Skip to main content

Member Reviews

I requested this book on a whim, to be very honest and before I even realised that there was a huge hype over this – which meant that I went in without any expectations hanging over my head.

Which is EXACTLY WHY I fell in love with the book – I actually spent the whole day reading it because I found myself invested in Luc and Oliver’s romance!

Luc, with his absentee Rockstar father who is now making a comeback – has made paparazzi all the more interested in Luc’s not so exciting life! Case in point – his photo being clicked just at the wrong time and taken out of context means that he will lose his job unless he shows that he is in respectable mature relationship.
With his friends in tow; and eccentric co – workers, he hatches a plan to get himself a fake boyfriend – just so that his charity fundraiser will go smoothly and wit irritating negative press for him and the charity he works for.
The only candidate he can find is the staid, intelligent friend of a friend, Oliver, who has already refused his advances in the past and who he knows is totally wrong for him – and thus, he knows that it would be the perfect solution, not just for him but apparently for Oliver too!

This was a slow burn romance between two individuals who look like they are only superficially broken; but have deep seated issues that seem to come between them and successful romantic relationships – and when I say slow burn; I do mean a while lot of slow burn; because Luc and Oliver do take their time to find themselves falling for each other!

Hilarious banter, opposites attract romance that could have been made only better with Oliver’s PoV!

Was this review helpful?

Review: Boyfriend Material by Alexis Hall // Or, Fake Your Way Into A Relationship

★★★★☆ | Yes, I love the tropes

❤️ m/m fake relationship
❤️ opposites attract & hate to love
❤️ “we’re so different but are we really??”
❤️ emotional baggage

ARC received from NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Luc O’Donnell is a messy, anxious, and disastrous individual.

As a son of a rockstar, all his mistakes are well documented on the pages of magazines and gossip portals so when a compromising photo is about to ruin his life again he enlists the help of his friend group to find him a pleasant boyfriend who could help him repair his reputation.

Oliver Blackwood seems like a perfect man for the job. A barrister, an ethical vegetarian, and zero scandals on his account.

Except he hates Luc, doesn’t he?

I liked how those supposedly complete opposites managed to find a common ground and work through their issues. I’m a huge sucker for opposites attract AND hate to love so this was my jam.

The fake dating trope was also quite fun and organic though I would like it more overt in the early stages of their relationship? Hard to explain without spoiling anything but after [redacted] it didn’t feel like fake dating fake dating?

It was fun and tropey and had lots of British humour which I loved — Luc’s snarky narration was the best part of the book.

But it also had a deeper side with Luc’s and Oliver's emotional baggage.

There’s dealing with anxiety, difficulty with talking about one’s emotions, lots of back and forth, messing up and apologising.

In the end, I liked it very much but I still felt like something was missing? I loved the characters and had fun listening to it but I missed the intensity that would make my heart beat faster here.

Was this review helpful?

3 I thought I'd love this more stars. The characters were quirky, unique and for the most very likable. There is plenty of British humor (Oliver's texts were the best part and very funny). Luc one of the MC's lives a life where nothing seems to go right and he has his foot in his mouth more often then not. But not a lot happens in this book plot wise and the fake boyfriend trope is used a bit differently in this plot as well. No steam (it's fade to black) and not much angst. It's actually a bit of enemies to lovers and while Luc did grow on me he'll never be one of my favorite characters. Honestly, I'm not quite sure what was missing for me except maybe some drama or angst or maybe it was just Luc sometimes seemed a bit whiny to me. Still overall I think a lot of people will enjoy this book if for nothing else then the humor and the diverse cast of characters in the book.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the chemistry between the two main characters. I could make the comparison to Red, White, and Royal Blue. The vibes were similar with fun banter and an adorable story. I always enjoy a fake dating trope so this was a fun read. Overall I would give it a 3,5/5

Was this review helpful?

This book started out a bit slow for me and I was just about to call it quits then I held out for a bit more and ended up liking the story.

