Cover Image: The Year's Best Science Fiction Vol. 1

The Year's Best Science Fiction Vol. 1

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC of this book. A great collection of great authors. Loved most all of the stories. Highly recommended to lovers of fantasy and sci-fi.

Was this review helpful?

I am the type person that usually stays away from short story collections. I am not completely sure why. Perhaps it is that I prefer stories that have longer story arcs, with multiple plot twists and a larger cast of characters. Maybe I feared that some short stories are not going to be “as good” as the author’s longer stories, almost like these were brief concepts or ideas. I think it’s the former and not the latter. The author’s in this collection got my attention and I’m glad it did. Jonathan Strahan did a phenomenal job pulling together fantastic short stories from some fantastic authors. Some of which I already knew, and others which I didn’t. The best part being that I got to discover new authors in the process of reading this collection and maybe that is one of the reasons collections such as this are awesome. There are too many stories to cover here but I will cover some of my favorites of this book.

This collection starts off with a bang and really sets the tone for the entire collection. Charlie Jane Anders’ story is thought provoking and intense. I don’t think there is a better story to start off with. There are similarities from our real world cultural/political divides in this story. This story might be an exaggeration of our social divide but 2020 has been an extreme year with social distancing due to a virus and social injustices. There has been enough craziness in our reality that makes Anders' story feel like a possible reality due to the conflicts we are seeing as a nation. After reading this story I was left feeling like we just need to stop, take a moment and think…like really think. What are we doing to each other?

Equally as thought provoking is N. K. Jemisin’s Emergency Skin. This first came out as part of the Forward collection from Amazon Original Stories and it was my favorite from that collection. It really feels at home in this book and fits right in with this collection of stories. The pacing of this story is just perfect slowly revealing layers of truth to a space traveler returning to Tellus (our planet) after a group of humans leave a dying Earth to start a new society. They return with caution to explore the old Earth they left behind. I don’t want to spoil this one, I love it and if don’t have time to read all of these stories, you should definitely read this one.

I enjoyed the lighter tone of I (28M) Created a Deepfake Girlfriend and Now My Parents Think We’re Getting Married by Fonda Lee. There is a bit of craziness in this story too and a sense of exaggeration but with a feel of “I can see this happening”. People in society would take hold of something like this and turn it into an obsession. This story shines a light on the chain of events that lead one person to obsess over this “tool” but sadly, I there are people in the real world that cling to social media and do the very same thing with current social apps.

Other stories that you might want to jump to first (you don’t have to read these in order!) The Galactic Tourist Industrial Complex by Tobias S. Buckell, Now Wait for This Week by Alice Sola Kim and Song of the Birds by Saleem Haddad. There is something here for any fan of science fiction and you may find yourself adding to your TBR list after discovering a new author from this book. I highly recommend this collection.

I want to thank Jonathan Strahan, all the authors who are in this book, Simon & Schuster, Saga Press and NetGalley for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I find it difficult to review anthologies, Most of these stories are really good. There are always good and bad in anthologies but the good far outweighs the bad in this one.

If you are looking for some interesting short stories get this book. The stories are by both established and new authors and I can't say I was bored with any of them. I think Mr, Strahan picked a very good mix!

Was this review helpful?

Some good, some not so much

What can I say, it's an anthology. Some stories are good, some are bad, with one or two standing out at either end. It's always good to read new authors.

I was going to post this review the other day but when I opened the Amazon review page, the one-star review by Futurearrival caught my eye. Futurearrival writes that except for a few, the stories here are full of biggotry and hate. These are strong words so I went back and reevaluated the collection.

I'm not a short story reader and I don't have Futurearrival's history with the earlier editions of this anthology series edited by the late Gardner Dozois. So I have no notions about Dozois' legacy and how that might affect Futurearrival's opinions.

There are 28 stories in the collection and while there is a lot of anger in these stories, I don't see it as bigotry and hate. Most of anger is about caste oppression and the fight against it. Many of the rest of the stories reflect anger at damage to the environment. A few express anger about bad men and the havoc they cause. All in all I don't see that Futurearrival's reflective anger is warranted.

Was this review helpful?

Anthologies can be hit or miss depending on the editor’s vision. I picked this one up on NetGalley hoping to see a glimpse of the current short fiction world. What I didn’t expect was how many of the twenty-eight stories would win me over. These stories provide a diversity of voices and narrative styles, along with authors from many nations and/or ethnicities. The stories overall have more of a literary and sociological feel than the pulpy roots of the genre, but for every surreal tale, there is one more plot driven.

