Northwest Resistance

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date: 31 Jan 2020

Member Reviews

This series value is in its gorgeous artwork and dedication to excellent and educational storytelling. I continuosly recommend this to any teachers I work with and will be doing so with this newest title as well.
Was this review helpful?
The illustrations and graphic detail in this graphic novel are fabulous - the colours are so apt for the storyline and the characters have wonderful facial expressions.

I haven't read the first two volumes but that doesn't mean I couldn't read this as a standalone.

I enjoyed learning something about Canadian History as I am from the UK and it is not something I have ever learned about. The timeline at the end is useful but it would have been nice to have some more of that detail in the graphic novel itself. Well researched and thought provoking.

I didn't really engage with the main character though and the subject matter itself wasn't of massive interest personally.

Thanks to Netgalley and Highwater Press for this ARC.
Was this review helpful?
I have enjoyed the Girl Called Echo series. It follows Echo, who is Metis, as she time travels back and forth from the present day to the time of the Metis resistance. It reminds me of Kindred by Octavia Butler.
My biggest issue with the series is that the volumes are so short. It would be easier to follow if the author made each volume longer and spent more time with Echo in the present day. The author should also slow down the plot when she travels back in time. It's difficult to keep track of everything that's going on in the past. The author tries to compensate for this by providing a timeline at the end, but it is a huge information dump for such a short book.
I would love to see more of what is going on with Echo and her mother in the present day. After three volumes, I still don't feel connected to her character. She is more of a device that's being used to present the historical information, but her present-day issues are throwaway material.
I don't know much about the history of Canadian Indigenous people and I appreciate an owned-voices series that shows what they went through. Flaws aside, I think it is a great tool for teachers and recommend it to anyone who doesn't know about the Metis or Canadian Indigenous history.
Was this review helpful?
I'm not familiar with First Nations history in Canada so this was an excellent introduction to one of these stories. Perhaps it's because I haven't read other books in this series, but I didn't connect with the main character. The art is fantastic, though, and the history is told clearly and succinctly. I also appreciated the appendix of terms and dates in the back.
Was this review helpful?
This comic is a wonderful way to teach parts of history many people might have forgotten. To who that Canadain Indigenous people went through many of the same things that happen in America. It shows the history in a way that would be easy for a younger audience to understand, along with keeping their interest.  Though many places seemed very information drop, overall it is an amazing graphic novel.
Was this review helpful?
I would recommend that anyone looking to read this series actually read the entire three volumes because they are short and highly enjoyable! Informative and entertaining!
Was this review helpful?
[I was sent a copy of this comic on Netgalley in return for an honest review.]

'Northwest Resistance' is the third volume in the graphic novel series, 'A Girl called Echo'. It follows the main character (Echo) as she explores her heritage and the history behind The Settlers and the Canadian government.

Despite being only a short read, the comic is extremely well written and presents the story in both a captivating and interesting manner. We explore the history directly alongside the main character, and are given a more in depth understanding of how things may have turned out the way that they did.

I thought the artwork was beautiful and did a great job of conveying Echo's emotions, along with the story as a whole. The comic is perfect for both young and old readers as it is rather straight forward and easy to understand.

Overall, I thought the comic was very informative and I would definitely be interested to read the 4th volume when it comes out!

Rating: 4/5
Was this review helpful?
Educational, action-oriented, and ancestral historical fiction involving Louis Riel and the Metis and First Nations people...along with a young back-and-forth through time travelling 13 year old Metis girl. She's experiencing the strength and pain of her current and ancestral relatives. The graphic novel format for this story is geared toward teen readership, as both educational and to show the real life righteous struggles of the Metis and First Nations people in Canada. A worthy goal and an excellent story with good art.
Was this review helpful?
This text provides an accessible entry for students engaging in history related to Louis Riel and the Metis. The graphic novel format is engaging, and creates opportunities for students to work through image and text connections. I think based on my reading of it, it would be important to be read in series (as it seems to be intended) in order to understand the time-travel element that occurs. The time travel element does allow students to engage in the historical material in a way that asks, "what would it be like to be at important events when they happened?". One critique is that some dialogue comes across more like written language than spoken making it sometimes feel artificial to a reader.
Was this review helpful?
Thanks to NetGalley for providing a copy of this title!

Northwest Resistance is the third volume of the A Girl Named Echo graphic novel series, and like the first two volumes, is quite good. The story once again follows the titular Echo as she is transported mysteriously to the relevant time periods significant to Metis history. In this case the 1885 resistance. 
	Plot: Echo encounters Louis Riel and Gabriel Dumont at the outset and throughout the conflict, dropping in periodically such as at the Battle of Duck Lake. Weaving through the historical narrative is the contemporary one, Echo and her concern for her ill mother reflects the violent struggle of the Metis fighting for their rights. A major theme present in both is hope. Hope that things will improve and holding out hope under implausible odds.
	Setting: Physically, the story takes place in the prairie provinces (Saskatchewan, Manitoba mostly), while the time period jumps back and forth between the present day and 1885. 
	Characters: Echo is once again our protagonist, with several major and minor supporting characters including Echo’s own ancestors, and important Canadian historical figures like Louis Riel. The characterization is mostly broad, but well done. Echo herself is a little thinly drawn.
	 Final Thoughts: For a series that provides historical knowledge and context while attempting to tell its own narrative, you can do far worse than Katherena Vermette’s series.
	Recommended Grade Level: 7+
Was this review helpful?
As a Canadian teacher, I find the ‘A Girl Called Echo’ series particularly relevant for the classroom. This is the 3rd installment in a series about Echo Dejardins, a Métis youth living in the present day. Each book tackles a different aspect of Métis history (a subject that is often missing from many historical perspectives). Echo travels back in time to visit the time period each event occurred so the books jump back and forth between present and past.

This particular book focuses on The Northwest Resistance, an uprising against the Canadian Government led by the Métis. What I love most about these books is the sense of identity Echo is gaining as the books progress. Each time she learns about her heritage she discovers a piece of herself.

The graphic novel format is perfect for the classroom and provides an interesting way to look at Indigenous issues in a lens that is relevant for students.
Was this review helpful?
The third volume in the "A Girl Called Echo" series, this time readers (and Echo) are taken back in time to 1884-85. Following the Red River Resistance efforts that ultimately ended with the Canadian government making Metis land part of Canada, the Metis fled to and made their home in the North-West territory. However, more and more settlers are arriving and the buffalo are disappearing. The Metis are ready to once again make their stand against the Canadian government.

This graphic novel series is short, but incredibly well-done.  There is not only the amazing concept of teaching history through a graphic novel format, but the way that the main character--Echo--interacts with her history by literally allowing her to travel through time (the mechanics of which are never explained, and can honestly continue to be left to the imagination) as she makes friends to guide her through the time period. Echo's history teacher in the present also serves well as a sort-of narrator for certain parts, which well emphasizes that this event--just like the Pemmican Wars and the Red River Resistance--is part of Echo's past, present, and future as a Metis.

Again, this graphic novel series is phenomenal and I wish more like it existed: blending art, story-telling, and history together in a captivating way for readers young and old. I look forward to more books featuring Echo's time-travel escapades, especially with the little cliffhanger in Echo's present that we are left with on the very last page, the "To be continued..." dangling like a carrot on a stick.
Was this review helpful?