Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Five college friends – and I use the term loosely – get together for a reunion weekend billed as a baby shower. For most of them they haven’t seen each other in years. Old grudges, hurt feelings, and jealousy are all emotions swirling within this little group and centered on the character who is hosting the shower at her lavish home. Those old hurts and jealousies run rampant from the first moment they are all together. One of them disappears after a drunken, drug-filled night. This is the premise of THE GIRLS WEEKEND.

The hostess, Sadie Mactavish, is a famous author, manipulator and control freak.
June Moody is a college professor who has just been dumped.
Kimiko is marijuana dispensary owner.
Amy is the pregnant friend and Em rounds out the crew.

I have to admit there wasn’t one character in the quintet that had any kind of redeeming value as a human. Each of them was annoying in their own way and I had a hard time feeling any compassion or empathy for any of them. The indiscriminate use of drugs and overabundance of alcohol throughout the book was another turnoff for me.

That said, the way the “mystery” evolves, and is told, is top-notch.

I was kept guessing until the last chapters about what happened. It is a very talented author who can take unredeemable characters and somehow weave a very effective, thoughtful and engaging story around them, so kudos to Jody Gehrman for that.

All in all, this was a good read. 4 stars from me and a thanks to Netgalley & Crooked Lane books for a look-see.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book and read through it in days, but felt that it wasn’t unique enough to stand apart from other thrillers/mysteries in the market.

The Girls’ Weekend is about a group of friends who get together after many years apart for a baby shower. The book’s protagonist June Moody initially opts our because of her long-standing competitive relationship with the host and her friend, Sadie, but decides to go after her boyfriend abruptly dumps her. Right from the start, it’s apparent that all of the women in the group have some sort of parent conflict with Sadie. So when she suddenly disappears after a night of debauchery, everyone is a suspect. To clear her name in the police investigation, Sadie must find out what really happened to her friend and that night that she can’t remember.

I liked that this story flowed well. It was easy to read and I liked the character of June Moody. Since she was a likeable character and Sadie was not, I was really rooting for her throughout the book. I also liked the premise and setting. It reminds me of Agatha Christie’s novels and had a really whodunit feel. The author also has a great sense of humour, which comes out in parts of the book.

But the book was a tad predictable in terms of who the perpetrator was. I also found it hard to believe all of the women were actually good friends. They just seemed to really hate each other and even though, the book made note of their history, I still didn’t buy that their friendship was that solid for them to have a reunion.

Overall I enjoyed reading this book though.

Was this review helpful?

Five college friends get together for a baby shower. One of them goes missing and no one remembers what happens. After a night of heavy drinking they wake up to find one of them missing and dried up blood in the house. They all draw a big blank on what happened.

As the story unfolds you suspect almost all characters at some point. With some clues here and there I did sniff out who did it pretty quickly, but with the twists and turns in the book I started doubting it. It was a thrilling read, didn’t bore me for one second. Some characters seem a little flat, but I think that is because it is told from one point of view.

Was this review helpful?

This book was good. A light read that had me guessing who the killer was. Towards the end it did fall a little flat but overall enjoyed the characters, the drama, the twists and back stories on why each character could have did it.

Was this review helpful?

From the first chapter I couldn’t put this down! I quickly found myself interested in these characters. Five college best friends come together for a fun weekend to celebrate ones pregnancy. But after a night of fun partying and drinking, they wake up to the house a mess and don’t remember anything. Were they drugged? And if so, by whom? Also, one character is missing. The character who seems to have pissed off each of the other characters in one way or another so everyone is a suspect or hiding something. This was a quick read for me, twisty and fun, and I enjoyed it a lot! There were secrets galore! Would definitely read more from this author in the future.

Was this review helpful?

I had doubts when I started reading this book that it could be anything other than petty jealousies from college carried over into adulthood, but I was proven wrong. This was an excellently crafted mystery with a surprising depth of character development. This is reminiscent of a classic mystery in which you're given cause to suspect every character and yet it's still a surprising end. I'm never a huge fan of throwing romance into a good mystery, but in this novel it wasn't overdone and so I have very little reason to argue against it.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls Weekend was an intense thriller about a fun weekend gone wrong. June has not seen Sadie, her college friend in years, when Sadie invites their group of 5 to her house for a reunion. She has not seen Kimiko or Amy in years either, but her relationship with them does not compare to the intense rivalry that has plagued June and Sadie's relationship. June begrudgingly decides to go at the persuasion of her friend, Em, who she does stay in touch with. The five girls arrive to Sadie's estate, hoping for a good time. But old tensions surface enough to make everyone uncomfortable. When the host, Sadie, is no where to be found one morning after a night of drinking, everyone in the house is a suspect. Everyone at the estate has possible motive, including the landscaper and Sadie's husband, Ethan. Did Sadie disappear on her own, or did something more sinister go down?

This plot was fresh, but also contained elements of a classic thriller that keep the reader guessing. I enjoyed June' character, but would have loved more detail into Sadie's life. Jodie Gehrman did a great job at putting together a conclusion that is sure to be a shock. This book contains some Gone Girl vibes, and the reader really does not know if the accident is real or orchestrated by the missing Sadie. A bit more character depth would have helped me get more engrossed and attached to the story.

Was this review helpful?

