Cover Image: The Holdout

The Holdout

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Guilt or innocence? It is a hard thing to decide for someone and sometimes harder for individuals on a jury. Ten years ago, a jury decided to acquit Bobby Nock on the murder of Jessica Silver, a student of his. The jury came back with a unanimous decision after a contentious few days of discussion. Now Maya Seale, an up-and-coming defense attorney in LA, is approached by Rick a fellow member of the jury ten years ago. Rick is working with a podcast to bring to light new information about Bobby Nock and how they made the wrong decision ten years ago. Maya along with the other jurors return to the hotel they were sequestered in. The rooms are made to appear as they did ten years ago. On the night they arrive, Rick and Maya go away from the others to have a separate discussion. When things get heated, Maya leaves the room only to return and discover Rick dead from blunt force trauma to the head. Who killed Rick? Law enforcement think it's Maya but she knows she innocent. Maya will do anything to help clear her name and avoid jail time.

This story is told in alternating chapters between present time and a chapter from the point of view of each juror. The chapters from the past help to add another layer not only to the old case but who may have killed Rick. This is not your typical murder mystery but one that is more character driven, a la Agatha Christie. In a publishing world full of psychological thrillers it's nice to come across a mystery that is still empactful and makes you think although it may not be a suspenseful. Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars.
this felt like a modern take on the classic "whodunnit" Agatha Christie-type story - her stories are even brought up a few times. personally, I liked how tied to the justice system and juries this was but those who do not like courtroom dramas will probably not like that aspect. I liked the several discussions of racial issues within the criminal justice system, especially that Maya's white knight personality was called out (made me a little uncomfy that the author is white but I think it was still handled well). usually someone trying to investigate a crime they have no business investigating bothers me, but I think because Maya does have some sort of legal/criminal knowledge it didn't bug me as much. I also liked that I didn't really get much opportunity to guess who was actually responsible for both crimes.
I thought this was going to be more focused on the true crime documentary which I really would have liked but sadly it wasn't. the middle became a little tedious and boring. the ending felt a little rushed and almost unsatisfying, even though all questions are answered. overall, this was a pretty fun mystery but it didn't do anything new or crazy.

Was this review helpful?

This courtroom drama was inspired by Moore’s (Academy Award-winner for Best Adapted Screenplay for The Imitation Game) real-life experience serving on a jury in 2008 and sending that defendant to prison for murder. Moore thinks his jury was correct, but always wonders about the small chance they could’ve gotten it wrong. The Holdout does not have a particularly thriller-y vibe, but it’s easy to quickly turn the pages. It looks at the impact of a high profile trial on the jury (particularly one that is sequestered)…how it affects the jurors’ lives, families, and mental state…and how slippery the legal system is in the U.S. It’s a less weird, more accessible version of The Body in Question (one of my Underrated Gems of 2019). The Holdout would make a great book club pick as there is lots to unpack about how we handle juries in the U.S., their ability to render fair and impartial decisions within these circumstances (particularly for high profile cases), and whether or not what we ask of jurors on high profile cases is fair. If you like a courtroom drama that delves deep into a serious issue, The Holdout is for you!

Was this review helpful?

This novel gives a behind-the-scenes look at a sequestered jury in the trial of the decade in Los Angeles. Maya Seale, a successful criminal defense attorney, was invited to a 10-year reunion of the jury who issued a fateful verdict that began a chain reaction of events in the lives of the jurors and the victim's family. Maya, who had been the lone holdout on the jury, successfully convinced the other members to issue a not-guilty verdict. At the reunion, one of the jurors who reluctantly agreed to the not-guilty verdict in order to end the sequester was murdered and Maya was implicated as the murderer. As she races to prove her innocence, she finds out that the murdered juror had been obsessively investigating the decade old case in order to prove Maya wrong. In his quest to do so, he uncovered secrets and misdeeds of each of the other jurors, the defendant in the original case, and the victim's family.

Great legal thriller reminiscent of John Grisham's early work (think "The Runaway Jury", and "The Pelican Brief"). Through the storyline, Graham Moore bluntly posits that the our judicial system is severely broken, namely the worst thing an innocent person can do is tell the truth when accused of a crime.

Was this review helpful?

