Skip to main content

Member Reviews

Okay. If I had rated this book at 98%, I probably would have given it 4 stars. I may still give it 4 stars. I don't know. We'll see how I feel after hashing this all out. But that last 2% of the book, man....

<img src="https://media.tenor.com/images/e75a7a2fe32970ca40cf8424b79702c1/tenor.gif" "description"/>


*deep breath*

Here's the thing: I thought this was a really good book. Like, "I'll read just one more chapter and then suddenly it's 2am" good.

Does that mean I think it's a good Pandemic Read? Not for me, no.

There's a line in the book...:
<i>"Fear danced silently in my blood, its invisible tentacles wrapping around me and squeezing."</i>

This was basically me the *entire* time I was reading. Young did an excellent job building tension -- not suspense, there's a difference -- that made my stomach roil with anxiety. From the opening chapters of the book -- with Fable's tangle with Koy and her escape off Jeval -- Young nailed that anxiety-inducing uncertainty.

But during a pandemic (and right before college campuses open back up) was perhaps not the best time to be reading a story that literally made my heart race.

Still, I was invested.

✔︎ -- No Love Triangle! You know that's a bonus for me. There was some misdirection early on, but thankfully, that's all it was. (And I predicted the "correct" direction correctly, so brownie point for me.)

✔︎ -- Diversity! Sort of. Our protagonist is still a white female, but there are two characters -- Auster and Paj -- who are in a gay, interracial relationship. They don't necessarily have their own story independent of the main plot, but I appreciated the way that Young presented their relationship. That is, it's established early on that love is a weakness and has no place on the trading ships -- and when it does, it doesn't end well. So Auster and Paj's relationship is "hidden" not because they're gay, but because all relationships on ships are hidden. If people know what you care about, they use it against you.

✔︎ -- The world-building. Even though they're traders by nature, the characters in this book had a sort of pirate-vibe -- maybe this was Young's way of telling a pirate story without the associated connotations of pillaging, plundering, raping, etc. There's a clear system and hierarchy in place -- there wasn't a map in my ARC, and I really hope there's a map in the published book -- with the guild-masters and the rings and everything. It's not a very rosy life for anyone, it seems, but maybe that's reserved for Bastian? I read some reviews that weren't fond of the gem-sage concept, or didn't think it was well-developed/executed, and I have to disagree. My hunch is that Young gave us what we needed to know to follow the plot of this book, and it's going to come back into play in the sequel(s). More on my hypothesis below.

✔︎ -- The pacing. Especially compared to the last book I read, the pacing was ON POINT here. There was one part about 70% through, where they were getting new sails, where it hit a bit of a snag, but I thought Young's pacing was excellent. Maybe a bit too fast in some cases...like a stone skipping on water, we jumped over chunks of time to keep the action moving. (I'm thinking of near the end, when Fable and West are dredging...they're underwater and then POOF! Everything's loaded on the ship and we're back in Dern. Wait--what? Same with offloading the cargo at the end -- if it's enough cargo to get them free, that happened very quickly.)

Which, yes. It doesn't make sense to spend a chapter detailing them getting treasure off a sunken ship if it's all going to end well. But...Young's knowledge of sailing/ship stuff was almost on a Moby Dick level. (Okay, not quite, because that would be an insult. Melville spends waaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much time with the whaling stuff.) But the analogy stands: there's a lot of description about sailing and ship jobs, so it was a little jarring to skip the "retrieving buried treasure" part, since so much attention had been paid to the other details.

*shrug* Not a big deal.

Okay. Let's get to some of the spoilery stuff.

✘ -- I had a tricky time pinning down Fable's age. I know she's 17/18, but "is older than her years" because she was abandoned, Survivor-style, on a terrible island for four years. (No one in this world seems to live a life of comfort...where are all these gems going? Who funds the money? I get that we're supposed to think it's Bastian and maybe that's where the rich, happy people live, because there is not a lot of joy in this world.) Point is--sometimes she acted like a teenager, impulsively jumping to conclusions, rebelling against orders; and other times she seemed mature and wise, like at the end with Saint, in the tavern. Which is better than the alternative, where characters (and the plot) are driven entirely by negative emotions. (Someone is always angry, yelling at someone, lashing out...I'm finding that to be a pet peeve of mine these days.)

✘ -- This is relatively minor, but I was bothered by the fact that she goes to such great lengths to prove she's NOT A THIEF -- no, really; she literally almost drowns in a very Moana-moment where's pinned in some coral -- aaaand then turns around and steals from the ship. *facepalm* Girl. Not your best look.

