Cover Image: Lois Lane and the Friendship Challenge

Lois Lane and the Friendship Challenge

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

I was so excited to see a Lois Lane graphic novel being added to the DC Zoom line-up. Unfortunately, I didn't really like this as much as I expected to. Lois was rather annoying and unlikeable at times. I do think it's a good starting point for more Lois graphic novels, especially with the ending. The art is the highlight of the book! It's bright, fun, colorful, and extremely engaging.

Was this review helpful?

Oh how I wanted to love this. I mean? A graphic novel about young Lois Lane written by Grace Ellis and illustrated by Brittney Williams? Yes, please! Sadly...it's just kind of mediocre. Lois was actually pretty unlikable for most of the book. I mostly enjoyed it otherwise, but seeing as Lois is literally the titular character, having her be unlikable is pretty unfortunate. I will still purchase for my collection, because I think kids will check it out, but it's definitely not a necessary purchase.

Was this review helpful?

I'm tired of reading about crappy friendships where one friend treats the other friend like crap. I applaud the addition of a Black women but other than that I didn't care for this book at all.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel was a great insight to a young modern Lois Lane. The premise of this book is about friendship, and the pitfalls of popularity. Young Lois wants to be the next viral sensation, but her best friend just wants to get ready for camp. You'll enjoy this cute story and get a look at how Lois got into Journalism.

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes going into this because I like what DC has done with Wonder Woman middle grade comic. This is not good though! Lois Lane is a terrible friend, a bully, and just an overall turd! She steamrolls everyone in her life and treats people who care about her like crap. It was honestly really hard to read!

I give the writing one star, but I can’t rate the book overall that low because I really like the illustrations by Brittney Williams. The characters are really expressive and fun, and literally ever scene with people in the background looks like a real community and not just some cut and paste (white) faces. I love how she drew Henri, especially her fashion. The character wears a blue and black polka dot jumpsuit at the end which is absolutely *chef’s kiss* incredible. I honestly felt really bad for most of the characters because they have to put up with such a horrible (fictional) person.

I definitely will not be recommending this to the kids at my library. I don’t want anyone to think that this is an ok way to treat people!

Was this review helpful?

The character Lois is a real know it all, and that's exactly what I'd expect from her. The friendship conflict was a little too much (but I can honestly imagine 10 year olds doing the same thing). It has a similar cheesiness as the Babysitters Club. The mystery could have been a lot better planned out.This book would be good for 3-4 grade students.

Was this review helpful?

It's the first day of summer vacation, and thirteen-year-old Lois Lane has the perfect plans for how she and her best friend will spend their time - if only Kristen weren't going away to dreaded summer camp. So when the fireworks for the annual bike race go missing and Kristen decides they should put on their detective caps, Lois gets a little carried away. Will she be able to salvage their friendship, make amends for her wrongs, AND figure out who stole the fireworks before it's too late?

While Lois wasn't necessarily the most lovable character - she had a big problem with listening for 99% of the story - she was extremely real and relatable, someone I think a lot of young readers are going to connect with. Fans of Grace Ellis will recognize some "tropes" of her tales: friendship, conflict, strong female leads, a fun mystery. But there's more here, too, as Grace provides kids with an especially important lesson about letting the facts inform the story rather than our own biases. Plus, in a surprising twist for readers who recognize Lois' name, there are no super heroes here (though there IS some super advanced, super cool technology).

All told, a great summer read for fans of Shannon Hale, Raina Telgemeier, and Victoria Jamieson - among many other greats of GN realistic fiction.

Was this review helpful?

A very sweet graphic novel! I love the tiny nods to the larger DC universe, but I also love that it was very much its own modern friendship story.

Was this review helpful?

Very cute, fun origin story of Lois Lane, reporter. It is definitely for a younger audience and feels like lower middle grades. I do not see my 8th graders really loving this, but I think I could rope in a few 7th graders.

Was this review helpful?

