Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I absolutely adored this story. It was great to get a glimpse into New York’s World Fair through the stories of Max and Vivian. Both women are strong and independent. They’re trying to solidify their places in their respective fields - Max as a journalist and Vivian as a film actress. Both wind up at the NY fair and their summer spent their changes their lives. I loved learning the history of the fair and getting fun little tidbits such as how pickle pins were very popular. This book dives into the biases against women during this time and I really enjoyed seeing Max and Vivian push against them and forge their paths. I would definitely recommend this for a fan of historical fiction.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the setting for this one-- the 1939 World's Fair! I had never realized how huge this fair was nor all the events. So I was immediately immersed into the world but the characters just fell a bit flat for me. I kept thinking that something really exciting would happen and, of course, there was a small twist but it was also very somber thinking about World War II and how these women's lives were just about to change. I would still recommend this if you love historical fiction. It's not my favorite genre and I think a book has to be spectacular in this genre to really grab me.

We Came Here to Shine comes out soon on June 16, 2020 and you can purchase HERE.

Vivi Holden would eventually realize that not getting what she wanted that day was the best thing that could have happened to her. But it was still early in Los Angeles. And the not-getting hadn't yet taken place.

Was this review helpful?

The 1939 World's Fair brings together a Hollywood starlet and a plucky up and coming reporter. 1. I love the word Plucky and hope that is how I'm described.

Vivi and Max (Maxine) are brought together by an equal right for women speech and develop a friendship as they both come to terms with the male dominated industries they are both in. This is a book of friendship, of female power and of the enduring spirit of women.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read and review this book.

Was this review helpful?

I liked that this book took me to a place in history I have not explored in a book before. Set during the World Fair held in New York in 1939, this story follows two women: Vivi, an aspiring Hollywood starlet and Max, an aspiring journalism student. They both end up in jobs they don’t really want at the World Fair, and in the process of working those jobs, discover who they really want to be.

I did not enjoy the writing style of this book. It felt a bit juvenile and static to me. Because of that it was hard to really get a feel for the characters. The character development lacked depth.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Susie Orman Schnall's Subway Girls, so I was excited to read We Came Here to Shine. And it did not disappoint! If you also liked her Subway Girls, I really think you'll like this one, too. I love how she takes a lesser known about real-life event and builds a fictional story about it. Of course, I know a little bit about the New York World's Fair, but I don't know very many details from the fair, nor have I heard any stories about what happened there.

We Came Here to Shine tells the stories of two girls who begrudgingly work at the fair. Vivi is a Hollywood actress sent to the fair by her agent to star as the lead swimmer in the Aquacade. Max is assigned to the fair's press office as her college internship, despite the fact she was really hoping to work for the New York Times. The two stories are told separately and then eventually become intertwined.

I wouldn't say this book absolutely blew my mind, but I did find it a super enjoyable read filled with strong women trying to make their way in 1930s New York. It's hard not to fall in love with both Vivi and Max, especially as you learn how dynamic their stories actually are. I feel like I got an insider's peek at the actual stories from the New York World's Fair, rather than just seeing pictures and learning about the history of the fair.

Schnall definitely has a knack for storytelling and I can't wait to see what she tackles next. Something tells me it will also cover strong females overcoming obstacles and making an impact on the world.

Was this review helpful?

My Two Cents: I was initially interested in We Came Here to Shine (and actually reactively received it from the publisher) because I previously read The Subway Girls and loved it! Author Susie Orman Schnall has a knack for finding little-known historic events and making them come alive so much so that readers like me subsequently spend hours looking back and researching the past just to get another glimpse at that time period.

I also love that Susie's characters are always headstrong young women coming-of-age in a man's world (at least from what I've seen and read so far). Max and Vivi were both relatable characters thrown together at the World's Fair of NYC in 1939, which neither of them expected or wanted to be tied to. While their friendship took off very quickly and would be difficult to cement in today's world, it made sense for the time period and wasn't forced. It was like a summertime friendship where you meet someone on vacation and become attached until the summer/vacation ends.