✘ -- This is also a spoilery point but goes back to my point about Fable's age. Her reaction to Saint's revelations...confuse me. First, she's painted him as this callous, cruel "pirate king," with Clove being the paternal figure. But, when she goes to see him, he (1) keeps his word (I thought for sure he was going to break his promise and laugh in her face, because pirate king.); (2) basically sets her up for life (if she can get the treasure); and (3) reveals that he's not a total asshat and deadbeat as he hired West to basically look after her.
And Fable gets pissed because she feels she didn't really earn her survival....? I guess? First, she gets over this pretty quickly, so it doesn't seem to be *too* much of an issue for her and is more of a convenient reaction to build tension between them. Second, she's looking for proof that her father cares for her, and SHE GETS IT. I know she is still a teenager, so perspective, but Saint was not a monster IMHO. I'm not saying he's a...."saint" (oh, terrible pun), but he was clearly affected by Isolde's death (and by "affected" I mean "broken") so he did what he could to protect his daughter. Again, not saying it's the right call, but it doesn't seem like there was a pleasant place he could send his daughter to anywhere in this world so....

✘ -- Okay. Last thing that bugged the crap out of me. Like I said -- 98% of the way through, this was 4.5 star book for me. But then the end. I knew "something" was coming, because things go off relatively smoothly for the last 10-15%, but it doesn't feel like the "end."
And once Fable left the boat, by herself, I knew what was going to happen.
Yes, she was going to get the ring back from the pawn shop.
And yes, she was going to meet Zola. (Because didn't Saint tell her, in a clear instance of foreshadowing, that if she ever got in trouble with Zola, to come straight to him, Saint?)
And then they kidnapped her.
And it just felt like the ending of <i>Six of Crows</i> where they figure out that Kaz cares for Inej and they kidnap her. And as much as I LOVED Six of Crows, the ending bothered me because a strong, kick-ass female character got kidnapped like a princess in a fairy-tale and became a damsel in distress.

WHY?!?!!

So, yeah. That's where I'm at.

Final Thoughts:
1--Soap Opera Rules apply here. If you don't see a body, or if someone says someone else is "gone" (and not "dead") -- they're not dead.
2--OBVIOUSLY the character of Holland is important and will probably be a major player in the sequel. You don't just drop breadcrumbs like that and leave them there to mold. I think this is why I'm okay with the amount of info we got about gem sages. If I remember correctly, these are they key bits of info for the sequel:
--Being a Gem Sage is a hereditary thing: Fable got it from Isolde, who clearly got it from her parents.
--(Is it matriarchal? IDK.)
--Holland is a Gem Sage (I think...) and this is how she made her fortune.
--Zola fled Bastian because he pissed off Holland.
--Isolde also fled Bastian because...something.
--Zola knows Isolde because Fable "reminds him of someone."
My hypothesis? Perhaps Isolde and Holland are related -- mother/daughter? -- and Zola is taking Fable to Bastian to appease Holland by giving her her granddaughter. And Holland will use Fable as leverage against Saint? IDK.

But maybe we'll finally see some happy people in Bastian. Because the only places we've seen in this world have been very bleak -- and if there's that much money/gems floating around, someone's got to be enjoying it.

**I received an ARC from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Fable by Adrienne Young, published by St. Martin's Press, is book one the Fable Series.
Lets get introduced to the characters.
Fable is the 17 year old daughter of a very powerful man. She's had a rough life after her beloved mother died and my heart was hurting for her.
The author created a fantastical world, a story of a young girl finding her place and family while surviving in a mens world.
A really great read. The story continues in Namesake.

Was this review helpful?

**I received an ARC of this book via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review."*

In short, this book was amazing. Young built a beautiful world of adventure on the high seas, and the plot kept me on the edge of my seat all the way through. I was a big fan of Fable as a strong heroin who really made her own destiny, and the sprinkle of romance was just enough that it didn't take away from her storyline as a free spirit. The characters were dynamic and filled with personality, with detailed writing that crafted beautiful imagery all throughout the novel. I would describe this story as Pirates of the Caribbean meets VE Schwab's A Darker Shade of Magic series. I can't wait to read the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

Wow. I cannot begin to express how much I loved this book.

Previous books by this author have been hit or miss for me, so I was not sure what to expect when I started reading. A friend suggested I pick this one up when it became available on Netgalley and I figured I'd give it a shot. I was blown away.