Jonathan Strahan begins the anthology with an essay on the state of the genre not only in short stories but across all mediums including non-fiction. This essay has enough examples you could easily use it as a reading list for the year. He also names the short fiction venues that he considers top markets.

The purpose of this volume, according to Strahan, is to honor works by stellar authors whether established or still becoming known. The theme celebrates diversity and the impact of culture. Rather than attempting to constrain speculative fiction into a narrow definition, Strahan aims to reveal how the genre can be both timely and interesting.

He succeeded on behalf of this reader. I am posting my review in two parts so I can call out all the stories that spoke to me, whether my favorites or those that came close. So, with no further ado, on to the stories:

These two were my favorites in the first half, a purely personal reaction. However, there is no question they are strong, well-written tales.

Kali_Na by Indrapramit Das
While I appreciated other stories, in Kali_Na I found my first favorite. It’s hard to articulate why without spoilers, so I’ll say only this: When Internet trolls come out in force to greet a newborn AI version of the Goddess Durga, the caste system might not be the only tradition to survive to modern day. It’s a cyberpunk-like vision of future India seen from the bottom looking up.

Sturdy Lantern and Ladders by Malka Older
I usually tidy my notes for the review, but here’s a direct quote: “Okay, wow. This is just wow.” I love this story for how it begins, because I’m sympathetic, then it takes us somewhere fascinating and new. Besides, it stars an octopus. I’d say more, but better you experience it on your own.

The below stories all had something about them I enjoyed, and/or which made them stand out. Appreciation is personal. While the missing stories did not catch my attention, they might still earn yours.

The Bookstore at the End of America by Charlie Jane Anders
The Bookstore at the End of America begins this volume with a glimpse down the path America is currently walking. The story has an almost magical realism tone. It looks at bias and the consequences of same, but more in raising questions than forcing answers on the reader. I like how it makes me think about these questions while reminding me of reading about a real-world library that exists on the U.S./Canadian border. I hope that library never faces what Charlie Jane Anders’ one does.

The Galactic Tourist Industrial Complex by Tobias S. Buckell
As you might have guessed from the title, this short story offers a quick glimpse of a future where alien tourism wins. It’s something we’ve seen in smaller scales on our planet, but this is planetwide. But how our world has changed because of this commerce is only part of the story. Seen through the eyes of a taxi driver, the struggle to anticipate alien demands is both compelling and thought provoking.

Song of the Birds by Saleem Haddad
This story didn’t speak to me in part because of the focus on suicide. However, the strong imagery was compelling enough to warrant a mention. Nor is it the only story to include suicide as an aspect.

The Painter of Trees by Suzanne Palmer
This is an odd story, but a powerful one about ambition, arrogance, and claiming what is not your own. The author plays on the anonymity of first person, shared with a third person point of view (POV), to create a sense of mystery. There were enough clues to give me the answer before the reveal, but I still needed confirmation. It’s not only the mixed POV that makes this story stand out, however. I found the first-person narrator unsympathetic to the point of arguing with the page. In terms of engagement, this story earns a place, and I appreciate the questions it raises for all the method leaves me frustrated.

The Last Voyage of Skidbladnir by Karin Tidbeck
This story doesn’t have a firm plot, which is bizarre in a lot of ways since it’s a spaceship passenger vessel and has many of the older tropes mentioned. Instead, it’s beautiful for what it says and shows for both the speaking characters and those without a voice. The story didn’t go quite where I expected, but living ships and mechanically inclined, fix-it characters are some of my favorites.

Contagion’s Eve at the House Noctambulous by Rich Larson
The story sucked me into the moment with its sensory detail, so I accepted the strange happenings around me without question. And what’s happening is strange beyond question. This is the first one I’d classify as horror, and I don’t read horror because of the ability to be sucked in rather than despite it. I can safely say this is a strong horror offering, in part because it had the possibility of being something different had it made another choice.

Submarines by Han Song Translated by Ken Liu
As an example of the diversity within these pages, this story has two names attached, the author and the translator. It’s another odd story of unknowns and unknowables told through the perspective of an ignorant narrator. There are no answers to the many questions raised, and as a reader, I’m left trying to find meaning where none is offered. I don’t know whether this makes it more powerful a story or less. The imagery lingers, as does the tantalizing possibility of answers far beyond the life of our narrator.

