Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Anything that has to do with Paris I have to pick up! But this book kept me interested! I never knew about these important people keeping the library open during ww2. And how they put their lives at risk for their Jewish patrons. I loved the characters and this heart warming story. So important! A must read. Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity!!

Was this review helpful?

It's 1939 and Odile is working at the American Library in Paris while her twin, Remy, goes off to war. Besides Odile, most of the characters in the earlier time line are real people, or based on real people. (Make sure you read the author's notes at the end, they are fascinating). As we move through Odile's life in Paris during the war, we switch back and forth with Lily, a teenager in Montana in the 1980s. Lily is struggling with bullies, teenage angst, crushes, and family issues, but is fascinated by the widow next door who no one really knows. While some might find the switching between timelines distracting, I really enjoyed getting a glimpse into how Odile's life moved on and changed after the war. And, I found Lily's story to be relatable, too.

I love strong female protagonists and Odile, though flawed like all of us, is a strong woman. She's surrounded by mostly strong women and it was a pleasure to see them relate to and overcome the horrors of war. I also loved that they were all flawed and real, too. Everyone made mistakes, some learned, some did not. The same is true with Lily and the women she is surrounded with in Montana.

One thing that I expected that never materialized was more focus on the horrors of war. There were really no graphic descriptions of violence/gore, mistreatment of others (with two exceptions near the very end of the book), or lengthy scenes of suspense related to the Nazis. This book really wasn't focused on the war itself or the Nazis, but more on the library and their efforts to carry on service and on Odile and her life. It was actually refreshing since many historical fiction novels lately seem to focus on the brutality of war.

I definitely recommend this to fans of historical fiction, literary fiction, strong female protagonists, and good descriptive writing. I wasn't blown away, but I thoroughly enjoyed reading it.

Disclaimer: I received a free electronic copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley.com in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The Paris Library by Janice Skeslien Charles, is a dual time line historical fiction.

Paris: 1939: Odile Souchet has her dream job, working at The American Library in Paris. Her family would love to see her married, but her priority, is to be self-sufficient. Times are difficult, especially with the prospect of war. At least Odile's job at the library, allows her to take refuge in her one true solace, books. When squabbling with her parents or her beloved twin brother, books always provided a means of escape, and the American Library in Paris provided a like minded community.

Froid, Montana: 1983: When Lily decides to do a school project focusing on Paris, she rings the doorbell of her lonely neighbour Odile. After the 3rd ring, Lily wanders in through the unlocked door. Lily and Odile, both lonely, become quick friends.

As the story alternates between Odile and Lily, the author describes the heroic efforts made by the community at The American Library in Paris to help its subscribers, as Paris fell under German occupation. Much of the story is based on fact, little known by most of us, but researched in depth by author, Janet Skeslien Charles. Those of us who frequent libraries often, know how they are actually mini "communities", a place where the librarians (and all the staff), become our friends. They are also places to meet up with friends, and of coarse, places with just the book we are looking for. The American Library in Paris was just this place, but what was remarkable, was that the people that worked there during the war, placed themselves at great risk, and the author wanted people to know this little documented part of history.

Interestingly, at one point in the novel, the author describes what it was like in Paris, just as France fell to Germany, before the Germans actually invaded Paris. The way the author described the uncertainty of the future for the people of Paris, sounded almost like the uncertainty we are facing today, with the cover 19 pandemic:

The city of Paris ... "turning to a ghost town. Could the Germans get this far? Even the generals did not know. Maybe that was the most frightening - we didn't know what would happen."

As our cities and downtown centres turn to ghost towns, perhaps we could relate to the fear the Parisians felt back in 1940. I certainly felt this description was more real to me now that our cities have become ghost towns and we face incredible uncertainty.