An adorable middle grades graphic novel featuring future ace-reporter, Lois Lane. Lois is on a quest to film the perfect friendship challenge video, before her best friend leaves her for sleep away camp. When a mysterious theft, a rival business, and new girl in threaten her plans, she has to put aside her feelings to save the fireworks. Lois is likable, relatable 13 year old girl- she feels things deeply, protects her friendship, and wants to be a social media star. This book will be a big hit in any middle school classroom. I know I will be adding it to my own.

Was this review helpful?

When I saw the synopsis for this book I was so excited. Having always been a fan of superheroes and comics, I am always looking for new stories to share with my kids and students. While I love how quick this book was to read, along with the illustrations and the idea for the story, overall I feel like it missed the mark. I found Lois to be annoying (in a little sister way) instead of enduring. I was hoping her character would come across as being more mature. With that being said, I found it difficult to connect to the character. I know that this is Lois as an adolescent, but I would have liked to seen her grow more as a character within this book.

Was this review helpful?

Quick read with great illustrations. It definitely ended with room for a sequel. I am looking forward to reading more!

Was this review helpful?

I have been a big fan of the other DC graphic novels that have come out. That being said, I found this one disappointing. I loved the artwork, including the coloring and character design, but I could not relate to the Lois character. I found her hard to relate to and annoying for a large part of the book. While it was a fun and sweet story, there were just a lot of parts that fell flat for me. I do still have readers who will like the characters, art, and story, but it was not really for me.

Was this review helpful?

I think I would have enjoyed this book more if I wasn't already such a big Lois Lane fan. It's cute seeing her as a kid, but she doesn't feel like the character I know and love. It would be a fun book if it weren't about LOIS LANE, but instead some other unrelated character, but it isn't, and unfortunately, that makes it harder for me to enjoy. Still a fun read, but not one that will satisfy people who already love the character.

Was this review helpful?

What in the Hades did this author do to Lois Lane. This is Lois Lane as a middle grade student. I hate her. She's whiny, she's obnoxious, and she's a terrible friend. I know all kids grow up to be different people. There's lots of canon of Lois Lane and her adventures with Superman but this as a start off tale sucks. Lois Lane is way too involved in her phone. She has a vidme channel which is like YouTube, and she's so concerned about winning this online contest and how many hits she gets Etc. I find it disgusting. The artwork is well done which is the only thing that makes the story likable but Lord knows if you want to continue the series get a different author. Lois Lane has never been my favorite character but this just eweeee. I would not suggest this book for anybody. We have enough brats in our current society; we don't need our kids to read about them.

Was this review helpful?

Good but not great. Illustrations were wonder...eye-catching and expressive. The story fell a bit flat for me, though. I couldn’t keep up with the young impulsive Lois Lane and the plot of stollen fireworks seemed contrived. The whole tone of the book was angry, which does portray preteen girls; however, was draining to read.

Was this review helpful?

Bold, eye-catching graphics, but the story of a bike race, stolen fireworks and a friendship that is having a few hiccups is rambling and main character Lois Lane is so flighty and bounces from activity to activity so fast that I could barely make it to the end. Resolution was complete and not 100% predictable so coupled with the great artwork and the fact that graphic novels fly off most school library shelves, this one would find readership. Content is free of any red flags. Thanks for the dARC, NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book. The artwork is great. It's a quick, enjoyable read that would be great for older elementary aged kids and middle schoolers. There are great messages about priorities, friendship, and being considerate of others.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and DC Comics for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

This is another perfect addition to the DC Zoom series. Not only is the artwork vibrant and wonderful, it captures the meaning of friendship and making mistakes along the way while growing up. I also loved the mannerisms of Lois Lane! Really captured her personality to a tee!

Was this review helpful?

I wasn't sure what to expect of this but I thought it was a great contemporary take on Lois Lane as a younger version of herself. The illustrations and book are super engaging and the plot would appeal to my young readers. It helps for students to see these real world situations of friendships and challenges that are universal in this format. I will be purchasing this for our library collection.

The publisher generously provided me with a copy of the book upon request on NetGalley. The rating, ideas and opinions shared are my own.

Was this review helpful?