Vivi, in particular, was endearing to me. She had so much heart and kindness beneath the cliched actress facade. I loved her backstory and the way her connection to NYC was woven into the narrative. Her storyline - from finding out about her sister and family to discovering how her fiance coped with a false betrayal - was the highlight for me. Vivi's unfolding past and the journey she took to get to LA and back to NYC is what kept me rushing through some of Max's chapters to get back to Vivi's perspective.

Max, on the other hand, while still likable to an extent, rubbed me as selfish and judgmental. The way Max lashed out at anyone who didn't agree with her was not only surprising for the time, but also made her relationships less realistic. I can't imagine staying friends with someone who would be so mean and speak so poorly of someone who had simply expressed an opinion to help. The way she stormed out on her best friend and a guy she liked when she didn't initially get the internship she wanted was incredibly immature. I was a bit surprised when he continued to come back and hang out with her after a couple of these tantrums.

Max's character flaws didn't make me enjoy the novel any less. If anything, it's refreshing when a writer doesn't try to make the main characters all be the loving, likable heroines we're used to. It's unrealistic for every reader to relate to every protagonist and despite my aversions to Max, I would love to see a sequel following Vivi's life (or maybe even both Vivi and Max) after the World Fair. For now, I will just keep loving Susie Orman Schnall's take on historic events.

https://thebookbasics.wordpress.com/2020/06/02/we-came-here-to-shine-by-susie-orman-schnall/

Was this review helpful?

I loved this! At first, I wasn’t sure how it would go, but everything fell together perfectly. I love a strong and encouraging female friendship, and this gave me that. I loved seeing both women’s personal struggles in their personal and professional lives be overcome. Very inspiring and highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

4 stars... We Came Here to Shine is the first book I have read by Susie Orman Schnall I really enjoyed her writing. I found the characters to be fairly well developed. The setting of the Worlds fair was such a unique setting. Plus how many books do you read about old hollywood? I dont read a lot of them. I fell in love with Vivi's character. Max was a little harder for me to get into a groove with. I loved the little bits if mixed media in the form of news paper articles that are thrown in. All in all I think it was a solid place to start with this author.

Was this review helpful?

Star rating: 3.5/5
"Being a bold and determined girl is neither good nor bad. It depends on how you use it."

Summary:
Set during the 1939's World Fair in New York City, this unique piece of historical fiction addresses feminism, women in the workplace, and the value of friendship.
Vivi Holden is an up-and-coming movie star disappointed to be reassigned by her agent from a lead role in a movie to the World Fair's Aquacades. Max Roth is an aspiring journalist, equally disappointed to be assigned to the World Fair's publication for her summer job instead of the New York Times, as she had been hoping, and even more devastated to learn that she won't actually get to write any articles. The two women meet by chance at the festival and become fast friends. Though the two are very different, they are both dealing with the difficulties of being women working in male-dominated industries, and they help one another make tough decisions, stand up for themselves, and find their own way.

Review:
I can honestly say I've never read another book like We Came Here to Shine. I am a huge fan of historical fiction, and it was refreshing to find a piece that is not centered around a war. I also know very little about both the World Fair and water ballet, so I started out excited to learn more.
My first impression of this book was that it gave me serious Dirty Dancing vibes, but with water dancing, and with the focus being more on friendship than romance. I read this over a span of days with sweltering 90-degree-heat, so the parts that centered around Vivi's Aquapades made me want to be right there in the water next to her. I loved the descriptions of the fair - the attractions, the food, the important visitors, the grandiosity of it all.
However, this book fell short for me in a number of ways. I felt that the time period wasn't accurately portrayed - it often felt like a modern story plopped into 1939 with a few details changed. One of the reasons I tend to love historical fiction is the feeling of being immersed in a different era, and this book just didn't do that for me. Furthermore, many aspects of the plot simply felt unbelievable or unnecessary, like "Frank the Villain." Even Vivi and Max's friendship, which is arguably the whole point of the story, felt forced.
Overall, while fans of historical fiction may find the believability factor lacking. this book was a perfectly pleasant summer read and a truly unique story. I recommend We Came Here to Shine for fans of Kristen Hannah and Marie Benedict. Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the ARC - this book will be available to the public on June 16 2020!