This novel really threw me for a loop. I would have bet my paycheck that the main character who went missing, Sadie, had set up her own disappearance in order to escape her life..... however, that wasn't the case. I don't want to give too much away, but suffice it to say, this was not the case. I had a hard time putting this down, and conversely, will have an easy time recommending this to others. Nothing like curling up with a twisty, atmospheric suspense novel on these cold North Georgia mountain nights!

Was this review helpful?

A decent read, and enjoyable. Not great but I finished it and didn't take any shortcuts. Engaging and interesting.

Was this review helpful?

What could possibly go wrong with a group of college friends get together for a reunion weekend? Well, in the case of The Girls Weekend by Jody Gehrman a lot. This was a wonderfully written and the author had a really engaging style that pulled me into the drama and the story. Old gripes and conflicts bubble beneath the surface and when something happens that changes the entire trajectory of the weekend the women find themselves trying hard to come together and make some sense of the mystery that is happening right before their eyes.
I loved this book and was excited to get an copy from NetGalley for review purposes. It was fabulous book with an author who knows how to write. Great suspenseful novel that will be hard for anyone to put down once they start reading it.

Was this review helpful?

Who wouldn’t enjoy a reunion of college girlfriends for a baby shower? Sadie invites everyone to her posh and exclusive San Juan Island home for just such.

Despite the tension prevailing that seems to have cultivated from years of distance between the five, the weekend starts out with fun-filled activities - a spa gathering, kayaking, and so on.

As the first day unwinds, the group partakes in wine and gin and tonics (minus pregnant Amy of course). Soon everyone retires for the night.

But trouble emerges when the gang awakes with strange ideas of what they did after they retired the night before. Add to the mixture that the host seems to be missing. Sadie’s car is gone but her cell phone is found on the garage floor.

Suddenly everyone realizes they are suspect because none are without a history with Sadie. Everyone has reason to possibly want Sadie out of the picture. Everyone is on edge. Everyone trusts no one.

Maybe Sadie’s perfect life wasn’t as perfect as it appeared from the outside.

What a wonderfully convoluted and “salty” mystery that kept me guessing until the very end.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A total page turner!
While the set up might not have been too original—a reunion of five college friends, buried secrets, a murder (or is it?)—this was compellingly executed.
Highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

This is a fun read, I loved the main character, June, the professor. Like many of us, beset with doubt, confusion and some jealousy of a friends' success. Dragged along with others of a college gang, the weekend was to celebrate an upcoming birth.
Once they all get together, it is clear that things are both the same and different. Old dynamics and new mistrust color how they get along, or don't.
When the beautiful,rich and impossible hostess disappears, suspicions and doubts about who is responsible tear them apart.
The final explanation for what happens makes sense and things wrap up pretty nicely.

Well written and a quick read, fun.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls Weekend by Jody Gehrman- bleh, I couldn't get through the first chapter of this book. The characters came off as self involved, ego- driven, and selfish. Gave up on this.

Was this review helpful?

The Girls Weekend by Jody Gehrman was a good read overall. Some of the scenes were heart-pounding and had me thinking about what I would do faced with similar circumstances surrounding a possible murder and being a suspect. The writing was good, and the development of the various unique characters was done well. There were times when I questioned some of the characters' actions and believability, but it didn't get in the way of my continuing the story. The plot and revealing of events had me questioning and guessing what may have happened on the night in question and had me going back and forth on who might have been guilty.

I thought the book might end in a Gone Girl style, but the ending and resolution, for me, was satisfying.

The Girls Weekend was a good mystery, and I like the overall story and the characters.

I would be interested in reading more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

A good thriller full of secrets and lies and even a murder. Perhaps not as good as the others out there but I great read

Was this review helpful?

A good all round 'whodunnit' lots of people with motives and secrets that keep spilling out as the book unfolds. It has the feel of an Agatha Christie where all the suspects are in one place and can't leave. I would mark it down for being able to guess where the ending was going and not having any massive twists but overall I would recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity to preview The Girls Weekend by Jody Gehrman. This is really a "chick book" and is set up with 5 women who knew each other in college. They all have their backstories, but this is led by the voice of one of them. Approaching 40 years old and reflecting on her life is June Moody. June is a college professor who has a reasonably decent life. But June has always felt inferior to one of her friends, Sadie, who not only took her boyfriend, but is now a successful writer.
So all five women meet at Sadie's mansion to catch up and celebrate each other's lives. But old feelings come up and soon after a night of drunkenness, Sadie has disappeared. But the clues are all over the place - blood, missing statues, and other clues that tell the women that something terrible may have happened. And since they are on a mansion with limited access, one of them may be responsible and one of them may be a murderer.
I got thru this book and some parts were good, however, I was disappointed in the dialog and ending. This was just ok for me.
2.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Five women were best friends in college and are now getting together for a weekend in WA state to celebrate the pregnancy of one of them. A lot of buried emotions hang in the air at this reunion, and that's complicated by the disappearance of one of the women, apparently accompanied by violence. But, no one else can remember what happened that night. This novel was a real page-turner, with each character having a good reason to hate her. Fast paced and a good read!

Was this review helpful?

I liked the book blurb and plot idea. the writing was ok and moved the reveal forward. There was just too much suspension of disbelief required. I finished the book but not sure why, I think I was intrigued by the possibility of a mother daughter plot line..

Was this review helpful?