Cover Image: The Pull of the Stars

The Pull of the Stars

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

Thank you Net Gallery and the publishers for allowing me to read this advanced Copy of The Book Of Lost Names. Like so many people during the late 1930’s Eve and her parents didn’t see what the Nazi’s would do. Once she does, her specific talents develop. She becomes a forger which allows Jewish Children and others in Peril to escape Nazi occupied France. This was a wonderful story with fully developed characters and evolve over the course of the war. I sobbed through the ending but wished there were a few more chapters to allow Eve, to see the fruits of her labor. I loved this book. I am a great fan of Kristin Harmel. This book does not disappoint. I think it was one of her best.

Was this review helpful?

Reading this novel about the pandemic of 1918 seems all too real in light of the COVID19 Pandemic a century later. Unknowingly, the author's book was ready for publication right on the heels of this more recent virus. The author brings the struggles of Doctors and especially nurses into reality. The darkness of such times is lightened only by the compassion and personal care given to those suffering from this rare flu. It is definitely a timely novel, being able to read the revelation of the past Pandemic while living with the present Pandemic.
This was a difficult read because the narrative did not include dialogue tags or punctuation for dialogue that makes it easier for the reader to follow the context of the story.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve always been a fan of Emma Donaghue’s books, and this one did not disappoint! This book follows Julia Power, a nurse on a Labor and Delivery floor during the 1918 flu pandemic that cares for expectant mothers with the flu. The story follows three days in the ward, and tests Julia in many ways from caring for sick patients to managing her relationships with the people around her.. This book feels incredibly timely and absolutely worth picking up. Once I started it, I couldn’t put it down!

Was this review helpful?

First sentence: Still hours of dark to go when I left the house that morning. I cycled through reeking Dublin streets that were slick with rain. My short green cape kept off the worst, but my coat sleeves were soon wet through.

Premise/plot: Set during the Spanish Influenza of 1918 in Dublin, Ireland, it follows Nurse Julia Power closely over the course of three days in the maternity fever ward. Julia is a midwife; she's used to losing patients--either mothers, or babies, or sometimes both mother and baby. She has a way of marking each loss of a patient; she's diligent and hardworking, but caring as well.

Readers get to know a few other characters as well including one person from history: Dr. Kathleen Lynn (1874–1955).

My thoughts: What an incredibly intense read!!!! For better or worse. There's nothing beautiful or glamorous about being a nurse/midwife. And the women in her ward, in her care, well they're fully fleshed/realized characters. This is like a super-super-super-super-super intense episode of Call the Midwife minus the hope and humor.

There are essentially NO CHAPTERS, just four sections (if I counted right, which is always doubtful!). I'm not sure if the lack of chapters kept me up reading, or, if it was my need to know if anyone would be okay, if the patients would live to see another day or night.

I'm not sure if the narrative style is technically stream of consciousness, but, if I had to guess I'd say it might very well be. It is very in the moment and personal. We see everything through Nurse Power's eyes.

Reading this during COVID is an experience in and of itself. I think that's why it's being published perhaps a little earlier than originally intended?

I noticed just one headline about the flu today, low down on the right: Increase in Reports of Influenza. A masterpiece of understatement, as if it were only the reporting that had increased, or perhaps the pandemic was a figment of the collective imagination. I wondered whether it was the newspaper publisher’s decision to play down the danger or if he’d received orders from above.



That’s what influenza means, she said. Influenza delle stelle—the influence of the stars. Medieval Italians thought the illness proved that the heavens were governing their fates, that people were quite literally star-crossed. I pictured that, the celestial bodies trying to fly us like upside-down kites. Or perhaps just yanking on us for their obscure amusement.



But wasn’t it the whole world’s war now? Hadn’t we caught it from each other, as helpless against it as against other infections? No way to keep one’s distance; no island to hide on. Like the poor, maybe, the war would always be with us. Across the world, one lasting state of noise and terror under the bone man’s reign.



THE PUBLIC IS URGED TO STAY OUT OF PUBLIC PLACES SUCH AS CAFÉS, THEATRES, CINEMAS, AND PUBLIC HOUSES. SEE ONLY THOSE PERSONS ONE NEEDS TO SEE. REFRAIN FROM SHAKING HANDS, LAUGHING, OR CHATTING CLOSELY TOGETHER. IF ONE MUST KISS, DO SO THROUGH A HANDKERCHIEF. SPRINKLE SULPHUR IN THE SHOES. IF IN DOUBT, DON’T STIR OUT.



It occurred to me that in the case of this flu there could be no signing a pact with it; what we waged in hospitals was a war of attrition, a battle over each and every body.



THE GOVERNMENT HAS THE SITUATION WELL IN HAND AND THE EPIDEMIC IS ACTUALLY IN DECLINE. THERE IS NO REAL RISK EXCEPT TO THE RECKLESS WHO TRY TO FIGHT THE FLU ON THEIR FEET. IF YOU FEEL YOURSELF SUCCUMBING, REPORT YOURSELF AND LIE DOWN FOR A FORTNIGHT. WOULD THEY BE DEAD IF THEY’D STAYED IN BED?