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. The characters, the time period in which the book is set, the attention to detail and the storyline all made for a compelling read.

Was this review helpful?

#We Came Here to Shine #Net Galley

And "Shine" they did! Historical fiction with an intriguing story, what more could you ask? I very much enjoyed this pre-World War II, women pushing the way for equal rights, finding one's place in the world, and learning to stand up for what you want story. This book takes place at the New York World's Fair in 1939. The descriptive narratives made me check that fair on Google. It was a perfect setting. It has a wonderful lesson for young ladies, "listen to yourself, find out what YOU want, and go for it"!

Was this review helpful?

The Great Depression was ending and for those of us in the USA, war was just a story in the newspapers we did not want to read or talk about. Besides, something big was happening on both coasts. Hollywood was having one of its best years of film making in 1939; so many big hits that it would be remembered as its Golden Year. In New York, the 1939 World’s Fair was about to open at the end of April, with FDR giving the opening speech. The theme was the future and it looked bright with the official motto as: “Dawn of a New Day.” However, the more popular phrase, “The World of Tomorrow,” which labeled the exhibit and Pavilion areas, gained favor.

The story concentrates on two main characters: Maxine (Max) Roth, a young journalism student at NYU, about to be assigned to her summer internship with the rest of her predominantly male, class, which was quite normal for 1939. Over on the west coast in Hollywood, Vivi Holden, a young, new actress is about to begin her first day of filming a hot, new picture, sure to be up for many awards, when word comes down from studio heads that they’ve replaced her with someone else. Someone with more experience, someone more, ‘womanly,’ someone more believable in this role. Vivi is speechless and gobsmacked!

Max’s main rival in class gets assigned to the NY Times, she gets assigned to cover the World’s Fair for its own newspaper, “The Fair Today” a daily publication covering the goings-on at the Fair.
Vivi was offered a position to replace the star, Eleanor Holm, and swim with Johnny Weissmueller at the Fair’s Aquacade. What Vivi did not know at the time was how elaborate and popular this show was. The specially built amphitheater sat 10,000 people and involved hundreds of performers. It was a spectacular musical and water extravaganza with its own orchestra. It became the model for all those fantastic Hollywood movies involving swimming, think Esther Williams. (Sorry, I love this!)

So, back to our novel. Max does a marvelous job on the Fair’s paper, so much so, she turns up some juicy reporting as an amateur investigative reporter, benefiting the Fair. Overall, she impresses the Fair’s management, her teacher at NYU and her classmates.
Vivi is the true professional and good sport helping the show, Max and her sister (you’ll see) all in one summer.

Combined with history, a World’s Fair, and great storytelling you cannot miss the entertainment value of the book. I adored it and recommend it.

Note: Some of the buildings from the 1939 Fair were saved and used for the NY 1964-5 Fair, held at the same exact location: Flushing Meadows, Queens, NY. I knew some things looked familiar! Especially the life-size globe in the center!
Susie also wrote The Subway Girls

Thank you Netgalley, St. Martin’s Griffin, and Susie Orman Schnall

Was this review helpful?

This was my Memorial Day read. I really enjoyed learning about the 1939 World Fair in New York. The descriptions of the exhibits, the restaurants and the amusement zone drew me back in time and was the perfect escape for the weekend.

I also really loved the two main characters and the peek inside old Hollywood, synchronized swimming extravaganzas and the male dominated world of journalism. The two women were perfectly characterized and I loved discovering their friendship and their ultimate life outcomes.

There is a little love, a little mystery and a whole lot of pushing back against the male dominated work worlds.

#NetGalley #WeCameHeretoShine

Was this review helpful?

Schnall as always transforms you into another time, what we thought was a simpler time, but not everything is as simple as it appears from the surface. Schnall is able to bring the beauty of the era to you so clear. If you love historical fiction and being taken to a simpler time then you will need to get this one!

Was this review helpful?

A great book on the power of friendship and strong bond. For those who feel that no matter how hard you try there are always some obstacles, read this book and grow strong.