As the Last I May Know by S. L. Huang
This is a powerful story of understanding war. It asks the same question covered in the movie War Games but puts it into more personal terms. The practice that serves as the story’s backbone is horrific, but that very quality makes it the best and possibly only way. The story offers a deep dive into another culture and the conflict between old and new ways. It plays with the reader’s emotions and pushes us to ask what we would do in the same situation.

A Catalog of Storms by Fran Wilde
This is a neat, surreal concept. It turns a story of lists into something emotional that plays with the reader’s sympathies tangibly. I enjoyed the imagery, the concept, and ultimately the question between desire and cost.

Dune Song by Suyi Davies Okungbowa
The narrative voice in this story is powerful and the description strong. I found the story to turn on belief and choice. Nata is trying to find her mother and find other civilizations. She rejects the ways of her village, choosing to reach for freedom rather than huddle in the dark and let fear swallow their voices whole. This makes it powerful.

P.S. I received this Advanced Reader Copy from the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.

PART TWO

As I read through the second half of this book, I found the editor’s focus on current concerns led to several stories with themes and elements in common. I’d expect something like this in a themed anthology, but it surprised me here where the publication date is what brings these stories together. While this repetition could have disadvantaged the later stories, their approaches had enough originality to counter the downsides. The included stories explore a variety of differences whether or not sharing a theme. Narrative style, plotting, and even perception of time proved flexible in these tellings, something intriguing while it asks a lot of the reader at times.

As with the first section, I’m only mentioning the stories I connected with, which doesn’t mean there’s nothing interesting about the others. My choices result from personal taste, whether in content, characters, style, or theme. The other stories could be someone else’s favorite, despite not speaking to me.

Once again, two stories stood out from the rest of the second half.

Soft Edges by Elizabeth Bear
This is a beautiful story about philosophy and human nature running alongside a police procedural. It shows how to respect people’s choices and contrary positions without compromising the bigger picture. It also demonstrates how personal pronouns can become part of a normal introduction without awkwardness or stopping the narrative. Nicely done.

The Archronology of Love by Caroline M. Yoachim
This story is right in my sweet spot. It mixes alien contact with neat technology while still making the characters approachable. It’s both personal and immense with real learning and change.

While not my absolute favorites, as you can see from the blurbs below, these stories were strong contenders.

Emergency Skin by N. K. Jemisin
This is a strange story with an odd but perfect narrator. It’s mostly told sideways from the collective voice embedded in the main character’s head as it tries to explain away everything the character encounters as a false narrative. The meaning and plot are obvious from the start but that doesn’t matter. A fun read with deeper implications.

Thoughts and Prayers by Ken Liu
This story focuses more on the timely and less on the speculative element, though when it appears, the element is critical. The tale explores the problematic nature of media consumption on the internet through the window of gun violence. Thought provoking, the story is painful in its circumstances. The narration cleverly mirrors the characters’ progress through the story.

At the Fall by Alec Nevala-Lee
This story grew on me as I read it. I found the narration through an advanced research vehicle (?) creature (?) fascinating. The plot itself was predictable first in the cause and then by design as the narrator undergoes a long, dangerous journey. Her method of experiencing space and memory informs her discovery path, but the reader knows little and not much happens actively. It’s a gentle story, an odd adjective considering the circumstances she faces, but one I learned to appreciate.

Reunion by Vandana Singh
This is a story of becoming rather than doing. While the main character accomplished a lot in her attempt to restore the planet, it is her growth in connection and understanding that form the foundation. This is a fresh approach to the theme of climate repair and one that speaks to me. I enjoyed the vision she has of humans as part of the world, not controlling it. But the small glimpses of her interactions with people and the frailty of her own body made this story work for me.

Secret Stories of Doors by Sofia Rhei
The beginning of this story didn’t grab me, but I’m glad I kept going. In a surreal narrative, this tale takes the premise of “history is written by the victors” a step further. It offers a warped future with more twists to discover.

And there you have it. I clearly found many stories to enjoy. This anthology tackles questions we face in modern times through the lens of speculative fiction. Most fell into the science fiction category, though often near future, and didn’t shy away from the more painful topics of suicide, rape, and gun violence either. Climate reconstruction seems the most common element taken on. The differing proposals spoke not just to the science but also to the underlying cultural and social elements, much to my delight.

I’m happy I plucked this anthology from the list and plan to track down more by authors I “met” or was reminded of here.

P.S. I received this Advanced Reader Copy from the publisher through NetGalley in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

As primarily a reader of novels, short story collections are not always on my reading list. However, I do find them to be an interesting way to find some possible new authors to read further. So, I do find value in collections like this one. There is much food for thought in most entries, whether they were favorites or not. Many authors of diverse cultures are included, so this anthology also serves as an introduction to many. Although I have read several author's works previously, there were many that were new to me.

