Cover Image: Miss, What Does Incomprehensible Mean?

Miss, What Does Incomprehensible Mean?

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This is a great book, which clearly shows how much work teachers put into their job, the amount that is expected from them and the amazing influence that they can have on young lives. It also demonstrates how painful experiences in early life can shape a future but can also be used for good.

Was this review helpful?

I love, love, love this book with all my heart. A kind of ‘Bridget Jones diary’, by a fifty-something English teacher, the memoir is tender, warm, honest and very, very funny. For me, a story which makes me laugh and cry, sometimes in the same paragraph, is bound to be a winner.

As a teacher, I could relate to that peculiar blend of frustration and passion which characterises the job. There are also many moments of humour in school and the way Fran Hill describes these had me (almost) longing for my old job back. Interactions with students and colleagues had me laughing out loud. Everything is there – the clever one, the quiet one, the attention seeking, the work shy. And that’s just the teachers.
As a human being, also in my ‘middling’ years I could totally relate to the bittersweet way in which the young can unwittingly cause us to look back. Hill gets the balance just right here. We are moved but not pitying, stirred but not sad We see how our own stab at ‘being young’, along with those who helped or hindered us, can impact our relationships.

I found the few mentions of faith intriguing. It is a rare thing to find a writer who speaks of it so naturally, so honestly, rather than as someone who has made better choices, and is a better person, than everyone else. Faith can be fragile and messy as well as sustaining. Less is definitely more here, and, in my opinion, Hill has got this just right.

I would heartily recommend the book. If you are a teacher, it will have you nodding with recognition. If not, it will open up a world which, for many reasons, is often shadowy and closed to those outside it. I envy you this read. I want to do it all over again, for the first time.

Was this review helpful?

A good easy read with an interesting style of writing. I enjoy memoirs of various occupations and this one didn't disappoint.

Moments of funny, moments of reflection and moments of not niceness this is a book well worth a read

Was this review helpful?

This book gave me sleepless nights.

No, not nightmares. I struggled to put it down and go to bed because Fran Hill made me care about the characters.

Her memoir of a year teaching English in a British secondary school is by turns funny, poignant, and most of all honest. Her description of contemporary teaching in the State sector is one that I recognise from having several friends in the profession.

Written in diary form, 'Miss' struggles and also laughs with students, colleagues, family, and church. Clearly based on her own lived experience but with names and events suitably altered, amalgamated and fictionalised, this is a serious dose of reality with a smile on its face. And as such, it is a far better account of lived-out faith than the 'When I became a Christian, all my troubles went away' books.

Enthusiastically recommended.

Was this review helpful?

The writing style of the book was frankly terrible. Instead of prose it is more written in snappy, bullet point style, which is hard to read and lacks flow. My first thought was 'please tell me this woman isn't an english teacher', and lo and behold that's exactly what she is. I can't believe that an english teacher can put together something as badly written as this!

Was this review helpful?

This year in a life of an English teacher in a secondary school is done on the form of a journal. She’s in her 50’s, menopausal with spots, a bit chunky round the middle,loves a drop or two of Baileys, totally overwhelmed with marking, the usual a mixture of students and there’s Ofsted looming following a rather poor report in the last inspection.

This is a very funny memoir which I chuckled my way through and much of it resonates as I’ve been there, done that and worn out the t-shirt! I laughed out loud at the heads unmotivational motivational speeches, the work avoider (trust me, there’s always at least one who has it down to a fine art), there’s always a Rebekah (very clever), a Zak who struggles and a León who surprises himself. There are some of the funny classroom situations she gets herself into and the conversations with her colleagues are fun too. The conversations with the mirror and the scales are especially funny. It’s full of humour throughout and some is very witty, clever and a bit snarky and I love the literary references. I wish she hasn’t reminded me of exam invigilation which is death by boredom - we used to count the bricks on the rear wall of the sports hall and never got the same number twice. What can we say about the hovering (or hoovering) presence of the inspectors? It’s almost a relief when they come, a bit like toothache. I really enjoyed the various plays on words the author gave to that venerable institution. However, what shines through all this is her sheer hard work, her absolute dedication to her job and her students , the hours and hours she put into marking which clearly made her the excellent teacher her colleagues declare her.

