Member Reviews
Librarian 497576
I thought this was a really interesting concept and was drawn in by the description. I thought it moved along somewhat slowly but think that may have been partly on purpose. Seems like the character was able to stop and really think about all of the past moments of his life in order to reconcile them and truly move on. |
BROKEN PEOPLE by Sam Lansky is a novel about self discovery. The main characters’ name is Sam as well. Sam moves from New York to the West Coast. He reluctantly attends a party where he overhears a conversation about a shaman who claims to cure what ails you in three days. Not only is Sam trying to adjust to his life in Los Angeles he is suffering from depression. With the help of the friend who hosted the party a three day retreat with the shaman is arranged. Sam is a bit skeptical about the shaman’s methods and claims but at the same time Sam is willing to try anything that might help him deal with his emotional issues. During the treatment Sam’s past is revealed and explains how he came to be living in Los Angeles. I read this book a few months ago. I have mixed feelings about the story. Overall I liked the book. I didn’t quite buy into the method of the cure but at the same time this is fiction so the possibilities are endless. I liked the style of writing and would probably read another novel by Sam Lanksy. Thank you to Harlequin for the opportunity to read an advanced digital edition of BROKEN PEOPLE. |
This well-written book feels more like a memoir than fiction. The author draws on his own experiences and the reader often feels like a listener to his therapy sessions. . |
Librarian 569651
I'm not sure if this was supposed to be a memoir or a fictionalized memoir. Ironically in the book the main character is writing a memoir, but his editor says that he's not removed enough from the experience in order to successfully write a memoir.
This is kind of the case here. A memoir is being written that centers around a retreat where a shaman can "heal" you over a weekend. There are three nights where a hallucinogen is administered and the shaman summons the spirit to help rid you of your demons. There's a bit of hippy talk ("clearing the spiritual debris") but overall it's a trip down memory lane. The narrator goes through a series of failed relationships and health scares. He doesn't take responsibility for his actions and this is somehow all cleared up with self-acualization.
The whole book was a bit weird and not quite what I was expecting.
|
Tiffany M, Librarian
Have problems that you wish would just go away? Crave a quick fix and you're open to new age/culturally-appropriated spiritual practices? Just enjoy hearing about the messy lives of others? Miss Southern California and just how California California is? This could be the book for you. Sam is a recovering addict with a successful memoir. He's got a lot of mileage out of his past mistakes and struggles...but he's found himself at a plateau with past patterns (and his new book deal). He wants to make real progress in his life, but like most of us, doesn't necessarily want to put in the hard years of work to make the changes. Sam lucks into a free weekend away with a shaman renowned for his fast transformative work. Through his sacred plant-elicited visions and insights we learn about Sam's past entanglements and eventually witness the blossoming of hope and possibility in his life. |
I could not connect with this book but glad I had the opportunity to read it Thanks NetGalley for the opportunity |
This is a very funny book about being in crisis and seeking spirituality and not sure if you actually want it. It's a send up of the L.A. life, the "guru", and new age movements and it if you liked Less by Andrew Sean Greer, you will love this book because I felt it has a similar voice and was about a troubled LGBTQ male writer |
Jessica M, Librarian
28-year-old, gay writer, Sam lives in Los Angeles. he's insecure, depressed, and a former addict. He is ready to heal. When his proposal for his 2nd memoir is rejected, his best friends, urge him to try a three-day ceremony with a Shaman. To set him on his journey, the Shaman gives him ayuhuasta. Will his journey help him heal? Can he learn to forgive and love himself? A story of introspection, examining his past, and taking steps forward, it is a well-written and realistic portrayal. It can be dark at times, because it deals with depression, drugs, and self-loathing. However, readers who enjoy realistic fiction, LGBTQ+ stories, and books about dealing with real issues will enjoy reading this book. |
I was unsure of the book at the beginning, it felt a little too referential, but the latter two-thirds were so worthwhile and evocative. |
Erika H, Librarian
I am not saying this is a bad book. I just could not get into it. I didn't really feel anything for the characters, couldn't connect. Maybe I was just not in the right place when I was reading it, but it just didn't work for me. I do appreciate the opportunity to have had the chance to read it, and I would not deter anyone from picking it up. (I know we ordered it) |
