social media, delivered by a reliable and entertaining storyteller.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Farrar, Straus and Giroux for the ARC of this book. A memoir about discovering who you are in your mid-20s, set in Silicon Valley. Initially, I expected this would be an expose of the early days of the start-up boom, and to an extent it is, but the overarching theme is what it's like to be in your mid-20s and still figuring out your place. The author spends a lot of time comparing herself to her (mostly male) peers, usually feeling as though she's falling short. Those who remember going through a similar soul-searching at that age (or those currently experiencing it) will likely relate, regardless of your career path. Anna writes with self-awareness and humor, and while I think she lets some male peers off too easily, I appreciated she tried to portray (most of) them as more than just cookie-cutter tech bros. Those looking for a hard-hitting examination of the challenges women in tech face should look elsewhere, as this is a more personal story that only scratches the surface of those issues.

Was this review helpful?

It was interesting to read the experiences of someone who had very little interest in technology outside of everyday use, as she navigated the innards of start-up culture. I definitely got the impression the book was talking to people who similarly didn't have any interest in or familiarity with the sector beforehand, though, and as such, I didn't really read anything new to me. It would be a pretty good introduction to the bizarre cultural bubble of that particular chunk (both in space and time) of start-up culture, though.

Recommended for anyone interested in the tech sector's cultural influence, but who may not necessarily be sure where to begin.

Was this review helpful?

Debut author Anna Wiener shares her engaging professional story of her move from a small Brooklyn, N.Y. literary agency to an exciting new tech start-up: “Uncanny Valley: A Memoir” highlights the big money, big deals, contracts of big business, the big talent and big egos of the male staff that dominated the Silicon Valley tech industry. Fifty men and six women worked at the (unnamed) tech start-up where Weiner was first employed.

While living in her North Brooklyn apartment --furnished with second hand furniture, a roommate she barely knew, Wiener’s position as an assistant editor at a NYC literary agency had run its course. There was no room for advancement except to marry rich, inherit money, wait for colleagues to transfer or die. Wiener’s $31,000 annual salary (no benefits) wasn’t enough to live on—even with no credit card or educational debt and no dependents. Wiener loved the free hardback books, and the rapidly shrinking book world as she knew it— still, she interviewed for a non-tech position for an e-book start up: she got the job. “Hello, San Francisco!”

The $65,000 annual salary with company dental and medical benefits was almost too good to be true. Wiener treats readers to amazing descriptions not only of the tech industry, but of San Francisco: the Castro and Mission districts (where she lived) the hippies, freaks, weirdos, leather daddies, the rambunctious homeless population, the paid company group ski trip and various company sponsored retreats.
Wiener’s new job was similar to providing customer support to a small team of (boy-men) software developers: “like immersion therapy for internalized misogyny”. Wiener soothed, cheered them up, affirmed, advocated for success and ordered them pizza. One colleague had a PhD in Biology and wanted to be known as the doctor. The 25 year old CEO was “ambitious and awkward”; she appreciated his “hard-won praise”, and he reminded her of her high school classmates at a Manhattan math science school.

Often the storyline was hard to follow. Wiener seldom named names and never identified start-ups or tech companies she wrote about. Rereading the story doesn’t help. Her boyfriend Ian, worked in robotics and very little was revealed about their relationship. I wondered if they had broken up a few times. Noah, a trusted co-worker, was fired from her team and was (likely) very successful in tech. Now “Patrick”, I think, may have been the man himself—though, we have no way of knowing. Still, Wiener is a marvelous storyteller, and I wouldn’t want to miss anything she might write in the future. ** With thanks and appreciation to Farrar, Straus, Giroux, via NetGalley for the DDC for the purpose of review.

Was this review helpful?

Job listings are an excellent place to get sprayed with HR’s idea of fun and a 23-year-old’s idea of work-life balance.

I identified with so much of this book - not necessary the tech piece, as I've never worked in tech - but the boy's club mentality highlighted throughout the book and perks from upper-management who have no idea what employees really want had me actually laughing out loud. Turns out being a woman is pretty much the same bullshit across industries (which wasn't entirely expected, but was still disappointing).

The other piece I loved was the culture talk - we've all been on Slack dropping an emoji to show we're present, trying to use the most buzzwords, feeling alternatively invested and disgusted at ourselves and our place in the corporate monster.

I would've liked more ties to Anna's real life outside of work, or more of the overarching consequences of all the choices that she was semi-present for, but would recommend regardless!

Was this review helpful?

This memoir is about working in the boys club that is Silicon Valley, but I feel like it was such a spot-on takedown of office culture in so many industries. The whole 'work hard, play hard' thing - work 80 hours a week, but you can drink beer at your desk! - has always been a peeve of mine. I loved how Weiner didn't mention any corporate entities, but you knew exactly who she was talking about. Brilliantly written and truly anger-inducing, I highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?