During a tense murder trial, high school teacher Bobby Nock is accused of murdering a wealthy white student. Initially the lone "not guilty" vote, juror Maya Seale swings her fellow jurors to acquit. During a reunion of the jurors ten years later, a fellow juror turns up dead in Maya's room. Now, Maya is the main suspect, and it's her turn to prove her innocence. The Holdout will keep you guessing whodunit, then and now. 

Graham Moore's legal thriller reminded me of John Grisham's early books, combining court room drama with insightful looks at the justice system. The action keeps the narrative moving along at a fast clip while the flashbacks help you understand how Maya was able to sway so many jurors. A quick read, The Holdout is a perfect beach read if you are looking for something to take with you for spring break.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 Stars!

An enjoyable legal thriller that unravels in dual timelines and maintains relevance in both. This was definitely a slow burn in many ways but built up to a fantastic ending.

Was this review helpful?

Wow!!! I loved this book so much more than I expected to, really. This is my first experience with this author and it certainly won't be my last! This title first caught my attention when I heard that it was going to be one of February's Book of the Month Club choices. I have had a lot of good luck with their picks, so I was glad to get my hands on a copy!

I legitimately cannot remember the last time that a book's plot so completely took my by surprise! And multiple times, too! I loved it! Maya's role - from juror to attorney and beyond works so well here! She's a believable character - as are the rest of the cast. The book definitely has cinematic flair, too! I was completely captivated! It's original, fresh and while definitely an exciting mystery, this is a discussion starter, too! There is a lot more depth to some of the book's points and themes. The plotting, fast pace and characters all work so well here - this is truly an excellent book! I really and completely loved this and I can't wait to check out the author's earlier novels - as well as keep my eye out for any in the future!

Was this review helpful?

This book ended up not really being for me and I DNFd it fairly early. That isn't to say it's a bad book - it seemed relatively well-written and I know it will have an audience, but it just wasn't something I was enjoying or felt connected to while reading. Hope to see more from this author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a slow burn for me in the best possible way. Usually with thrillers or dramas, I fly through them – having to figure out what’s happening ASAP – but for this one I wanted to savor every detail. It has all the twists that you expect in this genre and had me guessing until the very end of the book. It’s hard to talk about without giving away a ton of spoilers, but I promise that you won’t regret picking up this courtroom drama!⁣

Was this review helpful?

4.5 stars! (Which I’m rounding up to 5!)

Hard to put down, well-written, and it has a good plot with a crazy twist ending. I really liked the time jumps between “now” and the trial ten years prior (and how with each time jump to the past, it focused on a specific character from the jury), as it kept me turning page after page to figure out the reason behind it. Definitely enjoyed this thriller!

Thank you to Random House and NetGalley for the free copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

In Holdout, Graham Moore gives us a legal thriller different than any I have read before, and I hated to turn that last page. Protagonist Maya is part of a jury convened to decide on the guilt or innocence of Bobby Nock, a twenty-five year old teacher accused of murdering one of his students. Jessica Silver vanished on her way home from school one day and hasn’t been seen since.

The story alternates between the trial itself and a meeting of the jurors ten years later as they participate in the making of a docuseries about the case. The flashbacks of the trial are told from the viewpoint of each of the jurors as the novel progresses, and when one of the jurors is murdered while making the docuseries, everyone becomes a suspect.

Moore does a masterful job keeping the reader guessing about the original murder as well as the newest one, and each of the jurors pull the reader in with their own life stories told along with their experiences during the trial. When their individual secrets threaten to be revealed during the present day murder investigation, the consequences for all involved could be disastrous.

Moore’s strength in his characterization coupled with his ability to weave together a mesmerizing story make this a book you don’t want to miss.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, I was a little bit skeptical going into a mystery/thriller about a jury. From my (limited) experience, they tend to be somewhat predictable. And for the first half of The Holdout, I was pretty sure that it was. I genuinely thought I knew what had happened. I’m pleased to say, I was wrong.

This book had so many twists and turns, I might have gotten whiplash. Just when you think you know what’s going on, there’s another twist to shake up the story, all the way to the very end. I really enjoyed that about this book. It was unpredictable, in the best way. If you like thrillers and are tired of seeing what’s coming a mile away, I can almost guarantee you’ll like this one.