From the very first page, FABLE jumped into my heart and I knew this was going to be a book to treasure. The sea imagery is gorgeous, I felt like I was reef diving along with the main character (Fable), like I could smell the ocean, feel the cool water on my skin. The characters were also intriguing and I kept wanting to know more about them. And of course, this was a high seas page-turning adventure that never stopped.

This book kept me guessing throughout, and I was very invested in finding out how people were connected to each other and what would happen next. The relationships weaved in the story were fascinating. I started this book as a buddy read, a few chapters each day. But after a couple days I had to reach out to my friend to let her know I could no longer hold myself back from finishing the book in a single sitting. Then I stayed up until 2am. And wow, that ending. I immediately ran to request the next book!

If you like high seas adventure, mystery and perhaps a bit of magic, THE OCEAN, pirates, and perhaps sharks- this is the book for you. Pre-order it immediately. I already want to read it again.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press for an egalley in exchange for an honest review.

This just might be my favorite Adrienne Young story yet. After all, I had only read the first chapter and then hurriedly requested book 2 on Netgalley. Yes, it's that good. A seafaring adventure in which our title character, Fable searches for the father that left her behind years ago while also searching for her own place in the world. But who can Fable trust?

Fable is a fierce and determined character and I was pushing for her to succeed right from the very beginning. There are some fairly dangerous people that Fable encounters but she's not afraid to rise to the challenge. There's a little bit of romance but it comes in a little late in the book and it was a little bit predictable. I am glad Young didn't really linger on it that much and ensured that the adventure was still the focal point.

I have a feeling this is going to be quite the hit come September.


Goodreads review published 03/07/20
Expected Publication Date 01/08/20

Was this review helpful?

Ok, so I absolutely fell in love with this main character, she was both sassy and fierce but also kind and goal oriented. I liked that she wasn't heartless but she also wasn't afraid to stand up for herself. I also loved the story, side characters and the complexities that each is going through or went through. Everything about this book was perfect, I just loved it so much. The world building was done very well, you could tell it's a big world but the author only explained as much as necessary to the plot.

I don't really have much to say, except if you love swashbuckling and the high seas/coast than you'll love this story.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book free from Netgalley for an honest review.

4.5 Stars

Firstly, I LOVE THIS COVER!!
Secondly, this book is awesome! I love the characters, I love the storyline, I love the secrets we keep finding out. I’m pissed at the way it ended and that I will have to wait forever to get book 2. All around great read that makes you not want to put the book down!

Was this review helpful?

I just absolutely loved this one. Let's start with the cover... so gorgeous. And the plot and the characters and the ending.

So Fable is left on an island by her father after a shipwreck (harsh, right?) and he basically tells her that if she can survive, get off the island,and find him, he will give her something. So she struggles for about 4 years before she has enough money (sort of) to get off the island. There's a lot more going on, but you get the point. And that's just the first couple of chapters.

I could not put this one down. If you like YA, fantasy, pirates, action, adventure, or any combination of the above, this might be just the thing for you. And there's another book coming! I'm totally hooked.

Was this review helpful?

Do you like Pirates of the Caribbean? Or Six of Crows? How about a book that mashes elements of the two together? If so, I think this book will be for you, especially if you love stories that focus on the darker aspects of ships and piracy in fantasy lore.

I have to admit that it took a little bit of energy to get invested in Fable. The first few chapters are just following the main character, Fable, as she goes about her regular routine dredging. Dredging is basically the term that’s used for a ship’s diver. The dredger dives into the sea and searches for valuable items, like pyre or coins. While the process is interesting, it wasn’t a great way to introduce the reader to the world. I have to be honest, I was struggling to get through those first chapters because of how uninterested I became over the course of Fable's dredging explanation. Thankfully, though, the pace picked up and the plot started rolling right after those introductory pages.

So, like I said, Fable is a dredger. Now, the idea of a dredger in the world Young has created doesn’t seem super realistic when it comes to diving. As for as I know, humans can’t dive hundreds of feet without scuba gear, so I’m not entirely sure how “human” Young’s characters actually are. Besides some mention of small magics, there’s nothing that would indicate special lungs are a thing. Other than that quirk, Fable is an intriguing protagonist to follow. She’s had a rough life, and it’s entertaining to follow her on her journey to find her father and get her family back.

