Cover Image: It's MY Tree

It's MY Tree

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This was a cute story about a squirrel who is very possessive over his tree and his pinecones, but learns that sharing is not as scary as he thought it would be. The illustrations in this book are beautiful. My kids enjoyed reading it together. Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Fun to read aloud with the dramatic flair of a greedy squirrel. Hilarious illustrations to accompany - we loved the angry eyes. Reminded me of a combination between the Ice Age creature and Wild E Coyote.
Lots of giggles with this one. Definitely one that will be revisited.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Kids Can Press for this free e-book. This review is mine alone.
I loooooove the illustrations- the cover is what caught my eye. The squirrel looks a bit craze so I just know the story going be a bit silly. My 3 and 5 yr old thought the story was entertaining. We can tell that the squirrel was just trying to protect what he thought was his right to the pinecones and the tree. But at the end of the story, when he went a bit ‘mad’ at self isolation with the walls - he got more greedy on what he thinks he’s missing outside of fortress. The ending kind of was disappointing cause it just drops off like a cliffhanger. Overall, it was a fun read!

Was this review helpful?

Nice simple artwork and easy to read. Topic may resonate to some kids well. Another good choice for a library collection in the emotions section.

Was this review helpful?

I was drawn to this book just from the cover. Such a cute book and pretty pictures. Would definitely recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

*thank you to Netgalley, Olivier Tallec and Kids Can Press for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review*


3 stars.

I'm not quite sure what to make of this. In the beginning it said it was about Greed. So I thought, 'ok, sure.' But then I was reading it and I saw it differently. Maybe it's due to my personal trauma but I saw this, (well, for the first 90% of it but I'll get back to that), as being a story about protecting what is yours and your need to keep something special to yourself. There is nothing wrong with that.

But the last 10% roughly I did start to see where the author was going with the story. The fact the Squirrel wanted more and more, now THAT is greed. 

The illustrations were good. I could give or take them but I did like the use of colour and the way they blended together. It was nice and gave them a soft touch.

Overall, this wasn't anything fantastic, but it wasn't bad either. It's one you would probably enjoy but then forget about. Unless you are a big fan of Squirrels then this will probably enjoy it more.

Was this review helpful?

Cute book with darling pictures. It had just the right amount of words on the page to keep my 4 year olds interest. The storyline was very cute, but it ended abruptly and I get like it didn’t resolve everything. My daughter liked it though so I guess that’s what matters.

Was this review helpful?

It's MY Tree by Olivier Tallec has one of the cutest and most amusing covers I've seen in a while, and we haven't even gotten into the story yet!

This little squirrel has a tree and it's HIS tree, don't be mistaken. He loves his tree very, very, very, very much, especially since it produces pine cones which he also loves. He comes to the realize that someone might one day want his tree for their own, and that is just horrifying! Especially when curiosity and further greed takes over him...

There isn't much of a lesson in here. I was really hoping he'd learn to share or something, instead of just seeing tons more squirrels and trees. I saw some potential there, but I also love educational books with themes. This book is just a cute book that could be a conversation after. Without a resolution to the problem of greed, I'm not sure where this story was going other than showing a greedy squirrel.

I love the illustrations! They are goofy, colourful and quite charming. Honestly, it's one of my favourite so far this year. It's quirky and definitely attracts my attention.

The plot gets one star, but the illustrations get five. So, I shall meet in the middle with three pine cone shaped stars!

Thank you to NetGalley and Kids Can Press for providing me a free copy of this book in exchange of an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I'd recommend taking a look at this one just for the illustrations. That squirrel is hilarious. As for the story... it lost me.

This squirrel has a tree and pinecones... and a bunch of worries. What if someone decides his tree is their tree? Maybe he should build a wall to keep others away. But... what if there's an even better tree with better pinecones on the other side of that wall?