The Holdout is told in alternating timelines, ten years apart. The first covers the events surrounding the trial and the other, what happens ten years later. And what happens ten years after the trial is honestly a lot more exciting than the actual trial. Which was a little bit disappointing. I found myself wanting to skim those chapters and get back to the story I was more invested in. But, those chapters did give an excellent background to the story as a whole. So, while I could see that they were necessary, they weren’t the most exciting to read.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book. It’s exciting and thrilling and an example of great writing. Once I got into it, I had a hard time putting it down.

Was this review helpful?

It’s the most sensational trial in recent memory. A fifteen-year-old girl, daughter of a wealthy real estate businessman, disappears. The subsequent investigation uncovers her relationship with a 25-year-old man who happens to be her English teacher. Even though there is no body, he is arrested and charged with her murder. It appears this will be an open-and-shut case for the prosecution. And, it almost is, until 23-year-old Maya Seale, who believes the defendant to be innocent, convinces the other jurors to vote “not guilty”.

Fast forward ten years. The jurors reassemble for a true crime show. Maya, who is now an attorney, is reluctant but agrees to join them because there is speculation that one of the jurors has proof that the suspect they exonerated is actually guilty of murder. All is good until one of the jurors is found dead in Maya’s hotel room and she is under suspicion.

The Holdout is a compelling story, told from several points of view and moving nearly seamlessly between the original trial and the present-day murder. The story itself is well-conceived and plotted. But the addition of the underlying concerns, including issues of race, class, law enforcement, and the inequalities in our society are what really makes this book a stand-out. The author has done a stellar job in weaving these issues into an entertaining story, making The Holdout an outstanding book that questions our attitudes and beliefs.

Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for providing a copy of this book for review.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

I want to start by saying, I don't typically read or watch courtroom dramas, I never thought it was something I would enjoy but I really enjoyed reading this book.

I absolutely LOVED the way the author switched back and forth between the trial and ten years later at the reunion and subsequent murder investigation of one of the former jurors. The flashbacks to the trial were from the perspectives of each of the jurors which was a really interesting way to present the trial and what was going through each of their minds during the process.

I also really enjoyed the look into the jury process. I've been called for jury duty but have never been selected to sit on a trial and the process and how it was described was fascinating.

The book was well paced and I definitely didn't feel I was trudging through any parts but there were a few things that sit right and that's why I didn't rate this at 4 or 5 stars.

Spoilers below:
Several times during the trial, Maya (the main character) says something to the effect of 'they'll never really know' so when the "big reveal" happened in the last 5 pages or so, it seemed really forced and kind of a let down. I would've much preferred it going unsaid.

The other thing that bugged me is how much she was involved in her own investigation despite being told by her boss to do nothing. She knowingly could've compromised evidence or witnesses and screwed herself. But I get it, it's a story and how else would we the readers been privy to the investigation if not through the main character.

With those two little issues aside, this was a very enjoyable read and definitely opened my eyes to a new genre of books that I've avoided in the past.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for this ARC of The Holdout by Graham Moore.

Maya is a defense lawyer with a passion for justice. But she's hiding from her past. Ten years previous she was on the jury for a high profile case with a very unpopular verdict, a verdict that she was responsible for. Now, all these years later, the jury is being brought together for a docu-series. But what should be a pleasant and emotional reunion becomes dangerous when one of them turns up dead in his room, and all fingers point to Maya.

This is a great read for fans of John Grisham. I do love a great crime drama, and this has everything, romance, betrayal, murder, sex, and a lot of social justice issues. It's quick moving and very readable. I very much enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

If you’re looking for an entertaining 2 for 1 mystery with some interesting twists scattered about, this book is for you! As long as you don’t mind suspending disbelief and scratching your head about some ridiculous behavior on the part of someone you’d expect to be much smarter than that, you’ll most likely find this to be as fun a read as I did. The short of the plot- Maya is currently a criminal defense attorney (the previously mentioned “smart” character who does some really dumb things) but 10 years ago she was a college grad who served on a jury. Not just any jury, but a scandalous trial involving the murder of a young wealthy white girl by her older black teacher. Maya was the lone holdout when the jury initially voted and she was able to somehow change their minds - that decision ended up costing her as well as the others in unexpected ways. The story alternates between each jury member then in 2009 and Maya now when a true crime podcast decides to reunite the jury members 10 years later. That’s really all you need to know as the plot unfolds in surprising ways.

