Skip to main content

Member Reviews

This book is exactly what it says on the tin - letters/poems the author is writing to younger iterations of herself - and yet it's exactly this that confused me while reading it and makes me not really know how to review it now.

First off, I'm unsure about how I feel about calling chopped-off sentences with no real rhyme or structure (yes, yes, free verse) poetry, but I do sometimes find them effective, both in this book and in general.

It was more the content that made me unsure of who this was meant for and where it was all going. The letters are sorted chronologically, but some of the earlier ones seem a bit too heavy to be messages to a 12-year-old girl (or maybe I'm just insensitive and underestimating kids?). They were deeply personal but also frustratingly abstract (is this a cop-out? or is it art?). They were, after a while, slightly repetitive, and uniformly depressing - and then, at later points in the book, extremely self-aware. ("my poems are all / starting to sound the same / they blur into each other")

And, somehow, that was what threw me off the most, that the author knew how she was coming across, supposedly to her younger self, but really to her readers, was aware of the weaknesses in her approach and chose to forge on without changing it.

It begs the question of who the book is for. There must be an audience for it, someone who, like the younger iterations of the author, really does need to hear that they are important in a hundred different varieties. I liked a handful of said varieties, but wasn't really the right audience for the rest.

Was this review helpful?

Such beautiful words! I feel like a lot of this is highly relatable to who I was in the past as well. I wish the file would have been able to be downloaded on my kindle, but I ended up being able to read it on my phone.

Was this review helpful?

This was very moving and an important read. I feel that things like this should be read by everyone, as it is one way to truly understand and connect with others. I loved everything about this.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you netgalley for providing the e-arc in exchange of an honest review.
This poem books was in way of a journal , and some of them are so raw that they make you feel the sadness. The book was short and good read. Do read it when it comes out next year!

Was this review helpful?

i don't know if i would call this a poetry book because its more like a self reflection journal. I felt there was struggle in this book because of how similar each poem was but i feel this book fits with the current authors coming out with poetry such as "Rupi Kaur" and even the title not having proper punctuations just like Kaur. this poetry didn't work for me but parts of it did show the authors pain and growth it just wasn't enough to save the book in my opinion

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes for this one.
Sadly, I couldn’t really get into the writing style of this book. Interesting and relevant topic and beautiful illustrations.

Was this review helpful?

Poetry is so hard to review and evaluate. It’s such a personal journey and if you’re not on the same journey or haven’t been on it it can often be difficult to understand and interpret. This is such a beautiful book of poetry however I think that anyone could relate or appreciate it.

Was this review helpful?

This is the new style of poetry that Rupi Kaur does so well. Sadly this one misses the mark. Without anything flowing like we are used to for poetry, they should be thought provoking and this poetry collection didn't do that for me. The writing was flat and lacked flow and style. It is such a heavy topic (self harm) but the collection didnt bring me in emotionally like it should have.

I found it difficult to read because of the childish font and the illustrations. They just didn't match.

Overall, this would be a pass for me.

Was this review helpful?

This is a poetry collection in the popular modern style of journal poetry, very self focused and not exceptionally poetic. The style of all of the poems was fairly similar, leading to a kind of run-on journal feel of it about the author's life. Little color sketches accompany some of the poems. Some readers may enjoy the poems because they relate to them, but it feels so personal that it doesn't feel relatable, yet it feels so impersonal that the reader doesn't feel much empathy either. Not a lot of poetic devices are used here, just free verse poetry about her life and unhappiness for the most part.

Trigger warning-- self harm. There are other minor triggers too, but this is a big one from the start.

I read a temporary digital ARC of this book for the purpose of review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed what this voice in verse had to offer in this collection. I’m glad to share good things about this book as a lover of poetry.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you, NetGalley and the publisher, for providing me with an advanced e-copy for an honest review.

TRIGGER WARNINGS: self-harm, suicide, abusive relationships, depression, and anxiety.

I had a weird experience ready this book because it’s the first time I’ve actually felt triggered while reading something, but I could relate a lot with the feelings presented on this collection especially those of the first and second sections. Still, I felt like the way it was written made feel the author detached from her own words and feelings. I did, however, loved the aesthetics (drawings and font) of the book. I feel that it sets it apart from most poetry collections.

Book's release date: February 25th, 2020 by Andrews McMeel Publishing

Was this review helpful?

I found the collection frustrating. It was deeply personal, yet somehow, it felt like the writer was detached from the writing. I’m not sure I’d even classify this as poetry, so much as stream of consciousness writing. There’s not really anything lyrical or poetic or groundbreaking about the writing. It’s just…fine.

I also found the aesthetics of this book rather distracting. The font choice made it difficult to read. The graphics were oversized and thus overwhelmed the writing. Overall, a miss for me.

Was this review helpful?

"This book is the way I say "You didn't break me", it's the way I look fear in the eye and tell it, 'I did what you said I couldn't, I did it, and I did it loud"

From it's very first lines, I knew I was going to like letters to the person I was. And it was the case. I fell in love with Sana's writing!
As a lover of words, I must say that I was impressed by the broad subjects she deals with in Letters to the person I was.
It is smart, beautifully writtend, and most of all: so true. The drawing are adding another dimension, more powerful to the poems.
The only thing I regret is the font: it is really uncomfortable to read!

Was this review helpful?

It's hard to put into words what this was like to read. Heartbreaking and healing. That last section of poetry was so good.

Was this review helpful?

You can feel the pain in this poetry collection. You can feel the humanness and the pain of being alive. It’s like Sana Abuleil has let her skin bleed bare and opens. There is bravery and connection in this openness. It is years and their feelings written out on a page. It is healing. The drawings are beautiful and charming, and they reflect the flashes of images shown in this reading process. If you want to be plunged into the pain of the past and the joy of the future, read this.

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this.

Was this review helpful?

For some reason the ebook version has multiple of the same page, but other than that I loved it. I think there always things we wish we could tell our younger selfs.

Was this review helpful?

Abuleil's way with words affected me deeply. I'm usually not that into poetry, but I really connected with quite a few of her poems. You can feel that what Abuleil writes about is deeply rooted in herself, and this vulnerability she's showing in her art is touching!

Was this review helpful?