Mary C, Librarian
What if there was someone who could heal you of all your problems in 3 days? Although skeptical, that sounds like exactly what Sam needs. Suffering through depression & addiction, Sam’s life doesn’t feel like it has much purpose. He journeys with a friend to meet a shaman, who takes them on a 3 day journey of self-reflection and healing. This book was ok. It was hard to connect to and fairly dry and unfortunately a bit boring at times. It was well written, but just didn’t hold my attention. |
Thank you to Netgalley for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review. A mesmerizing account of a young man struggling toward self-awareness and eventually, self-acceptance. Often a difficult read, the author/narrator is intense and simultaneously self-absorbed and obtuse. He can be very difficult to like, perhaps due to the fact that he dislikes himself so thoroughly. His journey to learning to accept his flaws makes for a good story. While this genre isn't my preference, I concur with the critics who recommend it. |
Amy C, Librarian
DNF. Too much angst and self-loathing. The whole California scene seemed cliched and shallow, and I just didn’t care enough about Sam to keep reading. This one was just not for me. |
“H e fixes everything that’s wrong with you in three days.” What a perfect opening line for a book! Who wouldn’t want to fix everything you hated about yourself in practically no time? And so we are hooked as we are plunged into the life of Sam, a gay writer living in LA, having left behind his life in New York, his former lover and his friends but still carrying enormous self loathing. Through a series of chance encounters Sam is given an opportunity to meet a shaman who, we are told, has .the ability to free an individual and show him a better path. Buck, a wealthy architect invites Sam to accompany him to meet Jacob, and following the initial meeting, the two decide to embark on the journey. toward a better life. Sam is the author of a memoir about his personal struggles with addiction and recovery. Knowing this about him, the reader understands therefore that he has demons in his past. As Sam begins the 3 day process of facing those demons under the guidance of the shaman, he goes deeper and deeper into his memories and the readers go with him. This is not an easy book to read. Sam is deeply troubled, totally self-absorbed, craving love but unable to reciprocate. His narrative is raw and unflinching and the reader soon is as disgusted with Sam as Sam himself is. I pushed on through his broken relationships but it was not a pleasant trip. The question at the end is whether the trip was worth it, both for Sam and the reader. You will have to decide for yourself if that initial promise was fulfilled and whether the journey was worth it. |
The relatable young adult struggle of wanting to “fix” yourself, can you really be fixed in three days? Dry and youthful, a wonderful book for anyone who is in or has been through their 20s |
Nelda B, Librarian
First this book is mainly about the characters and recalling memories. There is no plot. I found Sam, tiring. I could not sympathize with him. He has been searching with help from drugs and finds a shaman at a wellness retreat who promises to help him. Its not the gay aspect of his lifestyle that bothers me, its just the personality of Sam and so many beautiful, white people. |
Jessica F, Librarian
Heavy topics but compelling. Almost felt like peeking into someone's life in a detached way which makes it sound not engrossing, yet it was. Sam is a writer who is gay, a recovering addict with intense body dysmorphia, and has severe anxiety. We are in his head as he attempts to "cure" himself through a three-day ayahuasca fueled binge with a shaman, which basically is just him reliving all of the memories of past dysfunctional relationships in every minute, horrific detail. And yet, so many of the emotions, the relationship problems, the self-loathing, the questioning, are universal. And the writing is so brilliant that it all feels personal. Reminds me a bit of My Year of Rest and Relaxation by Ottessa Moshfegh. I can see why some might not enjoy this. It can be uncomfortable, a bit pedantic, maybe even smug, with a somewhat pat ending. But I believe those are all or mostly intentional and to me the glimpse into the life of this character was fascinating. |
Kristin W, Librarian
It is odd when it feels like the author of a novel is also the main character of the novel. Sam Lansky does this with such grace. Broken People also uses another odd narrative device, an Ayahuasca trip, to tell much of the story in the novel. This is a character-driven novel. |
Austin B, Librarian
Great memoir and parody of a memoir at the same time. The story itself is both sad and funny, but it's the metacommentary on memoir writing that makes this book shine. |
I wanted to love this book but sadly I just could not connect with anything in the story. I picked it up and put it down so many times thinking maybe I just wasn’t in the mood for this type of book but just never found my self connected to it. |








