Cover Image: The Girl From the Attic

The Girl From the Attic

Pub Date:   |   Archive Date:

Member Reviews

This is a fantastic middle grade book. I loved reading it. The plot and mood were very deep and I loved getting to know the characters.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the colour and the premise of the book which made me request it on Net Galley.

The starting was a drag and one could not figure out the purpose of the scenarios being presented in the book but it proceeded well. The simple language and a moderate pace made it a quick read.

The main character, Maddy Rose, however, is very, very annoying. Kind of unrealistic in my opinion and it was difficult to relate to the decisions she was making some times.

Overall, an enjoyable one time read.

Was this review helpful?

A warm, touching read. Coming from someone who does not really read middle grade anymore, I got some major Coraline vibes (one of my favorite animated films).

Was this review helpful?

The Girl from the Attic is an engrossing, exciting middle grade historical fiction. I cannot wait to share this book with my kids. It is sure to be a hit!

Thank you NetGalley and Common Deer Press for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book from NetGalley, this is a honest review.

Maddy just moved in a old house in the countryside with her pregnant mom and her new stepfather. Days are really boring for her and the only thing she hopes for are the emails from her dear friend Amy who is in some paradise beach on holiday while she is stuck in this pathetic old house just because her new stepdad decided it was nice to move from the city to the country. Days pass by until one day she see a cat sneaking into the attic and she decides to follow it thorough a door and she find herself in the past!
Here start her travel between past and present at the discovery of the house when it was first built and of the family that used to live there!

I liked the book.
Maddy is a very spoiled kid, as all 12year old kid are nowadays, that only want with to stay all day in front of a computer chatting with friends, until she discover how people used to live in the past and that all that she gives for granted it was not granted at all once, not even your own bed.
I liked Maddy's growth in the book, from totally spoiled brat to more patient and understanding kid (but not too much :D), I loved Clare and aunt Elle and most of all Shadow!
The only thing that I didn't liked is the pace, it's a rather slow book that burns everything at the end so while I dragged for the first chapters I read the last chapters in a flash.

Recommended for young readers :)

Was this review helpful?

This was an enjoyable easy MG READ with the teenage protagonist, Maddy travelling back in time within her own house. Issues such as tuberculosis, loss, family values, personal responsibilities, step parents and a new baby are all thrown into the mix and Maddy has to grapple with all of these. There is a good depiction of egotistical preteen/ teen angst and an evolving sense of personal responsibilities in a changing family. Maddy realises she may have to soften or change her tone and to not take everything as a personal attack, and that her attitude affects others.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publishers for an ARC of this book.

This was such a wonderful story, and honestly reminded me a little of Coraline in a way. The story follows Maddy as she grows accustomed to a new home, only to discover a secret door that’s opens to he past! I was super excited by the premise and it did not disappoint. Throughout the way Maddy learns to accept change instead of remaining averse to it.

The flow of the book was really good and the language isn’t hard to read at all. I’d definitely recommend this book for children!

Was this review helpful?

Plot line: Maddy moves into a strange new house in the country with her mother and step father. She meets a black cat that leads her through mysterious door in the attic.
Review: When I saw the title of the book, I knew I had to read it. It’s a book that pulls you in the story with each turn of page. I was curious like our main character Maddy to find out what was going on behind the attic door. Her meetings with Clare were interesting and insightful. I liked how meticulously the author showed the changes in time and relationships through a house. I also liked the role of our furry figure Shadow. It was an enjoyable read. I would recommend the book to readers who are trying to escape from reality in fiction.
Thank you Netgalley , Common Deer Press and Marie aprons for the ARC for honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was a very different book. Definitely a heartbreaker. Echoes of Pan's Labyrinth and Coraline. Interesting note: the time travel really brings up the problem with modern day technology consumption. I liked it, though it took me FOREVER to read. I recommend.

Was this review helpful?

I decided to use my tools from my blogging to see if I could find something that I could read with my 11 yr old in an attempt to encourage her to read a little more. We discussed the synopsis and she agreed to read it with me.

Ms Prins does a wonderful job of telling a story that blends to past with the present, using the similarities of the octagonal home that Maddy moves into. We found it fun to learn about the differences in how things were done between the two time periods. On her ventures to the past she learns many lessons that make her rethink her opinions and feelings around the issues and events going on in her own home.

The characters are likeable and help to draw you into the story. The reader can easily understand the emotions and feelings of the characters as you read. In fact my daughter might have gotten a little teary eyed a time or two while reading. We found ourselves looking forward to read time to see what was going to happen next.

I feel many middle aged girls would enjoy this read.

*** Advanced copy provided in exchange for an honest review. ***

Was this review helpful?

Title: The Girl From the Attic
By: Marie Prins
Publisher: Common Deer Press
Genre: Middle Grade | Sci Fi & Fantasy
Pub Date; 01 Oct 2020
Review on Goodreads: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/3339664217

Maddy is a young girl who has just moved to a new home. This is not by her own choice and she is angry, Angry about the move,. angry that her mam married Dan and that they are now having a baby. That is until Maddy discovers a hidden door and a black cat.

It is possible that Prins uses the past to show the reader just how far medicine has come in the last 100 or so years. The rest of the story seemed to have little discernible lessons. Maddy constantly does the opposite of what she is told and even when there is no real reason for her to go through the door she does.
Her friend Amy is also a convenience to the story I'm not sure how many parents would look after someone else's child for three weeks, and this is when Maddy's little sister is seriously ill, yet she is off having fun with her friend.

Though I enjoyed the time travel aspect, unfortunately a lot of things in this story felt disjointed and not well knitted together. The last 100 pages were written well where emotion was concerned, but it all lacked a feeling of conclusion. As in the rest of the story it didn't make complete sense..

