Sayaka Murata’s back with another story of a social outsider - and it’s even worse than Convenience Store Woman!

Natsuki is a little girl that gets physically and verbally abused by her horrible mother, sexually abused by her teacher and, after a bout of incest, attempts suicide - guys, you’ll never believe it but somehow she turns out to be a complete mess of an adult!

Yeah I didn’t like Earthlings at all. A lot of the gross scenes felt gratuitously described to little or no effect (beyond the obvious shock factor) and the message Murata seemed to be going for felt trite and immature. Conformism is brainwashing, maaan, society is like a factory, etc. This kind of banal commentary isn’t new or clever - rejecting societal norms doesn’t make you a radical, it makes you an average teenager.

I get that Japanese society is more restrictive than most western societies. There’s a strong emphasis on family, living outside of the norm is discouraged, it’s patriarchal (though this is slowly changing), and the focus is much more on the group than the individual. Perhaps something like this would seem more transgressive in that context. But not to this reader in the UK - this was just childish silliness.

Natsuki was an annoying character for the most part even though I felt sorry for her. Her inner dialogue was irritating - as a kid she’s either banging on about survival or wittering on about being an alien or a witch with her imaginary friend Piyyut, and as an adult she’s talking idiotically about rationalism. Yuu and Tomoya were equally stupid - they all deserved each other. Three morons exchanging stilted comments about nothing to highlight… what? That this is what a buttoned-down society reduces people to when they don’t fall in line? I’m not impressed if it is.

I found Earthlings unpleasant for large portions of the novel, the characters all absurd, the point obvious and simple, and the story always really, really boring. After this and Convenience Store Woman, I don’t think Sayaka Murata’s books are for me.

DNF at page 46.

trigger warning
<spoiler> emotional abuse, sexual assault on child by teacher, gaslighting, bullying</spoiler>

This book is about Natsuki, who is a magician. Her alien friend from another planet bestowed magical abilities on her - or so she thinks.

I did not dnf this book because it's bad, because it isn't. Yet again this is a case of triggering material presented without warning.
<spoiler> Natsuki is subtly mistreated by her mother. A neighbor makes a comment about how grown up she is, and that that's cool, and her mother slides in chiding her daughter for being clumsy and ugly. This is only one instance, every time Natsuki and her mother are shown together, the latter mistreats her child - while the other child is praised. Natsuki has the typical warped self image one gets through gaslighting.

This already made me feel iffy, abusive mother-daughter relationships always hit too close to home for me, and then Natsuki is sexually assaulted by her pedophelic teacher. </spoiler>

If I had been warned beforehand, I might have reacted differently. As it stands, I dnf this one and hope that some day in the future, the need for warnings will be logical to everyone.

I recieved a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is one of the most disturbing books I've read in my entire life. I haven't felt this way since J.T.Leroy's last novel, but this one by Murata at least, has no pretension to be real, but unfortunately it's quite realistic if you know a bit about mental illness. Heavy and definitely not for everyone.

Questo é uno dei libri piú disturbanti che abbia letto nella mia intera vita. Non mi sentivo cosí dall'ultimo romanzo di J.T.Leroy, ma questo della Murata almeno, non ha nessuna pretesa di essere reale, ma purtroppo é piuttosto realistico se uno conosce un po' le malattie mentali. Pesante e decisamente non per tutti.

THANKS NETGALLEY FOR THE PREVIEW!

I had heard so much about CONVENIENCE STORE WOMAN that when I saw this on NetGalley, I decided to give it a go even without having read Murata's previous book. Wow, what a roller coaster! The writing is immediate and accomplished. I was drawn instantly into Natsuki's world, and felt compelled to follow her through her trials. She deals with some horrifying things -- almost all of the adults in her life let her down, and she finds herself further and further pushed to believe herself a cog in a giant wheel of expectation on drudgery. She retreats into fantasy in order to cope. It culminates in an unforgettable final scene. I closed this book unsure of exactly what I had just experienced. It's challenging, provocative, and frightening. The voice here is assured. Whether or not this works for all readers, it's undeniable that Murata is commanding voice in subversive literature.

