Cover Image: Luz

Luz

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Idk, I think I'll always be very indifferent about books that are not own-voices. This is a tough sell for me.

Was this review helpful?

This was not a book for me. i Struggeled with the book, i had a hard time to connect with the characters and didn`t feel like the story was honest, espesially when reading the afterwords of the author.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the cover of this book, so clear so simple, so unlike the stories kids need to hear about the treks their parents made to America. I realize Thomas isn't try to tell any more than the story of one person, but many of us need to hear the story.

Was this review helpful?

Really good read. Would recommend to friends and family. I could sympathise with characters (important for any fiction novel!) and looked forward to picking it up and reading the next few chapters! Interesting plot line and a good ending. Will look out for more novels by the author. Thank you.

Was this review helpful?

This is a sore subject for me because this is a story about a Mexican woman crossing into the United States written by a white author who will never understand what their struggles are truly like. The writing is phenomenal. It's richly vibrant. As a minority woman I just couldn't get into the story. Maybe others will think otherwise. Happy reading!

Was this review helpful?

A sincere thank you to the publisher, author and Netgalley for providing me with an ebook copy of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review.

This is not my usual genre, I’m more into crime/thriller books and even psychological thrillers too so I am extremely pleased and grateful to them for opening up my mind to something totally different.

Was this review helpful?

Luz by Debra Thomas from She Writes Press - This is a story of three migrants teenagers, Alma, Rosa and Manuel (from Guatemala), who try to make their way from Oaxaca in Mexico to the US. Their journey is fraught with many dangers and loss of life but ultimately there is hope of a better life.

Few things I enjoyed in Thomas’ writing are her descriptions of the desert scenes and the violence that takes place there, the maths problems Alma writes up as a coping mechanism through her journey and last but not the least the author’s notes at the end where she talks about why she as a white woman, had to seek the advice of the award winning author, Alma Luz Villaneuva, before appropriating the voice of a Mexican young woman. As a reader who cares about how authorial voice is used, I respect this gesture. There’s sensitivity, compassion and openness in Thomas’ writing.

Luz is reminiscent of The Bluest Eye. This is a compliment to the author. She has piqued my interest in Mexican literature and I will now go look for some more great writing from the country.

Why do I not score Luz higher? The story is powerful but it could have been deeper and richer in certain parts like the depth of Alma’s grief at the loss of Rosa. I wanted a more primordial sense of loss and pain but what I got was a more muted one.
This is still a great read. Definitely a buy.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to She Writes Press & NetGalley for the Advanced Reader's Copy!

Available June 9th 2020.

I struggled with this book, not with the story but with the concepts behind them. In the foreward of this book, author Alma Luz Villanueva notes that she is hesitant about reading a book about the trauma of migration between Mexico and the United States by a non Hispanic white author but that she was persuaded by the afterword. As a curious reader, I quickly jumped to the afterword in which the author describes her work with Latinx students as well as her work with BorderLinks. She states "at this point in my life, I wanted to write about the undocumented immigrant community in a way that others could see through their eyes and experience and understand why they were driven to leave their homes and risk their lives to come to our country." And that's exactly the issue with Luz. The story is technically well written, vividly described, but it is not honest, true or empowering. Thomas's writing is just that, her writing, her American citizen's viewpoint of immigration and the story reeks of American savior complex. Perhaps if Luz was a different story, if it was Thomas tackling her native upstate New York family's racist viewpoints or her story as a working class woman who decided to work with undocumented persons, it would have felt more genuine.

Was this review helpful?