Thank you #netgalley and Janet Skeslien Charles for giving me the e-ARC of #theparislibrary, in return for my honest review. I highly recommend reading it! On book shelves June 2nd, 2020.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve been reading a lot of historical fiction about the Nazi reign in France lately, but this one had a unique storyline that I enjoyed.
The Paris library is a story centred around Odile who worked at the American library in Paris before and during the war. What I liked about this book was that it really humanized regular citizens throughout the war and really showcases real struggles that they had. Odile faces many different types of struggles such as sending her families only rations for the week to her brother at war, delivering books from the library to Jewish people, determining what she can and can’t say to her police officer father and fiancé. The list goes on. This book has a major twist at the end that will definitely stir up some emotions. If you like historical fiction, you’ll definitely like this one! 4/5⭐️

Thank you to Atria books & Net galley for the advanced reader copy. This title is released June 2nd 2020!

Was this review helpful?

“Grief is a sea made of your own tears. Salty swells cover the dark depths you must swim at your own pace.”

Lily feels lost in the aftermath of her mother’s death and her father’s marriage to another woman just a year later. She then gains two brothers in quick succession and starts helping more at home than being with her friends. A neighbor, Odille, has taken a liking to Lily and starts giving her a place of sanctuary at her house where she can learn French and vent about her life. Odille is a Frenchwoman who married an American soldier at the end of WWII. As Lily opens up, she wonders what Odille’s story is and why she never talks about the family and friends she left behind in Paris.
I received an email about The Paris Library from NetGalley and requested an advance copy to read. All they ask in return in a fair review. The storyline looked promising as I love historical fiction and it was focused on the American Library in Paris during WWII.
The Paris Library flashes back to give the story of Odille who applies to work at the American Library in Paris before the war starts. She wants some independence after seeing her aunt be ostracized after divorcing a cheating husband. Her father, the police commissioner, brings home a new potential suitor once a week, but Odille has not interest. Her twin brother, Remy, is not being pushed to marry. Their world quickly changes as German troops approach France and eventually get to Paris. Remy enlists, Odille splits time between the library and the hospital and her father must abide by the German’s new laws. As Odille falls in love with a policeman, Paul, she starts seeing that their world isn’t simple and betrayal can happen in just a few words.
The Paris Library is a captivating read, especially since it’s historical fiction based on real people who worked at the American Library in Paris and kept it open during the entire occupation of Paris. There are rumors that the library was a possible hiding place of some Jewish patrons. The books gives a glimpse into an important part of what happened in Paris during WWII and will leave a reader wondering what they would do in Odille’s shoes.

Was this review helpful?

I love WWII stories, and as a former librarian, of course I love libraries as well, so this was a novel I couldn't pass up. I love the fact that so much of the story revolved around the American library in Paris; it was so fascinating to see how the library operated and to get glimpses of the patrons and employees. I also loved how the book took place in two time periods, and how Odile tried to pass along some things she'd learned to Lily--and how Lily also imparted some wisdom to Odile. The writing has an elegance to it that makes me wish I were more eloquent; while I'm hopelessly blunt American in my language, I adored the graceful French feel of the book. The characters in the book were realistic, with both virtues and flaws, and while I wish it were possible to dig deeper into some of their backstories, what I did get to see of them made me want to scoop them off the pages and bring them into my life. They're also the sort of characters you desperately want to discuss with someone, so this is definitely a book to share with friends and book clubs!
4.5 stars.
I read an ARC provided by the publisher via #NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

The cast of diverse but likeable characters in this WWII story reminds me very much of the Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Society. What brings this motley group together is the American Library in Paris. It's their refuge.

Odile desperately wants to work at the library. She's memorized most of the Dewey Decimal System and even thinks in Dewey! Quite frankly, she doesn't need the job because her father is a good provider but books are in her blood. She soon adopts the "regulars" as her family and feels more at home at the library than with her own family, except for her brother Remy. However, their idyllic life is about to be shattered beyond recognition with the arrival of the Nazis, especially Odile whose youth and inexperience will prove to be her greatest challenge.

The story alternates between WWII Paris and Montana in the 1980's. Odile has retreated into herself but a young teenage neighbour girl has decided that Odile needs to start living again. She wants French lessons. Odile recognizes a younger version of herself in Lily and the two form a bond that will prove to be invaluable to them both.

A WWII account that is different from the rest.

Was this review helpful?

