
Member Reviews

I could not put this book down. Rick Riordan Presents does it again. Loved the way the author dealt with the death of a brother. Can hardly wait for the next one.

This is one of those books that I can't wait to get into the hand of middle grade readers, even though I freely admit, it's not the kind of book I really enjoy. What I DID enjoy was Sikander, the main character. It's so rare to find a book with an Arab (or actually an Arab-American) character that rings true and isn't focused on what's become almost a cliche: the refugee child who escapes war and is adjusting to his new life in America. That description certainly fits Sik and his family, but that's definitely NOT what the book is about. The book is about the gods from Ancient Mesopotamia wrecking havoc on modern-day New York City, complete with a mysterious plague that changes people into bizarre dog-like creatures. (Like I said - not my style of book, but I know kids are going to love it!) Sik could be any one of a number of middle grade Arab boys I know. I can't wait to hand them a book with a hero that looks, talks and acts like them! I also liked the way his Islamic faith is respectfully handled even as he interacts with "the gods". (As an aside, I'm waiting for the day that one of the Rick Riordan Presents books manages to do the same with a Christian character.) Highly recommended.
This review is based on an ARC received from the publisher through NetGalley.

The plot and storyline were excellent, but two big things ruined it. First, he used politics - specifically the complete emphasis on Muslim inclusion - to turn the story into a propaganda machine. At times, it felt like he was even trying to convert the reader to Islam.....and there's no place in my classroom for any sort of religious conversions. Secondly, he made Gilgamesh a pacifist gardener....and as anyone who is familiar with the Epic of Gilgamesh knows, he's the Hercules of the Mesopotamian mythology....a loud, arrogant fighter. So...good plot, but not for use in my classroom.

Fans of Percy Jackson and Aru Shah will love this fast-paced, action-packed novel. Chadda Sarwat’s characters, Sik and Belet, are insanely likeable and Sarwat makes Mesopotamian mythology engaging. I admit, prior to reading this book, I knew nor cared little about Gilgamesh and others, but now I would love to read more. I hope there is a sequel.
I love the diversity represented in all of the Rick Riordan Presents titles!

Many times students are not exposed to mythology beyond the Greeks and the Romans. That is why I love the Rick Riordan imprint. The Mesopotamian mythology that is woven into this story was unknown to me and I cannot wait to share it with my students. They will enjoy reading Sik's story of adventure while trying to defeat Nergal. The mystery behind what Nergal is seeking will keep readers engaged as well watching the relationship between Sik and Belet develop. Another fantastic book from Rick Riordan presents!

This book is very reminiscent of the Percy Jackson series. Good character development, interesting integration of Mesopotamian mythology and great story progression. I love the fact that it stars Muslim characters and incorporates part of that culture in a real way, without being heavy handed. I could confidently put this book into the hands of Percy Jackson fans and know they will enjoy it.

I so greatly appreciated this new Rick Riordan Presents book in so many ways. First, as a compelling story for all readers. Then, as a book so well-suited to young readers. Finally, as a historical and cultural work — highly recommended.