Continuing and expanding upon the themes of CONVENIENCE STORE WOMAN, Earthlings questions assumptions about what it means to be a part of civilization. Like CONVENIENCE STORE WOMAN, the main character is a woman who doesn't fit in, who finds some solace by partnering with a man who shares her radical ideas about society.

Whereas the earlier book presents a relatable character in a realistic setting whose rejection of societal norms seems rational, EARTHLINGS centers on an individual so deeply damaged by childhood sexual abuse and familial verbal abuse that she entirely disassociates from the world. Her only refuge from trauma is to consider herself alien, a denizen of another planet stranded on earth. Through fantasy and disassociation, she is able to do what the adults in her life fail to do: protect herself. I like that the novel defies easy categorization, as the author bends genre in completely unexpected ways. The turn the narrative takes in the end is logical yet stunning: a horror parable rather than science fiction.

Murata has a tremendous instinct for surprise, for turning a narrative on its head. The simplicity of the language and the innocence of the protagonist carries one along to the shocking conclusion. Yet while Convenience Store Woman is a book for a wide audience, I think many may find this book difficult to finish due to the specificity and violence of child abuse as well as the extreme nature of the ending. EARTHLINGS would make a terrific film in the vein of PARASITE.

Thank you to Netgalley and Grove Atlantic for providing an ARC of this book.

I'm torn by this. On the one hand it's an interesting read on the other it's a little bit horrific.
I wasn't expecting the book to be quite so graphic. The way her mother and teacher in particular treat her was very difficult to read. I almost stopped at that point. I wanted to get to the end though and find out what happened.
I'm not really sure. Was it real, a fantasy?
Worth a read if you want something challenging but take note of trigger warnings.

This is probably the most peculiar book I've read in years. Earthlings is a gripping, strange, shocking and still somehow wonderful book that probes and troubles your mind. This was my first experience with Sayaka Murata's writing, and now I want to read all of her work because, at least in this story, she really captures society in a way that few can actually describe. Definitely one of my favorite reads so far this year.

I really liked Convenience Store Woman, it was so funny and weird, so I was excited to read Earthlings. It's a weird but much darker than her previous novel that becomes more shocking as the book goes on, towards the end it's a total shift from what I thought the book was going to be. I loved it. A Murakami like novel about a Natsuki is a young girl in Japan who doesn't fit in with her family and the rest of society. She doesn't want to be in the "baby factory" society where she will just grow up to be a mother. When a vacation to the mountains to her grandparents place, her cousin Yuu tells her he's an alien and he's always searching the stars for a ship to take him home. She wonders if there is more to live than this and goes on a search to find it. A novel about girl's places in the world and Japanese society, it's a great book.

I am going to be honest. I started reading this book, got a bit confused, and turned to some other reviews to see if they could help me out. At that point, quite a few of the other reviewers mentioned that there are graphic child sex scenes in this book and that removed my desire to continue reading this book. My apologies to the author and the publisher.

I honestly didn’t know this book was going to be so dark. I liked this one better than Convenience Store Woman but wish I had known the disturbing topics in this book beforehand. It was relatable how the main character Natsuki felt different from anyone she knew and couldn’t fit into society but overall while I was reading this book it was just shocking and at the end I just wanted to move onto my next book.

Sayaka Murata returns! I loved Convenience Store Woman and Murata's voice and unique characters. This book definitely follows up and develops her voice further. It is a wonderful quirky, tightly wound, amusing yet heartbreaking book about experiencing and healing from trauma, about bonds that connect us, about our role in society or the role outside of society. This book will not be for everyone, given that there are heavy trigger warnings for child sexual abuse and incest. However, overall I found myself relishing the book (it is charming yet unsettling the same way Convenience Store Woman was) and the food for thought it provided. 4 stars.
I received an ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

An absolute masterpiece on feeling “alienation” in society.