Was this review helpful?

Vivi and Max are unlikely friends. They both end up working at the World’s Fair in NYC in 1939. They have very different struggles in their positions, and work hard to reach their dreams. The story development is a little slow at first but then the book is a very enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

We Came Here To Shine is the inspiring story of two women who challenged the role and limited expectations of women in the 1930's. Inequality in the workplace was common with all prestigious jobs held by men. Women who dared speak of the disparities were viewed as disgruntled employees and most often dismissed. The title "We Came Here To Shine" says it all . . . Vivi, an aspiring actress, and Max, a journalist intern, are intent on confronting and conquering a misogynistic world to shine brightly on their own merits. Under circumstances beyond their control, both women find themselves "demoted" to work the 1939 World's Fair in their respective professions for the summer. Both are ambitious, tenacious, and optimistic. Both determined to take control of their own destiny by challenging their designated roles in a male-oriented society. When the two women cross paths, they recognize something in each other and a bond of sisterhood forms. The story that unfolds is told through alternating chapters and points of view as these two women join forces, daring to reach for the stars.

Readers are transported back in time to the vibrant 1939 World's Fair in We Came Here To Shine. Schnall's historical details and descriptive passages engage all five senses with all the excitement and anticipation associated with this place and time in history. You can see and feel the sense of awe and wonder on fair-goers faces as they enter this new magical place. The story progresses at a steady pace as readers watch both women persevere and grow stronger in their purpose. The plot line focuses mainly on these two women and their journey to be recognized as equals and reach seemingly unachievable goals. Fans of historical fiction will love We Came Here To Shine. Highly Recommended!
3.5 Stars

Was this review helpful?

I loved Susie Orman Schnall's Subway Girls, so I was excited to read We Came Here to Shine. And it did not disappoint! If you also liked her Subway Girls, I really think you'll like this one, too. I love how she takes a lesser known about real-life event and builds a fictional story about it. Of course, I know a little bit about the New York World's Fair, but I don't know very many details from the fair, nor have I heard any stories about what happened there.

We Came Here to Shine tells the stories of two girls who begrudgingly work at the fair. Vivi is a Hollywood actress sent to the fair by her agent to star as the lead swimmer in the Aquacade. Max is assigned to the fair's press office as her college internship, despite the fact she was really hoping to work for the New York Times. The two stories are told separately and then eventually become intertwined.

I wouldn't say this book absolutely blew my mind, but I did find it a super enjoyable read filled with strong women trying to make their way in 1930s New York. It's hard not to fall in love with both Vivi and Max, especially as you learn how dynamic their stories actually are. I feel like I got an insider's peek at the actual stories from the New York World's Fair, rather than just seeing pictures and learning about the history of the fair.

Schnall definitely has a knack for storytelling and I can't wait to see what she tackles next. Something tells me it will also cover strong females overcoming obstacles and making an impact on the world.

Was this review helpful?

Wow it is so nice to read a historical fiction book that is NOT about the war or any affiliation with it. I have loved Susie Orman Schnall's previous books and this one in my opinion is another best seller!!!!!!!!! Her style of writing truly makes you fall in love with the character's and I absolutely love the narrative perspective she added little tidbits of into this story. We have Max & Vivi, two young women living in the 1930's trying to make it in a man's world. Both of them in their different careers feeling the impact that being a man had bck in those days. We follow them along in their career journey as they show that they have what it takes and stick it to the men in their careers who they to hold them back. Thank you to Netgalley and St. Martin's Griffith for my honest review

Was this review helpful?

I love reading books set in this time period. The glitz and glamour are always lovely to imagine. This novel about strong females and friendship was delightful to immerse in. I didn’t enjoy it as much as Subway Girls but it was a fun read nonetheless. Nothing “big” really happens so the plot kind of puttered along. Reading about the Worlds Fair was fun and I enjoyed the facts and behind-the-scenes glimpses. Overall, this was a fun read featuring strong, likable female characters and a unique setting. 3.5 ⭐️. My thanks to the publisher for the gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?