I was with the story up until the end. I hoped that there would be some sort of lesson for the squirrel, but there doesn't seem to be (unless kids are supposed to read between the lines and deduce their own resolution and message). When the greedy squirrel climbs his wall to see what he's missing out on, he sees a forest full of worried-looking squirrels just like him and... that's the last page. So, did he learn anything? Or is he just going to start fights with every squirrel who dares to cross his path?

While the story might not have been for me, I'm kind of in love with the illustrations. The goofy, petrified-looking squirrel is a great main character, and I loved seeing his different facial expressions. The pictures are done in a fairly limited palette that incorporates a lot of oranges and yellows. The illustrations definitely work.

It's too bad I can't say the same for the story.

Was this review helpful?

It’s MY Tree, by: Olivier Tallec
It started out as a very cute book, then it got a little side tracked with an abrupt ending. I really wanted to like this book. I’m just concerned children will not fully understand this book if reading it alone. It really needs to be explained at the end. I recommend this book for grades 2nd-3rd.

Was this review helpful?

This is a book with a great premise: teach a child that being selfish and hoarding or not sharing is actually a greater cost to them than sharing.

The artwork is colorful, The story idea is good. The challenge is that the entire story is a build-up of being selfish, complete with building a wall and talk of keeping what is "mine," There is a *lot* of talk about keeping what is "mine." There is a lot of energy going into that effort, a lot of emotion even.

Then the resolution is simply two images in succession (of a moment, something happening) -- a striking set of images -- but without text, striking to an adult, but it could be fairly inconsequential to a young child. What is remembered is the long story of holding on to what is "mine." That is the higher energy value, what gets fed into the reader. The resolution image punchline may be skipped by the child. I think I would have not read this to my child when very young.

Thank you to NetGalley for an advanced reader copy for review. Not posting to Goodreads for the lower rating I've given.

Was this review helpful?

Just a little story about greed....and pinecones...

A simple little book about a squirrel who didnt want to share so he closes himself off from the rest of the forest. But eventually he realizes there is more beyond his wall and his 1 tree. This book could easily be used to prompt a discussion with children about the troubles with not wanting to share. The illustrations were really cute too.


I received a digital copy of this book from the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

The illustrations are amazing and so captivating. My kids enjoyed the story but they were disappointed in the ending. They thought it lacked one and I would have to agree. Sadly the author missed a great opportunity to teach a great lesson on either sharing or greediness/selfishness. I also thought it would of been great if he would of interacted with woodland characters maybe it would of made the book just a little better.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the opportunity to read and review this title.

The illustrations are fantasic! The story was great and kept my interest, but the end was just, well, boring. It lacked that final punch. I understand where the author/illustrator was going - it just needed a little bit more.

Was this review helpful?

Can a squirrel have a tree all to himself? This colorful book tries to teach a lesson about greed, but falls a little short. I kept wanting more woodland creatures to interact with the squirrel. Maybe I just wanted there to be happy ending where the squirrel learns to share.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun story, but I felt like it lacked an ending. I think the author missed a great opportunity to show the squirrel learning to share and/or appreciate what he already has. The illustrations were wonderful - the squirrel's face and eyes were so expressive!

Was this review helpful?

The artwork is great! I really love the way it looks and I think it would fit right in with what is popular among children currently. I liked parts of this book, for example, the humor was just right. However I felt like the ending was incomplete and lacking the punchline. I don't know what to make of it and I'm not sure if children would know either.

Was this review helpful?

This is the story of squirrel who is very possessive of his tree and his pinecones. I can see preschool teachers across the country falling in love with this story of absurd selfishness. It's going to be a great tool to teach young children about selfishness and sharing.

Was this review helpful?

A possessive and selfish squirrel doesn't want to share HIS tree and HIS pine cones with other animals of the forest.
He thinks about all the measures (extreme measures) he can adopt to keep everyone away.
I love the message but I'm not sure it is conveyed in the right way and I found the ending a little confusing..

Was this review helpful?

I liked the illustrations and the fact that it has the message about not being selfish, but the end had me a bit confused.

Was this review helpful?