I believe my favorite selection is "Emergency Skin," by N.K. Jemisin. I am an optimist at heart and this story not only was one of the most optimist (in my opinion), but has a fun little quick that appeals to my sense of humor. And, has something to say about how we treat our world. Overall, I believe the second half of the book is the strongest, but others may feel otherwise.

Which is a great segue into this discussion; most of these stories do deal with issues that need to be taken seriously in our world. Climate change is a major topic in many stories. Sexual politics and consequences are included, as well others. There is much to think about in these stories, even if the story itself doesn't appeal. If readers enjoy dystopian fiction they will find the majority show a disturbing view of our future as a world (species?)

A worthy contribution to an examination of international short science fiction.

Was this review helpful?

Gardner Dozois’ Year’s Best collections were a staple of my childhood, mostly because it was some of the only science fiction my local library could be relied on to buy every year. If this inaugural volume is anything to go by, Jonathan Strahan is a worthy successor. This is an anthology of 28 stories from 2019, delightfully diverse and spanning a wide range of themes.

“Everybody needs books, Molly figured. No matter where they live, how they love, what they believe, whom they want to kill. We all want books.”


Charlie Jane Ander’s “The Bookstore at the End of America” serves as a not particularly subtle introduction to a group of stories about how the stories we tell divide us, unite us, and bring us hope. Almost all of the stories were new to me even if the authors weren’t. The only exception was S.L. Huang’s bombshell “As the Last I May Know,” about one child and a nation’s “ethical” solution to nuclear warfare, which won the Hugo for short story this year. Also as unsurprisingly exceptional – even though I hadn’t read it before – was N.K. Jemisin’s “Emergency Skin,” which handles a topic (climate change and apocalypse) others cover in this anthology with unbelievable skill and a frankly unparalleled storytelling ability. Despite the subject matter, it’s surprisingly hopeful, as is Malka Older’s “Sturdy Lantern and Ladders” about a behavioral researcher who job is to provide stress relief for a research octopus.

For new-to-me authors, I was particularly taken by Indrapramit Das’ “Kali_Na,” about an AI goddess and a poor, lower-caste Indian girl. On the less than hopeful and more rage-filled side (this is 2020, we all need a little bit of screaming into the void at this point), Alice Sola Kim’s “Now Wait For This Week” is a not-particularly-subtle Groundhog-Day-like take on sexual harassment. Karin Tidbeck’s “The Last Voyage of Skidbladnir” is one of the few outright adventure-type stories, following a human grease monkey on a strange interstellar cruise ship. I’d also add Tegan Moore’s “The Work of Wolves,” from the point of view of an Enhanced search and rescue dog who’s puzzled by her cold relationship with her handler, to that pile.

I was especially touched by Caroline M. Yoachim’s “The Archronology of Love.” One of my favorite styles of science fiction is plopping down relatable characters in different-but-not-so-different places and times, using that lens to reinterpret our lives. This story is a heart wrenching tale of a woman who’s lost her husband and the future they were planning to share and now has to unravel the mystery of the failed colony, all the while dealing with her nearly grown up son.

Overall, even if some of the stories weren’t to my taste, they were for the most part high quality. I also appreciated the long introduction listing the editor’s favorites from the year, regardless of length or format. While I’d already read or added most of them to my TBR, I found a few new gems. This is definitely a worthy successor to one of my childhood favorites and I will definitely be picking up next year’s edition!

I received an advance review copy of this book from NetGalley. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.

Was this review helpful?

Excellent way to get into science fiction.

Excellent variety and length of well-written stories.

Highly recommended for new and season sci-fi readers.

Was this review helpful?

I have always been a huge fan of The Year's Best Science Fiction anthologies and was elated to see they were back. I love reading short stories from well-loved authors as well as discovering many new authors through these incredible stories. There are author introductions at the beginning of each short story and a recommended sci-fi reading list at the of the volume. I have to say, I was quite impressed with Strahan’s inaugural edition.

I thoroughly enjoyed this mix of science fiction and speculative fiction. 3 of my favorites were, “The Bookstore at the End of America,” by Charlie Jane Anders (about a bookstore and masterful world building), “The Work of Wolves,” by Tegan Moore (Fascinating perspective), and “I (28M) created a deepfake girlfriend and now my parents think we’re getting married” by Fonda Lee (Had me giggle snorting). And in my true fashion where I can’t stick to anything, I’m gonna add a 4th lol, simply because I love dystopians, dark humor, and the rebel in me doesn’t want to stick with 3, “Secret Stories of Doors,” by Sofia Rhei.