When I started this book, it was with a sense of been there, done that. We've seen a lot of WWII historical fiction with current day characters learning about events and people and alternating past and present throughout. But, WWII is my jam and and libraries are, too, so I gave it a try and was pleasantly surprised by The Paris Library.

This is Odile's story - she's a Parisienne who works in the American Library in Paris as the Nazis invade and occupy the city. Her brother joins the army and is captured. Her fiance is on the police force and is pretty much doing the Nazis' bidding - which only escalates as the occupation continues.

The reader is introduced to the many characters who work at or are patrons of the library. They are the everyday sparks of joy (and sometimes sadness) in Odile's life.

The present day is actually the 1980's in Montana. Odile is a widow living in a small town that has pretty much just left her alone. Her neighbor is Lily, a motherless teen who decides to get to know Odile and learns about herself in the process.

My thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an advanced reader's copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thoughtful novel with a dual timeline, telling the story about a librarian during WWII, and flash forward to Reagan-era as she teaches a young girl French.

Was this review helpful?

What an interesting story about librarians and life in Paris during WWII. Think it's only for librarians? Not at all! The story keeps you involved in the lives of Lily, Paul, Margaret, Boris and all that visit the library in times of uncertainty.

Was this review helpful?

The Paris Library is a book lover's dream. It's not a fast paced page turner, but it's rich in well developed characters, varied relationships, questions, life lessons and history. I loved Odile, her library team and her book references with Dewey decimal connections. She is human and flawed but a wonderful teacher and companion years later for a lonely teenager she meets, Lily.

In the author's notes at the end, we learn Janet Skeslien Charles actually worked at the American Library in Paris and was inspired to write this story from her time there, the people she met and the records she came across.

Advanced reader copy courtesy of the publishers at NetGalley for review.

Was this review helpful?

I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of “The Paris Library”. compliments of Net Galley, Janet Skeslien Charles, and Atria Books, in exchange for my honest review.
I have to begin with this…. I LOVED reading this book!!!
Odile Gustafson is an elderly widow living in a small town in rural Montana. The townspeople know that she arrived after World War II as the wife of a local young man who had been stationed in France during the war.
Lily, the teen-aged girl who lives next door, has always been curious about Odile. A school project, to write a report about France, provides an opportunity for Lily to learn about her neighbor while obtaining first hand information about France.
This story travels between 1940’s Paris and 1980’s rural Montana. It is a story of love, family, friendship, loyalty, fellowship, feat and forgiveness.
It is a story about books, the love of reading, and The AmericanLibrary in Paris, a wonderful sanctuary for the book lovers and readers of Paris.
Odile felt incredibly fortunate to have been employed at the library. She loved all of her co-workers and the wonderful group of loyal patrons who regularly visited the library.
Miss Reeder, the director of the library, and an American (she was a real person!), was committed to maintaining the purpose of the library, despite the Nazi invasion of France and the swarms of Nazi soldiers who had infiltrated Paris.
Several of the friendships and the experiences of the time period shaped and influenced the life of Odile…
As the bond between Lily and Odile strengthened, Odile shared many of her own experiences. Her goal was to prevent Lily from making some of the same mistakes she made. There are some things that Odile will never share though…. Private experiences during the war have caused her much pain.
Love and deceit can occur no matter the place or time. Whether in Paris during WWII or small town Montana during the 1980’s, it is possible. But, forgiveness…is it just as possible?
Prepare yourself to experience the wide range of emotions that accompany this story.
I loved this book!!!

Was this review helpful?

This book focuses on the American Library in Paris during WWII, but specifically the relationships of the people who work there and the regulars. It is based on some real people. I kinda wish books would mention that at the beginning instead of the end because when I read the postscripts about being based on real people and/or events, it gives the book an even deeper meaning for me.
I rush to pick up any book that mentions libraries or bookstores in the title and this one is a strong read if you are into relationships. It doesn't really delve as deep into the nitty gritty of WWII.

Was this review helpful?

As I expected, this book was kind of a mash-up of two books that I’ve read in the last several years and enjoyed: Lilac Girls (for the experience of everyday girls during WWII) and The Giver of Stars (plucky ladies share the love of reading despite all odds).