While I really enjoyed the first 60% of this book, the remainder began to feel a little convoluted and overly detailed. I admire the author’s ability to craft a cinema like feel with fast paced dialogue and plot twists, however, I was left feeling like the characters were surface level, often behaving in ways that made no sense.. Maybe there were just too many issues that the author was trying to tackle and incorporate but I ended up feeling disconnected from the story on many occasions. As for the ending, I thought it was just ok. I’d recommend this for a easy beach or weekend read

Was this review helpful?

I like a good legal thriller so The Holdout by Graham Moore caught my eye. It ended up being more than that....

Maya Seale was the foreman on a contentious case - the murder of fifteen year old Jessica - by her teacher. The others jurors initially said guilty. But Maya swayed them - and he was found not guilty. Maya's experience with the court cemented her decision to become a lawyer. Another of jurors has been investigating the case since the 'not guilty' verdict. He's finally convinced a true crime series to make a documentary. A big part of it will be a reunion of the twelve. All well and good - until one of them turns up dead - and Maya is the prime suspect.

Every one of those jurors has secrets, both then and now. Moore deliciously ekes them out, flipping from present to past and back again. Each of the jurors is given page time. Though Maya is the lead character, I found I enjoyed some of the supporting players more than I did her.

With some plot developments, you'll need to take a few grains of salt - which I happily did. The legal aspects of the case were interesting and underlined how truths - and lies - can be manipulated.

Moore provides lots of twists as the story progresses. I thought I had the ending figured out, but one last aha! was an unexpected surprise. You get two mysteries for the price of one in The Holdout. An entertaining, escapist read for me.

Was this review helpful?

While I am reading a book I usually take notes to remind myself of both positive and negative things that stand out about a book. This time, I didn’t make a single note. I didn’t dislike the book, but it just didn’t make much of an impression on me. It wasn’t suspenseful, the characters weren’t likable, there were huge ethical lapses and the ending didn’t satisfy me at all. So I guess that’s my impression. I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.

Was this review helpful?

This is entertaining courtroom drama. In a sensational murder trial the jurors are sequestered in a LA hotel during the 4 month trial. Everyone on the jury except for Maya, knows the accused is guilty of the murder of a 15 year old girl. Maya is stubborn though, thus the title THE HOLDOUT. She convinces the others to acquit Bobby Nock of murder. Life is disrupted for the jurors. People hate them. The public has convicted the young teacher for murder. Maya goes on to law school becoming a defense lawyer. At a reunion of the jurors, she finds herself arrested for the murder of one of the jurors. The storyline goes back and forth between the trial and now. Maya’s lawyer wants to have her plead self-defense, but Maya pleads not guilty. She’s determined and when the real culprit is found, it is a shocker as well as how Maya has the charges against her dropped and the real murderer protected. Great read. At times I wondered if that is really how courtrooms and the legal system work, but I don’t have enough knowledge to do more than wonder. Whatever, the book is an interesting escape for the reader.

Was this review helpful?

Moore's twisty suspense novel follows the aftermath of one jury's decision to acquit an alleged murderer. Maya Steele, the jury's one original holdout, manages to convince the other jurors of the accused's innocence in a more modern "12 Angry Men"-esque story. When the jury reconvenes 10 years later for a TV reunion, one of them ends up dead and Maya morphs from juror to defendant. I didn't guess most of the twists in the story (which is always a very good thing!), and I appreciated how Moore tied up every single loose thread by the end of the book. The pacing also really helped to make this ultra-readable and I didn't ever feel bored (even when the chapters switched back and forth in time periods). My only issue was that there were only some brief chapters dedicated to certain juror's experiences in the trial - this ended up leaving me confused sometimes at which one was which. I think the ending would have been a tiny bit more powerful if I had been able to keep these side characters straight. Otherwise, I enjoyed the ride - and I'll definitely be willing to check out other titles from Moore in the future.

Was this review helpful?