Many thanks to Saga Press and Netgalley for the DRC and the opportunity to share my thoughts.

Was this review helpful?

I love discovering new authors and amazing short stories by some of my favorites. The easiest way to accomplish both is by reading anthologies. Short to medium length stories, usually written around a theme, by both well known and coming up authors. This one is truly some of the best science fiction this year. Invest an afternoon and evening to these 10 stories and you will not be sorry.

Was this review helpful?

With Gardner Dozois' passing, science fiction lost not only a brilliant writer but also one of the most prominent editors in the genre. Since 1984, he'd presided over the premiere collection of sci-fi's shorter works via his Year's Best collections, which numbered thirty-five at the time of his demise. Two years on, Jonathan Strahan and Saga Press have stepped into the void to present 2019's best for eager fans who've missed these definitive anthologies.

Mr Strahan's inaugural volume starts off strong, from an introduction that champions diversity to several shorts that absolutely kick ass in delivering on that promise. My belief in Charlie Jane Anders' talent was finally vindicated with her story here, The Bookstore At The End Of America. The volume opener isn't exactly a subtle tale but it is both entertaining and thoughtful, and I felt it much more deeply than I have her other, more celebrated works. The next story, Tobias S Buckell's The Galactic Tourist Industrial Complex is a must for fans of Nnedi Okorafor's Hugo-winning <a href="http://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2020/06/10/laguardia-by-nnedi-okorafor-tana-ford/">LaGuardia</a>, treading in the same far-future of extraterrestrial immigration. The Hugos are actually quite well represented here, with 4 of the 28 stories being nominees for either <a href="http://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2020/06/08/hugo-awards-2020-short-story-nominees/">Best Short Story</a> or <a href="http://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2020/06/11/hugo-awards-2020-novelette-nominees/">Best Novelette</a>. Tbh, I didn't really care for any of those selected for this volume besides N. K. Jemisin's terrific Emergency Skin, which has also been my favorite work of hers so far.

Continuing the theme of short stories that improved my opinion of the author compared to their prior works was Kali_Na by Indrapramit Das, whose debut novel <a href="http://www.thefrumiousconsortium.net/2019/01/04/the-devourers-by-indra-das/">The Devourers</a> was firmly meh for me. In contrast, I was blown away by Kali_Na's ideas of godhood and virtual avatars, a wonderful application of real-world sociology to the ways technology can transcend the mundane. I was also impressed by another Indian-set story that melded technology with psychology, Anil Menon's The Robots Of Eden. While Saleem Haddad's Song Of The Birds was set hundreds of miles away in Palestine, it was another excellent, and moving, examination of behavior modification technology. Crossing Asia in the other direction, we get to Han Song's Submarines -- translated for us here by Ken Liu, who also contributes an original story -- about migrants on the Yangtze River. All four of these stories manage to evoke a sense of place that's as vital to the narrative as their speculative natures are.

There's a very similar feel to Sofia Rhei's Barcelona-set Secret Stories Of Doors, as well as to the scathing critique of New York City's upper class in E. Lily Yu's Green Glass: A Love Story. Ted Chiang's It's 2059, And The Rich Kids Are Still Winning reads less like a story and exactly like a sociological treatise, only from the future. I almost forgot I wasn't reading an article while enjoying it. Fonda Lee's near-future comedy I (28M) Created A Deepfake Girlfriend And Now My Parents Think We're Getting Married is also the kind of thing I could imagine reading on Reddit in ten years or less. Well, from the Twitter account AITA_reddit anyway; I've so far managed to avoid getting a Reddit account and am quite happy to keep it that way. Of the other far future stories, Rich Larson's Contagion's Eve At The House Noctambulus was my absolute favorite for sheer goriness (plus it reminded me of one of my all-time favorite books, Gideon The Ninth.) Honorable mention goes to Alec Nivala-Lee's At The Fall, which was like Homeward Bound meets Finding Dory, only with AI.

Despite the vast majority of these books dealing with planet Earth and humanity's secrets, there were several stories that traveled off into space. Of these, my favorite was Karin Tidbeck's The Last Voyage of Skidbladnir, which deals with a very unusual form of interstellar travel. Overall tho, there was less of a focus on outer space and more on the planet we're living in and what we're doing to it, an understandable change of emphasis given the ways we're beginning to reap what we've sown on this planet. Which isn't to say that this is a depressing book: on the contrary, many of the stories here speak of resilience, resistance and optimism, in the finest tradition of the genre.

