I am a huge mystery fan. Like Mrs Bunce, I grew up on Trixie Belden. I read every mystery I could get my hands on.

I requested both Myrtle books from Netgalley, mostly because I LOVED Star-crossed and Liar’s Moon (READ them!). I really enjoyed both books, though if you are a young adult or adult reader, this is decidedly middle grades. As a connoisseur of young adult kit, I am already dreaming of Myrtle marrying Mr. Blake year when she grows up. His humor, competence, and devotion make him my very favorite character, although Peony (the cat), with her hilarious interjections, is a close second.

I was more fascinated on the mystery than the first. I am a sucker for a train story. But I missed Myrtle’s dad, and I was frustrated with Miss Judson for being far less encouraging and sympathetic than she was in the first book. I did peg the bad guy based on his or her extremely suspicious behavior, but I may not have done so if I had been a 12 year old, for whom this book is intended. The ending implies that the next release will be a Christmas mystery, which makes me super excited to see what happens next! More twisty suspense, Mr. Blakeney, and Peony please!!!

In this second book starring Myrtle Hardcastle, 12-year-old detective, less time is spent introducing the series' characters and more time setting up a rollicking good mystery. Lots of local color and quirky suspects add to the twists and turns of the plot. Sure to become a new favorite series for middle grade mystery lovers. Highly recommended.

Review based on an ARC provided the NetGalley.