I felt that the author here did a great job jumping between “modern” day (the 1980s, which made sense as a time frame for Odile to be the right age) and WWII times. I really liked how the author wrote Lily, the 1980s teenager, because she seemed way more like a realistic teenager than you often find in books.

As can be expected in a WWII book, there are a couple of scenes toward the end of the book that are hard to read because of the violence. If someone doesn’t cope well with violence, I wouldn’t necessarily shoo them away from this book - the violence is not ubiquitous and passes fairly quickly.

It was interesting reading about the experiences of normal people in Paris during WWII while being self-isolated due to the Coronavirus pandemic. It gave me some perspective for sure. People have endured much worse at many points in history.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author and the publisher for a complimentary ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this book but it was just alright for me, I loved the story of the Paris Library and its role during WWII. The characters in the library were all very vivid and real and Odile’s story was heartbreaking. It was the modern day parts of the book that just had me a bit bored. I found it hard to get through. It did all come together in the end but getting there was a bit of a push.

Thanks to Netgalley and Atria books for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

This book was an interesting one for me. I dream of going to Paris someday and I am a librarian, so the premise had me immediately. However, it did take some time for me to really get into the story (at the start I found the jumps to 1980s Montana to put me a bit off-balance). The middle had me engaged as France got closer and closer to war, and then again the final 20% of the book (I read this ARC on my Kindle) took a sharp left turn that left a bad taste in my mouth. A great addition for a public library and an incredibly atmospheric read, however not one for my personal library as I felt it was a borrow, not buy.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve somehow been drawn to books about Paris during World War II lately and not sure why. However, as a book worm, a book about a library during the war was fascinating. It was good but also sad and seemed like it had a lot of repetition. I’m glad that Odile got away but sad for her too. She had to leave everyone behind and not able to get back but love how she bonded with her young neighbor and became such a confidant for her. I hope the author writes more!

Was this review helpful?

Not just another World War II novel, the Paris Library is a tribute to those who tried to keep their patrons reading at the American Library in Paris. After the war in 1980s Montana a touching relationship evolves between Odile who worked at the library and Lily, a young girl who has lost her mother. Odile guides Lily during her teen years as she navigates her relationship with her father and stepmother.

Was this review helpful?

The Paris Library
Janet Skeslien Charles
June 2 release

Four Stars, but I’d give it Five Stars if . . .

The Paris Library is a fictional tribute to the amazing librarians who kept the American Library open during World War II Nazi-occupied Paris. Putting their freedom at risk, the staff continued to include and care for their Jewish subscribers banned from the library.

The novel moves between WW2 in Paris, and the 1980s in Montana, USA, and is primarily told from two points of view. The first is french Odile's, a young Parisian woman working at the library during the war and later living as a widow in Montana. The second viewpoint belongs to Montana-born, Lily, a young girl grieving the loss of her mother and life as she knew it. When the older woman's and the young woman's lives finally intersect, their unexpected friendship helps them learn, heal, and grow together.

This novel is character-driven rather than plot-driven, but with one small change, it could be both. If the publisher would move Chapter 47, Odile's Birthday in 1983, to the beginning of the book, I would have been hooked immediately and known what and why I was reading The Paris Library, and I would have read it much faster. I beg the publisher to make this change so that some readers will not prematurely give up on Odile and Lily. With this small change, it would be five-stars, no doubt.

The Paris Library is a thought-provoking read that reminds us about the importance of friendship, honesty, and compassion during chaotic and life-threatening times. Without friendship, honesty, and compassion, we risk becoming who and what we hate. The Paris Library is a superb choice for fans of The German Girl and Lilac Girls.

I was given a complimentary copy of The Paris Library in exchange for a fair and honest review. I will wait to share my review elsewhere until the book is fina and released. Thank you, Atria Books and Janet Skeslien Charles for the opportunity to read The Paris Library in advance.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was great. I like that the author used real people and events to tell this story. Obviously the main characters are fictional, but a lot of the minor characters were real people. I thought this was really well researched. The story itself was compelling. The underlying theme is betrayal and forgiveness, both of yourself and others. I thoroughly enjoyed it and I definitely recommend it.

Was this review helpful?