The Year's Best Science Fiction Vol. 1: The Saga Anthology of Science Fiction 2020 edited by Jonathan Strahan was published yesterday by Saga Press, and is available from all good booksellers.

Was this review helpful?

This first volume in a new series of "The Year's Best Science Fiction, edited by Jonathan Strahan, is a great collection of current visions and important overarching themes in the genre. Many of the stories carry a message of economic and societal inequity amid vast climate and ecological changes and technological advances that affect, to varying degrees, rich and poor alike. A few pure fantasy stories are mixed in with an otherwise strong showing of global authors in hard, soft, and speculative fiction. The nearly-pure fantasy ranges into space, while a few stories descend to the seabed, and several bring us to witness shifting sea-level as it reclaims megacities such as Mumbai and New York.

In my own opinion, three of the stories stand out for their different focus amid the sci-fi and fantasy of the others. In one, "The Work of Wolves" by Tegan Moore, the inner life of an enhanced-intelligence search-and-rescue dog is told from the dog's perspective, an innovative approach to a narrative that might otherwise have remained a mundane story about augmented biology. In "Now Wait for This Week" by Alice Sola Kim, a young woman relives the week of her birthday over and over, sort of like "Groundhog Day" but with a strong #MeToo element to the story. And in "Secret Stories of Doors," Sofia Rhei turns the Ministry of Truth from George Orwell's "1984" fully inside out, with some help from HG Wells and Orson Welles, in a global dystopia where fiction is banned.

Finally, one story by Ken Liu entitled "Thoughts and Prayers" strikes a particularly resounding note in our present time, when the mother of a teenager killed in a mass shooting allows the anti-gun lobby to tell her child's story. The public grieving brings out a particularly virulent troll response, leading to psychological terrors that tear the surviving family apart and send the mother into an emotional spiral from which she never recovers. With such events going on in the real world and online, it's no wonder that every day feels like another foray into the increasingly uncanny valley between memory and good science fiction.

Was this review helpful?

The Year's Best Science Fiction by Jonathan Strahan is a superb page turner. Well worth the time and the read! Looking forward to the next novel.

Was this review helpful?

What a collection of books! I thoroughly enjoyed the wonderful works of authors like Rebecca Roanhorse, Maria Machado, and so many more talented sci-fi authors!

I appreciated the introduction to the book, that being the author's introductions. It gives a little glimpse into the careers of these talented people. Through this story, I found myself writing down the names of certain authors in order to look them up later, and hopefully find more of their works to add to my library.

I appreciate people like Jonathan Strahan who take the time to put together anthologies so others can enjoy short stories. It was riveting and I think he made excellent selections from 2020's sci-fi! Some were action-packed while others were more thought-provoking, and I enjoyed the change of pace and build-up that each story brought.

Was this review helpful?

An excellent book of science fiction and speculative fiction is to rea.d. The beginning of the volume is the standard industrial discussion given in most science fiction anthologies of the year. There are introductions of the authors at the beginning of each short story.. At the end of this volume there is a recommended list of reading of science fiction.

I enjoyed reading it. The stories are excellent with some authors that I knew and those I didn’t know. I definitely have some authors to add to my authors to watch for list (for my reading pleasure). I know I will be looking for volume 2 next year! This is a must read for all science fiction lovers!

Was this review helpful?