As a companion piece to Convenience Store Woman, Earthlings takes leaps forward in cementing the ideas of the first book, and then no holds are barred as the book becomes a Tarantino-like exaggeration of our characters reasonably realistic lives.

I will write up a full review on my J-“lit blog and add links later.

I wish this were available sooner so I could talk more about it and let get friends to read it.

I have never read anything by Sayaka Murata before, so I approached Earthlings with no particularly expectations as to what it would be like. I was delighted by what I found, however. The story and its characters captured my interest right from the start, and I loved Murata's prose style which flows from the dreamlike to the stark in a gentle, non-jarring way. The themes in this book resonated deeply with me, and I felt a certain kinship with Natsuki that kept me invested in her progress through the story.

Earthlings is a wonderful depiction of the darker side of society and the norms it imposes, particularly the judgment it passes on those who don't conform. Although the story verges on the fantastical, the themes it explores are very much grounded in the reality of contemporary life, and I thought Murata handled that balance perfectly. Based on my experience with this book, I am keen to read more of her works in the future.

To close, I should say that Earthlings is not a book that will appeal to everyone. It contains some dark themes and depictions of events that may put off some readers. However, if you are not affected by such things I highly recommend this quirky and thought-provoking work.

This book was a little different to what i was imagining. I am not saying I didn't like it, I Cared about Natsuki when it seemed like no-one else did in the book and knew I had to finish and I so hoped she had her happy ending. I am giving this book a 5 star review because it was so well crafted the development of the characters, excellent book cover. I just want to have a second book now to see how the story continues.

HOLY MOLY. Just a warning without spoilers, this is definitely a MATURE read, so if you can’t handle any topics around abuse then steer clear.

Also there may be spoilers from this point on, I’m trying to be as broad as possible because this was really well written.

***

So I wasn’t sure what to expect when I requested this ARC, but I was drawn in immediately by the author. She does such a fantastic job of humanizing the children in the story, and really captures the chuunibyo period of childhood really well. It’s an awkward time with experimentation and confusion about what it means to be an adult. You can see this continue through the book as the characters either change and mature or are stunted in this stage due to numerous reasons.

Unfortunately, I also felt she did a good job on catching some of the overtly abusive Asian family dynamics seen in some families. You could feel the outside characters uncomfortable and it makes you feel uncomfortable as well. This background adds to understanding why characters developed the way they did, sadly.

I didn’t expect to find myself liking a general fiction like this, but it was written in such a way that it’s kind of a train wreck that you can’t look away from. You want to keep reading because you, with some little pieces of hope, want things to turn out well for the characters. Well, guess you got to read it if you want to find out.

There's a lot going on with just the first few chapters. There are a lot of characters which get introduced, a lot of good and not-so-good things happening in the life of Natsuki.
I would say it's a coming of age fiction where it depicts sexual abuse/molestation by a male teacher, a mother who appears to be downright disappointed in her daughter and rather abusive on a constant basis, a close male cousin who is supposedly to be the secret boyfriend/husband. So many things are not handled properly at all. I wasn't expecting this one to be so horrifying! The young girl is trying to escape the pain and neglect believing herself to be a magical being. Damn, it hurts. But I seriously could not grasp the real intention of this book. Yes, I did read this one till the end. It's rather like something written in a very dark, twisted kind of story but without a plot or a theme to discuss about. The characters are so damn annoyingly blind and too whimsical. Too many graphic scenes in the story but I just cannot see the significance of it. The second half did not get any better. The ending was a complete mess.
Maybe I was expecting something else from this story. Even if I wasn't, this one was just not for me.
I got triggered but I didn't get anything out of it - at least all it had to do was give me some assurance or some kind of closure. Too much of abuse and physical violence just don't go well if the story doesn't do anything about it.

I was expecting too much from this book I suppose. I totally love the first book by the author. This is a total let down for me.
But I am glad #NetGalley gave me an ARC of it.
Thank you.