Overall, a very enjoyable read which reminds me why I used to loved my job especially the students, being in the classroom and the camaraderie and the things I didn’t like - Ofsted obviously, Forth Bridge marking, and blooming SIMS!!!!

Thanks to NetGalley and SPCK for a copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

As an ex-school teacher myself, I'd been looking forward to reading this memoir based on the author's experience of teaching English in secondary schools. The diary format made it easy to read, meaning it would be a good book to dip in and out of...although I was so hooked that this wasn't an option!
The characters - both staff and pupils - are well-observed, and I frequently found myself sniggering at pupils' responses to lessons and homework. However, Fran Hill also manages to explore some of the darker aspects of school life. This is done with great sensitivity, so that I found myself really caring about the characters and how their stories unfolded.
I also liked the fact that Hill included snippets of her home life, so the reader gets to see how her career impacts on family and church relationships, and I was particularly moved by the way she used this as a mechanism to explore her own vulnerabilities.
Would definitely recommend this book!

Was this review helpful?

A touching yet humorous look at a year in the life of a teacher. There's a good mix of work and home life which features Hill's battles with the mirror and scales as well as an upcoming Ofsted inspection. The only downside for me was the heavy focus on religion which detracted from the rest of the book somewhat.

An easy, honest and entertaining read.

Thanks to SPCK Publishing and NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book as an ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I thank the publisher and author for this amazing opportunity.

I immediately requested this book when I saw the title because it hits so close to home. I work in education, and I swear I have had this exact phrase said to me about six billion times. I was very excited to pick it up, but I don't think this was quite what I was expecting. While I knew this memoir would be written in diary form, after a while the repetitiveness of it became quite dull after a while. I do understand that this repetitiveness is part of the position, and I do believe that it is quite a realistic look into teaching for not school-staff, but it started to blend with my actual existence and bore me a little bit. I also started to find the humour very annoying after a while — particularly in relation to Mirror and Scales. The constant mentions and repetition of negative body image started to bring forth my own insecurities about my appearance again, which was not a good thing for my already struggling mental health.

The issues with spirituality, being mid-menopause, and the age of the narrator did not achieve what they were supposed to with me as I am 19, so I don't believe that I was the target audience for this book in that sense. While I did grow up religious, I have some specific religious trauma to sort through personally, so this did not speak to me that much. In saying this, it did just feel like a natural part of life as opposed to a big deal, which I really appreciated.

In saying this, the main thing I appreciated about this book was the insights into actually dealing with these students on a daily basis. Monitoring them, watching them grow and develop, and deal with all the stresses that these fantastic young people face. There was a diverse range of students going through diverse struggles that are very realistic and worked really well from an educator's perspective. This is the success point for this book, in my opinion.

I believe that you would enjoy this book if you don't work in education and want a more realistic look into what teaching is actually like.

Was this review helpful?

All human life is here in this witty and touching memoir of one academic year in a teacher’s life. From the annoying headmaster to the supportive teaching assistant, from the fellow teacher always on the edge to the mysterious ailments of the Head of Department, I found plenty to keep me turning the pages.

I read the book in two days, resenting the household duties that tore me away. What is Camilla’s secret? Will Zak be OK? Can Sally find the strength to call it a day with Archie? How about the Goater? The author blends school life with home life, a supportive spouse, a bathroom mirror and scales who tell the author the Awful Truth every morning and her Bible study group, who learn about her back story at about the same rate as we the readers do.

There are many things to love about this book. For me, one of them was the delicate blend of humour, truth, characterisation and painful delving into the past. Several passages took me right back to places I haven’t been for a very long time. This is very clever writing.

Any teacher reading this book will be laughing wryly and nodding their head. Parents too will recognise much of the depiction of school life. It’s a great read and I cannot recommend it highly enough.

Was this review helpful?

A laugh out loud, eye opening account of life in the classroom, and just what your little darlings get up at school as told by a teacher, who has great patience and humour in all situations. Well worth a read for those who have to home school their children recently and may have a new found respect for the job teachers do.

Was this review helpful?