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Review copy provided by the publisher.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Why would you want a volume of the year's best short science fiction? Well, several reasons. If you don't keep up with short fiction but like it, a one-volume summary from an editor whose taste aligns well with yours can give you a glimpse, at least, of the gigantic world beyond. If you do, you might want some of your favorite stories conveniently in one place, with some perspective that will let you say in 2029, oh yes, that's what 2019 was like in short fiction, those stories were published at basically the same time. Or you might enjoy having someone hit a few highlights that you didn't manage to get to yourself.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Because unless someone is directly paying you to read <em>all the short SFF</em>, you <em>will</em> miss some things. I sure do. (I suspect that even the people who are directly paid miss things too. There's a lot.)</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>So how does this volume do with that? Pretty well, I think. There are several stories I enjoyed the first time around and am glad to see again collected--notably Fran Wilde's "A Catalog of Storms" but also Ken Liu's "Thoughts and Prayers," Fonda Lee's "I (28M) Created A Deepfake Girlfriend and Now My Parents Think We're Getting Married," and Indrapramit Das's "Kali_Na." I would not have made the same choice as Strahan for Best Elizabeth Bear Story of the Year, but "Soft Edges" is a good story, it's just that there's tough competition for that position.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Of course I definitely want a YB volume to introduce me to great stories I've missed, and this one delivers. There aren't any I'd consider duds--all have solid reasons to be included (please note that this has <em>not</em> always been the case for me with YB volumes)--and several new stories would have made my favorites list if I'd read them in time. Stand-outs for me in this category included Suzanne Palmer's "The Painter of Trees," Karin Tidbeck's "The Last Voyage of Skidbladnir," Malka Older's "Sturdy Ladders and Lanterns," and Alec Nevala-Lee's "At the Fall"--all very different and very compelling.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Strahan didn't hit even remotely all of my favorites for 2019, but that would have been impossible and should not be expected. His taste leans toward more exposition than implication in some of these stories, but it's quality exposition. He also limits his remit to science fiction as distinct from fantasy, which is a distinction I often find counter-productive...except when it's a matter of fitting vast available material into a book of usable size, in which case it becomes pretty understandable. You could do a lot worse than this one if you tried to pick good stories from 2019.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->

Was this review helpful?

This is an excellent anthology from so many amazing SF authors. Not all of these stories blew me away, but the ones that did will stay with me forever. This is the type of anthology where you realize what kind of breadth Science Fiction has as a genre. From alternate present-day musings, to near future dystopia, or to completely unrecognizable futures of humanity, this collection encompasses them all.

Was this review helpful?

Gallery/Saga Press and renowned short fiction editor Jonathan Strahan begin a new Best SF of the Year series with this new anthology which presents Strahan's view of the best science fiction of 2019. His task is daunting. There is more short science fiction published every year in an increasing number of venues world wide that I find it difficult to comprehend how one person can keep up with it all. And yet, Strahan finds 28 diverse stories written by diverse authors from around the world that not only prove that science fiction in the short form is alive and well, but it is alive and well in places that traditional readers would not even think to look.

Some of his selections not only show up as finalists for various awards in 2020, a few of them were winners and were outstanding tales. Charlie Jane Anders' "The Bookstore at the End of America", Locus Award winner for Best Short Story, gives us a tale of what may be the not too distant future in which California is a separate country from the rest of the United States. The division is based on liberal versus conservative values. The titular bookstore resides on both sides of the border, as the owner hopes to bring people of warring nations together to find common ground and get along. The other short story winner here is S.L. Huang's "As the Last I May Know", one of my favorites in the book. It is a gut wrenching tale of what lengths a society will to go to prevent using a devastating weapon during wartime. It's a brilliant story.

There are a bunch of short story award finalists here too. Fran Wilde's Hugo and Nebula finalist "A Catalog of Storms" straddles the boundary of science fiction and fantasy (in my opinion, anyway) in relating the story of how a town beset by storms uses the names of the storms to gain control over them. Those who name the storms, however, become "weathermen" and are lost forever to the town. Locus Award finalist "I (28M) Created a Deepfake Girlfriend and Now My Parents Think We're Getting Married" by Fonda Lee is a charming tale that I suspect many of us can relate to. Our protagonist, trying to get his parents off his back, does exactly what the title says and the result is what the title says. What happens in between is the fun part. Another Locus Award finalist, "The Galactic Tourist Industrial Complex" by Tobias S. Buckell, is an amusing tale of aliens that come to Manhattan looking for the American experience and end up doing very American-like things. In one more Locus Award finalist, the incomparable Ted Chiang gives us "It's 2059, and the Rich Kids are Still Winning", a look at how things, meant to help the greater good, only help those who aready have the help they need. It's a
classic have versus have not piece, and I loved it.

The novelette category is well represented in the book as well in terms of award recognition. Hugo winner and Locus finalist "Emergency Skin", by N.K. Jemison, relates the story of a mission from an earth colony back to the home world in order to acquire a key element to their survival. The expect to find no survivors, no civilization. What they find instead is something that they can't believe. A truly terrific story well-deserving of its Hugo win. "The Archronology of Love" from Carolyn M. Yoachim, both a Hugo and Nebula finalist, is a poignant tale of a group of archronologists looking for the reason a research colony disappeared, and what the leader of that team finds. It's a gut wrenching tale.