Was this review helpful?

This is a brilliant, timely and unputdownable novel set during the 1918 flu pandemic in a poor Dublin hospital during the days leading up to the Armistice, Julia is a nurse whose job it is to look after women with the flu who are just about to give birth. In case you don't know, the Spanish Flu was most lethal for pregnant women. In her tiny ward with just three beds, Julia tries valiantly to save her patients and their babies. She's helped by Bridie, a new volunteer, and Dr. Kathleen Lynn, a rebel on the run from the police.

This is an intense and immersive read, not only because of Donoghue's vividly precise research, characters and story but also because this is oh so relevant to what we're all going through right now with the current pandemic.

As I closed this book I swallowed back tears but was also left with a feeling of hope. A stunningly good book that should be read by everyone.

Was this review helpful?

Vita gloriosa vita. Life glorious life.

There’s an aura throughout this story that is somewhat bleak, while at the same time gripping in the dangers, the then fairly recent uprising that occurred Easter 1916, WWI, the conditions these people face during the 1918 pandemic – something that we have all recently become too familiar with. There’s also so much tender consideration, kindness from this nurse and her young charge that comes to assist the ward where Julia Power works, the Maternity / Fever ward, designated for those women with the flu who are separated from the healthy maternity patients. Along with that, some lovely writing, too.

Julia is a nurse nearing her 30th birthday, and when she arrives at work that morning she’s informed that she will be in charge, for the day, of this newly formed ward, and that the other nurse scheduled is ‘missing in action,’ with two expectant, as well as sick, mothers in her care - one having died during the previous night’s shift. And while no assistant is promised, one eventually appears, Bridie Sweeney.

Bridie is a delight, a wonderful addition, both to Julia and to the reader, as she brings much light to this story. A young woman who isn’t quite sure of her age, having been left in one of the Catholic convents, she’s known little of the world, and nothing about love, the only treatment she’s had at the hands of the nuns has not been kind. Bridie shares her story, little by little with Julia. Julia, being a kind hearted woman, cringes a bit at how unflinchingly Bridie shares the trauma she’s endured, but opens her heart more to her in the process of getting to know her, and begins to look forward to her company. This relationship adds so much light that’s so needed in such a dark time.

But, there’s so much more to this story than I could tell you in a few short paragraphs.

So many of the small details of this might seem too conveniently placed - the lack of disinfectant, the having to make do with other medical necessities normally available, the signs that seem to echo those of our current times, but Donoghue began writing this story in October of 2018, long before this pandemic we are all living through began. So many similarities, the shops closed, companies that appear to be deserted. A changed world from the one they knew, all that and in addition, they were still dealing with the repercussions of the war that only ended in November of that year. Families with losses from both the war and the pandemic.

While I haven’t read all of her books, I’ve read a few others by her - Room, Frog Music, and The Wonder and I have to say that out of all of those, that I think that she’s outdone herself with this one, as much as I enjoyed, loved the others. There is so much tenderness in the way these characters are shown, and so much compassion in how this story is shared, it served as a lovely reminder that there still is love, tenderness and compassion in this world.


Pub Date: 21 Jul 2020

Many thanks for the ARC provided by Little, Brown and Company

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating read. The story of a midwife during the Spanish Flu epidemic...crazy to be reading it during the Covid-19 pandemic! A little to much medical info for me but the characters grabbed my interest and made me want to learn more.

Was this review helpful?

A brilliant historical novel that tells us the story of 3 women, two fictional and one taken from the pages of history. Julia Powers is a 29 year old maternity nurse in 1918 Dublin, where she is taking care of pregnant women who are also afflicted with the deadly flu. Influenza is causing havoc in Ireland on top of the war that is raging in Europe and the author does an amazing job of conjuring up an authentic sense of disease ridden Dublin which reminds the readers of our present day pandemic. Nurse Julia is overworked and almost at her wit's end trying to care for her patients alone when 22 year old scrappy Bridie Sweeney walks in to her ward and offers her help as a volunteer. Bridie is an orphan who grew up in the orphanage run by Catholic nuns. Although Bridie is unaware of any nursing work, she is a fast learner and soon makes herself indispensable to Nurse Julia. The third woman in the novel is Dr. Katherine Lynn, a true historical figure and a dedicated philanthrope, who belongs to Sinn Fein and is wanted by the Dublin police. The story spans only 3 days in the lives of these 3 women yet it takes the readers on a captivating journey of life, birth, care, pain and love. Beautifully woven within the plot are small vignettes of lives of women from different social strata of early 20th century Dubline and also gives us a slight glimpse of the broken men who came back home from the deadly war. While the book transported me to the place and time and I simply could not put it down, I must mention there are graphic descriptions of child birth which may give squeamish readers a pause. In my opinion, this is a gem of a historical fiction. The author started writing the book in 2018, but she handed the manuscript to her editor in March 2020 when Covid broke out and changed everything.