As for the other characters, we have West, Willa, Paj, Auster, and Hamish. West is the swoon-worthy captain. Willa is the only female crew member of the Marigold. Paj and Auster are harboring a secret romance. And Hamish counts the coins. Unfortunately, besides West and Willa, the other three characters don’t really get a lot of time in the spotlight. They’re all fun, and they have major Six of Crows crew vibes, but I wanted more development from each of them. I mean, we barely know anything about Hamish. I will say that Fable’s relationship with her father was fascinating to watch unfold, however. Every time I anticipated some sort of development between the two, Young would take the characters in a totally different direction. Super unpredictable.

All in all, despite some of my nitpicks, this was a gripping fantasy read. It gave me flashbacks to my teenage days obsessing over Will Turner and Elizabeth Swan, and it also had a major cliffhanger that means I’ll have to get my hands on book two somehow, someway. While Fable isn’t my favorite read of the year, it does provide exactly what it’s meant to: a sea adventure full of swashbuckling heroes, villains, and all types of people in between.

3.5/5 stars

*Note: I received a copy of this book to review from the publisher via NetGalley. This in no way affected my opinion/review.

Was this review helpful?

I had trouble putting this book down, I mean give me a book with a strong female protagonist and I will be slightly biased, but this one is an amazing read. A strong main character in Fable, who has lived the last four years trying to survive on an island surrounding by thiefs where she was left behind by her own father. Her goal: get off the island and find her dad to get what is hers like he promised.
She ends up on a boat with a ragtag crew of people and they get into some adventures, intrigues and then we're at the end and I need the sequel fast!
What I liked about the characters is that they are hardened by life and not one of them is entirely good, they're like you would expect them to be if life is difficult and people do what they need to do in order to survive. Yet there is the shimmering of hope when you see real connections are still possible,,,it might take time, it might take work and there is an internal struggle cause who can you really trust? But friendship, loyalty and love will always have a place in the world. Even in the pirate world.

I'll be waiting here, not so patiently, for the second book in this serie.

*** An ARC was provided by Netgalley in exchange for a honest review. ***

Was this review helpful?

I was absolutely swept away by Fable! I finished it in one afternoon because I couldn't stop reading! I loved this high-seas world that Adrienne Young created. She wrote fantastic characters who were more than what they seemed at first glance. I can't wait to get my hands on the next book! That cliff hanger ending just about did me in.

If you love pirates, adventure, or just a great YA, keep your eyes out for this book! It publishes September 1, 2020.

Thanks so much to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for this digital ARC!

Was this review helpful?

This book was amazing!! I‘m usually not a huge YA fan, but this sea-world fantasy just blew me away...I was hooked immediately, and 350+pages simply flew by.

Fable is a 17 year-old gem mage who, after she lost her mother in a shipwreck at 14, was left on an island of cutthroat dredgers (salvage divers) by her trader father to fend for herself. She survives for 4 years until she bargains for a voyage to her father‘s home on West‘s ship (a trader who has been purchasing her salvaged pyre). West‘s misfit crew takes her in after she proves herself and thus begins their adventures (including meeting up with her seemingly uncaring father, clashing with a truly evil villain and exploring Fable‘s gem mage abilities inherited from her mother).

The world-building was spot-on, and the cast very well thought-out. This is the first of a duo, and I cannot wait for part two. Highly recommend.

Thank you to #NetGalley, #StMartinsPress and #WednesdayBooks for providing me the ARC. The opinions are strictly my own.

Was this review helpful?

The only issues I had were the politics, it felt disconnected, and not enough questions were answered by the end of the book.

I thought Fable was an interesting character. She works hard but she learns to take direction which is a rarity in YA. Usually the main character has a crappy attitude and knows more than everyone else in the room. I also liked the relationship with her father-it was very mysterious and I'm curious to see if develop further in book two.

I liked all the characters and how they contributed to the plot; I also liked the romance.

This was a very good pirate book full of colorful characters, action, and romance.

Was this review helpful?

I received a free ARC of this book from Netgalley in exchange for my honest review.

I really enjoyed this one! You can almost taste the salt of the sea, and there's just the right amount of adventure and intrigue. Leapt right over to the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

This was a great pirate story, full of sea voyages, bartering, near-death experiences and sailing knowledge. I loved Fable and her wily, slick ways. She had to forage and find her own way and she was scrappy. The crew she stumbles on was good fun as well as we got to know them

This ends on a cliffhanger so I look forward to reading book 2.

Was this review helpful?

Fable is more about love than adventures. It’s sweet and heartfelt but it lacked the drive I was hoping would color this book bright and agile, mixing the seemingly melancholic undertone. I wouldn't say it's a bad thing if you are in the mood for something slow and contemplative. The positive side of the story that it gives insight into the heart of our main character Fable. She is highly reliable and I could've easily imagined myself in her shoes.