Luc O'Donnell character is a bit of a Debbie Downer and jaded about like. He has a legit reason but his bitterness got a bit tiresome at the beginning. Luc needs help with a fake boyfriend to help change his image, and this is where Oliver Blackwood enters.

Oliver is a bit stiff of a character but he loosens up as the story continues and his dry sarcasm comes out and is super endearing.

The banter between Luc and his friends and Oliver's friends is the best part of the story. Also Luc's mom and her bff are quirky and hysterical. They're such a great addition to the story.

As Luc is trying to mend his life he starts to trust more. I loved the chemistry and communication between Oliver and Luc. Even though Oliver came across as the one who has it all together as the story unfolds we realize he doesn't which is on par with life because too many pretend they have their life together when in reality they don't.

Even though it started off slow for me once I got hooked I couldn't put the book down as all the characters grew on me. I'm super happy I didn't quit.

Was this review helpful?

"I don't want fine, fine isn't enough. Isn't not about the open fire or whatever other clichés you can conjure up, but yes, I want a connection. I want you to care as much as I care. I want you to need it and want it and mean it. I want it is matter."

Boyfriend Material is a British slow burn romance that is humorous and witty. Lucian and Oliver dwell on their imperfections through humor. Luc's last boyfriend sold him out to the paparazzi.. Luc's father wants his son back in his life after being diagnosed with cancer. Lucian gets Oliver to pretend to be his boyfriend, their relationship turns real.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately this one just wasn't my writing style. However, I know that it will work for some of my patrons, and the plot was still fun.

Was this review helpful?

I always love me a good gay rom-com, and Boyfriend Material did not disappoint. It's very much in the vein of Red White and Royal Blue, in that it deals with an unlikely match that leads to a storybook romance. I thought that Oliver was one of the most beautifully drawn characters that I have read in a long time. That being said, I think that the book could be about 20% shorter. We didnt need so much of the office banter, and the part with Oliver's family felt a little forced. But all in all, I found it a really enjoyable read, and I was certainly rooting for them at the end. And there's a little bit of Love, Actually thrown in there, so that should be enticing for an audience as well.

Was this review helpful?

I had the pleasure of both reading and listening to this absolutely hilarious fake dating M/M romance. This is my first book by Alexis Hall, but I was immediately drawn in by the witty writing and laugh out loud humor. Luc and Oliver couldn't be more different, but their opposites attract/forced proximity romance completely worked. I loved seeing them slowly lower their walls and show a more vulnerable side to each other. The relationship grows and builds in the perfect way. It felt honest and true to the characters and I appreciated that the misteps were included right along with the milestones. I found this closed door romance incredibly sexy and sweet.

The entire cast of characters was delightful. Even Jon Fleming played his role perfectly and I fell even more in love with Oliver during that first meeting with Luc's father. Luc's group of friends, coworkers, and mother were an absolute highlight of the book and so many times I laughed out loud while reading and listening. They were all so loyal and supportive in the most goofy ways and I'm pretty sure I cackled every time Odile was on the page.

The narration by Joe Jameson could not have been more perfect and I am incredibly impressed by his performance. He gave each character (male and female) a wonderfully unique voice that truly fit with their personality and I had no trouble differentiating between who was speaking. His comedic timing was spot on and his delivery really made the audiobook truly one of the best I've listened to.

Boyfriend Material was exactly the book my heart needed!

Audiobook Review
Overall 4.5 stars
Performance 5+ stars
Story 4 stars

*I voluntarily read and listened to a review copy of this book. Thank you Libro.fm, Dreamscape Media, and Sourcebooks Casablanca.*

Was this review helpful?

Received an ARC on #NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

This book is being touted as the next Red, White & Royal Blue but honestly it doesn't pull me in the same way.

It was a fun read with some comedy but I just didn't fully believe the love story and some the humor didn't land the way it seemed to be intended?

Overall it was a good book but it definitely is not my favourite.

Was this review helpful?