But that's just a fraction of the stories in this book. As with every "best of" collection, the reader's mileage may vary. Among those that didn't make any finalist list (and in some cases I find it a severe oversight by those picking the awards, and then again it's my opinion anyway), one of the best is Saleem Haddad's "Song of the Birds", a difficult to describe but thought provoking tale of a girl who mourns the loss of her brother, only to discover that the world she is living in isn't what she really thinks it is. This is a terrific tale. Rich Larson's "Contagion's Eve at the House Noctambulous" seems to be a traditional tale of "remembering how we got here so we don't get here again", but it ends with a twist I should have seen coming but didn't. Indrapramit Das gives us "Kali_Na", an AI "goddess" brought into the world who learns all the wrong things from the future equivalent of trolls. Some things never change.

Other interesting stories include "Now Wait for This Week", by Alice Sola Kim. It's a kind of a groundhog day story, with Bonnie experiencing the same week over and over again. Her exasperated friends are not caught in the same loop, so interesting things occur as the reader returns to the point where each week starts. Bonnie's roommate tries to help her get out of the loop, but things just don't turn out as planned. Peter Watts - I'll read anything by Peter Watts - gives us "Cycloperus" - named after the Cyclopterus lumpus (a lumpfish), go figure - where the world is falling apart and Alistor's management hires a deep sea sub to go to the bottom of the ocean floor in search of resources. Alistor is obviously not who he appears to be, and I do feel sorry for Koa, the pilot of the vessel. Standard Watts stuff, which makes it very good. Tegan Moore's "The Work of Wolves" is an engaging story of operatives whose job it is to rescue stranded people, and the dogs that work with them. Carol resents her new AI dog - her previous dog was not enhanced - but comes to love and respect the dog - Sera - when they are assigned to a non-typical mission. A nice little twist was unexpected, thus making
it a twist, I suppose. "Soft Edges", by Elizabeth Bear, is not so much a police procedural as it is a story about a
scientist who can help with a murder investigation but doesn't want to due to philosophical beliefs. E. Lily Yu's "Green Glass: A Love Story" is a tale of excess to the n-th degree. Very bizarre, but strangely engaging.

The list goes on. There are stories by Greg Egan, Suzanne Palmer, Karin Tidbeck, Malka Older, Han Song, Anil Menon, Suyi Davies Okungbowa, Ken Liu, Alec Nevala-Lee, Vandana Singh, Sofia Rhei, and Chinelo Onwualu to go along with the others that I mentioned. Every one of these stories is good, and although not all of them are to my tastes, all of them speak to the international scope of the short science fiction field today. Strahan has once again knocked it out of the park, and has shown that the field is secure for years to come.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Gallery Books/Saga Press for letting me read and review this array of different, unique, and great Science Fiction stories. This is a well rounded and interesting collection of stories that cover quite a broad range in Science Fiction and has familiar, well-known authors as well as offering work of new more unknown authors also.
There's so much in anthologies, it's sometimes hard to know how or what exactly to review about all the stories and authors in them because there's so much in them. This has quite a few authors I'm familiar with and enjoy, some unknown and new to me authors that I'm more interested in checking out more of their work now and a large range of stories covering various topics. The stories range anywhere from Outer Limits to Twilight Zone types of Science Fiction.
I enjoyed a lot of the stories, but there were some that I didn't like as much and there were a few that got me emotional and a few that kind of scared me, or maybe better wording would be greatly disturbed and creeped me out. Some of the stories were very far out there with Sci-Fi, others were more mainstream type and others were uncanny with how close to our reality they are.
This is a pretty great collection of stories put together that can show you more of the authors you already love and introduce you to more new and awesome Science Fiction authors. I also enjoyed a wide range of topics and stories with the various types of Science Fiction.
If you like anthologies and Science Fiction, make sure to have this one on your list to check it out as soon as it comes out. The only CW/TW I would put here is that there's some profanity and such in some of the stories, but other than that not much.

Was this review helpful?

The Year's Best Science Fiction Vol. 1: The Saga Anthology of Science Fiction 2020. This collection of short stories is not a light read at 608 pages, but because they are short stories it is easy to pickup read and put down, until you have gotten though all of them. The collection offers a glimpse at dystopian but believable panes of existence. I can see the stories easily being made into Twilight Zone or Dark Mirror episodes. The writers have created unique, fascinating worlds that give pause to make you think. It is a fascinating and sometimes chilling look at society and our possible futures.

**FULL DISCLOSURE** I received an ARC of, this collection for review purposes. The editor requested a review, but made no conditions for it. I am writing this review based solely on my enjoyment of this collection.

Was this review helpful?