Was this review helpful?

**The Pull of the Stars by Emma Donoghue**- available July, 21st 2020
.
This was my first Emma Donoghue book and I really enjoyed it. It was a quick but meaningful read. The story follows a maternity nurse during the 1918 flu in Ireland. While The book sheds light on the corruption of the Catholic Church, the war, and politics taking place in Ireland, the majority of the storyline is about the flu and closely follows one nurse during a few days of her hospital work. As a nurse, I have great appreciation for this book and it pulled at my heart strings for nurses who came before me. I am very proud to be a nurse and I enjoyed comparing how somethings in our profession have improved over the past 100 years, while other things are much the same. Two things really stood out to me. First, in 1918 nurses were not trained how to take blood pressures and would have to call a physician if one was needed. Two, nurses had to boil water and mix their own IV fluids.
I would highly recommend this book to any nurses out there or anyone who enjoys historical fiction. This is a very timely book given the current pandemic.
This is a book who’s main character with stick with me for a while as I continue wonder what happened to her after the book ended.
This ARC ebook was given to me free by #netgalley in exchange for a free review. Thank you to #emmadonoghue and #hacherttebookgroup#littlebrownandcompany #thepullofthestars

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Little, Brown, and Company for an advance copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Reading about the influenza pandemic of 1918, which killed more people than World War I, may seem like a crazy idea in the middle of the COVID-19 pandemic, but I have found that learning more about the past helps me put the crisis we are living through in perspective. This book is a wonderful piece of historical fiction. It provides context about not only the Great Flu but also what childbirth, mothering, and healthcare was like in Ireland during this time period, and the roles that religion and poverty played in a person's life. The book takes place over the course of a few days, so the story is primarily driven forward by the characters, their backgrounds, and their relationships. Overall, this is a great book and I highly recommend it to anyone who is curious about learning more about the 1918 pandemic through the lens of historical fiction.

Review posted on Goodreads on May 29, 2020.

Was this review helpful?

This book is a total marvel in every way. Not only is it filled with compassion, heart, humanity and soul, it sucks you right into that hospital in 1918, and doesn’t let go. I would love to see what happens to Julia and Barnabas, and I so hope for a sequel. One of the best books for me this year so far, as we battle our pandemic. What a treasure and bestseller this will be!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the free ARC.

The timing for this book was perfect, as was the story. A nurse in Ireland is taking care of pregnant women who also have caught influenza. She is also taking care of her brother who came back from the war with PTSD or shellshock. The posters on the wall, the saying like: "coughs and sneezes spread diseases", the shortages, the quarantines, the overrun hospitals, everything reminds us that COVID 19 is not the first time humans have had to go through this. The book points out other issues like orphan abuse, the suffragette movement in Ireland, the problems with Irish home rule and Sinn Fein resistance. Very well researched, very involving story line. My favorite mini moment was when I realized what the origin of the title was.

Was this review helpful?

I love getting lost in the brilliant writing of Emma Donoghue. Ironically, this new novel covers three days in the life of Julia Power, a maternity nurse, in a Dublin public hospital during the 1918 flu epidemic. Julia works in a tiny three cot ward where pregnant women suffering from the flu recuperate and give birth.

Julia works a twelve-hour shift, six days a week. On the first day, Julia receives some help, a volunteer, young Bridie Sweeney. Bridie doesn't know anything about nursing, but she is a whiz at getting whatever Julia needs and sprints on every errand. Bridie asks tons of questions, so as a reader, I learned much about caring for the sick and expectant mothers.

Julia's only family is her brother, Tim, back from the war and unable to speak as a result of his traumatic experience. Like other working-class Dubliners, the brother and sister have very little, barely enough food to keep them going. Julia loves her brother and prays that he will get better soon. She thinks of him always as she sees other men suffering in the hospital.

An additional powerhouse character, Dr. Kathlleen Lynn, a known rebel, enters Julia's ward and helps to save lives and comfort Julia and Bridie when things seem useless. The only peace both characters experience is a little time spent on the roof of the hospital, gazing at the stars. The title of the book comes into play with that beautiful night.

Emma Donoghue wrote this book before COVID hit the world, but her timing might have come from the stars. I will always read ED's books, and I hope a new one is coming soon.

Thank you to the author, HarperAvenue, and NetGalley for this e-ARC, which will come out on July 21, 2020.

Was this review helpful?

I was pretty excited to get my hands on this book....it has all the things I love to read about...historical, nursing, the flu...It reminded me of the show "Call the Midwife" which I also love! This book is definitely not for the squeamish, the delivery parts were quite detailed but I was so impressed with the research that must have gone into it. I did feel like the end was rushed...and it made some of the relationships not as real as they could be. I wish they could have developed a bit more but this could have been because I really didn't want the book to end.

Overall, loved this book. It's one that I kept looking down at the screen to make sure there was still more to read. I almost wish there could more of this story to see where these characters end up.

Thanks Netgalley for the copy!

Was this review helpful?