LOVED LOVED LOVED. Such a sweet romance. This one was hilarious - I thoroughly enjoyed and would recommend to romance fans. Light on the steam if that's not your thing (basically closed door) - I cannot wait to read more from this author!

Was this review helpful?

Mostly fun, interesting story, but there were a few issues that would require content warnings. The part near the ending also stressed me out so it ended more of a 4 star book rather than a 5 star one.

Was this review helpful?

Boyfriend Material is filled with excellent friendships, terrible jokes and (by some serious Alexis Hall sorcery) dick pics that make you smile. It’s a book brimming with ridiculous names, Britishness, and supporting characters with quandaries so bizarre that a sense of being inside a Hugh Grant era romantic comedy seems unavoidable.

Those eclectic supporting characters really are the backbone of this story. A lot of how this romance comes together is because Luc’s colleagues and friends offer him unconditional support –in small, frivolous ways, and in the ‘come over to help clean your apartment’s evidence of the depressing last few months because your fake-boyfriend is coming over’ moments, too.

The tabloids have crushed Luc’s self-esteem, along with any vague sense of joy and ambition, career or otherwise. And while Luc objects to how offensive and homophobic it is, the fact of the matter is that donors to the non-profit he works at see him as “entirely the wrong sort of homosexual” and to keep his job, he needs to find a means of ‘correcting’ that image. So, fake boyfriend it is.

Enter, Oliver. He is thoughtful, kind, and so sincere it almost breaks my heart. He also well-and-truly fumbles his way through texting Luc, which is fantastic and endearing every time. Both men were feeling somewhat hopeless about their romantic future, but this fake relationship begins something completely wonderful (and awkward, and frustrating, and upsetting, of course) between them.

Amidst the workplace drama, blooming emotions and doorstep apologies, Hall manages to include nuanced conversations about ethical consumerism, the merits of having straight friends, navigating strained family relationships, drag culture, and the judicial system. It’s brilliant, and beautiful, and truly the perfect read for right now.

I had an actual smile on my face the entire time I read this book. My family fully thought I was texting someone I had a crush on. I really, really recommend you read Boyfriend Material.

Side note: I don't particularly enjoy when the first romantic encounter / flirty meetcute in a book is with someone outside of the pairing we’re here for. That's maybe the only thing I wish was different in this book, mostly because it was really cute between them in those opening scenes. Until, of course, when it wasn’t.

Content warnings: homophobic workplace, parent with cancer diagnosis, (what is the word for 'A man I trusted sold me out to the tabloids'?) Brief moments suggesting Oliver’s disordered eating. At the very end, we meet Oliver’s emotionally abusive, super mean parents. You can definitely still follow the story if you need to flip past those pages.

Was this review helpful?

I had an awesome time reading this one and it was exactly what I needed. It made me feel good and that is always a big plus in my book ;)

I loved the writing style of this one and being new to Alexis Hall, this is good news, because this means I can now start a whole new list of books to my TBR list.

Now as funny as this book was to me, it's not all there is to it. There were definitely some other emotions involved while I read this one, though the snark and banter were my favorite :P

It took a while for the characters to grow on me, but once they did, I was all in. I could have done with an epilogue though... It is one of my pet peeves, I just NEED one ;)

All in all an awesome read and I will definitely be checking out more work by this author.

Was this review helpful?

This book got me all heart eyes. I absolutely loved it.
Boyfriend Material made me laugh out loud, cry, smile, be angry,...
In my opinion all characters were unique in their own way. Alex made me laugh most of the time, Lucien made me smile and cry and also laugh with how witty he is, plus he’s super relatable.
Hall’s writing style is very quick to read. It’s clear that a lot of effort has been put in the emotional aspects of this book, the humour aspects of this book, the love aspects of this book,...
I think this might be one of my favourite books of 2020.

Was this review helpful?

Luc is sorta famous, and that means he's fair game to the media. When his newest "indiscretion" threatens to ruin what is left of his life, he has to show the media that he can have a normal relationship with a respectable guy.