I felt Dan to be be a controlling, borderline abusive character who had a sudden change of heart. I am sure that if he were real that change of heart would have reverted once Carla and Coralee where home
I think there was a good plot here but the execution was sloppy.

Was this review helpful?

This is a well paced time traveling story where a young girl is able to go back in time in her new (old) house. It does a good job dealing with issues like stepparents, feeling alone and ignored, and health scares, while also giving kids a realistic view of life in the early 1900's with all of its risks and realities. The chapters are short, making it good for read-alouds or early readers.

Was this review helpful?

I requested and received an e-ARC of this book from Marie Prins and Common Deer Press through NetGalley in exchange for my honest opinion.

I found the very beginning of this book hard to read as it focuses a lot on the shape of the house Maddy and her family have moved into and I didn't find it particularly interesting. Then we got into the meat and potatoes of the story of Maddy and her blended family and all of the feelings she was having about the changes in her life. I think that kids will relate to the emotionss Maddy is going through as she figures out her place in their new family. I liked the time travel aspect of this book and I love how it all tied together at the end.

I would definitely recommend this book to young readers.

Was this review helpful?

A fun introduction to time travel books for the middle grade set, I enjoyed seeing Mandy interact with both the past and the present. This wrapped up well, and I think my 7 year old would enjoy it a lot!

Was this review helpful?

What an impudent little girl, especially to her stepfather Dan and her mom Carla, Maddy she shows all respect and kindness to the folks she met in her strange trips back to the past. when her very pregnant and exhausted mother needed her, she quickly disappears, hiding away in the past from doing any chores. She thinks Dan hated her, when in fact, she was the one who didn’t want him in her life. She wanted her real father, sad to say, the twirp had walked out on them when she was a toddler. I find Maddy’s jaunt’s into the past had been too frequent for she seems to be two different persons a nice little girl when in the past and, in reality, she was rude and a little too much into herself.

Was this review helpful?

Maddy doesn’t like her new Dad or the beat up octagonal house they move to in the country. When an elusive black cat leads her through a small attic door into a version of her house from one hundred years ago, she meets the boy Claire and his ailing sister, Eva. Meanwhile, in Maddy’s world, her pregnant mother needs her help but, often, the cat leads her back to Claire’s where her knowledge of the modern world and his reality clash. His uncle’s soap factory, a deserted mansion and Maddy’s scheme to help cure Eva play out against her real life problems - disappearing when she should be helping, the premature birth of her sister, her father’s annoyance of her seemingly unpredictable behaviour. Dealing with events in both worlds matures Maddy, forcing her to make choices and decisions that lead to a better understanding of both herself and her own family.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book enthralling and captivating!
Despite MG not being my usual genre, I loved this book. The characters, plot line and just the general book were all amazing.
I found the characters likeable and easy to connect with- it was a great read!

Was this review helpful?

I received an electronic ARC from Common Deer Press through NetGalley.
Maddy has to adjust to a new stepfather, a move to the country and a new sibling on the way quickly. It doesn't go well. She's angry and confused and feels like she can't trust either adult in her life.
While exploring the old home, she finds an old quilt and sees a black cat. She follows the cat and discovers an old doorway that doesn't make sense in their house. She goes through and is immediately back in time to the early 1900's. She bravely gets to know a boy about her age and interacts with him and his aunt more than she does in her own time period. Events happen in each that bring heartache. Maddy figures out how to be part of her new family and life calms again. I like the connecting characters to both times - human and feline.
Prins created characters that are not completely likeable but are realistic. Middle grade readers will relate to Maddy's feelings about adjusting to new normals. The setting provides enough eeriness and action to appeal to most readers.

Was this review helpful?

A huge thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for sending the e-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

It's a really touching story that almost got me into tears. It is really interesting, fascinating and relatable. I love the way it teaches children to be grateful for being in a decent family. I highly recommend this to older kids because of its length and the depth of the topic.

Was this review helpful?

12 year old Maddy finds herself shifting between two worlds that are 100 years apart..Maddy's step-father Dan shifts to a house in the countryside ,commonly known as the octagon,far away from their bungalow in the city when Carla Maddy's mother expects a baby.In the Octagon Maddy is lead into an unknown attic by a strange black cat called Shadow.It leads her to the family who lived in the same house a hundred years ago.A few days after her visits to the past ,Maddy meets Clare and her sister Eva ,who is suffering from consumption(now known as tuberculosis). Maddy and Clare join hands in a soap making project through which they can make money and Clare could find a way to save Eva.Was Maddy's plan of helping Clare to save Eva successful?(I would prefer not to give spoilers by revealing it and leave it to the readers to find out what happens).

The story is a complete mixture of emotions- You would laugh at Maddy's innocence,cry when Maddy and Clare part away and hate Dan for not being pleasant to Dan(at least I did hat him in the beginning). Clare and Maddy's friendship stands as an example that friendship is all about understanding and teaching importance lessons of life to each other.Maddy meeting Clare stood as a turning point that changed her perspective towards life.I really cried when Clare departed.A book that makes you cry stays within you forever and so is this.The character of Maddy is very well potrayed -just as a modern youth,who neglects the responsibilities and acts as per will but with the guidance and words of a right person ,the youth suddenly transforms into a responsible being ,just as Maddy .

The writing style is so attractive.Narration is simple,lucid and highly appealing.I really loved the cover that aptly describes the plot.
This title is set to released on 1st Oct,2020 and do not think before picking it up because it's not going to disappoint you in any way!
Thank you @netgalley for approving the copy.
Happy Reading!
#TheGirlFromtheAttic #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?