Secondary characters were also very nice. The romance part was great, and I am for sure going down with this ship, but I wished the development of said romance was more slow, so the reader could feel it and soak it and invest in it. I wasn't 100% invested, though I still ship the couple as I was saying earlier. There was also a secondary couple which was maybe even more curious for me to read about. There was a long, old story behind the romance, and I would love to see more of it in the sequel.

Getting back to the plot, the story is about the 17-years old Fable, whose father dropped her on a small and unfriendly island to fend for herself for four long years. After that time Fable decided to get back to her father and ask for what is hers. She requests for help from mysterious West (I know right, it wouldn't be interesting if he wasn't mysterious, haha) and his crew. On their way, the whole crew will have to face danger but also their inner demons.

All said and done, I highly recommend Fable because it is an entertaining story written in a very beautiful language. It makes you relate with the characters and hope for a happy ending for all of them. Also, it's got quite a few curious villains, and I am looking forward to their stories in the next instalment!

Was this review helpful?

I binged this book in a couple of days! Loved the pirates. I’ve never read anything by this author so it was wonderful to step into a new story.

If you want Mystery, intrigue, pirates, and bass ass females, this is the book for you!

Was this review helpful?

Fable is a binge-worthy read filled with danger, heartache, and an extremely loveable heroine. I am obsessed with this book.

Adrienne Young has done it again. I am absolutely a fan of her writing and she has created another fascinating world that you can’t wait to know more about! The Narrows is a deadly place to live and Fable has done what she must to survive and find her way back to her Father. She is determined prove to him and herself that she can live a life at sea by his side.

When she’s forced to leave the island where she’s lived on her own for the past four years, Fable is sent on an adventure she couldn’t have expected, discovers what she’s willing to do for family and finds herself along the way. I fell in love with the Marigold crew and how much they care for each other especially in the cutthroat world of trading on the Narrows. This book had me from the first sentence to the last and I cannot wait to read the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

Plot: 5 stars
Characters: 5 stars
Writing Style: 4 stars
Cover: 5 stars
Representation: 4 stars
Enjoyment: 4 stars
Overall: 4.5 stars

First things first: That is a *gorgeous* cover!

The book itself started out as a disappointment. I really enjoyed Sky in the Deep, and I was intrigued by the description. Also pirates. You really can't go wrong with pirates. For the first 30% of the book, however, Fable seems overly young and far too tough - enough that it wasn't very believable. I really considered DNFing.

However. I stuck it out and I'm so glad I did. I ended up giving this book 4.5 stars because, after that rocky start, I loved every minute of it.

There is more to the crew than at first it seems, more to Saint, more to Fable. The love story, when it came, was swoony. It was full of adventure and adrenaline and freedom. And risk and grudges and revenge.

I loved how Fable lived by her father's rules, and when she chose to break them. I loved her interactions with him, especially the last one. They have a complicated relationship and that really comes through. And I love how she felt her mother around her sometimes as if she wasn't truly gone.

I love her relationship to the crew of the Marigold too. They don't want her there at first, but they grow on each other and by the end seem to have adopted her into their little family. I definitely want to see more of their interactions in the next book.

And that ending! Needless to say, I'm eagerly anticipating the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly, I was on the fence about requesting this book from NetGalley, but after reading so many fantastic reviews, I decided to give it a try.  Now, I'm raring to get my hands on the second in the duology.

From the first page, your heart goes out to Fable.  She's literally abandoned on an island full of criminals by her father - it's a true sink or swim situation.  Over the course of two years, she struggles to survive and learns some hard lessons along the way.  Considering all she experiences, her trust issues are valid.  Without such a strong, independent, charismatic MC, I'm not sure this book would have gotten such stellar reviews, but for me, Fable and her quest made the story.  With much of the setting on the open sea, it receives bonus points.

Stakes are high, and Fable is in near constant danger.  When the crew of the Marigold reluctantly take her in, she discovers they harbor many secrets of their own.  After a rough getting-to-know-you period, trust and relationships form - I'm a sucker for found family stories.  And if anyone ever needed the support of a family, it's this group.  With the crew, West's and Willa's characters are well-developed, but the remaining three aren't as clear-cut and seem interchangeable.  The author could have more planned for them in the next book - I'm anxious to learn their stories.

If you're a fan of pirates, high seas adventure, closely-guarded secrets, and feisty main characters, I highly recommend Fable.  Now I need the second book!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.  Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?