I received a free copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Luc is the son of two rock stars - his mother Odile, who stopped music to live off the royalties and raise her son; and his "father" is the infamous Jon Fleming who abandoned his family for the rock n roll life.
Interest in the rockstar hasbeen has increased now that he's joined a reality tv series - which means Luc is under renewed pressure from the media, who already have him pegged as a junkie and sex addict.
The media's coverage of Luc is threatening his job, as he is coming across as "the wrong type of gay". As this is the only place that would even hire him, Luc will do anything to keep his job, including recruiting a fake boyfriend, preferably one that suits the heteronormative ideals that his clients imagine is a "good gay".

Luckily, his friend Bridget has just the guy. Oliver is perfect. He's a middle-class lawyer who charms everyone he meets. He's good-looking, perfectly-respectable, and willing to go ahead with the deal as he needs a fake boyfriend to take to a family event.

OMG this book was hilarious. Perfect British humour - I just wanted to give it a hug.
I completely love Luc's mum, Odile - she is so embarrassing, I loved all of her scenes and was full-on laughing when she got to meet Oliver. (Luckily I was in the house alone, so didn't have to explain what was so funny)

I definitely got vibes of Bridget Jones' Diary, especially with Luc's very loud, very sweary, but would-drive-to-the-ends-of-the-Earth-for-you friends.
With all the group messaging that went on, they did sometimes blur together as background friends, but they all still had their individual character traits.

They all deserve a medal for sticking beside Luc, who has increasingly become a prick over the last five years. But they remember what good-Luc is like, and they are waiting for that version to come back.
It seems like, after the world turned on Luc, he no longer makes any effort to be civil to friends and strangers alike.
I loved that Oliver called him out on his mean-streak, and other little jabs that Luc makes without even thinking about it.

I did feel that the book's climax came mid-way through the book, as Luc's story seems complete. I did keep checking how far through the ebook I was, and I was surprised to see how much was left.

I thought that Oliver's story was tacked on at the end, to mirror Luc's journey.
Don't get me wrong, it was very moving and very well-done, as you realise that Oliver is a product of his family's expectations, and... well, I don't want to say anymore, because it's all worth reading first-hand.
It did change the flow of the book, and was a little slower.

The ending did pick up the pace again, and I really enjoyed Luc's big expression of love, even if it didn't all go to plan.

This book was funny, cute and had emotional depth to boot. I will definitely be looking forward to more of this author's work.

Was this review helpful?

I'm a fan of the fake boyfriend trope in general and this quintessentially British romance is the perfect example of it. While on the surface the funny dialogue and awkward situations make for a hilarious story, underneath is an abundance of feelings and an honest look at the way we present ourselves especially in a relationship. The main characters, Luc and Oliver, are both flawed and realistic, and their worries and fears are illustrated clearly. The romance is a slow-burn - seriously, don't expect anything romantic until at least halfway through the book. But the wait is worth it! That said, I thought the plot is very predictable and the bad guys are kind of stereotypical. I also found the supporting characters to be pretty thin. Except for a character named Alex Twaddle (seriously!) who absolutely needs his own spinoff.

Was this review helpful?

A perfect weekend read. Much funnier than I had expected, sweet and charming with likable characters. A nice cozy romcom that took itself just seriously enough.

Was this review helpful?

Overall – 5
Performance – 5
Story – 5

I loved this book and the audio was wonderful!

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley but ran behind in my reading and didn't get it read by release day. When I was finally able to read it, I found out that the audiobook was available so I decided to listen to it instead. OMG! The audiobook is fantastic! Joe Jameson sounds so much like another of my newly favorite narrators that I suspect it's the same person. I won't say who because I know some narrators prefer not to have their different personas connected.

I have heard so many good things about Alexis Hall's writing and I even have a few of his books in my gargantuan digital library. However, Boyfriend Material is the first one I've actually read/listened to and now I feel really sad about that. On the other hand, I'm also happy because I can now dive right in to more of his stories.

On to how I felt about the book. I LOVED everything about it except for one tiny thing that I'll get to later. Fake boyfriend stories are among my favorite romance tropes. This one was really funny in places, heartwarming in others, and in a few spots a bit heartbreaking. I always love rooting for the underdog and here we had two of them.

Both Luc and Oliver have had bad luck when it comes to romance. When they agree to fake date each other, readers know that it can only lead to one thing (because this is a romance) and that is a happy ending. It's also pretty safe to assume that the path to the HEA won't be particularly smooth.

The wide cast of secondary characters added so much to this story. Luc's friend Alex was so funny. How he reacted to Luc's jokes would be almost unbelievable if I didn't personally know at least one person like him (really dense when it comes to humor). Joe Jameson's comedic timing throughout the book was spot on. As a US reader/listener who reads and listens to a lot of British authors, I appreciated the humor throughout the story; I thought it was a good blend of British and US wittiness.

I should probably mention that if you're looking for a story with hot, sexy time you might want to pass this one up. Just know that if you do, you'll be missing a fantastic story. Oh, and the one tiny thing I didn't like about this one? I wanted an epilogue so, so much. I'm the type of reader who never wants a good book to end and I really wanted to see how Luc and Oliver are doing a few months, or more, down the road.

This review is already getting too long. The only other thing I can say is: read or listen to this, I don't think you'll regret it a bit.

A review copy was provided by the publisher via NetGalley but this did not influence my opinion or rating of the book.

Was this review helpful?

This book had me at Brittish MM romance book but it had so much more.

Boyfriend Material had two of my favorite romance book tropes wrapped into one book. It was an opposites attract love story set off with a fake relationship. That was hook enough to have me want to read my first Alexis Hall book. Overall, it delivered with a few hiccups, but it’s worth a read for fans of these romance tropes.

Let me be honest and say that Luc O’Donnell is a bit of a train wreck. He’s been burned (pretty badly) in the past and has had to live in the quasi-famous limelight cast by his famous rock star parents. Since his father is trying to re-invent himself and make a comeback, Luc’s every move is all the more scrutinized (and falsely embellished) in the tabloids. One compromising photo too many however puts his job at a non-profit in jeopardy when donors start backing out of a high-profile event. His one chance at redemption turns out to be a fake relationship with a respectable boyfriend to clean up his image. That “job” falls to Oliver Blackwood, a barrister, who is the opposite of Luc in every way.

Overall, I liked this book but at times the things that I enjoyed went a bit too far making me cringe. For example, I loved the tone and writing style of this author. The witty banter was spot on and there were several clever one-liners, jokes and little tidbits dropped along the way that I enjoyed (like the Marie Kondo reference to spark joy and the clever take on dick pics). Other times however the prose was just too wordy and I found myself skimming.

Luc’s friends were a great group who stood behind him 100% despite his curmudgeon ways. But even their antics were a bit much and over the top when it wasn’t necessary every time they were mentioned. Alex, Luc’s coworker, was a hoot and yet several of his scenes would go on and on long after I was over his nonsense.

There is also a fine line between self-deprecation and depressing and Luc crossed that line a few times for me. I understood that he unfairly had to deal with the ugly side of fame while not personally being famous at all and that really wrecked his self-esteem. But his paranoid, untrusting and unhappy ways often left me just depressed for the guy and questioning what Oliver saw in him to want to deal with that. Yet he had his moments when honesty finally came through, especially when he shared about his ex-boyfriend so you could understand his inability to trust and be vulnerable with another person.

Oliver was my favorite. He was such a nice guy. He was so empathetic and understanding with Luc and yet he didn’t let Luc walk all over his feelings. His stuffy vocabulary made me smile and I loved the way he stood up for Luc when others were not so kind. Toward the end we learn more about him and his motivations which made my heart hurt for him. It was nice to see the role reversal when Luc stood up for him.

As a newbie to Hall’s stories I enjoyed this book. Was it the best of the year, no, but fans of Brittish rom-coms and fake relationship romances will find it a good read.

*Thank you to NetGalley for the advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?